1 Samuel Chapter 31 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 31:1–6
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1Now the Philistines fought against Israel, and the men of Israel fled before them, and many fell slain on Mount Gilboa. 2The Philistines hotly pursued Saul and his sons, and they killed Saul’s sons Jonathan, Abinadab, and Malchishua. 3When the battle intensified against Saul, the archers overtook him and wounded him critically. 4Then Saul said to his armor-bearer, “Draw your sword and run me through with it, or these uncircumcised men will come and run me through and torture me!” But his armor-bearer was terrified and refused to do it. So Saul took his own sword and fell on it. 5When his armor-bearer saw that Saul was dead, he too fell on his own sword and died with him. 6So Saul, his three sons, his armor-bearer, and all his men died together that same day.
What the first hearers heard
To Israelite hearers this verse sounded like the closing of a circle. The book's account of the Philistine wars had opened with Israel "fleeing before the Philistines", its priests killed and the ark captured (1 Sam 4). Israel had then asked for a king "to go out before us and fight our battles" (8:20). Now, at the end of Saul's reign, the same enemy wins the same rout, and the king himself is caught in it. The verse carries no comment. It does not need any: the reader has just heard Samuel's ghost announce this exact outcome (28:19), so the report shows that word coming true.
It also cleared the ground for David. The story has just placed David a hundred miles south recovering his people from the Amalekites (ch. 30). So the hearers knew he had no part in the catastrophe on Gilboa. It was not his treachery and not his doing, and when he came to the throne it would not be by shedding Saul's blood. Finally, the words of this report, fallen and slain, are the words of David's lament (2 Sam 1:19–27). Israel learned to grieve this battle in song: "How the mighty have fallen... O mountains of Gilboa."
From the study of 1 Samuel 31:1.
Verse by verse
-
1Now the Philistines fought against Israel, and the men of Israel fled before them, and many fell slain on Mount Gilboa.
Full study →Meanwhile, while David was away in the south, the Philistines were already locked in battle with Israel. The fighting men of Israel broke, turned their backs on the Philistine line and ran. As they fled, they were cut down, run through by sword and spear, and lay dead across the slopes of the Gilboa ridge.
The Hebrew opens with the enemy's name and an ongoing verb ("the Philistines were fighting"). This swings the story back from David's victory at Ziklag to the northern front, where events have been running at the same time. Then come three quick verbs, "fled... fell... slain", and the whole defeat is told in one breath. The words are chosen with care. Fled before the Philistines repeats the disaster at the start of the book, when Israel fled, the priests died and the ark was taken (1 Sam 4). Fight is the very thing Israel wanted a king to do for them (8:20). Fell and slain are the words David will soon use in his lament: "How the mighty have fallen... slain on your heights" (2 Sam 1:19, 25). This one plain sentence is the beginning of the end of Saul's house. What Samuel's ghost foretold at Endor ("the LORD will give the army of Israel into the hands of the Philistines", 28:19) is now coming true.
-
2The Philistines hotly pursued Saul and his sons, and they killed Saul’s sons Jonathan, Abinadab, and Malchishua.
Full study →The Philistines caught up with Saul and his sons and stuck to them, clinging to the fleeing royal party so closely that there was no escape. Then the Philistines struck them down: first Jonathan, whose name means "the LORD has given," the crown prince and David's sworn friend; then Abinadab; then Malchishua, "my King is help." The verse closes on the words "the sons of Saul."
The verbs move fast, in a quick chain of "and… and…": the enemy catches up, then kills. The verse begins and ends with Saul's name, and his heirs fall in between. Readers who knew the story would hear three echoes:
- Samuel's words at Endor the night before: "tomorrow you and your sons will be with me" (28:19).
- A reversal of Saul's best day, when Israel had "clung after" the fleeing Philistines (14:22). Now the Philistines cling to him.
- A reversal of the victory song "Saul has struck down his thousands." Now it is the Philistines who strike down Saul's sons.
What dies here is not only a group of soldiers. It is the future of Israel's first royal house.
-
3When the battle intensified against Saul, the archers overtook him and wounded him critically.
Full study →The battle grew heavy on Saul. With his sons already dead around him (v. 2), the whole weight of the fighting came down on the king himself. The shooters found him, men armed with the bow. Philistine archers picked out the tall king from a distance and got him within range. And he writhed, exceedingly, before the archers. Saul was seized by anguish because of them. The Hebrew verb is the one used for a woman twisting in labor and for people shaking with terror.
