2 Esdras Chapter 12 Read as one passage

2 Esdras 12:10–35

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10He said to me, “This is the interpretation of this vision which you saw: 11The eagle, whom you saw come up from the sea, is the fourth kingdom which appeared in a vision to your brother Daniel. 12But it was not explained to him, as I now explain it to you or have explained it. 13Behold, the days come that a kingdom will rise up on earth, and it will be feared more than all the kingdoms that were before it. 14Twelve kings will reign in it, one after another. 15Of those, the second will begin to reign, and will reign a longer time than others of the twelve. 16This is the interpretation of the twelve wings which you saw. 17As for when you heard a voice which spoke, not going out from the heads, but from the midst of its body, this is the interpretation: 18That after the time of that kingdom, there will arise no small contentions, and it will stand in peril of falling. Nevertheless, it won’t fall then, but will be restored again to its former power. 19You saw the eight under wings sticking to her wings. This is the interpretation: 20That in it eight kings will arise, whose times will be short and their years swift. 21Two of them will perish when the middle time approaches. Four will be kept for a while until the time of the ending of it will approach; but two will be kept to the end. 22You saw three heads resting. This is the interpretation: 23In its last days, the Most High will raise up three kingdoms and renew many things in them. They will rule over the earth, 24and over those who dwell in it, with much oppression, more than all those who were before them. Therefore they are called the heads of the eagle. 25For these are those who will accomplish her wickedness, and who will finish her last actions. 26You saw that the great head disappeared. It signifies that one of them will die on his bed, and yet with pain. 27But for the two that remained, the sword will devour them. 28For the sword of the one will devour him that was with him, but he will also fall by the sword in the last days. 29You saw two under wings passing over to the head that is on the right side. 30This is the interpretation: These are they whom the Most High has kept to his end. This is the brief reign that was full of trouble, as you saw. 31“The lion, whom you saw rising up out of the forest, roaring, speaking to the eagle, and rebuking her for her unrighteousness, and all her words which you have heard, 32this is the anointed one, whom the Most High has kept to the end [of days, who will spring up out of the seed of David, and he will come and speak] to them and reprove them for their wickedness and unrighteousness, and willheap up before them their contemptuous dealings. 33For at first he will set them alive in his judgment, and when he has reproved them, he will destroy them. 34For he will deliver the rest of my people with mercy, those who have been preserved throughout my borders, and he will make them joyful until the coming of the end, even the day of judgment, about which I have spoken to you from the beginning. 35This is the dream that you saw, and this is its interpretation.

What the first hearers heard

For Jewish readers around AD 100, living after the Temple's destruction and under the dynasty that destroyed it, this verse did three things:

  • It identified the enemy. The 'great head' was the emperor who began the war of 66–70, almost certainly Vespasian. Readers who knew how he died would recognise him at once.
  • It confirmed God's control. The vision's 'predictions' line up with real events: one king dies in bed, the next is killed by his partner, the last falls by the sword (12:26–28). That match made the rest of the vision believable: the lion-Messiah confronting the eagle and its burning (12:31–34).
  • It denied the oppressor any peace. Even the one Flavian who was not murdered died in torment. The destroyer of Jerusalem did not slip away untouched. This answered, in part, the question that drives the whole book: how can God let Rome triumph over Zion? The answer here is that God's judgment was already working inside Rome's own ruling house, and its full end was near.

From the study of 2 Esdras 12:26.

Verse by verse

  1. 10He said to me, “This is the interpretation of this vision which you saw:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 11The eagle, whom you saw come up from the sea, is the fourth kingdom which appeared in a vision to your brother Daniel.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 12But it was not explained to him, as I now explain it to you or have explained it.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 13Behold, the days come that a kingdom will rise up on earth, and it will be feared more than all the kingdoms that were before it.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  5. 14Twelve kings will reign in it, one after another.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 15Of those, the second will begin to reign, and will reign a longer time than others of the twelve.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  7. 16This is the interpretation of the twelve wings which you saw.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  8. 17As for when you heard a voice which spoke, not going out from the heads, but from the midst of its body, this is the interpretation:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  9. 18That after the time of that kingdom, there will arise no small contentions, and it will stand in peril of falling. Nevertheless, it won’t fall then, but will be restored again to its former power.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  10. 19You saw the eight under wings sticking to her wings. This is the interpretation:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  11. 20That in it eight kings will arise, whose times will be short and their years swift.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  12. 21Two of them will perish when the middle time approaches. Four will be kept for a while until the time of the ending of it will approach; but two will be kept to the end.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  13. 22You saw three heads resting. This is the interpretation:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  14. 23In its last days, the Most High will raise up three kingdoms and renew many things in them. They will rule over the earth,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  15. 24and over those who dwell in it, with much oppression, more than all those who were before them. Therefore they are called the heads of the eagle.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  16. 25For these are those who will accomplish her wickedness, and who will finish her last actions.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  17. 26You saw that the great head disappeared. It signifies that one of them will die on his bed, and yet with pain.

