Judges Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Judges 5:15–17
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15The princes of Issachar were with Deborah, and Issachar was with Barak, rushing into the valley at his heels. In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision. 16Why did you sit among the sheepfolds to hear the whistling for the flocks? In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision. 17Gilead remained beyond the Jordan. Dan, why did you linger by the ships? Asher stayed at the coast and remained in his harbors.
What the first hearers heard
For the first hearers this line did two things.
- It gave honour. Issachar's leaders and fighters were named, in a song meant to be retold, as loyal to Deborah and Barak and as having charged into the most dangerous ground. Being praised in a victory song was a lasting public credit for the tribe.
- It shamed. Reuben, Jacob's firstborn (Gen 49:3–4 already has "unstable as water, you shall not excel"), is mocked for big talk without action. Its fine resolutions turn, in the next verse, into dithering among the sheepfolds. Hearers would have laughed at the wordplay: Machir's real "decree-makers" marched, Reuben's decrees never left its head.
Underneath the humour is a serious point. Tribal kinship and loyalty to Yahweh required people to show up. The song judges the tribes by what they did when the summons came, not by what they intended.
From the study of Judges 5:15.
Verse by verse
-
15The princes of Issachar were with Deborah, and Issachar was with Barak, rushing into the valley at his heels. In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision.
Full study →Issachar's own captains and chiefs stood with Deborah. The whole tribe was as solidly behind Barak as Barak himself, true to him, and they were let loose down into the valley, the open chariot plain of Jezreel, right on his heels as his followers. Then the song turns from praise to a taunt. Among Reuben's clans, scattered across the stream-cut uplands beyond the Jordan, there were great decisions of the mind: firm resolutions, as if engraved, made with all the seriousness of a war council.
The irony is sharp. Just before this, the poet praised the "commanders" (literally "decree-makers") who actually came down from Machir. Reuben also made "decrees," but only inside its own head. The next verse finishes the joke by changing one letter: the grand resolves turn into endless searchings of heart, while Reuben sat among its sheepfolds listening to shepherds' pipes. Issachar marched. Reuben only made its mind up, over and over.
-
16Why did you sit among the sheepfolds to hear the whistling for the flocks? In the clans of Reuben there was great indecision.
Full study →"Reuben, why did you stay put, settled down among your sheep-pens and campfires, listening to the shepherds whistle and pipe to their flocks, while the rest of Israel was answering the call to war? Among Reuben's clans (and Reuben was certainly divided) there were great deliberations. You made grand resolutions, then had grand second thoughts, and in the end you never came."
The verse is a taunt sung in public. Deborah's victory song turns from praising the tribes who came (Ephraim, Benjamin, Machir, Zebulun, Issachar, Naphtali) and speaks straight to Reuben, Israel's firstborn tribe. The question "why?" is meant to shame, not to find something out. The picture is deliberately peaceful: a herding camp, the shepherd's whistle, the flocks. That calm is the accusation. The tribes who came were pouring down into the valley "at Barak's heels" while Reuben sat. The last line repeats the end of verse 15 with one letter changed. "Great were the resolves of heart" becomes "great were the searchings of heart." Reuben resolved, then reconsidered, then stayed home. "Heart" here means the mind that plans and decides, so "searchings of heart" is not admirable soul-searching. It mocks a committee that talked through the whole battle.
-
17Gilead remained beyond the Jordan. Dan, why did you linger by the ships? Asher stayed at the coast and remained in his harbors.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
princes
sarim (sar)
- What we hear
- Sons of a king; royalty.
- What they heard
- Chiefs, officers, commanders: the tribe's leading men and war captains. Issachar had no monarchy.
-
in v15
heart ("thoughts/resolves/searchings of heart")
lev
- What we hear
- Feelings and emotions; inner turmoil or soul-searching distress.
- What they heard
- The mind and will: where a person plans and decides. "Resolves of heart" are deliberate decisions.
-
in v15
on foot (KJV)
beraglav
- What we hear
- Walking rather than riding: an infantry detail.