Most English Bibles say Saul was "badly wounded." That may be right, since arrows were flying and pain fits the verb. But the Hebrew does not actually say "wounded." It describes a man convulsed with agony or dread under a rain of arrows. The next verse sharpens the picture: Saul fears what the "uncircumcised" will do to him if they take him alive, and his armor-bearer is "exceedingly afraid," the same "exceedingly" used of Saul here. The verse marks the moment the end becomes unavoidable. Samuel's word at En-dor ("tomorrow you and your sons will be with me," 28:19) is closing in, and the king is pinned under a battle too heavy to carry.
-
4Then Saul said to his armor-bearer, “Draw your sword and run me through with it, or these uncircumcised men will come and run me through and torture me!” But his armor-bearer was terrified and refused to do it. So Saul took his own sword and fell on it.
Full study →Saul, his sons already dead around him and his own body badly wounded by Philistine archers, turns to the man closest to him, his squire, who carries his weapons and fights at his side. He gives a curt order: "Pull out your sword and run me through with it." The reason is not pain but shame: "or these uncircumcised will come and run me through, and make sport of me." In Saul's mouth "uncircumcised" is a slur. It marks the Philistines as outsiders to Israel's covenant, the last people a king of Israel should fall to. It is the same word David spat at Goliath. What Saul dreads is being taken alive and turned into the enemy's plaything: mocked, mutilated, paraded, made a trophy of their gods' victory. Either way he is pierced, but who strikes the blow decides whether he dies with honor or in disgrace.
But the armor-bearer would not. The Hebrew describes a refusal of the will, not a failure of nerve or strength. It gives one reason: "for he was very much afraid." The text does not say of what. Later in the story, though, David asks the man who claims to have killed Saul, "How were you not afraid to lift your hand against the LORD's anointed?" That suggests the squire's fear was at least partly dread of killing the anointed king.
So Saul took the sword and fell on it. The Hebrew says only "the sword," not whose. "Fell" is the word that runs through the whole chapter and into David's lament, "How the mighty have fallen." Saul's fall onto the blade is the last fall of Israel's first king.
-
5When his armor-bearer saw that Saul was dead, he too fell on his own sword and died with him.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
6So Saul, his three sons, his armor-bearer, and all his men died together that same day.
Full study →And so Saul died. With him, in the same blow, died his three sons, the squire who carried his weapons, and even the whole band of men around him. It all happened on that one day, and they went down together.
The Hebrew begins with a single verb in the singular, "and he died, Saul." Everyone else is added after it, like people dragged along in his fall. The sons (Jonathan, Abinadab and Malchishua, 31:2) were his heirs, so their deaths all but end the royal line. The "bearer of his gear" was not a baggage carrier but his sworn battle companion, who had just refused to kill the king and then fell on his own sword beside him (31:4-5). "Also all his men" adds one more group as a climax: his personal fighting retinue. It does not mean the whole army, which the next verse says fled.
"On that day" points back to Samuel's grim words the night before: "Tomorrow you and your sons will be with me" (28:19). The last word, "together," gives the verdict. Israel's first king, the king the people had "asked for," fell with his house and his court in a single stroke.
Where the English drifted
-
in v2
smite (YLT); "smote" in older paraphrases
nākâ (wayyakkû)
- What we hear
- To hit or deliver a blow, sometimes with a quaint or comic flavour.
- What they heard
- In a battle report, to strike down fatally. Verse 6 confirms that all three sons died.
-
in v3
wounded (him critically / badly)
vayyaḥel (ḥul/ḥil)
- What we hear
- A reader takes it as a plain medical fact: arrows struck Saul and he was severely injured, perhaps fatally.
- What they heard
- 'He writhed / was in anguish / trembled.' The verb describes Saul's state of agony or terror because of the archers. It does not say an arrow hit him. A wound is possible, but it is an inference.
-
in v3
sore (KJV: 'the battle went sore… he was sore wounded')
tikhbad / meʾod
- What we hear
- 'Sore' now suggests aching or tender, as in sore muscles.
- What they heard
- In 1611 English, 'sore' as an adverb meant 'grievously, severely.' The Hebrew says the battle was 'heavy' and Saul's anguish was 'exceedingly' great.