    "And as for what you saw, the great middle head vanishing from sight: that means one of these three kings will die in his own bed, and not by the sword, but even so he will die in torment."

    In the vision (11:33) the biggest of the eagle's three heads does not fight and is not cut off. It simply disappears. The angel explains that this king will die a natural death on his sickbed, unlike the other two heads, which 'the sword will devour' (12:27). Then comes the sting, tamen, 'yet'. The quiet bedside death will still be full of tormenta, wracking agonies, a word much stronger than modern English 'pain'. For the Jewish readers this was written for, a tyrant dying in agony was a familiar sign that God had judged him. The 'great head' is most likely the emperor Vespasian, who began the war that destroyed Jerusalem and died of a violent illness in AD 79. The verse grants that he died in bed, which was public knowledge, but it refuses to let that look like escape. The 'will die' is written as prophecy, but for the first readers it was already history, offered as proof that God's plan in the vision was on schedule.

    Full study →
  18. 27But for the two that remained, the sword will devour them.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  19. 28For the sword of the one will devour him that was with him, but he will also fall by the sword in the last days.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  20. 29You saw two under wings passing over to the head that is on the right side.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  21. 30This is the interpretation: These are they whom the Most High has kept to his end. This is the brief reign that was full of trouble, as you saw.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  22. 31“The lion, whom you saw rising up out of the forest, roaring, speaking to the eagle, and rebuking her for her unrighteousness, and all her words which you have heard,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  23. 32this is the anointed one, whom the Most High has kept to the end [of days, who will spring up out of the seed of David, and he will come and speak] to them and reprove them for their wickedness and unrighteousness, and willheap up before them their contemptuous dealings.

    "That lion you saw is the Anointed One, the King whom God Most High has been holding back, kept in store until the appointed end of this age. He will rise from David's own line, the promised royal heir. He will come and speak to the rulers of the eagle-empire. His words will be a court verdict: he will convict them of their crimes against God and their injustice against people, and he will pile up in front of them, where they cannot look away, the record of their arrogant contempt."

    The picture is a trial. The roaring lion of verse 31 is not first a beast that tears its prey. It is a royal judge whose weapon is his mouth, echoing Isaiah 11:4, where the son of Jesse "strikes the earth with the rod of his mouth." The verbs move in legal order: he speaks, he convicts, he lays out the evidence, and only then (v. 33) does he sentence and destroy. "Kept to the end" tells readers in despair that God's deliverer already exists in God's plan and is being held back on purpose until the empire's time runs out. "Anointed" means the Davidic king of Jewish hope. It does not carry the full later Christian meaning of "Christ."

    Full study →
  24. 33For at first he will set them alive in his judgment, and when he has reproved them, he will destroy them.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  25. 34For he will deliver the rest of my people with mercy, those who have been preserved throughout my borders, and he will make them joyful until the coming of the end, even the day of judgment, about which I have spoken to you from the beginning.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  26. 35This is the dream that you saw, and this is its interpretation.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v26

    yet with pain

    tamen cum tormentis

    What we hear
    He died of an illness that hurt: ordinary pain, perhaps mild.
    What they heard
    He died in torments: wracking, torturous agony (the word comes from the vocabulary of the rack and of torture). In this setting the phrase signals divine judgment on an oppressor.
  • in v32

    the anointed one / the Messiah

    unctus (Latin); meshiḥa (Syriac); likely mashiach (lost Semitic original)

