Judges Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Judges 8:8–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8From there he went up to Penuel and asked the same from them, but the men of Penuel gave the same response as the men of Succoth. 9So Gideon told the men of Penuel, “When I return in triumph, I will tear down this tower!”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the Gideon cycle, this short verse did several things:

  • It showed Israel divided. Judges keeps returning to tribes that would not join a fight (compare 5:15–17, where Reuben, Gilead, Dan and Asher stayed home in Deborah's war). Here two Israelite towns side with whoever seems likely to win. The refusal is repeated, so it reads as a pattern, not one town's mistake.
  • It set up the payoff. The doubled refusal (v. 8) and doubled threat (vv. 7, 9) prepare for vv. 13–17, where Gideon returns, flogs Succoth's leaders with thorns, tears down Penuel's tower and kills its men. A listener knew the threat would be carried out.
  • It raised an uncomfortable question. The Gideon who in ch. 6 doubted himself is becoming a man who takes revenge on fellow Israelites, and who soon makes the ephod that "became a snare" (8:27). Many readers think the narrator lets the reader feel both things: the towns' disloyalty was real, and Gideon's response goes far past justice. The parallel with Jacob, whose meeting with God at Penuel ended in reconciliation, makes the contrast sharper.
  • It played on the name. "Face of God" refusing God's deliverer is the kind of name-irony Hebrew storytelling enjoys.

From the study of Judges 8:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8From there he went up to Penuel and asked the same from them, but the men of Penuel gave the same response as the men of Succoth.

    From Succoth, down on the floor of the Jordan valley, Gideon led his worn-out band higher up the Jabbok valley to the next Israelite town, Penuel, and made the same plea word for word: give my men bread, they are exhausted, and we are chasing the kings of Midian. The men of Penuel, speaking as a town and secure behind their fortified tower, gave him the same answer Succoth had given. In effect: Have you already got the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna? Show us the kings' hands, cut off as proof, and then we will feed your army. So the town that carried the name "Face of God", where Jacob once met God face to face, turned its face away from the deliverer God had raised up. The verse is built as a mirror ("he spoke to them like this… they answered just as Succoth answered") so that the second refusal echoes the first. The listener knows by now what Gideon will say next, and that what comes back down this road will be judgment, not thanks.

    Full study →
  2. 9So Gideon told the men of Penuel, “When I return in triumph, I will tear down this tower!”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    the men of Penuel

    ʾanshê Pənûʾēl

    What we hear
    Some local residents, a few individuals who happened to say no.
    What they heard
    The town's adult male citizens acting as its governing body. The refusal was an official civic decision binding the whole town.
Every word
  1. וַיַּ֤עַל

    wayyaʿal · H5927G

    go up, ascend · v8

    'And he went up.' Literal: Gideon climbs from Succoth on the Jordan valley floor eastward and higher up the Jabbok valley to Penuel. The 'and' form moves the story on to the next step.

  2. מִשָּׁם֙

    mishshām · H8033G

    there; from there · v8

    'From there,' meaning from Succoth, where he had just been turned down (vv. 5–7). It ties the two refusals together in one line of travel.

  3. פְּנוּאֵ֔ל

    Pənûʾēl · H6439G

    Penuel / Peniel ('face of God') · v8

    The destination, given with no preposition, the normal Hebrew way of marking where someone goes. This is the place where Jacob said he had 'seen God face to face' (Genesis 32:30–31), and a Hebrew hearer would know the story behind the name.

  4. וַיְדַבֵּ֥ר

    wayədabbēr · H1696G

    speak · v8

    'And he spoke.' A general verb for speaking. Here it stands for the request repeated from v. 5: bread for his worn-out men.

  5. אֲלֵיהֶ֖ם

    ʾălêhem · H0413

    to, toward · v8

    'To them.' 'Them' points ahead to the men of Penuel, who are named only in the next clause, as often happens in Hebrew storytelling.

  6. כָּזֹ֑את

    kāzōʾt · H2063

    like this, in the same way · v8

    'Like this,' meaning the same words as at Succoth. The narrator doesn't repeat the speech. The short word tells the reader it was the same plea word for word.

  7. וַיַּעֲנ֤וּ

    wayyaʿănû · H6030B

    answer, respond · v8

    'And they answered.' A plural verb: the town answers as one body. Their answer, a refusal, mirrors v. 6.

  8. אוֹתוֹ֙

    ʾôtô · H0853

    direct-object marker + 'him' · v8

    'Him,' meaning Gideon. The particle marks him as the person the answer is directed at. English has no separate word for it.