-
in v3
hit him (KJV)
vayyimtsaʾuhu (matsaʾ)
- What we hear
- The archers struck Saul with arrows.
- What they heard
- 'They found him,' meaning they located him and reached him. The Hebrew does not say they hit him.
-
in v4
uncircumcised
ʿărēlîm
- What we hear
- A neutral physical description, or an odd detail about Philistine anatomy.
- What they heard
- A contemptuous ethnic and religious slur: outsiders to the covenant, unclean, the most shameful enemy to be defeated by. It was the standard insult for Philistines (Judg 14:3; 1 Sam 17:26).
-
in v4
torture me / abuse me
hitʿalləlû bî
- What we hear
- Inflict physical pain on me (torture), or a vague general 'mistreatment.'
- What they heard
- Toy with me, make sport of me: humiliating a helpless victim for one's own pleasure and as public display. Physical cruelty may be included, but the core is degradation and spectacle.
-
in v4
armor-bearer
nōśēʾ kēlāyw
- What we hear
- In some churches, a personal assistant who serves a pastor; to others, a porter who carries luggage.
- What they heard
- A military squire: the warrior's shield- and weapon-carrier, fighting at his side, finishing off fallen enemies, and bound to him by personal loyalty.
-
in v6
all his men died
kol-anashav
- What we hear
- Saul's entire army was wiped out.
Every word
-
וּפְלִשְׁתִּ֖ים
ufelishtim · H6430G
-
נִלְחָמִ֣ים
nilchamim · H3898A
fighting · v1
A participle, describing action already in progress: 'were fighting'. It reads like 'meanwhile', running the battle in parallel with David's raid in ch. 30. It is the same verb the people used when they asked for a king to 'fight our battles' (8:20).
-
בְּיִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל
beyisra'el · H3478
against Israel · v1
With the verb 'fight', the preposition be- means 'against'. 'Israel' here means the nation's army under Saul.
-
וַיָּנֻ֜סוּ
vayyanusu · H5127
-
אַנְשֵׁ֤י
anshei · H0582
men of · v1, v3, v6
'The men of', meaning the able-bodied men called up to fight. The supplied data files this plural under אֱנוֹשׁ; it works as the plural of אִישׁ ('man').
-
מִפְּנֵ֣י
mippenei · H6440G
from before · v1
Literally 'from the face of'. It pictures men turning their backs on the enemy line in front of them and running.
-
וַיִּפְּל֥וּ
vayyippelu · H5307J
and they fell · v1, v4
'Fell', the ordinary Hebrew word for dying in battle. It comes back as the refrain of David's lament for Saul and Jonathan: 'How the mighty have fallen!' (2 Sam 1:19, 25, 27).
-
חֲלָלִ֖ים
chalalim · H2491A
slain, pierced · v1
Literally 'pierced ones': men run through by sword or spear, usually dead. 'Fell slain' is a set battlefield phrase. David's lament uses the same word for Jonathan lying 'slain on your heights' (2 Sam 1:19, 25).
-
בְּהַ֥ר
behar · H2022G
on the mountain of · v1
'On the mountain/hill country of'. Hebrew har can mean a whole ridge or range, not just a single peak.
-
הַגִּלְבֹּֽעַ׃
haggilboa' · H1533H
Gilboa · v1
The Gilboa ridge, on the south-eastern edge of the Jezreel Valley. It is where Israel had camped (28:4), and where it was cut down while retreating from the valley floor.
-
וַיַּדְבְּקוּ
wayyadbəqû · H1692
to cling; (causative) to overtake, pursue closely · v2
The basic verb means 'stick to, cling'. In this 'make cling' form, used of pursuers, it means to catch up with, stay right on someone's heels. The Philistines latched onto Saul's group and would not let go.
-
אֶת־
’et- · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v2, v4
An untranslatable particle showing that Saul is the one pursued.
-
שָׁאוּל
shā’ûl · H7586G
Saul · v2, v3, v4, v6
Israel's first king, the one named first as the target. The name means 'asked for', which recalls the people asking for a king (1 Samuel 8).
-
בָּנָיו
bānāyw · H1121A
his sons · v2, v6
Saul's sons who were fighting beside him, the princes and heirs of the royal house.
-
וַיַּכּוּ
wayyakkû · H5221
to strike, strike down · v2
In a battle account this ordinary verb for 'strike' means killing blows. The story moves quickly from catching up to killing.
