2 Samuel Chapter 2 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 2:23–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23But Asahel refused to turn away. So Abner thrust the butt of his spear into his stomach, and it came out his back, and he fell dead on the spot. And every man paused when he came to the place where Asahel had fallen and died. 24But Joab and Abishai pursued Abner. By sunset, they had gone as far as the hill of Ammah opposite Giah on the way to the wilderness of Gibeon.

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers, this verse was a turning point in the story of how David's kingdom was won. It answers three questions.

  • Who was to blame? The narrator records that Asahel refused after two warnings. Abner did not hunt him down. He killed a pursuer in open battle, and reluctantly. So when Joab later kills Abner in the gate of Hebron, under cover of peace talks, the audience is meant to see that act as private revenge, not justice. This matters for David's innocence: the story is careful to show that David did not plot Abner's death (3:28–39).
  • The cost of the war. The double "he fell… and died" and the soldiers stopping at the body make Asahel's death a moment of shared grief. Brother against brother, Israel against Judah, the war is killing the nation's best young men (compare Abner's cry in 2:26, "Must the sword devour forever?").
  • The start of a chain. The rare word ḥomesh (belly) marks a series of killings by thrusts to the belly (Asahel, Abner, Ishbosheth, Amasa). Hearers would recognise a pattern of blood calling for blood around David's throne. Joab and his brothers, the sons of Zeruiah, are "too hard" for David (3:39), and the pattern is only settled in 1 Kings 2.

From the study of 2 Samuel 2:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 23But Asahel refused to turn away. So Abner thrust the butt of his spear into his stomach, and it came out his back, and he fell dead on the spot. And every man paused when he came to the place where Asahel had fallen and died.

    Asahel would not turn aside. He had been told twice, and he kept coming after Abner. So Abner struck him with the back end of his spear, the sharp butt-spike meant for planting the spear in the ground. He drove it into the soft belly with such force (and with Asahel running straight onto it) that the spear came out through his back. The man who would not stop coming after Abner was struck with the spear's after-end, and it came out after him. He went down there and died where he stood, instantly. Then, as the men of Judah came up behind in the chase, each one reached the spot where Asahel had fallen and died, and each one stopped short. David's nephew, Joab's swift younger brother, lay on the path. The pursuit stalled there. Only his brothers ran on (v. 24). The belly wound itself will be repaid in kind when Joab later strikes Abner in the same place (3:27).

    Full study →
  2. 24But Joab and Abishai pursued Abner. By sunset, they had gone as far as the hill of Ammah opposite Giah on the way to the wilderness of Gibeon.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    under the fifth [rib] (KJV, YLT)

    ḥomesh

    What we hear
    A precise wound between the ribs, as if Abner aimed at a particular rib.
    What they heard
    The belly or abdomen, the soft area below the ribs. The bracketed "rib" is not in the Hebrew at all.
  • in v23

    butt of his spear

    ʾaḥarei haḥanit

    What we hear
    The blunt wooden end of a stick, which leaves the reader wondering how it could go through a man.
    What they heard
    The rear end of the spear, which commonly carried a sharp metal spike for planting it in the ground. It was a real weapon.
  • in v23

    died under it (YLT)

    taḥtav

    What we hear
    He died beneath the spear.
    What they heard
    He died "in his place": on the spot, instantly.
Every word
  1. וַיְמָאֵ֣ן

    vaymaʾen · H3985

    to refuse · v23

    "And he refused." The verb is a deliberate, settled refusal (the same verb is used of Pharaoh refusing to let Israel go). Asahel has now heard two warnings (vv. 21–22) and chooses to keep coming.

  2. לָס֗וּר

    lasur · H5493I

    to turn aside · v23

    "To turn aside." This picks up Abner's exact words in vv. 21–22 ("turn aside to your right or left… turn aside from after me"). The repetition makes the refusal pointed: Abner kept offering a way out, and Asahel would not take it.

