Other ancient texts · Early Christian writings

1 Clement

1 Clement is a long letter from the church in Rome to the church in Corinth, urging the Corinthians to end a split in which younger members had removed their church leaders. It is read as one of the oldest Christian writings outside the New Testament, and as an early view of church life, leadership and worship soon after the apostles.

  • about AD 96
  • Greek
  • Protestant Catholic Orthodox Ethiopian

Bound into Codex Alexandrinus (5th century) after the New Testament.

Should it be in the Bible?

The case for

  1. It was read aloud as scripture-like reading in early churches.

    The evidence

    Around 170 Dionysius of Corinth wrote that his church still read Clement's letter on Sundays (Eusebius, Church History 4.23.11). Eusebius (3.16) says it was read publicly in very many churches, both in the past and in his own day.

  2. Some early Bibles and canon lists included it with the New Testament books.

    The evidence

    Codex Alexandrinus (5th century) binds 1 and 2 Clement right after Revelation and lists them in its table of contents. A Syriac New Testament manuscript copied in 1170 places both letters among the general epistles, and the Apostolic Canons (canon 85, about 380) list both letters as New Testament books.

  3. It is very old and comes from people who knew the apostolic generation.

    The evidence

    It may be as old as some New Testament books. It speaks of Peter and Paul as figures 'of our own generation' (ch. 5), and Irenaeus says Clement had seen and spoken with the apostles. Clement of Alexandria quotes it often and once calls its author 'the apostle Clement' (Stromata 4.17).

The case against

  1. The major canon lists left it out.

    The evidence

    It is missing from the Muratorian fragment, Athanasius's Festal Letter of 367 and the councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397). No church today counts it as scripture. Eusebius accepted it as a genuine letter but did not put it among the accepted books of the New Testament.

  2. The letter does not claim apostolic authority and puts itself below the apostles.

    The evidence

    It looks back to 'the apostles' as an earlier generation that appointed leaders (chs. 42–44). It points the Corinthians to 'the epistle of the blessed Paul' as an authority (ch. 47), and it quotes the Old Testament as scripture without presenting itself that way.

  3. Some of its content calls for caution.

    The evidence

    Chapter 25 presents the legend of the phoenix bird rising every 500 years as fact, as proof of the resurrection. Chapter 23 quotes as 'scripture' a passage found in no known biblical book, and the author's name comes from later tradition, not the letter itself.

Both sides are written as strongly as the honest evidence allows, so you can decide for yourself. Researched by claude-opus-5-5.

When, where and by whom

Tradition, going back to Dionysius of Corinth (about 170) and Irenaeus, holds that Clement, a leader of the Roman church, wrote it from Rome around AD 96 under Domitian. The letter itself is anonymous and speaks for 'the church of God which sojourns at Rome'. Most scholars accept that it came from Rome and that Clement probably drafted it, and they date it between about 80 and 100, though some argue for as early as the 70s or as late as about 140.

Jesus, the New Testament and this book
  • Names Paul's letter to the Corinthians and its warning about factions (ch. 47, recalling 1 Cor 1:10–12). (strong link)
  • Chapter 36 closely follows Hebrews 1:3–13 (Christ as the radiance of God, greater than angels, with the same Psalm quotations). (strong link)
  • Quotes 'words of the Lord Jesus' (13:2; 46:8) that resemble the Sermon on the Mount and Matthew 18:6/26:24. The wording does not match any Gospel exactly, so the source may be oral tradition. (strong link)
  • Refers to the martyrdom of Peter and Paul and says Paul reached 'the limit of the west' (ch. 5). This may connect to Paul's planned trip to Spain in Romans 15:24. (likely link)
  • The vice list in 35:5–6 echoes Romans 1:29–32. Other passages echo 1 Peter and James. (likely link)
  • Origen and Eusebius identified the author with the Clement whom Paul praises in Philippians 4:3. (possible link)
  • Early use: Polycarp's letter to the Philippians (about 110–135) appears to borrow its wording. Irenaeus (Against Heresies 3.3.3) describes it, and Clement of Alexandria quotes it extensively. (likely link)
How it came down to us

The original Greek survives in Codex Alexandrinus (5th century), which has lost a leaf covering 57:7–63:4, and in full in Codex Hierosolymitanus (1056), found by Philotheos Bryennios in 1873. Early translations survive too: a Syriac version in a New Testament manuscript of 1170 (Cambridge), an old Latin version in an 11th-century manuscript, and two Coptic versions, one on a 4th-century papyrus in Berlin. Greek and Syriac churches were the main ones that kept copying it.

  • Greek text in Codex Alexandrinus and Codex Hierosolymitanus (1056)
  • Syriac, Latin and Coptic early translations
  • Eusebius, Church History 3.16, 3.38, 4.23 (citing Dionysius of Corinth)
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.3; Clement of Alexandria, Stromata
  • Canon lists: Muratorian fragment, Athanasius's 39th Festal Letter, Apostolic Canons 85, councils of Hippo and Carthage
  • Modern critical editions and studies of the Apostolic Fathers (e.g. Lightfoot, Ehrman, Holmes)

Chapters