-
יְהוֹנָתָן
yəhônātān · H3083H
Jonathan · v2
'YHWH has given.' He is the eldest son and crown prince, the hero of Michmash (1 Samuel 14) and David's sworn friend (1 Samuel 18–20). He is named first, and readers would feel the loss sharply.
-
אֲבִינָדָב
’ăvînādāv · H0041H
Abinadab · v2
A name meaning roughly 'my (divine) Father is generous/noble'. He appears only here and in the genealogies, and Samuel tells us nothing else about him.
-
מַלְכִּי־
malkî- · H4444
Malchi- (first part of the name) · v2
'My king…', the first part of a two-part name.
-
וַתִּכְבַּ֤ד
vattikhbad · H3513
to be heavy · v3
'And it grew heavy.' The battle became a crushing weight that bore down on Saul. This is the same root as kavod ('weight, honor, glory'), so the word may carry a grim echo in Saul's story.
-
הַמִּלְחָמָה֙
hammilḥamah · H4421
battle, war · v3
'The battle': the specific clash on Mount Gilboa between the Philistine army and Israel (31:1). It is the grammatical subject of 'grew heavy.'
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H413
to, toward, against · v3
'Toward/against': the weight of the fighting moved toward Saul and settled on him. The parallel in Chronicles uses the near-synonym ʿal, 'upon.'
-
וַיִּמְצָאֻ֥הוּ
vayyimtsaʾuhu · H4672
to find, reach, come upon · v3
'And they found him': the archers located Saul and got him within range. The word is 'find,' not 'hit.' It says they reached him, not yet what they did to him.
-
הַמּוֹרִ֖ים
hammorim · H3384
to throw, shoot · v3
'The shooters': a participle from the verb 'to shoot (arrows).' It is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'archers' (compare 2 Sam 11:24; 2 Chr 35:23).
-
בַּקָּ֑שֶׁת
baqqashet · H7198
bow · v3
'With the bow': the long-range weapon, probably the powerful composite bow (wood, horn and sinew glued together). It let Philistine troops strike Saul without closing in.
-
וַיָּ֥חֶל
vayyaḥel · H2342
to writhe, tremble, be in anguish · v3
'And he writhed/trembled.' The verb is used of a woman in labor and of people shaking with terror. As vowelled, it describes Saul's anguish, which could be agony from a wound or quaking fear of the archers. It does not by itself say 'he was wounded.'
-
מְאֹ֖ד
meʾod · H3966
very, exceedingly · v3, v4
'Exceedingly': this intensifies Saul's anguish. The same word in v. 4 describes the armor-bearer, who 'feared exceedingly' (yareʾ meʾod).
-
וַיֹּ֣אמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v4
The usual verb that moves a story forward. It opens Saul's last recorded words.
-
לְנֹשֵׂ֨א
lənōśēʾ · H5375W
to the bearer of · v4, v6
A participle used as a title, 'the one who carries.' Together with the next word it names a recognized military role.
-
כֵלָ֜יו
kēlāyw · H3627
his gear / weapons · v4, v6
Kəlî means any equipment or vessel. Here it means the king's weapons and armor, so the phrase is 'his weapons-bearer,' the king's squire.
-
שְׁלֹ֥ף
šəlōp · H8025
draw out · v4
A curt command: pull the sword from its sheath. Abimelech uses the same words to his own armor-bearer in Judges 9:54.
-
חַרְבְּךָ֣׀
ḥarbəkā · H2719
your sword · v4
The servant's own blade. Saul wants the death blow to come from his own man's hand.
-
וְדָקְרֵ֣נִי
wədoqrēnî · H1856
and pierce me through · v4
A command: run me through. The verb means a thrust that pierces right through the body and kills.
-
בָ֗הּ
bāh · H9034
with it · v4
'With her.' The ending is feminine because 'sword' is a feminine noun in Hebrew.
-
פֶּן־
pen- · H6435
lest · v4
Introduces the outcome Saul is desperate to prevent: 'otherwise…,' 'before…'.
-
יָ֠בוֹאוּ
yābôʾû · H0935G
they come · v4
The enemy closing in. The Philistines are near enough that capture is about to happen.