  3. וַיַּכֵּ֣הוּ

    vayyakkehu · H5221

    to strike · v23

    "And he struck him." A common word for any blow, often a fatal one. It echoes Abner's question in v. 22, "Why should I strike you (ʾakkekka) to the ground?" What he hoped to avoid now happens.

  4. אַבְנֵר֩

    ʾAvner · H0074

    Abner · v23

    Abner, Saul's cousin and army commander, now the real power behind Saul's son Ishbosheth. Naming him as the subject makes clear who carries responsibility for the blow, which matters for the blood feud that follows.

  5. בְּאַחֲרֵ֨י

    beʾaḥarei · H0310A

    behind, back part · v23

    "With the back part of." This is the rear end of the spear, the butt. The word is one of a chain of "behind/after" words: Asahel would not stop coming "after" Abner (v. 22), Abner hits him with the spear's "back end", and it comes out his "back".

  6. הַחֲנִ֜ית

    haḥanit · H2595

    spear · v23

    "The spear." A heavy thrusting spear, the weapon of a commander (Saul's own weapon is a ḥanit, 1 Sam 18:10–11; 26:7). Its butt usually carried a pointed metal cap so it could be planted in the ground, which is how the back end could go through a man.

  7. אֶל־

    ʾel- · H0413

    to, into · v23

    "Into." It marks where the blow lands.

  8. הַחֹ֗מֶשׁ

    haḥomesh · H2570

    belly, abdomen · v23

    "The belly." The soft abdomen below the ribs. The word appears only in 2 Samuel, and every time it marks a killing (2:23; 3:27; 4:6; 20:10). Here it starts the chain: Joab will later kill Abner with a blow to the same spot "for the blood of Asahel his brother" (3:27).

  9. וַתֵּצֵ֤א

    vatteṣeʾ · H3318G

    to go out · v23

    "And it went out." The verb is feminine to match the spear (ḥanit is a feminine noun). The thrust passes all the way through the body, which shows the force of the blow, probably added to by Asahel running into it at full speed.

  10. וַיִּפָּל־

    vayyippol- · H5307G

    to fall · v23

    "And he fell." The swift runner of v. 18 goes down in the middle of his chase.

  11. שָׁ֖ם

    sham · H8033G

    there · v23

    "There." It fixes attention on the spot, which becomes important in the second half of the verse.

  12. וַיָּ֣מָת

    vayyamot · H4191

    to die · v23

    "And he died." Plain and final.

  13. תַּחְתָּ֑יו

    taḥtav · H8478I

    in his place · v23

    Literally "under him" or "in his place": he died right where he stood, on the spot. It means instant death. It does not mean "under it" (the spear), as YLT's wording might suggest.

  14. וַיְהִ֡י

    vayhi · H1961

    and it was · v23

    "And it came to pass." This opens a new scene: what happened afterward at that spot.

  15. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all, every · v23

    "Every (one)." Not one man passed by without stopping.

  16. הַבָּ֣א

    habbaʾ · H0935G

    coming · v23

    "The one coming." The participle pictures a steady stream of pursuing soldiers of Judah arriving at the spot, one after another.

  17. הַמָּקוֹם֩

    hammaqom · H4725

    place · v23

    "The place." The bare word turns the spot of the killing into a marked place, a site where the pursuit broke off.

  18. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾasher- · H0834A

    which, where · v23

    It introduces the relative clause: "where".

  19. עֲשָׂהאֵ֛ל

    ʿAsahʾel · H6214G

    Asahel · v23

    Asahel ("God has made"), youngest son of Zeruiah, David's sister, and so David's nephew and Joab's brother. He is named only here in this verse, at the moment he is mourned.