  9. אַנְשֵׁ֣י

    ʾanshê · H0582

    men (of) · v8

    'The men of.' A common way to name a town's adult male citizens acting together, the people who make the decisions. It doesn't mean a few bystanders.

  10. כַּאֲשֶׁ֥ר

    kaʾăsher · H0834D

    just as, according as · v8

    'Just as.' It marks an exact match: the answer had the same content and the same contempt.

  11. סֻכּֽוֹת׃

    Sukkôt · H5523G

    Succoth ('booths, shelters') · v8

    The first town that refused, a few miles back down the valley. Ending the verse on its name sets the two towns side by side as partners in the refusal.

The world behind it

Where this happens. After the night attack in the Jezreel valley (Judges 7), the surviving Midianite force fled east across the Jordan. Gideon crossed after them with 300 men, "exhausted yet pursuing" (8:4). Succoth and Penuel were Israelite towns (Gadite territory, Joshua 13:27) along the Jabbok, the main river route from the Jordan valley up into the hills of Gilead and on toward the desert where the Midianites lived. Penuel stood higher up the valley than Succoth, which is why Gideon "went up". Penuel had a migdal, a fortified tower or citadel (v. 9). Jeroboam later fortified the site (1 Kings 12:25).

What was being asked. An army on the move lived off the towns along its route. Kin and tribal ties obliged Israelite towns to supply Israelite fighters. Gideon asks only for "loaves of bread" (v. 5), the bare minimum.

Why the towns refused. Their reply in v. 6 asks whether "the palm/hand of Zebah and Zalmunna" is already in Gideon's hand. Most commentators connect this to the practice of cutting off hands from enemy dead as proof of a kill and for counting. The practice is well documented in Egyptian records: tomb inscriptions such as that of Ahmose son of Ebana, and the battle reliefs of Ramesses III at Medinet Habu show piles of severed hands. The towns are saying: bring proof of victory first. Their caution made sense. Midianite raiders came every year (6:3–6), and a town that fed Gideon's pursuers would face reprisal if the Midianite kings escaped. Penuel was a fortified, self-reliant town, and it chose neutrality.

Echoes a Hebrew hearer would catch. In Genesis 32–33 Jacob passes through these same two places in the same order. He wrestles God at Peniel/Penuel ("face of God") and then builds booths at Succoth ("booths"). That ancestral story of meeting God and being reconciled with a brother hangs over a scene where brothers refuse each other.

From the study of Judges 8:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

Where were Penuel and Succoth?

  • Penuel = Tell edh-Dhahab esh-Sherqiyeh (the eastern of the twin hills on the Jabbok); Succoth = Tell Deir ʿAlla.

    Fits Genesis 32–33 and the order of Gideon's route here, with Penuel higher up the river. The twin hills dominate the Jabbok gorge. Deir ʿAlla matches the Jordan-valley setting of Succoth and the mention of bronze casting in 1 Kings 7:46. This is the majority view in recent atlases and commentaries.

  • Penuel = the western hill (Tell edh-Dhahab el-Gharbiyeh), or Succoth = another valley site such as Tell el-Ekhsas.

    There are no inscriptions naming either town. Some scholars argue that the pottery sequence at Deir ʿAlla does not fit an Israelite town well, and that the western Dhahab hill better suits an Iron Age fortified town. The exact sites are uncertain, though the general area is not.

in v8

Does the narrator approve of Gideon's response to Penuel's refusal?

  • The refusal was treachery, and Gideon's punishment is presented as deserved.

    Judges condemns tribes that fail to join Israel's wars (5:23 curses Meroz for not coming 'to the help of the LORD'). Gideon carries out exactly what he threatened, as a judgment promised in advance.

  • The episode marks Gideon's moral decline: rightful anger turning into excessive revenge on fellow Israelites.

    In v. 17 Gideon kills the men of Penuel, which goes beyond his threat in v. 9 (only the tower). The chapter goes on to his personal vengeance for his brothers (vv. 18–21), the gold ephod that 'became a snare' (v. 27), and Abimelech's bloodshed (ch. 9). Commentators such as Webb and Block read the transjordan episode as a turning point.

Sources
  • BDB (Brown–Driver–Briggs) s.v. עָלָה, עָנָה, אִישׁ, פְּנוּאֵל, סֻכּוֹת
  • HALOT s.v. פְּנוּאֵל, סֻכּוֹת, עָלָה
  • Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
  • Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
  • Robert G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
  • Trent C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 8:4–17
  • Egyptian evidence for severed hands as battle tallies: autobiography of Ahmose son of Ebana; Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III
  • Topographical list of Shoshenq I (Karnak) for Penuel/Succoth/Mahanaim

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.