The Bible · Old Testament

Ecclesiastes

Ecclesiastes is a wisdom book in which a teacher called Qoheleth ("the Teacher" or "the Preacher") tests pleasure, work, wealth and wisdom, and finds them all "hebel": vapor, breath, meaningless. People read it for its blunt honesty about death, injustice and the limits of human knowledge, and for its advice to enjoy life as God's gift and to "fear God and keep his commandments" (12:13).

  • Hebrew (with some Aramaic)
  • In every Bible

Why it's in the Bible, and the doubts

The case for

  1. Jews and Christians both accepted it as scripture early and widely.

    The evidence

    Copies were kept at Qumran (4Q109–4Q110, one dated to the mid-2nd century BC). The Mishnah rules that it 'defiles the hands', meaning it is sacred (Yadayim 3:5), and it appears in Melito of Sardis' list (c. 170 AD), Athanasius' Festal Letter of 367 and the Councils of Hippo and Carthage (393/397).

  2. It is anchored in the rest of the Bible's teaching on creation and judgment.

    The evidence

    It echoes Genesis: humans come 'from dust' and return to dust (3:20; 12:7; compare Gen 2:7; 3:19). It repeatedly calls God the giver of life and its joys (2:24–26; 5:18–20), and it ends by saying God will judge every deed (12:14).

  3. Its frank doubts sit alongside other trusted biblical voices rather than standing alone.

    The evidence

    Job, Psalms 39, 49 and 73, and Lamentations also struggle openly with death, suffering and unfair outcomes. Judaism reads Ecclesiastes aloud every year at the festival of Sukkot, and Paul's statement that creation was 'subjected to futility' (Rom 8:20) uses the same Greek word the Septuagint uses for Qoheleth's 'vanity'.

The case against

  1. Ancient Jewish teachers themselves argued about whether it belonged.

    The evidence

    The Mishnah records that the schools of Shammai and Hillel disagreed over its holiness (Yadayim 3:5; Eduyot 5:3). The Talmud says the sages wanted to withdraw it because 'its words contradict one another' (Shabbat 30b; compare 2:2 with 8:15). Leviticus Rabbah 28:1 says they found ideas in it 'that lean toward heresy'.

  2. Some of its statements are hard to square with the rest of Scripture.

    The evidence

    It says humans and animals share one fate and asks 'who knows' whether the human spirit goes upward (3:19–21). It also says 'the dead know nothing' and have 'no reward' (9:5, 10), and advises 'do not be overly righteous' (7:16). Readers have to decide whether these are the author's own views or positions he raises in order to test them.

  3. Its claim to come from Solomon is probably a literary device, and its pious ending may be a later addition.

    The evidence

    Its late Hebrew, Aramaic influence and Persian loanwords such as pardes, 'park' (2:5), and pitgam, 'sentence' (8:11), point well after Solomon's time. Franz Delitzsch remarked that if the book were from Solomon 'there is no history of the Hebrew language', and Luther doubted Solomon wrote it. The epilogue speaks about Qoheleth in the third person (12:9–14), which many scholars read as an editor framing the book.

Both sides are written as strongly as the honest evidence allows, so you can decide for yourself. Researched by claude-opus-5-5.

When, where and by whom

Tradition takes "son of David, king in Jerusalem" (1:1) to mean Solomon, writing in the 10th century BC. The Talmud (Bava Batra 15a) credits Hezekiah's scribes with putting it in writing. Most scholars, including many conservative ones, date it to the Persian or early Greek period (about 450–250 BC, often the 3rd century BC) and place it in Judea. On this view it is the work of an unnamed sage writing in the persona of Solomon, with an epilogue (12:9–14) that may come from an editor.

Jesus, the New Testament and this book
  • Paul's 'creation was subjected to futility' (Romans 8:20) uses mataiotēs, the Septuagint word for Qoheleth's 'vanity' (hebel), which suggests he had this book's outlook in mind. (likely link)
  • Jesus' parable of the rich fool, who plans to 'eat, drink, be merry' and then dies, leaving his wealth to someone else (Luke 12:16–21), parallels Ecclesiastes 2:18–21 and 5:13–15 on stored-up wealth passed on to others. (possible link)
  • James' 'you are a mist that appears for a little while' (James 4:14) shares the image of life as vapor or breath (hebel). (possible link)
  • Paul's teaching that all will appear before God's judgment (2 Corinthians 5:10; Romans 2:16) matches Ecclesiastes 12:14: 'God will bring every deed into judgment, including every hidden thing'. (possible link)
  • The New Testament never directly quotes Ecclesiastes. (strong link)
How it came down to us

The oldest copies are Dead Sea Scrolls fragments from Qumran Cave 4 (4QQoh a and b, 4Q109–4Q110). 4Q109 dates to around the mid-2nd century BC and closely matches the later Hebrew text. The full Hebrew text survives in the medieval Masoretic manuscripts, notably the Leningrad Codex (1008 AD); the Aleppo Codex lost this book. The Greek Septuagint version is unusually word-for-word, in a style like that of Aquila, and appears in the great 4th–5th century codices (Vaticanus, Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus). The book was also kept in Syriac (Peshitta), in Latin (Jerome translated it from Hebrew and wrote a commentary on it around 388 AD) and in Ge'ez by the Ethiopian church. Jewish scribes copied it as one of the Five Scrolls (Megillot).

  • Dead Sea Scrolls fragments 4Q109–4Q110 (4QQoh a, b)
  • Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex)
  • Septuagint and the codices Vaticanus, Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus
  • Mishnah Yadayim 3:5 and Eduyot 5:3; Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 30b and Bava Batra 15a; Leviticus Rabbah 28:1
  • Canon lists: Melito of Sardis, Athanasius' Festal Letter 39 (367), Councils of Hippo and Carthage
  • Jerome, Commentary on Ecclesiastes
  • Studies of the book's language (Persian loanwords, Late Biblical Hebrew), e.g. Franz Delitzsch's commentary
  • Luther's Table Talk
  • New Testament parallels (Romans 8:20; Luke 12; James 4:14)

Chapters

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12