Job Chapter 38 Read as one passage

Job 38:29–30

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

29From whose womb does the ice emerge? Who gives birth to the frost from heaven, 30when the waters become hard as stone and the surface of the deep is frozen?

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers this verse was part of the climax of the book. Job had demanded a hearing (31:35), and God answered not with a verdict but with a storm of questions about the world.

  • It turned Job's own words back toward creation. In chapter 3 Job used the language of womb and birth to wish he had never been born. Here God uses the same language for ice and frost. The world is full of births that Job cannot explain, and his own birth, which he cursed, belongs to that larger order.
  • It shrank human claims to knowledge. Job and his friends had argued as though they understood how God runs the world. Job cannot even name the "mother" of the frost on the ground each morning. How could he audit the moral government of the universe?
  • It left no room for rival weather powers. Neighboring peoples credited rain and dew to the families of storm-gods. A hearer would notice that this speech asks about the parentage of weather while no other god is in view. Whatever the precise answer, the questioner alone stands behind the weather.
  • It invited wonder rather than despair. The tone is sharp and also playful: the God who speaks seems to delight in ice, frost and frozen seas. The questions humble Job without crushing him, and they open his eyes to a world bigger and stranger than his suffering had allowed him to see.

From the study of Job 38:29.

Verse by verse

  1. 29From whose womb does the ice emerge? Who gives birth to the frost from heaven,

    "Out of whose womb did the ice come? And the white frost that comes down from the sky, who was in labor with it?"

    This is God speaking to Job out of the storm (Job 38:1). The verse is built from two questions, each opening and closing with "who?", and both have the same unspoken answer: not you, Job.

    The picture is a birth scene. Ice "comes out" of a womb, using the same words Job used in chapter 3 when he cursed the day he "came out of the belly". White hoarfrost, the powdery frost found on the ground at dawn with no visible cause, is "borne" by someone. In the previous verse God asked whether the rain has a father and who fathered the dewdrops. Now he asks about a mother. Between the two verses every possible parent is covered.

    The questions are not a lesson in how frost forms. They show Job how little he understands. Elsewhere the book points to God's breath as the source of ice (37:10). Still, the verse asks the question rather than stating the answer, and so it leaves Job facing a world whose ordinary marvels come from a source he cannot see, name or command. The verb forms can mean "came out" in the beginning or "comes out" every winter. Both senses fit, and the next verse shows the marvel being repeated: water turns as hard as stone and the face of the deep is locked tight.

    Full study →
  2. 30when the waters become hard as stone and the surface of the deep is frozen?

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v29

    gendered (KJV: "who hath gendered it?")

    yālad

    What we hear
    Classified or marked by gender; to do with male/female identity.
    What they heard
    Given birth to, brought forth, produced. KJV-era "gender" (as in "engender") meant to beget offspring.
  • in v29

    frost of heaven

    kəpôr šāmayim

    What we hear
    Frost from heaven, the dwelling of God and the redeemed. It sounds like a statement about the afterlife realm or the throne room.
    What they heard
    Frost from the sky: the white rime people believed settled from the night sky, like the "dew of heaven".
Every word
  1. מִבֶּ֣טֶן

    mibbeṭen · H0990

    from the belly/womb of · v29

    The prefix mi- means "out of". Beten is the belly, and especially the womb. Opening the verse with it makes a birth scene straight away: ice is pictured coming out of someone's body.

  2. מִ֭י

    mî · H4310

    who? · v29

    "Whose womb?" In Hebrew the question word comes right after "womb" (literally "from the womb of who?"). The word stresses that nobody can name the mother, and certainly not Job.

  3. יָצָ֣א

    yāṣāʾ · H3318

    go out, come forth · v29

    The ordinary word for a baby coming out at birth (Job 1:21; 3:11). The verb form views the action as complete ("came out / has come out"). It can point back to creation or to something that happens every winter. Most modern versions read it as a general truth.

  4. הַקָּ֑רַח

    haqqāraḥ · H7140

    the ice · v29

    Ice, or hard frost. In Israel and Edom it was rare and remarkable, seen on cold desert nights and in the highlands. The main pause in the Hebrew verse falls on this word, which closes the first question.

  5. וּכְפֹ֥ר

    ûkəpōr · H3713

    and the hoarfrost of · v29

    Hoarfrost is the fine white powdery frost found on the ground at dawn. It is the same word used for manna, which looked "fine as hoarfrost" (Exodus 16:14). It is linked grammatically to the next word: "frost of the sky".