    What we hear
    Jesus Christ, with his divine identity and death for sin taken for granted. This was especially easy for readers of the KJV-era Apocrypha, which Christians had copied and read.
    What they heard
    The awaited human king from David's line, appointed by God to judge Rome and rescue the faithful remnant of Israel. In 4 Ezra he reigns, then dies along with everyone else (7:29) before the final judgment. God himself carries out that judgment.
  • in v32

    reprove

    arguet (Latin); behind it probably elenchō / hokhiach

    What we hear
    Give someone a telling-off, a mild rebuke.
    What they heard
    Bring a legal case and prove guilt: convicting the defendant before the sentence is passed.
Every word
  1. Et

    et

    and · v26

    Moves the angel's explanation on to the next piece of the vision. It works as a simple link, not a contrast.

  2. quoniam

    quoniam

    since, because; as for the fact that · v26

    Brings up the detail of the vision to be explained: 'as for your seeing…'. The interpretation in 2 Esdras 12 repeats this pattern again and again (12:13, 12:17, 12:22 and so on).

  3. vidisti

    vidisti

    you saw · v26

    Points back to what Ezra saw in the dream in 11:33, where the middle head suddenly vanished. It marks this as a vision being decoded, not new information.

  4. caput

    caput

    head · v26

    One of the eagle's three heads. In the angel's key (12:22–23) the heads are three kings who rule at the end of the eagle's time.

  5. magnum

    magnum

    great, large · v26

    The middle head, the biggest of the three (11:4: 'the middle head was greater than the other heads'). It stands for the most powerful of the three kings.

  6. non

    non

    not · v26

    Negates the participle that follows: 'not appearing'.

  7. comparentem

    comparentem

    appearing, being visible · v26

    With 'not' it means 'no longer to be seen'. The head simply vanished (11:33) and was not cut off. The vision itself shows a quiet disappearance, not a killing.

  8. unus

    unus

    one · v26

    One of the three kings.

  9. ex

    ex

    out of, from · v26

    Partitive: 'one out of' the group.

  10. eis

    eis

    them · v26

    The three kings the heads stand for (12:23).

  11. super

    super

    upon, on · v26

    'On' his bed. The setting of his death is a private sickbed, not a battlefield or an assassin's dagger.

  12. lectum

    lectum

    bed, couch · v26

    'To die on one's bed' is an idiom for a natural death, as opposed to death 'by the sword', which is what verse 27 gives the other two heads.

  13. suum

    suum

    his own · v26

    'His' bed. Whether the word is written out varies among editions and witnesses. Either way the sense is his own deathbed.

  14. morietur

    morietur

    will die · v26

    Future tense. The angel speaks as if predicting, but the book was written after the event (see setting), so the 'prediction' describes something already known to the readers.

  15. et

    et

    and · v26, v32

    Joins the qualifying phrase that follows.

  16. tamen

    tamen

    yet, nevertheless · v26

    The turn in the sentence. He gets a natural death, *but* not an easy one. The word blocks any idea that this king got off lightly.

  17. cum

    cum

    with · v26

    Describes how he dies: accompanied by torments.

  18. tormentis

    tormentis

    torments, tortures, agonies · v26

    Plural, and stronger than plain English 'pain'. It means wracking agony. In Jewish writing of the time, a tyrant's agonising death was a recognised sign of God's judgment.

  19. ipse

    ipse

    he, this one · v32

    Points straight back to the lion of v. 31: 'that lion is this one.' This is the standard way an interpreting angel decodes a symbol in Jewish visions.

  20. est

    est

    is · v32

    The 'is' of interpretation, meaning 'stands for' (as in Daniel 7:17, 'these beasts are four kings').

  21. unctus

    unctus

    anointed (one) · v32

    Latin for Greek christos and Hebrew/Aramaic mashiach. Here it means the royal deliverer God appoints for the end, the Messiah. The lion image and the Davidic clause make it a king.

  22. quem

    quem

    whom · v32

    Opens the description of what God has done with this figure.

  23. reservavit

    reservavit

    has kept back, reserved · v32

    God has kept him in store and held him back until the appointed time. 2 Esdras 13:26 and 13:52 use the same idea of the Messiah being 'kept' and hidden for many ages.

  24. Altissimus

    Altissimus

    the Most High · v32

    The usual name for God throughout 4 Ezra, matching Hebrew 'Elyon and Aramaic 'Illaya in Daniel 7.