-
הָעֲרֵלִ֨ים
hāʿărēlîm · H6189
the uncircumcised · v4
A contemptuous label for the Philistines. It marks them as outsiders to Israel's covenant and so as the most shameful people to fall to.
-
הָאֵ֤לֶּה
hāʾēlleh · H0428
these · v4
'These uncircumcised.' The word points at them, as if Saul can see them coming, and it adds scorn.
-
וְהִתְעַלְּלוּ־
wəhitʿalləlû · H5953A
and make sport of / deal wantonly with · v4
This form of the verb means to amuse oneself at someone else's expense: to toy with them, humiliate them, abuse them for sport. Saul fears being made a spectacle of.
-
בִ֔י
bî · H9030
with me / on me · v4
Marks Saul as the one they would toy with.
-
וְלֹ֤א
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v4
Negates the next verb, which nearly always appears in the negative: 'was not willing.'
-
אָבָה֙
ʾābâ · H0014
was willing · v4
With 'not' it means a settled refusal of the will, not a physical inability. He would not do it.
-
כִּ֥י
kî · H3588A
for, because · v4
Gives the narrator's one explanation for the refusal.
-
יָרֵ֖א
yārēʾ · H3372G
he feared · v4
He was afraid. The text does not say of what: of killing the anointed king, of the deed itself, or just terror in the rout.
-
וַיִּקַּ֤ח
wayyiqqaḥ · H3947G
and he took · v4
Saul acts himself. The brief chain of verbs (took… fell) moves fast.
-
עָלֶֽיהָ׃
ʿāleyhā · H5921A
upon it · v4
'Upon her,' the feminine sword again. The verse ends on the blade.
-
וַיָּ֣מָת
vayyamot · H4191
and he died · v6
The ordinary verb for dying, in the form Hebrew uses to move a story forward ("and then he died"). It is singular because it agrees with the first name in the list, Saul, even though everyone listed after him is also its subject. This puts Saul at the head of the catastrophe.
-
וּשְׁלֹ֣שֶׁת
ushloshet · H7969
and three (of) · v6
"And the three of." These are the three sons named in 31:2: Jonathan, Abinadab and Malchishua. Another son, Ishbosheth (also called Eshbaal), was not at the battle and survived (2 Samuel 2:8).
-
גַּ֧ם
gam · H1571
also, even · v6
"Also, even." It breaks the run of "and…and…" and adds one more group as a climax: on top of everyone already named, his men died too.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all · v6
"All of." It stresses how complete the loss was. Its scope depends on what "his men" means (see below).
-
בַּיּ֥וֹם
bayyom · H3117G
on the day · v6
"On the day." It fixes everything on one single day of disaster.
-
הַה֖וּא
hahu · H1931
that · v6
"That (day)." It points back to the battle on Mount Gilboa. It also recalls Samuel's words the night before: "Tomorrow you and your sons will be with me" (28:19).
-
יַחְדָּֽו׃
yachdav · H3162B
together · v6
"Together, all at once, as one." It is the last word of the verse, so the stress falls on it: king, heirs, squire and retinue went down as one body.
The world behind it
The narrative jump. Chapters 28–30 do not run in time order. Saul's night visit to the medium at Endor (ch. 28) and David's dismissal from the Philistine army and raid on the Amalekites (chs. 29–30) overlap with the build-up to this battle. The noun-first, ongoing-verb opening of 31:1 picks up the thread from 29:11 ("the Philistines went up to Jezreel"). It tells the reader that the battle was being fought while David was far south at Ziklag. That matters for the story: David is nowhere near the battle in which Saul dies.
Why the Jezreel Valley. The Philistines held five cities on the southern coastal plain (Gaza, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Gath, Ekron). Here they marched far north to Aphek (29:1) and then into the Jezreel Valley, the great east–west corridor carrying the international coast road toward Beth-shan and the Jordan. Controlling it cut the northern tribes off from Saul's heartland in Benjamin and Ephraim. It also let the Philistines use their chariots on open, level ground (2 Sam 1:6 mentions "chariots and horsemen"). Israel's militia was best suited to hill country. It camped by the spring at Jezreel and on the Gilboa ridge (28:4; 29:1) and seems to have been broken in the valley and cut down as it retreated up the slopes.
