2 Esdras Chapter 3 Read as one passage

2 Esdras 3:20–22

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20“Yet you didn’t take away from them their wicked heart, that your law might produce fruit in them. 21For the first Adam, burdened with a wicked heart transgressed and was overcome, as were all who are descended from him. 22Thus disease was made permanent. The law was in the heart of the people along with the wickedness of the root. So the good departed away and that which was wicked remained.

What the first hearers heard

For Jews around AD 100, still reeling from the loss of the Temple, this verse said out loud something frightening. Having the Torah had not been enough. The covenant people had God's instruction in their very hearts, yet they kept failing, and the result was ruin (3:25–27).

It worked in several ways:

  • Explaining the disaster. It answered "why did Jerusalem fall?" without blaming the Torah and without simply saying "Israel was worse than other nations." The weakness was in the human heart, inherited from Adam and shared by everyone (vv.21, 26).
  • Protest to God. Inside Ezra's prayer, the verse is part of a complaint: God could have removed the evil heart (v.20) and did not. The first readers would have heard the boldness of lament psalms and of Job.
  • Getting ready for the answer. The rest of the book, through the angel Uriel and the visions, answers that this age is hopelessly sick. Only the coming age will heal it, when "the root is sealed up… illness is blotted out" (8:53) and "the heart of the earth's inhabitants shall be changed" (6:26). So the verse pointed readers away from hoping to fix things in this age and toward God's future new creation. Meanwhile they were to keep the Torah faithfully, as the few who "strive against the evil thought" (7:92).

From the study of 2 Esdras 3:22.

Verse by verse

  1. 20“Yet you didn’t take away from them their wicked heart, that your law might produce fruit in them.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 21For the first Adam, burdened with a wicked heart transgressed and was overcome, as were all who are descended from him.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 22Thus disease was made permanent. The law was in the heart of the people along with the wickedness of the root. So the good departed away and that which was wicked remained.

    "And so the sickness settled in for good. God's Torah really did come to live in the heart of the people, but it lived there side by side with the wicked root that had been in humanity since Adam. So the good packed up and left, and the evil stayed on."

    The speaker is "Ezra" (the narrator, also called Salathiel), praying in Babylon after Jerusalem has been destroyed. He has just retold the story from Adam to Sinai. In verse 20 he complained to God: you gave them the law, but you did not take away their evil heart, so that the law could bear fruit in them. This verse describes what came of that.

    • "The sickness became permanent." Humanity's problem is pictured as a chronic illness, not a series of slips. Adam already "carried" an evil heart when he sinned (v.21). Through his sin that condition became the lasting state of his descendants.
    • "The law was in the heart, along with the wicked root." This is bitter irony. Jeremiah had promised a day when God would write the law on the heart. In a sense the Torah did reach the heart, but it was planted in ground where a bad root was already growing. The fault is not in the Torah; the same book insists the law "does not perish but remains in its glory" (9:37). The fault is in the soil.
    • "The good went away; the evil stayed." The roles are reversed. What should have been temporary (the sickness) became permanent, and what should have taken root (the good the law was meant to produce) moved out.

    The verse is not a calm statement of doctrine. It is part of a protest, as one of the writer's questions to God: why give a cure that cannot work while the disease is still in place? The rest of the book takes up that question.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v22

    infirmity (KJV)

    infirmitas

    What we hear
    Physical frailty, especially from old age or long illness.
    What they heard
    A lasting weakness or sickness of the human heart and will, a moral and spiritual condition handed down from Adam.
  • in v22

    the disease was made permanent (read as 'original sin')

    facta est permanens infirmitas

    What we hear
    Augustine's doctrine of original sin: every person inherits Adam's guilt and deserves condemnation from birth.
    What they heard
    Adam's descendants share a lasting tendency toward evil (the 'evil heart'). Adam already had that heart before he sinned (v.21), and 4 Ezra still holds each person responsible for their own choices (7:127–129: 'this is the meaning of the contest'). The verse talks about a sickness that carries on, not about guilt transferred from Adam.
  • in v22

    the law

    lex (Greek nomos, Hebrew torah)

    What we hear
    A legal code, or a burden of rules opposed to grace.
    What they heard
    God's Torah: a gift of life-giving instruction that 4 Ezra treats as glorious and imperishable (9:37). The problem the verse names is the heart the law was put into, not the law itself.
Every word
  1. et

    et

    and · v22

    Joins this verse to the story of Adam in v.21, so it reads as the next step: Adam sinned, and as a result the sickness took root. It probably stands for the Hebrew 'and' (wə-) that opens clauses in a story.