  25. in

    in

    unto, until · v32

    Means 'up to' or 'for' a point in time.

  26. finem

    finem

    end · v32

    'The end' is a fixed term in 4 Ezra for the close of the present age, the moment God has set for history to turn.

  27. [dierum … loquetur]

    dierum, qui ex semine David orietur, et veniet et loquetur

    of days, who will arise from the seed of David, and will come and speak · v32

    Missing in the Latin and supplied from the Eastern versions. This clause makes the lion explicitly the royal heir of David and shows that his first act is to speak.

  28. ad

    ad

    to, toward · v32

    With the restored clause it reads 'speak to them'. Without it, the Latin is awkward ('kept to the end, to them'), and the KJV smooths this into 'kept for them'.

  29. eos

    eos

    them · v32

    The eagle's rulers, meaning the Roman emperors and their empire, who are addressed and put on trial.

  30. impietates

    impietates

    ungodly deeds, impieties · v32

    Acts against God and against right order, the charges in the indictment. The plural points to concrete deeds, not an abstract state.

  31. ipsorum

    ipsorum

    their (own) · v32

    Stresses that these crimes are their own. The rulers are condemned for what they actually did.

  32. arguet

    arguet

    will convict, expose, prove guilty · v32

    A courtroom word. He will lay out the case and prove them guilty, which is far more than scolding them.

  33. illos

    illos

    them · v32

    The defendants, the eagle-empire.

  34. infulciet

    infulciet

    will cram in, heap up, press upon · v32

    A vivid and rare verb: he will pile their deeds up in front of them like evidence stacked before the accused. The Latin reading is uncertain here.

  35. coram

    coram

    before, in the presence of · v32

    Face to face. The guilty are made to look at their own record.

  36. ipsis

    ipsis

    them(selves) · v32

    The accused themselves.

  37. spretiones

    spretiones

    acts of contempt, scornful dealings · v32

    Their arrogant contempt for God and for his people. In v. 31 the lion charges the eagle with this and with injustice.

The world behind it

The eagle vision. In 2 Esdras 11–12 (chapters 3–14 of 2 Esdras), 'Ezra' dreams of an eagle rising from the sea, with twelve wings, eight smaller 'counter-wings' and three heads. One by one the wings rule and vanish. Then the three heads take over. The middle head disappears (11:33), and the right-hand head devours the left (11:35). Finally a lion, the Messiah (12:31–32), rebukes the eagle, and the eagle is burned (11:36–12:3). The angel says outright that the eagle is the fourth kingdom of Daniel 7, now explained more fully than to Daniel (12:11–12). In other words, it is Rome.

Who the heads are. Most modern scholars (e.g. Stone, Metzger, Myers) take the three heads as the Flavian dynasty:

  • Vespasian (ruled 69–79), the great middle head. He commanded the Roman war against Judea from 67, and his forces under Titus destroyed Jerusalem and the Temple in AD 70. He died of fever and severe diarrhoea at Aquae Cutiliae in June 79. Suetonius (Vespasian 23–24) says he tried to get up, saying an emperor ought to die standing, and died in the arms of those holding him. Vespasian died 'on his bed', but no one could call it a comfortable death.
  • Titus (79–81), rumoured to have been hurried to his death by his brother (Suetonius, Domitian 2; Cassius Dio 66.26). This matches 'the sword of one shall devour him that was with him' (12:28).
  • Domitian (81–96), who 'shall fall by the sword in the last days' (12:28). He was in fact assassinated in AD 96.

Why the detail matters. The book was written around AD 100, probably under Domitian or soon after, by a Jew mourning the Temple's destruction. Apocalypses commonly 'predict' known past events, so readers can trust the parts still in the future: here, the fall of Rome and the Messiah's coming. Vespasian's well-known natural death was an awkward fact for a writer who wanted the destroyers of Jerusalem punished. The phrase 'yet with torments' resolves it. It places his death in the long Jewish line of oppressors who died in agony: Antiochus IV (2 Maccabees 9), Herod the Great (Josephus), Agrippa I (Acts 12:23).

From the study of 2 Esdras 12:26.

Where scholars differ

in v26

Who are the three heads, and is the 'great head' Vespasian?

  • The three heads are the Flavian emperors Vespasian, Titus and Domitian, and the great middle head that dies in bed is Vespasian. This is the majority view.

