1 Samuel
1 Samuel tells how Israel moved from rule by judges to rule by kings, through the stories of Samuel the prophet, Saul the first king, and David's rise. People read it for its well-known stories (Hannah's prayer, David and Goliath, Saul and the medium at Endor) and for its themes: God choosing the unlikely, obedience over ritual, and the start of the promise of a king from David's line.
- Hebrew (with some Aramaic)
- In every Bible
Why it's in the Bible, and the doubts
The case for
-
Every Jewish and Christian community that kept a scripture has received 1 Samuel, and no one is recorded disputing it.
The evidence
It sits among the Former Prophets in the Hebrew Bible and appears in every Christian canon list, from Melito of Sardis (c. 170) and Athanasius (367) to the Ethiopian church. Neither the Reformers nor Trent ever debated it.
-
Jesus and the apostles treated its events as real history with lessons for their day.
The evidence
Jesus defends his disciples by citing David eating the holy bread at Nob (Mark 2:25–26, from 1 Samuel 21). Paul's sermon in Acts 13:20–22 retells Samuel, Saul and David, quoting God's choice of 'a man after my own heart' (1 Samuel 13:14).
-
Several details fit the early Iron Age setting, and the book is frank about its heroes' failings.
The evidence
The 'pim' weight of 1 Samuel 13:21, a word later readers no longer understood, has been found on actual stone weights. The Tel Dan inscription (9th century BC) names the 'House of David', and the book openly describes the sins of Eli's sons, Saul and David.
The case against
-
Scholars disagree over how much of the story can be confirmed as history.
The evidence
There is no record of Samuel, Saul or David outside the Bible from their own time, and the 'House of David' inscription dates about 150 years after David. Some archaeologists (e.g. Israel Finkelstein) argue that 10th-century Judah was a small chiefdom, not the kingdom the stories suggest, while others point to sites like Khirbet Qeiyafa as evidence on the other side.
-
The book contains repeated stories and tensions that suggest several sources were joined together.
The evidence
David is introduced to Saul twice (16:14–23 and 17:55–58), Saul is rejected as king twice (chapters 13 and 15), and David spares Saul's life in two very similar scenes (chapters 24 and 26). 2 Samuel 21:19 says Elhanan killed Goliath, and 1 Chronicles 20:5 tries to reconcile the two accounts.
-
Its Hebrew text has been poorly preserved, and the early versions differ a great deal.
The evidence
The standard Hebrew text has many scribal errors; 13:1 even leaves Saul's age and length of reign incomplete. The Greek Septuagint's David-and-Goliath story is about 45% shorter, and the Dead Sea Scroll 4QSamᵃ has a paragraph about Nahash (at chapter 11) that the standard Hebrew lacks. Some readers are also troubled by the command to wipe out the Amalekites (chapter 15).
Both sides are written as strongly as the honest evidence allows, so you can decide for yourself. Researched by claude-opus-5-5.
When, where and by whom
Jewish tradition (Talmud, Bava Batra 14b–15a) says Samuel wrote it, and the prophets Gad and Nathan finished it after his death (compare 1 Chronicles 29:29). Most scholars see it as part of a larger history (Deuteronomy to Kings) put together in Judah around the 7th–6th centuries BC from older sources such as an 'Ark Narrative' and a 'History of David's Rise'. 1 and 2 Samuel were originally one book; the Greek Bible split it as '1–2 Kingdoms'.
Jesus, the New Testament and this book
- Jesus cites David eating the consecrated bread (1 Samuel 21:1–6) in the Sabbath debate (Mark 2:25–26; Matthew 12:3–4; Luke 6:3–4). (strong link)
- Paul's sermon in Pisidian Antioch retells Samuel, Saul's reign and David's choosing, quoting 1 Samuel 13:14 (Acts 13:20–22). (strong link)
- Mary's Magnificat (Luke 1:46–55) closely follows Hannah's song (1 Samuel 2:1–10): the humble are lifted up, the proud brought down, the hungry fed. (strong link)
- Luke 2:52 on the boy Jesus growing 'in favor with God and man' echoes the young Samuel in 1 Samuel 2:26. (strong link)
- The Messiah as David's son, born in David's town of Bethlehem, builds on David's anointing at Bethlehem (1 Samuel 16; compare John 7:42; Luke 2:4). (strong link)
- Samuel is named as the first in the line of prophets and among the heroes of faith (Acts 3:24; Hebrews 11:32). (strong link)
- 'To obey is better than sacrifice' (1 Samuel 15:22) shares the idea behind the scribe's words to Jesus that love is 'more than all burnt offerings' (Mark 12:33). (possible link)
How it came down to us
Fragments of three Samuel scrolls found at Qumran (4QSamᵃ, 4QSamᵇ, 4QSamᶜ) are among the oldest biblical manuscripts; 4QSamᵇ may date to the 3rd century BC. These scrolls often agree with the Greek Septuagint (complete in Codex Vaticanus, 4th century AD) against the medieval Hebrew Masoretic Text (Aleppo Codex, 10th century; Leningrad Codex, 1008). Jewish scribes kept copying it in Hebrew, and Christians copied it in Greek, Latin, Syriac and Ge'ez. Josephus seems to have used a text like 4QSamᵃ, and some modern translations, such as the NRSV, add readings from it.
- Dead Sea Scrolls 4QSamᵃ, 4QSamᵇ, 4QSamᶜ (Cross, Parry, Ulrich, DJD XVII)
- Masoretic Text (Aleppo and Leningrad Codices) and Septuagint (Codex Vaticanus)
- Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 14b–15a
- Early canon lists: Melito of Sardis, Athanasius' 39th Festal Letter (367)
- Tel Dan inscription; pim weights; Khirbet Qeiyafa excavation reports
- Critical commentaries (P. Kyle McCarter, Anchor Bible; Robert Alter) and debates on Deuteronomistic History and archaeology (Finkelstein, Garfinkel)
- New Testament passages: Mark 2, Luke 1–2, Acts 3 and 13, Hebrews 11