1 Samuel Chapter 9 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 9:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4So Saul passed through the hill country of Ephraim and then through the land of Shalishah, but they did not find the donkeys. He and the servant went through the region of Shaalim, but they were not there. Then they went through the land of Benjamin, and still they did not find them. 5When they reached the land of Zuph, Saul said to his servant, “Come, let us go back, or my father will stop worrying about the donkeys and start worrying about us.”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite listeners this verse did three things.

  1. It made the search feel real. It names districts they knew and paces out the trek with a repeated verb and a refrain of failure. They feel how long and tiring it is, and why Saul wants to turn back (9:5).
  2. It showed Saul as unassuming. The future king first appears as a dutiful son chasing his father's livestock through the hills, and failing. He is not scheming for a crown. The kingship will come to him unsought (compare 10:22, where he hides among the baggage).
  3. It set up hidden guidance. The search fails at every stage, yet it ends in Zuph, Samuel's district. Listeners who knew that Samuel had been told about Saul in advance (9:15–16) would hear the failures as the way God brought the two men together. The donkeys turn up on their own (9:20). What Saul "finds" is a prophet and a calling.

The repeated "not found" also sets up the turn in 10:2: "The donkeys you went to look for have been found."

From the study of 1 Samuel 9:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4So Saul passed through the hill country of Ephraim and then through the land of Shalishah, but they did not find the donkeys. He and the servant went through the region of Shaalim, but they were not there. Then they went through the land of Benjamin, and still they did not find them.

    Saul went on through the highlands of Ephraim. He went on through the district of Shalishah, and they found nothing. They went on through the district of Shaalim: nothing there. He went on through the territory of his own tribe, Benjamin, and they found nothing.

    The Hebrew is built like a weary refrain. Each stage of the trek opens with the same verb, "passed through," four times in all, and the stages end with a flat "not found" or a one-word "nothing." The verb moves between "he" and "they." Saul leads the search as his father's son, but he and the servant walk it and fail at it together.

    The places are real local districts, named the way an Israelite listener would know them. Ephraim is the large central hill country to the north. Shalishah and Shaalim ("Jackal-land," probably) are smaller areas whose locations are now uncertain. "The land of the Yeminite" is Benjamin, Saul's own tribe, so the search has looped back toward home and still turned up nothing.

    The listener is meant to feel the miles and the frustration. In the next verse Saul wants to give up. The story will then show that this failed search for lost donkeys was the road to the prophet Samuel, and to a kingship Saul never went looking for.

    Full study →
  2. 5When they reached the land of Zuph, Saul said to his servant, “Come, let us go back, or my father will stop worrying about the donkeys and start worrying about us.”

    By the time they had worked their way into the district of Zuph, the home country of Samuel's family, though Saul had no idea of that, Saul turned to the household lad who had been with him the whole trip and said: “Come on, let's head back home. Otherwise my father will drop the matter of the she-donkeys altogether and start fretting over us instead.”

    The Hebrew sets up two contrasting pictures. Kish leaving off the donkeys, valuable breeding animals and a real loss to the household, and Kish taking up anxious dread for his missing son and servant. Saul is being sensible and considerate: the search has gone on for days (compare 9:20), and a long absence will cost more worry than the animals are worth. The narrator, though, has placed the moment carefully. Saul is ready to give up just as he reaches the doorstep of the seer, and his guess about his father's state of mind is the very thing the seer will later tell him, almost word for word (10:2). That shows the seer really knows.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    mount Ephraim (KJV)

    har 'Efrayim

    What we hear
    A single mountain called Ephraim.
    What they heard
    The hill country of Ephraim: a whole highland region, the central ridge of Israel north of Benjamin.
  • in v5

    take thought (KJV)

    dāʾag

    What we hear
    Consider, think something over, plan.
    What they heard
    To be anxious, fret, worry. In 1611 English 'take thought' meant exactly this, as in KJV Matthew 6:25 'take no thought for your life'.
  • in v5

    sorrowful (YLT)

    dāʾag

    What we hear
    Grieving, sad, as if mourning a loss.
    What they heard
    Anxious dread about something uncertain. Kish is not mourning; he is worrying because he does not know where his son is.
  • in v5

    servant

    naʿar

    What we hear
    A menial or slave, socially insignificant.
    What they heard
    A household attendant or retainer, often young, sometimes a trusted agent. This one carries money and knows about the local seer.
Every word
  1. וַיַּעֲבֹ֧ר

    vayya'avor · H5674A

    pass over, pass through · v4

    'And he passed through.' Saul is the subject, as the one in charge of the search. This is the first of four uses of the same verb, which gives the verse the feel of a trek going on and on.

  2. בְּהַר־

    be-har- · H2022H

    mountain, hill country · v4

    'In the hill country of.' Linked to the name that follows, har means a whole range of highlands, not one peak.

  3. אֶפְרַ֛יִם

    'Efrayim · H0669G

    Ephraim · v4

    The central highland ridge north of Benjamin, named after the tribe of Ephraim. Saul heads north from his home at Gibeah into this hill country.

