2 Samuel Chapter 1 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 1:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4“What was the outcome?” David asked. “Please tell me.” “The troops fled from the battle,” he replied. “Many of them fell and died. And Saul and his son Jonathan are also dead.” 5Then David asked the young man who had brought him the report, “How do you know that Saul and his son Jonathan are dead?”

What the first hearers heard

Hearers of the books of Samuel would recognise this as a set scene: a runner from a lost battle, a dreaded question, and an answer that saves the worst for last. The wording deliberately repeats 1 Samuel 4, where the house of Eli fell in one day to the Philistines. Now the house of Saul falls the same way. The listener is invited to see a pattern: Israel's leaders who lose the Lord's favour end in defeat, and a new order follows (the faithful priest in 1 Sam 2:35, the man after God's own heart in 1 Sam 13:14).

The verse also carries strong feeling. For the audience, the news that matters is not the rout of the army but the last clause: Saul and Jonathan his son. Naming Jonathan as 'his son' marks him as heir and makes clear that the dynasty is finished. It also reminds the audience of the bond between Jonathan and David, which makes the lament of verses 19-27 bitter. The way David receives this news (vv. 11-16) is central to the narrative's case that he did not seize Saul's throne or celebrate Saul's death. Here the account begins showing that he learned of it as a grief.

From the study of 2 Samuel 1:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4“What was the outcome?” David asked. “Please tell me.” “The troops fled from the battle,” he replied. “Many of them fell and died. And Saul and his son Jonathan are also dead.”

    David said to him, “What happened? How did it turn out? Tell me, please, report it to me!”

    The man answered, “It is this: the army broke and ran from the battle. And more than that, a great many of the troops fell in the fighting and are dead. And more than that, Saul and Jonathan his son are dead.”

    The answer climbs in three steps, each beginning with and also: first the rout, then the heavy losses, then the deaths of the king and his heir, held back to the last word. To an Israelite ear, David's question ("What was the matter?") and the runner's staged report repeat the day another runner, with torn clothes and earth on his head, told old Eli that Israel had fled, the people had been slaughtered, and his two sons were dead (1 Samuel 4). The word fell, used here as soldiers' plain language for being killed in battle, is the word David will soon turn into his lament: “How the mighty have fallen!”

    Full study →
  2. 5Then David asked the young man who had brought him the report, “How do you know that Saul and his son Jonathan are dead?”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    the people (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    hāʿām

    What we hear
    The general population, civilians, ordinary Israelites.
    What they heard
    In a battle report, the men under arms: the tribal levy called up to fight, 'the troops'.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֨אמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v4

    The ordinary narrative verb that moves the story forward: David now speaks to the man who has just arrived from the Israelite camp (v. 3).

  2. אֵלָ֥יו

    ʾēlāw · H0413

    to him · v4

    Directs David's question at the messenger, who in v. 2 arrived with torn clothes and dirt on his head, the visible signs of bad news.

  3. דָּוִ֛ד

    dāwid · H1732

    David · v4

    David, at this point an outlaw living among the Philistines at Ziklag, freshly back from rescuing his people from Amalekite raiders (1 Sam 30).

  4. מֶה־

    meh · H4100

    what? · v4

    Opens an open-ended, anxious question. David does not ask about Saul specifically; he asks for the whole story.

  5. הָיָ֥ה

    hāyāh · H1961

    was, happened · v4

    Completed action: 'what has happened / how did it turn out'. The battle is over and David wants the result.

  6. הַדָּבָ֖ר

    haddābār · H1697

    word, thing, matter · v4

    Here 'the matter, the affair', meaning the battle and its outcome. The whole phrase 'What was the matter?' repeats word for word what old Eli asked the runner from the lost battle in 1 Sam 4:16.

  7. הַגֶּד־

    haggeḏ · H5046

    tell, report · v4

    Command form, 'make it known, report it'. This is the verb from which the word for 'messenger, reporter' (maggid, v. 5) is built: David asks the man to do what a messenger does.

  8. נָ֣א

    nāʾ · H4994

    please, now · v4

    A small particle that softens or urges a request, 'please' or 'do tell me'. It adds urgency and courtesy to David's demand.

  9. לִ֑י

    lî

    to me · v4

    'To me'. The pause mark here closes David's speech.

  10. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾăšer · H0834

    which, that · v4

    Usually a relative word ('who, which'). Here it introduces what was said, like opening quotation marks, much as Greek uses 'hoti'. KJV and YLT keep it as 'that'; most modern versions leave it untranslated.

  11. נָ֨ס

    nās · H5127

    fled · v4

    The army ran from the field. In Israelite battle reports, flight is the first sign of defeat (compare 1 Sam 4:10, 17; 31:1).

  12. הָעָ֜ם

    hāʿām · H5971

    people · v4

    In a battle context 'the people' means the fighting men, the tribal levy called out for war: 'the troops', not the civilian population.