What a rout meant. In ancient battle, most killing happened after a line broke and men ran. A fleeing soldier could not defend himself, and the pursuing side, often with chariots, could cut down whoever it caught. So "fled... and fell slain" describes one connected event. The verbs of v. 2 ("hotly pursued") carry on this picture as the pursuit closes on Saul and his sons.
Afterward. The Philistines hung the bodies of Saul and his sons on the wall of Beth-shan (vv. 8–10), at the eastern end of the valley. This shows how far their control had reached. For a time Israel's land west of the Jordan lay open to them (v. 7).
From the study of 1 Samuel 31:1.
Where scholars differ
in v2
How do Saul's sons in this verse relate to the list in 1 Samuel 14:49 (Jonathan, Ishvi, Malchishua)?
-
Ishvi is another name for Ish-bosheth/Eshbaal, who did not fight at Gilboa. Abinadab is simply missing from the earlier list (perhaps because he was born later or was omitted).
1 Chronicles 8:33 and 9:39 list four sons, including both Abinadab and Eshbaal. 'Ishvi' (possibly 'man of YHWH', from *'ish-yo*) could be a softened form of Ish-baal/Eshbaal, in the same way that 'bosheth' ('shame') replaced 'baal' in 2 Samuel.
-
Ishvi is another name for Abinadab.
The two lists would then match for the sons who fell in battle, with Eshbaal being a younger son who was left out of 14:49. This position has less direct support in the text.
in v2
Why does Jonathan, presented favourably throughout, die along with his father?
-
It is the shared fate of the royal house: judgment on the king falls on his dynasty as a whole.
28:19 includes 'your sons' in the sentence on Saul. 1 Chronicles 10:6 says 'all his house died together'. In the ancient world a royal line stood or fell as a unit.
-
The narrative is about the transfer of the kingdom, and Jonathan's death clears David's path without any guilt on David's part. The text does not present it as a punishment for Jonathan.
Jonathan himself had expected David to be king (23:17). David mourns him without reproach (2 Samuel 1:23, 26). The text never blames Jonathan.
in v3
Was Saul physically wounded, or overcome with terror, in v. 3?
-
He was badly wounded by arrows (the traditional reading).
The Septuagint ('he was wounded in the abdomen') and the Vulgate ('severely wounded') both read it that way. Archers had just 'found' him, so a wound is the natural result. The verb ḥul/ḥil can describe writhing pain. 2 Sam 1:9 pictures Saul still alive but stricken. Most modern translations (KJV, BSB, NIV, ESV, NASB, NLT) and many commentators follow this view.
-
He writhed or trembled in fear of the archers.
As vowelled in the Masoretic text, the verb is ḥul/ḥil ('writhe, tremble, be in anguish'), not ḥalal ('pierce'). With 'from/because of' it closely matches Deut 2:25 ('tremble and writhe because of you'). In v. 4 Saul gives fear of abuse, not a mortal wound, as his reason. The armor-bearer's 'exceedingly afraid' (yareʾ meʾod) echoes Saul's 'writhed exceedingly' (yaḥel meʾod). Some lexicons (HALOT) and translators allow 'be afraid' here.
-
The text deliberately leaves it open: anguish whatever its cause.
The verb names a state of anguish, not its cause. Pain and terror could both be present, and the narrator may simply portray a broken king without specifying a wound.
in v3
Is 'men with the bow' (ʾanashim baqqashet) original?
-
It is original: a narrative restatement for emphasis.
Hebrew narrative often adds a clarifying phrase in apposition (one noun renaming another). The Septuagint also has the doubled expression ('javelin-men, men archers').
-
It is a secondary addition or blend of readings.
1 Chronicles 10:3 has the smoother 'the shooters with the bow' without 'men.' The redundancy looks like a clarifying note or two readings combined.
in v4
How does 1 Samuel 31:4 relate to the Amalekite's account in 2 Samuel 1:6–10, where he claims he killed Saul at Saul's request?
-
The Amalekite is lying, hoping for a reward from David; 1 Samuel 31 is the narrator's true account.
The narrator's own voice in 31:4–5 says Saul fell on the sword and his armor-bearer saw he was dead. The Amalekite's story contradicts it in details (Saul leaning on a spear, chariots close by), and he produces the crown and armlet as if to win favor (2 Sam 1:10). Most modern commentators (e.g. McCarter, Klein, Alter) hold this view.
-
Both accounts are true: the fall did not kill Saul outright, and the Amalekite finished him.