  4. בְּאֶֽרֶץ־

    be-'erets- · H0776G

    land, earth, region · v4, v5

    'In the land of.' Here erets means a local district or area, not a country or nation.

  5. שָׁלִ֖שָׁה

    Shalishah · H8031

    Shalishah (place name) · v4

    A district probably in the western foothills of the Ephraim hills. It is usually linked with Baal-shalishah (2 Kings 4:42). The exact spot is uncertain.

  6. וְלֹ֣א

    ve-lo · H3808

    not · v4

    'And not.' It negates the verb that follows and marks the first failure.

  7. מָצָ֑אוּ

    matsa'u · H4672

    find · v4

    'They found.' The verb has no object, and 'the donkeys' is understood. It switches to plural, because Saul and the servant search together. 'Finding' runs through the whole story (9:11, 9:13, 9:20, 10:2).

  8. שַׁעֲלִים֙

    Sha'alim · H8171

    Shaalim (place name) · v4

    An unknown district. The name probably comes from the word for 'foxes' or 'jackals' (shu'al). It may be the same as the 'land of Shual' near Ophrah (1 Samuel 13:17), but that is only a guess.

  9. וָאַ֔יִן

    va-'ayin · H0369

    there is not, nothing · v4

    'And nothing,' or 'and there were none.' One clipped word, like a shrug. It varies the refrain 'they did not find' while saying the same thing.

  10. יְמִינִ֖י

    Yemini · H3227B

    Benjaminite, Yeminite · v4

    'The Yeminite,' a short form of 'Benjamin(ite).' So this is Benjamin's territory, Saul's own tribe (9:1 calls his family 'a Yeminite'). The search has brought him back around to home ground.

  11. הֵ֗מָּה

    hēmmâ · H1992

    they · v5

    An emphatic pronoun placed first. Putting the subject ahead of the verb sets a scene: 'they had just come…' This is the backdrop for what Saul says next.

  12. בָּ֚אוּ

    bāʾû · H935

    come, enter · v5

    'They had come/arrived.' A completed action, so it works as 'by the time they reached'. It marks the end point of the long search described in verse 4.

  13. צ֔וּף

    ṣûp · H6689

    Zuph · v5

    A district named after Zuph, the Ephraimite ancestor of Samuel's family (1 Sam 1:1). Without knowing it, Saul has walked into the prophet's home territory.

  14. וְשָׁא֥וּל

    wəšāʾûl · H7586

    and Saul · v5

    Saul's name, meaning 'asked (for)'. This echoes the people 'asking' for a king in chapter 8. Here it simply names the speaker, son of Kish.

  15. אָמַ֛ר

    ʾāmar · H559

    said · v5

    'Said.' With the subject placed first, the word links back to the arrival: as soon as they got there, Saul spoke.

  16. לְנַעֲר֥וֹ

    lənaʿărô · H5288

    to his lad / attendant · v5

    'To his lad.' Here the word means a personal attendant or retainer of the household, not necessarily a child or a slave. This attendant is about to take the lead in the story.

  17. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾăšer · H834

    who, which · v5

    Relative word, 'who'. It introduces a description of the attendant.

  18. עִמּ֖וֹ

    ʿimmô · H5973

    with him · v5

    '[Was] with him.' This repeats verse 3, where Kish told Saul to take one of the lads with him. The two have stayed together the whole trip.

  19. לְכָ֣ה

    ləkâ · H1980

    come! go! · v5

    The command form of 'walk/go' with an emphatic ending. In use it is close to an interjection: 'Come on!' It urges the other person, but it doesn't mean moving toward the speaker.

  20. וְנָשׁ֑וּבָה

    wənāšûbâ · H7725

    and let us return · v5

    A 'let us' form of the verb 'turn back, return'. It is a proposal: 'let's head home.' The verb is about direction, with no moral sense here. Saul is ready to give up.

  21. פֶּן־

    pen · H6435

    lest, or else · v5

    Introduces the outcome Saul wants to avoid: 'otherwise…'

  22. יֶחְדַּ֥ל

    yeḥdal · H2308

    cease, leave off · v5

    'He will leave off, stop.' Paired with 'from' it means to drop a matter. The Hebrew says nothing about worrying here. Literally it is just 'stop [bothering] about the donkeys'.

  23. אָבִ֛י

    ʾābî · H1

    my father · v5

    Kish, the head of the household, described in 9:1 as a man of standing and substance. The search was his order.

  24. מִן־

    min · H4480

    from · v5

    'From.' With 'cease' it marks what is being dropped: 'leave off from the donkeys.'

  25. הָאֲתֹנ֖וֹת

    hāʾătōnôt · H860

    the she-donkeys · v5

    Specifically female donkeys, which were valuable for breeding, milk and riding, and were a sign of wealth. 'The' refers back to the animals lost in verse 3.