  13. מִן־

    min · H4480

    from · v4

    'From' the battle: they ran away from the fighting.

  14. הַמִּלְחָמָ֗ה

    hammilḥāmāh · H4421

    battle, war · v4

    The particular battle on Mount Gilboa against the Philistines (1 Sam 31).

  15. וְגַם־

    wəḡam · H1571

    and also · v4

    'And moreover'. This is the first step of a rising series ('and also… and also…') that builds to the worst news last.

  16. הַרְבֵּ֞ה

    harbēh · H7235

    much, many · v4

    A verb form ('making many') used as an adverb: 'a great many'. The losses were heavy, not a few stragglers.

  17. נָפַ֤ל

    nāp̄al · H5307

    fell · v4

    'Fell' in the standard military sense, fell in battle, was struck down. The same verb becomes the refrain of David's lament: 'How the mighty have fallen!' (vv. 19, 25, 27).

  18. וַיָּמֻ֔תוּ

    wayyāmutû · H4191

    and they died · v4

    'And they died', the outcome of falling. 'Fell… and died' makes clear these were deaths, not just men wounded or routed.

  19. שָׁא֛וּל

    šāʾûl · H7586

    Saul · v4

    Israel's first king, the Lord's anointed, who had hunted David for years.

  20. וִיהוֹנָתָ֥ן

    wîhônātān · H3083

    and Jonathan · v4

    Saul's son and heir, David's covenant friend (1 Sam 18:3; 20:14-17). His name means 'the LORD has given'.

  21. בְּנ֖וֹ

    bənô · H1121

    his son · v4

    'His son'. It names Jonathan as heir: father and dynastic successor are gone together, so the royal line's future dies with them.

The world behind it
  • Where David is. David is an outlaw from Saul, living as a vassal of the Philistine king Achish at Ziklag. The Philistines had sent him home before the battle (1 Sam 29). On his return he found Ziklag burned by Amalekite raiders, chased them and got everyone back (1 Sam 30). Meanwhile the Philistines crushed Israel on Mount Gilboa, and Saul and three sons, Jonathan among them, died (1 Sam 31). This man arrives on the third day after David's return (2 Sam 1:1-2), so the news is fresh.
  • How bad news arrived. With no other means of communication, news of battle came by runner. A man who arrived with torn clothes and dust on his head was announcing disaster before he spoke (compare 1 Sam 4:12; 2 Sam 15:32). Messengers might expect a reward for important news, and the bearer of bad news was in danger (see 2 Sam 18:19-32).
  • Who is reporting. The man turns out to be an Amalekite (v. 8, 13). Saul lost his kingdom over Amalek (1 Sam 15), and David has just fought Amalekites. The report in this verse agrees with 1 Samuel 31. The man's claim to have killed Saul himself (vv. 6-10) does not, and David later says the man thought he was bringing good news (2 Sam 4:10).
  • What the news means for David. Saul's death removes David's persecutor and opens the way to the throne. It also means the death of the Lord's anointed and of Jonathan, David's covenant friend. The rest of the chapter shows David's response: mourning, fasting, and executing the man who claimed to have killed the king.

From the study of 2 Samuel 1:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

Is the messenger reliable? Do 2 Samuel 1 and 1 Samuel 31 conflict?

  • The Amalekite is lying in vv. 6-10, inventing a role in Saul's death to win David's favour. His summary in v. 4 is true, which lends his later lie credibility.

    1 Sam 31:4-5 says Saul fell on his own sword. 2 Sam 4:10 has David say the man 'thought he was bringing good news'. Saul's crown and armlet (v. 10) could have been picked up by a scavenger on the battlefield. This is the majority view among commentators (e.g. McCarter, Anchor Bible).

  • The two chapters keep different traditions about Saul's death, and the editor placed them side by side without harmonising them.

    Some source-critical scholars point to differences in detail (chariots and horsemen in 2 Sam 1:6 vs. archers in 1 Sam 31:3). The narrative itself, however, gives readers clues that point toward the lying-messenger reading.

in v4

What does ʾăšer do at the start of the reply?

  • It works as a quotation marker, like opening quotation marks ('that').

    The parallel use in 1 Sam 15:20, the Septuagint's *hoti*, and the standard grammars (GKC §157c, Driver).

  • It has a slight explanatory force: 'The fact is that…' or 'It is this:'.

    *ʾăšer* rarely introduces speech, so some see it as marking a formal or emphatic statement. The difference in meaning is small either way.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. דָּבָר, עַם, נָגַד, נָפַל
  • HALOT s.v. עַם ('troops, army'), נָפַל
  • Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §157c (ʾăšer introducing direct speech)
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel, on 2 Sam 1:4
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Comparison with 1 Samuel 4:12-17 and 1 Samuel 31:1-6 (Masoretic Text)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate of 2 Kingdoms / 2 Samuel 1:4

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.