  2. facta est

    facta est

    became, was made · v22

    'Became' or 'came to be'. It describes something that happened, a change from one state to another, and does not name anyone who caused it. The text does not say God made the sickness permanent; it says the sickness became permanent.

  3. permanens

    permanens

    lasting, abiding, continuing · v22

    Lasting, settled in for good. The illness did not come and go; it stayed on through the generations. The same verb comes back at the end of the verse in 'mansit' (remained).

  4. infirmitas

    infirmitas

    weakness, sickness, illness · v22

    A moral and spiritual sickness or weakness, not a bodily one. It is the condition that came from the 'evil heart' Adam carried (v.21). Modern translators render it 'disease'.

  5. lex

    lex

    law · v22

    The Torah, God's instruction given to Israel at Sinai (described in vv.17–19). It means God's gift of teaching and covenant, not a code of rules in the narrow modern sense.

  6. in

    in

    in · v22

    Inside. The Torah did not stay on stone tablets; it really reached the people's inner life.

  7. corde

    corde

    heart · v22

    In Hebrew thinking (behind the Latin is Hebrew lev/levav) the heart is the centre of thinking, choosing and wanting, not mainly of feeling. It is the same heart called 'evil' in vv.20–21.

  8. populi

    populi

    of the people · v22

    Israel, the people who received the law at Sinai, not humanity in general. The writer moves from Adam's descendants (v.21) to the covenant people in particular.

  9. cum

    cum

    with, together with · v22

    The key word of the verse: the law and the evil root lived side by side in the same heart. Neither drove the other out.

  10. malignitate

    malignitate

    wickedness, ill-will, malice · v22

    Moral badness or wickedness. It is the noun from the same word as 'cor malignum' (evil heart) in vv.20–21, so it ties the root to that heart.

  11. radicis

    radicis

    of the root · v22

    A plant picture: evil is like a root planted deep inside, which keeps sending up shoots. Compare 4:30, the 'grain of evil seed' sown in Adam's heart, and 8:53, where at the end the root is sealed up.

  12. discessit

    discessit

    went away, departed · v22

    The good 'went away' or left. The picture is of a lodger moving out, not of good being destroyed.

  13. quod

    quod

    that which · v22

    Turns 'good' into a thing: 'what is good'. In context this is the good the law was meant to produce, the 'fruit' of v.20.

  14. bonum

    bonum

    good · v22

    The good: right living as a fruit of the Torah. It probably stands for Hebrew tov.

  15. est

    est

    is · v22

    Completes 'that which is good'.

  16. mansit

    mansit

    stayed, remained · v22

    Stayed on. It picks up 'permanens' from the start of the verse: the evil was the lodger that never left.

  17. malignum

    malignum

    evil, wicked · v22

    The evil. It is the same word as the 'evil heart' (cor malignum) of vv.20–21, so the verse ends where the thought began.

The world behind it

When and why it was written. Chapters 3–14 of 2 Esdras (known to scholars as 4 Ezra) were written around AD 100, about thirty years after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem and the Second Temple in AD 70. The author writes in the name of Ezra, and sets the book "in the thirtieth year after the destruction of the city" by Babylon in 587 BC (3:1). The ancient catastrophe stands in for the recent one. The book was written in Hebrew (or possibly Aramaic). That original is lost, and so is the Greek translation made from it. What survives are translations from the Greek: Latin, Syriac, Ethiopic, Georgian, Armenian, Arabic and others.

The prayer this verse belongs to (3:4–36). Ezra goes over Israel's history to ask God why things are as they are: Adam (vv.4–7), the flood (vv.8–11), Abraham (vv.13–15), Sinai (vv.17–19), then David and Jerusalem (vv.23–27). The main charge comes in v.20: God gave the Torah "but did not take away from them the evil heart." Verses 21–22 explain why that mattered. Verses 23–27 then show the result: even under David the people sinned "like Adam", and the city was handed to its enemies. The question underneath is why God's people, who had the Torah, have been crushed by Babylon/Rome, which is no better.