- What they heard
- "At his feet" = following him, as his troops (cf. 4:10).
-
in v16
great searchings of heart
gedôlîm ḥiqrê-lēv
- What we hear
- Deep, sincere self-examination, the admirable soul-searching of a troubled conscience. The modern idiom 'heart-searching' comes from this KJV phrase.
- What they heard
- Endless deliberating and second-guessing, mocked in the song. 'Heart' is the deciding mind. The line follows 'great resolves of heart' (v.15) and contrasts big talk with no action.
-
in v16
bleatings of the flocks (KJV)
šeriqôt ʿădārîm
- What we hear
- The noise the sheep make.
- What they heard
- The shepherds' whistling or piping to call the flocks. It is a human, pastoral sound, set against the summons to war.
Every word
-
וְשָׂרַ֤י
wesaray · H8269
official, commander, leader · v15
The tribe's military and clan leaders, not royalty. As vowel-marked it means "my commanders," which may be Deborah or the singer claiming them as their own. Many scholars read the same consonants as "the commanders of."
-
בְּיִשָּׂשכָר֙
beyissaskhar · H3485
-
עִם־
ʿim · H5973
with · v15
"With" as in standing alongside: they joined Deborah's side in the muster.
-
דְּבֹרָ֔ה
devorah · H1683
Deborah ("bee") · v15
The prophetess and judge who called up the tribes (4:4–10). Here she is named as the rallying point.
-
כֵּ֣ן
ken · H3651
so, thus; right, true · v15
Either "as Issachar, so Barak" (equal in commitment) or, taking ken as "true, loyal" (as in Gen 42:11, "honest men"), "Issachar was true to Barak." Both readings point to steady loyalty.
-
בָּרָ֔ק
baraq · H1301
Barak ("lightning") · v15
The field commander from Kedesh in Naphtali whom Deborah summoned (4:6). The tribe is lined up behind him.
-
בָּעֵ֖מֶק
baʿemeq · H6010
valley, broad lowland · v15
"Into the valley": the broad plain of Jezreel along the Kishon, where Sisera's chariots had the advantage. Going down into it was the dangerous move.
-
שֻׁלַּ֣ח
shullach · H7971
was sent, was let loose · v15
A passive form, "was sent forth / was unleashed." It suggests troops launched or released down the slopes of Tabor, not a casual trip. BSB's "rushing" captures the momentum.
-
בְּרַגְלָ֑יו
beraglav · H7272
foot; (idiom) following · v15
"At his feet" is a Hebrew idiom for "as his followers, right behind him." The same phrase is used of Barak's 10,000 men in 4:10. It does not mean "on foot" as opposed to riding.
-
בִּפְלַגּ֣וֹת
bifluggot · H6391
divisions, clans; (related) channels · v15, v16
"Among the divisions/clans of." The root means "split, divide," and a related word means "stream-channel." So the phrase can also call up Reuben's wadi-cut land east of the Dead Sea, and it fits a tribe that was divided in mind.
-
רְאוּבֵ֔ן
reʾuven · H7205
Reuben · v15, v16
The Transjordanian herding tribe, Jacob's firstborn. The song now shifts from praising tribes that came to taunting those that stayed home.
-
גְּדֹלִ֖ים
gedolim · H1419
great, large · v15, v16
"Great" (plural). Here it is almost certainly ironic: grand resolutions that came to nothing, as v. 16 makes clear.
-
חִקְקֵי־
chiqqe · H2711
decree, resolution, decision · v15
From a root meaning "engrave, inscribe, decree." These are firm determinations, as if carved in stone. It echoes the "commanders" (meḥoqeqim, same root) of v. 14: Machir sent decree-makers who actually came down, while Reuben only decreed inside its own head.
-
לֵֽב׃
lev · H3820
heart, mind, will · v15, v16
In Hebrew the heart is where a person thinks, plans and decides, not mainly where they feel. "Resolves of heart" means decisions of the mind and will.