Josephus (Ant. 6.370–372) and some later harmonizers take this view. However, 31:5 says the armor-bearer 'saw that Saul was dead,' which counts against it.
-
Two different traditions about Saul's death were placed side by side.
Some source critics point to the difference in style and details. Even so, the final form of the book reads coherently as the narrator's truth followed by the Amalekite's self-serving lie.
in v4
What was the armor-bearer afraid of?
-
Dread of killing the LORD's anointed.
This fits the theme of Samuel (1 Sam 24:6; 26:9–11) and especially 2 Samuel 1:14, where David asks the Amalekite 'How were you not afraid (yārēʾ) to put out your hand against the LORD's anointed?', using the same verb. The two scenes appear designed to mirror each other.
-
Plain terror in the chaos of defeat.
The text gives no object for the fear, and the scene is a rout. BSB, WEB and others render it 'terrified.' Yet he shows no fear of death, since he then takes his own life (v. 5).
in v4
Does the narrative pass judgment on the way Saul died?
-
The narrator records it without condemning it, and Israel's tradition remembered it as a death that preserved his honor.
The verse itself makes no evaluation. The men of Jabesh honor the body (31:11–13), and David's lament praises Saul (2 Sam 1:19–27). Rabbinic tradition (Genesis Rabbah 34:13 on Gen 9:5) treats Saul's case as an exception to the ban on taking one's own life, and Josephus praises his courage (Ant. 6.344–350).
-
The death is the climax of divine judgment on Saul.
28:19 announces the death as judgment, and 1 Chronicles 10:13–14 says the LORD 'put him to death' for unfaithfulness and consulting a medium. Note that Chronicles names those offenses, not the manner of his death. Later Christian moral theology (from Augustine, City of God 1) condemned suicide generally, which shaped how many readers later viewed this scene.
in v6
Who are "all his men," and is the phrase original?
-
Saul's personal retinue or bodyguard, as part of the original Hebrew text.
"His men" is a common way to speak of a leader's own band (compare David's men in 1 Samuel 23-30). Verses 1 and 7 separate the fleeing "men of Israel" from those who died with the king.
-
A later expansion; the earliest text listed only Saul, his sons and his armor-bearer.
The main Septuagint witnesses lack the phrase, and 1 Chronicles 10:6 has a different phrase ("all his house") in its place. This suggests the end of the list varied as the text was handed down.
-
Hebrew "all his men" and Chronicles' "all his house" both express one idea: the destruction of Saul's royal establishment, not literally every soldier or relative.
Ishbosheth, Abner and Mephibosheth all survive (2 Samuel 2:8; 4:4), so both phrases have to be read as summaries of total ruin for the house, not literal head counts.
Sources
- BDB s.v. לָחַם, נוּס, נָפַל, חָלָל I
- HALOT s.v. חָלָל I ('pierced, fatally wounded, slain')
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 31:1 and the order of chs. 28–31
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Robert Alter, The David Story, notes on 1 Sam 31 and 2 Sam 1
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 28–31 (Jezreel, Gilboa, Beth-shan)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 31:1; 1 Chronicles 10:1 (Masoretic Text)
- BDB s.v. דָּבַק (hiphil 'pursue closely, overtake')
- HALOT s.v. דבק, נכה
- HALOT s.v. מַלְכִּישׁוּעַ, אֲבִינָדָב
- Septuagint 1 Reigns (1 Samuel) 31:2
- 1 Chronicles 10:1–14 (parallel account)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible) on 14:49 and 31:2
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 31
- BDB s.v. כָּבֵד; חוּל/חִיל; יָרָה; מָצָא
- HALOT s.v. חיל I; כבד; ירה
- 1 Chronicles 10:3 (parallel text, MT)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 31:3 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, 1 Regum 31:3
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), notes on 31:3
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10), on ch. 31
- BDB s.v. עָלַל, דָּקַר, אָבָה, כְּלִי
- HALOT s.v. עלל (hitp.), עָרֵל, דקר
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 6.344–372
- Genesis Rabbah 34:13
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 31:3–4
- BDB and HALOT s.v. מוּת, כְּלִי, יַחְדָּו, אִישׁ
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), notes on 31:6
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10), on 31:1-13
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
- Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (Old Testament Library), on 1 Chronicles 10:6
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 31:6; Vulgate, 1 Samuel 31:6
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.