The 'evil heart' in Jewish thought of the time. Genesis 6:5 and 8:21 say the "inclination" (yetzer) of the human heart is evil. Sirach (around 180 BC), the Dead Sea Scrolls, and later the rabbis developed this into the idea of an "evil inclination" (yetzer ha-ra') in every person. The usual Jewish hope was that the Torah was the cure for it. A saying in the Talmud has God say: "I created the evil inclination, and I created Torah as its antidote." 2 Esdras 3:22 is a darker voice from the same world. Here the Torah sat next to the evil inclination and did not overcome it.

A New Testament neighbour. Paul's Romans 5 and 7, written about 40 years earlier, are the closest parallel. Sin entered through one man, and the law is holy but cannot overcome the sin that "dwells in me". The two writings do not depend on each other. They are two Jewish thinkers of the first century wrestling with the same problem.

From the study of 2 Esdras 3:22.

Where scholars differ

in v22

Does 4 Ezra teach that Adam's sin passed a corrupted nature (or guilt) to all his descendants?

  • Yes, an inherited corruption. Adam's sin turned an existing weakness into a lasting state of humanity passed down through birth. On this view 4 Ezra is a Jewish forerunner of later Christian ideas about the effects of the Fall, though not of inherited guilt.

    3:21 ('as were all who are descended from him'); 3:22 ('became permanent'); 7:118 ('the fall was not yours alone, but ours also who are your descendants').

  • No, a universal tendency that each person still answers for. The evil heart was there before Adam sinned, and every person has it. Adam's sin is the first example of it, not the cause of everyone else's guilt. People remain fully responsible.

    3:21 says Adam already carried the evil heart when he sinned; 4:30 says the evil seed was sown 'from the beginning'; 7:127–129 says the contest is each person's own; 3:26 says later generations sinned 'as Adam had done'.

in v22

Is the 'evil heart / evil root' the same as the rabbinic 'evil inclination' (yetzer ha-ra')?

  • Essentially the same idea, in an early form.

    The wording goes back to Genesis 6:5 and 8:21 (the yetzer of the heart). 2 Esdras 7:92 speaks of the 'evil thought formed with them', which matches the language of yetzer ('the thing formed'). Sirach 15:14 and the Dead Sea Scrolls are earlier stages. Stone and others favour this connection.

  • A related idea, but darker and in some ways different.

    In the rabbinic texts the evil inclination can be useful, and Torah is a working remedy for it. In 4 Ezra the Torah fails to overcome it in this age, and only the end time removes it (6:26; 8:53). Some scholars (for example Bauckham and Hogan) stress how 4 Ezra develops the idea in its own way.

in v22

Does the angel Uriel, later in the book, agree with this pessimism, or is Ezra's complaint being corrected?

  • Ezra's complaint is largely answered and moved past by the angel's answers and the visions.

    Uriel moves attention away from human sickness toward God's coming age and the few who keep the Torah (7:19–25; 7:127–131). Ezra's outlook changes after the vision of the woman/Zion in chapter 10.

  • The diagnosis stands; what changes is where hope is placed, not the analysis.

    Uriel himself affirms the evil seed (4:30–31) and the healing at the end time (8:53). He never denies that the illness is lasting in this age.

Sources
  • Michael E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia; Fortress, 1990), comment on 3:20–22 and excursus on the evil heart
  • Bruce M. Metzger, 'The Fourth Book of Ezra', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1 (1983)
  • R. L. Bensly, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (1895)
  • B. Violet, Die Esra-Apokalypse (IV. Esra), GCS (1910)
  • R. Weber (ed.), Biblia Sacra iuxta Vulgatam Versionem, appendix: Liber Ezrae IIII
  • B. W. Longenecker, 2 Esdras (Sheffield, 1995)
  • K. M. Hogan, Theology and Theodicy in 4 Ezra (Brill, 2008)
  • Lewis & Short, A Latin Dictionary, s.v. infirmitas, malignitas, radix
  • F. C. Porter, 'The Yeçer Hara: A Study in the Jewish Doctrine of Sin' (1902)
  • Babylonian Talmud, Qiddushin 30b
  • 2 Baruch 54:15–19

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.