-
לָ֣מָּה
lāmmâ · H4100
why? · v16
Literally 'for what?' It opens a rhetorical, taunting question. The singer is not asking for information. She is shaming Reuben in front of the assembled tribes.
-
יָשַׁ֗בְתָּ
yāšavtā · H3427
to sit, stay, dwell · v16
'You sat / you stayed put.' The singer suddenly speaks to Reuben directly as 'you'. The verb pictures sitting still at home, the opposite of Issachar 'rushing at his heels' in verse 15. It echoes Moses' rebuke of Reuben in Numbers 32:6: 'Shall your brothers go to war while you sit here?'
-
בֵּ֚ין
bên · H996
between, among · v16
'Between.' With the dual noun that follows it means 'between the two ___', the same phrase used of Issachar in Genesis 49:14.
-
הַֽמִּשְׁפְּתַ֔יִם
ha-mišpetayim · H4942
sheepfolds / hearths / saddlebags (disputed) · v16
It has a dual ending ('a pair of ...') and appears elsewhere only in Genesis 49:14. Whatever exactly it named, it was something domestic and pastoral, either the pens or the cooking fires of a herding camp. The point is that Reuben stayed in the comforts of home.
-
לִשְׁמֹ֖עַ
lišmōaʿ · H8085
to hear, listen · v16
'To listen to.' This is a purpose phrase, and it is sarcastic: Reuben stayed home so that he could listen to shepherds' whistling, when he should have been answering the call to battle.
-
שְׁרִק֣וֹת
šeriqôt · H8292
whistlings, pipings · v16
It comes from a root meaning 'to hiss, whistle'. It means the shepherds' whistling or reed-piping used to call and calm the flocks. It is not the animals' bleating. The quiet pastoral sound is set against the noise of war in the poem.
-
עֲדָרִ֑ים
ʿădārîm · H5739
flocks, herds · v16
Flocks of sheep and goats. They were Reuben's wealth and his identity (Numbers 32:1), and they are what kept him at home.
-
חִקְרֵי־
ḥiqrê · H2714
searching, investigation · v16
'Searchings of.' It means probing, weighing and deliberating. The near-identical line in verse 15 had ḥiqqê, 'decisions/resolves'. The one-letter change turns 'big resolutions' into 'big second thoughts'.
The world behind it
An old victory song and roll-call of the tribes. Judges 5 is widely regarded as one of the oldest pieces of Hebrew poetry, often dated near the events themselves (c. 12th century BC). Its archaic grammar and vocabulary are part of why lines like this one are hard. Verses 14–18 are a muster roll. Israel was then a loose alliance of kin-tribes with no king, and they were expected to answer when summoned to fight in "the battle of Yahweh" (cf. v. 23, where Meroz is cursed "because they did not come to the help of Yahweh").
Praise and shame in public. The song names who came (Ephraim, Benjamin, Machir, Zebulun, Issachar, and Naphtali in v. 18) and mocks who didn't (Reuben, Gilead, Dan, Asher). In a culture built on honour and shame, a song sung at gatherings and wells (v. 11) made a tribe's reputation for generations. Being mocked in it was a lasting public disgrace.
Geography. Issachar's land lay in and around the Jezreel Valley, the very plain where Sisera's 900 iron chariots operated and where the Kishon flooded (4:13; 5:21). Its warriors were defending their own ground, and going "down into the valley" meant leaving the safety of Mount Tabor to face chariots on flat land (4:14). Reuben lived east of the Dead Sea on a herding plateau cut by deep wadis such as the Arnon. It was far from the fight and tied to its flocks (v. 16).
From the study of Judges 5:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
What does "Issachar ken Barak" mean?
-
"As Issachar, so Barak": the tribe matched its commander in commitment (or simply "Issachar too, and Barak").
Ken normally means "so, thus." The KJV and WEB take it this way.
-
"Issachar was true/loyal to Barak": ken as an adjective meaning "right, honest."