    Vespasian died of illness (Suetonius, *Vespasian* 24; Dio 66.17). Titus was rumoured to have been done in by Domitian, which matches 'the sword of one shall devour him that was with him' (12:28). Domitian was assassinated, matching 'shall fall by the sword in the last days'. This also fits a date for the book of about AD 100 (the 'thirtieth year' after the fall in 3:1), and the Flavian role in destroying Jerusalem explains the author's focus on them.

  • The heads represent other rulers: earlier proposals included Julius Caesar and his successors, or Septimius Severus and his sons. Others think the eagle chapters were edited or updated, so the identifications may have shifted.

    The number of wings and counter-wings is hard to map exactly onto any list of emperors, which has kept other options alive. A Severan reading (Severus died of illness at York in 211, and Caracalla killed Geta) fits a similar pattern. But it would require dating the vision a century later than the rest of the book, and most specialists find this less likely.

in v26

Was the verse written before or after Domitian's death?

  • Under Domitian (before 96). The deaths of Vespasian and Titus are past history, and Domitian's fall 'in the last days' is a real prediction.

    The vision expects the final head's end, then the Messiah's intervention, very soon, and treats this as the climax still to come.

  • Soon after 96. The whole sequence, including Domitian's assassination, is written after the events.

    The description of the last head's fall 'by the sword' matches what happened. Some scholars also read the anointed one's intervention after the heads as evidence of a later writing.

in v32

Does 'kept/reserved' mean the Messiah already exists, hidden in heaven?

  • Yes. The Messiah exists already and is hidden with God until his appearance.

    In 2 Esdras 13:26 he is the one the Most High 'has been keeping for many ages', and 13:52 says no one can see him until his day. The book also mentions those 'taken up' who will appear with him (7:28; 13:52; 14:9). 1 Enoch 48:6 and 62:7 have the Son of Man hidden from before creation.

  • Not necessarily. 'Kept' means reserved in God's plan; the Messiah is a human born of David's line.

    In this verse he 'will arise from the seed of David' (Syriac). He dies after his reign (7:29). Apocalyptic writing often speaks of future events as 'kept' or 'prepared' in God's purpose.

in v32

Is the Davidic clause original or a later addition in the Eastern versions?

  • Original; the Latin lost it.

    Several independent versions (Syriac, Ethiopic, Arabic, Armenian) agree on it, and the Latin is awkward without it. This is the majority view (Box, Metzger, Stone).

  • Possibly an expansion added to bring the figure in line with standard Davidic hope.

    The Davidic origin is otherwise not explicit in 4 Ezra. The ch. 13 figure rises from the sea. A minority of commentators treat the clause with caution.

Sources
  • Michael E. Stone, *Fourth Ezra* (Hermeneia; Fortress, 1990), commentary on 2 Esdras 11–12
  • Bruce M. Metzger, 'The Fourth Book of Ezra', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), *Old Testament Pseudepigrapha* vol. 1 (1983)
  • R. L. Bensly, *The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version* (Cambridge, 1895)
  • Jacob M. Myers, *I & II Esdras* (Anchor Bible, 1974)
  • Bruce W. Longenecker, *2 Esdras* (Sheffield Academic Press, 1995)
  • Lewis & Short, *A Latin Dictionary*, s.v. tormentum, compareo, tamen
  • Suetonius, *Vespasian* 23–24; *Titus* 11; *Domitian* 2, 17
  • Cassius Dio, *Roman History* 66.17, 66.26
  • 2 Maccabees 9:5–12; Josephus, *Antiquities* 17.168–170, 19.343–350; Acts 12:23
  • Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 56b (death of Titus)
  • M. E. Stone, Fourth Ezra (Hermeneia, 1990), on 12:31–34
  • B. M. Metzger, '4 Ezra', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1
  • G. H. Box, The Ezra-Apocalypse (1912)
  • R. L. Bensly & M. R. James, The Fourth Book of Ezra: The Latin Version (1895)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata (Weber–Gryson), appendix: Liber Ezrae IIII
  • HALOT s.v. יכח
  • BDAG s.v. ἐλέγχω
  • Psalms of Solomon 17; 2 Baruch 39–40; 1 Enoch 48, 62

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

24 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.