  6. שָׁ֝מַיִם

    šāmayim · H8064

    sky, heavens · v29

    The visible sky. People in the ancient world thought frost, like dew, fell or settled from the sky overnight. So "frost of the sky" means frost that comes down from above. It does not mean frost from God's dwelling-place.

  7. יְלָדֽוֹ׃

    yəlādô · H3205

    bore it, gave birth to it · v29

    In this simple form the verb usually describes a mother giving birth, which fits "womb" earlier in the verse. Verse 28 used the form for a father begetting. The ending -ô ("it") refers back to the frost.

The world behind it

Weather born of gods. In the surrounding cultures, weather was often a matter of divine family trees. The Ugaritic texts from Syria (about 1300 BC) give the storm-god Baal daughters connected with the weather: Pidray, "daughter of mist/light", and Tallay, "daughter of showers". Tallay's name comes from ṭl, "dew", the same word as Hebrew ṭal in verse 28. Mesopotamian creation stories describe the gods and the world being born from the mingling of primeval waters. A first hearer would therefore know the idea that rain, dew and frost have parents. Job 38:28–29 uses exactly that father-and-mother language, but no rival deity appears. The only one asking, and implicitly the only one who knows, is Israel's God.

Ice in a warm land. In the southern Levant and the Arabian fringe, where the book places Job's land of Uz, snow and ice were uncommon. They were known on the high ground and from bitter desert nights (Genesis 31:40: "heat by day, frost by night"). Water turning "hard as stone" (38:30) was a genuine wonder. Hoarfrost appeared overnight and was believed to settle from the sky like dew, which is why it is "the frost of heaven".

The storehouses speech. Verses 22–30 belong to a series of questions about weather: storehouses of snow and hail (v. 22), the path of lightning (v. 25), rain on uninhabited land (v. 26), and then rain, dew, ice and frost (vv. 28–30). Each question shows Job that the world is run by a wisdom and a care that do not revolve around human beings, or around his case.

From the study of Job 38:29.

Where scholars differ

in v29

What answer do the questions of vv. 28–29 expect?

  • God is the parent: the questions point to God as the source of rain, dew, ice and frost.

    Job 37:10 says ice comes from God's breath. In 38:8–9 God acts like a midwife to the newborn sea. Throughout ch. 38 the implied answer to "who?" is usually God (e.g. 38:5, 25, 36–37).

  • No one: weather has no parents at all. The questions deny the mythological idea that rain and frost are offspring of gods. God commands the weather but does not beget it.

    "Does the rain have a father?" is phrased as a question expecting "no". Neighboring myths (Ugaritic Tallay, "daughter of showers/dew") gave weather divine parents. Elsewhere Israel's poetry pictures weather kept in storehouses and sent out by command (38:22–23, 35), not born.

  • The point is Job's ignorance, not the identity of the parent. The answer that matters is "not you".

    Repeated "who?" and "have you?" questions (38:4, 12, 16, 22, 31–35) keep putting Job outside creation's workings. Some commentators (e.g. Clines) warn against getting a doctrine of God's parenthood out of rhetorical questions meant to show Job his limits.

in v29

Does the verse use maternal imagery for God?

  • Yes: if the implied answer is God, then God is pictured with a womb, as a mother giving birth to ice and frost.

    The womb and birth verb are typical of mothers, set in deliberate parallel to the father of v. 28. Other passages use birth imagery for God: Deuteronomy 32:18 ("the God who writhed in labor with you"), Isaiah 42:14, 46:3, and the sea "from the womb" in Job 38:8.

  • Not necessarily: the father/mother pair is a poetic way of asking about any parentage at all, and may expect the answer "none".

    The verse is a rhetorical question, not a statement. Pairing "father" and "womb" is a natural way to say "any parent whatsoever". If the questions deny that weather has parents, no image of God as mother is intended.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. בֶּטֶן, קֶרַח, כְּפוֹר, יָלַד
  • HALOT s.v. קֶרַח; כְּפוֹר II; יָלַד
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 38–42 (Word Biblical Commentary 18B)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15), on Ugaritic weather-goddesses
  • C. A. Newsom, "The Book of Job," New Interpreter's Bible vol. 4
  • Ugaritic Baal Cycle (KTU 1.3), on Pidray and Tallay
  • Septuagint, Job 38:29 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Job 38:29

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.