Ken as an adjective is attested (Gen 42:11, kenim, "honest men"; 2 Kgs 7:9, "not right"). It fits the praise context. Followed by YLT ("right with") and ESV ("faithful").
-
The text originally read "Naphtali" (or similar) instead of the second "Issachar."
Barak's home tribe was Naphtali (4:6, 10), which is otherwise mentioned only in v. 18. This is conjectural, with no direct manuscript support.
in v15
Is "great resolves of heart" (v. 15) sincere or sarcastic, and is it original?
-
Original and ironic: grand resolutions (v. 15) collapse into endless deliberation (v. 16).
The one-letter shift ḥiqqe/ḥiqre is a typical poetic play. Ḥeqeq echoes v. 14's meḥoqeqim ("commanders"), and v. 16's "Why did you sit…?" makes the sarcasm plain. Many modern commentators (e.g. Block, Butler) read it this way.
-
A copying variant: one verse originally matched the other.
Refrains are usually repeated exactly. A few manuscripts and versions read ḥiqre in v. 15, and ר and ק could be confused in some scripts. Many modern translations (ESV, NIV) render both as "searching(s)."
in v16
What exactly are the mishpetayim Reuben sat 'between'?
-
Sheepfolds or animal pens
Fits the pastoral context (flocks, shepherds' whistling) and Reuben's herding economy (Numbers 32:1). The traditional Jewish and English reading. The dual may reflect double-walled or paired stone enclosures.
-
Hearths, campfires or ash-heaps
Derived from the root šp̄t 'to set (a pot on the fire)', and related to ʾashpot 'ash-heap' (BDB). Gives the picture of lounging by the cooking fires of a camp.
-
Saddlebags (a donkey's double pack)
Fits Genesis 49:14 very well ('a strong donkey lying between the mishpetayim'). Supported by one Greek tradition's 'double load' (digomia). The dual ending suits a pair of bags.
in v16
Is the one-letter difference between verse 15 (ḥiqqê, 'resolves') and verse 16 (ḥiqrê, 'searchings') original?
-
Deliberate wordplay
Hebrew poetry often repeats a line with a small change. Here the change makes a sharp joke: grand resolutions, then grand reconsiderations, and no action. ḥāqaq is used earlier in the same poem (5:9, 'commanders/decree-makers'), so the poet knows the word.
-
Accidental scribal variation; originally the lines were identical
Some Hebrew manuscripts and ancient versions show identical lines. Many scholars regard 15b–16b as a refrain that has been disturbed in copying, and some think one occurrence is a misplaced duplicate.
in v16
Does pelaggot mean 'clans' or 'streams'?
-
Clans or tribal divisions
2 Chronicles 35:5, 12 use pelaggah for family divisions. A tribal roll-call naturally speaks of a tribe's subdivisions. This also allows the pun on a 'divided' Reuben.
-
Streams or watercourses
The related noun peleg means a water-channel (Psalm 1:3), and Job 20:17 uses pelaggot of streams. Reuben's land is cut by wadis such as the Arnon, so 'by the streams of Reuben' would continue the picture of a tribe lingering at home.
Sources
- BDB s.v. חָקַק, חֵקֶק, פְּלַגָּה, שַׂר, כֵּן
- HALOT s.v. חֵקֶק; פְּלֻגָּה; כֵּן II ("right, honest")
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus to Judg 5:15–16
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §130a, construct before a preposition
- R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- B. Lindars, Judges 1–5 (ICC)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
- T. C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judg 4–5
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁפְּתַיִם, שְׁרִיקָה, פְּלַגָּה, חֵקֶר, חָקַק, לֵב
- HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפְּתַיִם, פְּלַגָּה, חֵקֶר
- Septuagint, Judges 5:16 (Alexandrinus- and Vaticanus-type texts, Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Judges 5:16
- Genesis 49:14; Numbers 32:1–6; Psalm 68:13 (for parallels)
- B. Lindars, Judges 1–5: A New Translation and Commentary
- B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.