  20. וַֽיַּעֲמֹֽדוּ׃

    vayyaʿamodu · H5975G

    to stand, stop · v23

    "And they stood still," that is, they halted. The pursuers stop at the body in shock and grief, and the chase loses its momentum. Joab and Abishai are the exception (v. 24). The same verb comes back in v. 28 when Joab's horn finally makes everyone "stand still".

The world behind it

Civil war after Saul. After Saul and Jonathan died (around 1000 BC), David ruled Judah from Hebron. Abner, Saul's cousin and commander, had set up Saul's surviving son Ishbosheth (Ish-bosheth) as king over the northern tribes from Mahanaim (2:8–11). The two forces met at the pool of Gibeon. A contest between twelve champions from each side ended with all of them killed, and then a full battle broke out, which Abner's side lost (2:12–17).

Why Asahel chased Abner. Asahel was the youngest of the three sons of Zeruiah, David's sister (1 Chr 2:16), "as swift of foot as a wild gazelle" (2:18), and later listed among David's elite Thirty (23:24). Killing or capturing the enemy commander was the greatest prize a young warrior could win. Abner told him to settle for a lesser man and take his armour as a trophy (2:21).

Blood vengeance. Abner's second warning, "How could I show my face to your brother Joab?" (2:22), shows what was at stake. In Israel's kinship system, the nearest male relative (the goʾel, "redeemer/avenger") had a duty to avenge a family member's blood (Num 35:19; Deut 19:6, 12). Abner knew that killing Asahel would start a feud with Joab, David's most dangerous soldier. That is exactly what happened: Joab killed Abner at the gate of Hebron "for the blood of Asahel his brother" (3:27, 30). David condemned it as shedding "the blood of war in peacetime" (1 Kgs 2:5). In other words, Asahel's death counted as a killing in battle, not as murder.

The weapon. The ḥanit was a heavy thrusting spear. Its butt often had a pointed metal cap so it could stand upright in the ground (1 Sam 26:7), which is why the "back end" could kill.

From the study of 2 Samuel 2:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

Why did Abner use the butt end of the spear?

  • He was trying not to kill. He hoped to stop or knock down Asahel without the spearhead, but the blow proved fatal.

    Abner's two warnings and his stated wish to avoid a feud with Joab (vv. 21–22) show he did not want Asahel dead.

  • It was a practical backward thrust. Running away with a pursuer right on his heels, Abner jabbed backward with the butt-spike without turning around, and Asahel's momentum drove it through.

    The text says Asahel was "after" him (v. 22). A butt-spike was sharp (1 Sam 26:7). The spear passing right through the body suggests the combined force of the thrust and the runner's own speed. This view is favoured by several modern commentators (e.g. McCarter, Alter).

in v23

What does ḥomesh mean?

  • Belly or abdomen.

    Standard lexicons (BDB, HALOT). All four uses describe fatal thrusts in 2 Samuel, and 20:10 has the bowels spilling out. Ancient versions point to the loin or groin.

  • The fifth rib.

    Medieval Jewish interpretation based on ḥamesh, "five" (Rashi). This view was followed by the KJV. It rests on spelling, not on usage, and is now generally abandoned.

in v23

Did Abner incur blood-guilt by killing Asahel?

  • No. It was a lawful killing in battle.

    Asahel was warned twice and refused. David later condemns Joab for shedding "the blood of war in peacetime" (1 Kgs 2:5) and declares himself innocent of Abner's blood (3:28).

  • In the eyes of the clan, yes: the family's duty to avenge still applied.

    3:27 and 3:30 present Joab and Abishai acting "for the blood of Asahel their brother", which reflects the duty of the kinsman-avenger (Num 35:19), even though the narrator does not endorse it.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חֹמֶשׁ (II, 'belly')
  • HALOT s.v. חֹמֶשׁ
  • BDB s.v. מָאֵן
  • BDB s.v. תַּחַת
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
  • Rashi on 2 Samuel 2:23
  • Septuagint (2 Kingdoms 2:23)
  • Vulgate (2 Samuel 2:23)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.