  26. וְדָ֥אַג

    wədāʾag · H1672

    be anxious, fret · v5

    'And he will become anxious.' The verb form continues the feared future set up by 'lest'. Da'ag means fretting, lying awake with worry. A father's dread for missing sons will replace his concern for property.

  27. לָֽנוּ׃

    lānû

    for us · v5

    'For us', meaning Saul and the attendant together. Saul counts the servant in as someone the father will fear for.

The world behind it

Lost donkeys were a serious matter. The animals in 9:3 are she-donkeys (ʾatonot). They were valued for breeding, riding and carrying loads, and they were a mark of wealth (compare Job 1:3; Judges 5:10). Kish is called a man of substance (9:1). Losing several she-donkeys was a real economic loss, enough to send the heir and a servant on a search lasting days (9:20 says "three days").

The geography. Saul's home was Gibeah of Benjamin (10:26). From there the route runs north into the Ephraim hill country, through districts that can no longer be firmly placed, back into Benjamin, and then to "the land of Zuph" (9:5). Zuph is the home district of Samuel's family (1:1, "Ramathaim-zophim"). The narrator has steered the wandering search to the very town where Samuel is, though Saul has no idea. In 9:15–16 the reader learns that God had told Samuel the day before.

A familiar story-pattern. A young man sets out after lost animals and comes back with something far greater. Many cultures tell stories like this, and scholars often note the folk-tale feel of the chapter. The narrator uses it to show Saul as an ordinary, likeable young man doing a family chore, not someone grabbing for power.

From the study of 1 Samuel 9:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

Where were Shalishah and Shaalim, and what route did Saul take?

  • Shalishah lies in the western foothills of Ephraim (near Baal-shalishah, 2 Kings 4:42), and Shaalim is the 'land of Shual' near Ophrah (1 Samuel 13:17). On this view the search went round in a loop north and east of Gibeah before coming back south.

    Similar names in other passages. Baal-shalishah is often placed near modern Kafr Thilth. Shual is mentioned with Ophrah in Benjamin's north-east.

  • The districts cannot be located with any confidence, and attempts to map the route are guesswork.

    The names vary in the ancient translations (especially the Septuagint), Shaalim is not otherwise attested, and the identifications depend on names that only resemble each other.

in v4

Is the location of 'the land of Zuph' (9:5) and Samuel's town on the route meant to be significant?

  • Yes. The narrator steers the aimless search to Samuel's home district (compare 1:1, Ramathaim-zophim), pointing to God's guidance behind it (9:15–16).

    Zuph is linked to Samuel's family in 1:1. 9:15–16 says God had told Samuel in advance that the man would come.

  • The narrative point is clear, but the geography is uncertain. Samuel's town in chapter 9 is not named, and whether it is Ramah has been debated.

    Chapter 9 calls it only 'the city' (9:6, 9:10). Some scholars think this story was originally independent of the Ramah traditions in chapters 1–7.

in v5

Which city is the unnamed town in the land of Zuph where the seer lives (9:6)?

  • Ramah, Samuel's home town.

    Samuel lived and judged at Ramah (7:17; 8:4); Ramathaim-zophim is linked to Zuph (1:1); the 'land of Zuph' setting points to Samuel's family territory.

  • A different town, or a story that originally featured an anonymous local seer, later identified with Samuel.

    The narrative never names the city or calls it Ramah; the servant speaks as if the seer were a local figure Saul had never heard of; and the route back past Rachel's tomb near Benjamin's border (10:2) is hard to fit with some proposed sites for Ramah. Older source-critical scholarship (which tries to identify the earlier stories a text was built from) suggested an earlier folk story stands behind 9:1–10:16.

in v5

Does the scene portray Saul negatively?

  • Yes, it subtly foreshadows his weakness as a leader.

    Saul wants to quit, does not know about Israel's leading prophet, and has to be guided and financed by his attendant (9:6–8). Many literary readers see an early hint of a king who follows rather than leads.

  • No, it presents him sympathetically as a dutiful, modest young man.

    His reason for turning back is concern for his father, and the narrative elsewhere stresses his humility (9:21; 10:22). The servant's role may simply be a storytelling device to bring in the seer.

Sources
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. עָבַר, מָצָא, הַר, אַיִן
  • HALOT s.v. שָׁלִשָׁה, שַׁעֲלִים, יְמִינִי
  • Open Scriptures / STEPBible Hebrew morphology (supplied source data)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 9:1–10:16
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary), on 9:4
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 9
  • Anchor Bible Dictionary s.v. 'Shalishah', 'Shaalim', 'Baal-shalishah'
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, 1 Kingdoms 9:4 (place-name forms, cited with caution)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. דָּאַג (be anxious, fret)
  • HALOT s.v. חָדַל (cease, leave off)
  • HALOT s.v. נַעַר (boy; attendant, retainer)
  • HALOT s.v. אָתוֹן (she-donkey)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 9:1–10:16
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (translation and notes on 1 Samuel 9)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).