Judges Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Judges 5:6–8
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6In the days of Shamgar son of Anath, in the days of Jael, the highways were deserted and the travelers took the byways. 7Life in the villages ceased; it ended in Israel, until I, Deborah, arose, a mother in Israel. 8When they chose new gods, then war came to their gates. Not a shield or spear was found among forty thousand in Israel.
What the first hearers heard
To the tribes who first sang this song, the verse called up a time they remembered: when it was too dangerous to travel openly, when trade dried up and villages were cut off from one another. That would have made it hard even to gather for a common defence, and the song complains later that several tribes stayed home (5:15–17). Naming the era "the days of Shamgar … the days of Jael" anchored it in people's memory. With Jael it also adds a dramatic irony: a woman named as part of the dark backdrop turns out, later in the song, to be the one who strikes the decisive blow (5:24–27).
The verse works as the "before" picture in a before-and-after story. Stopped roads, twisted detours and dead villages (v. 7) set up Deborah's arising and the LORD's victory. Afterwards people could again "tell of the righteous acts of the LORD" at the watering places and "go down to the gates" (5:10–11), and the roads and public life came back. For an Israelite audience, freedom to walk your own land openly was a concrete sign that the LORD had saved his people.
From the study of Judges 5:6.
Verse by verse
-
6In the days of Shamgar son of Anath, in the days of Jael, the highways were deserted and the travelers took the byways.
Full study →Back in Shamgar's time (Shamgar "son of Anath", the fighter), back in Jael's time, traffic on the roads stopped dead. The caravans no longer came through. People who still had to travel, the ones whose business was the open path, kept to twisting, roundabout tracks, winding and doubling back out of sight.
The Hebrew is tightly made. The repeated "in the days of … in the days of" calls up a whole era by naming two figures. The word for "roads" appears twice. First the roads cease. Then they come back as the crooked roads people were forced onto, so the normal way of life has literally been bent out of shape. There is a play on sound as well: "the walkers … walked", ending on the long, twisting ʿăqalqallôt ("twisty-twisting"). The verb "ceased" starts a refrain that verse 7 repeats twice more ("ceased … ceased"), and it holds until "I, Deborah, arose." The verse is not about a moral "crooked path". It shows a country where you could not safely walk your own roads.
-
7Life in the villages ceased; it ended in Israel, until I, Deborah, arose, a mother in Israel.
Full study →The open-country folk of Israel, the farmers in their unwalled hamlets, stopped. Their life ground to a halt. It stopped, it simply stopped, all across Israel. Then I rose up, I, Deborah. I rose up as a mother in Israel: the one the whole people could look to for protection, counsel and rescue, the way a household looks to its head.
The verse continues the picture of v. 6. Roads were deserted and travelers crept along back paths. Now the exposed villages, with no walls against raiders and chariots, are emptied or paralysed. The word for the village folk is rare and could instead mean Israel's fighters, who 'held back' from battle. Either way, the nation is helpless. The three-fold 'ceased' sounds like a door being shut again and again. Then the verb flips to 'arose', said twice, climbing like a staircase until it reaches the title. Old as the Hebrew form is, it can also be heard as the singers' cry to her: 'until you arose, Deborah'. Either way the turning point is the same: when Israel stopped, she stood up. 'Mother in Israel' is not a statement about her children. It is a title of honour and authority, the female counterpart of calling a prophet or protector 'father'.
-
8When they chose new gods, then war came to their gates. Not a shield or spear was found among forty thousand in Israel.
Full study →Israel had gone after upstart gods, gods their ancestors never knew. The first hearers would have heard that as betrayal of the God who brought them out of Egypt. And then the war came: enemies stood at the gates of their towns, the place where they held court, traded and defended themselves. Look through all the ranks of Israel, through forty thousand men or forty clan contingents, the whole strength of the tribes: was there a single shield to be seen, or a single spear? Not one.
The poet asks the question with a mix of indignation and grief. The people were disarmed and helpless before an enemy with iron chariots, and they had brought this on themselves by turning from their God. This is the dark background for the next verse, where the song turns to praise the volunteers who rose up anyway and calls out "Bless the LORD!".
The opening line is hard Hebrew. Some read it instead as "God chose new leaders" (Deborah and Barak). Read that way, the verse speaks of God's answer to the crisis rather than its cause.
Where the English drifted
-
in v6
highways
ʾŏrāḥôt
- What we hear
- Paved, engineered roads for vehicles, or major motorways.
- What they heard
- The regular beaten routes between settlements and through the valleys, used by people on foot, pack donkeys and trade caravans. They might be unpaved tracks, and the same consonants can be read "caravans".
-
in v7
a mother in Israel
ʾēm bəyiśrāʾēl
- What we hear
- A warm, nurturing, motherly woman: a description of her personality or her family role.
- What they heard
- A title of public standing: the protector, counselor and leader on whom the community's survival rested. It is the female counterpart of calling a prophet or guardian 'father'. It does not tell us whether she had children.
-
in v8
new gods
elohim chadashim
- What we hear
- 'New' sounds neutral or even positive, as in fresh, innovative or improved.
- What they heard
- An accusation: upstart deities with no ancestral claim, gods Israel's forefathers never knew (Deut 32:17). 'New' marks them as illegitimate.
-
in v8
forty thousand
'arba'im 'elef
- What we hear
- An exact head-count of 40,000 soldiers.
- What they heard
- A round, poetic total for Israel's whole fighting strength. 'Elef may also mean a clan contingent ('forty units'), not a literal thousand.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v7
'A mother in Israel' is a title of leadership, not just tenderness
- What's often taught
- Deborah is often presented here as a nurturing, motherly figure, and 'a mother in Israel' is read as describing her gentle, caring character or a domestic, maternal role, as opposed to public leadership.
- What the text supports
The phrase comes at the climax of a verse about national collapse: roads deserted, villages paralysed, no weapons (vv. 6–8). The response is that Deborah arose, the verb used for deliverers stepping onto the scene. In Hebrew, 'father' was a title for a prophet, priest, counselor or protector (Judg 17:10; 18:19; 2 Kgs 2:12; 6:21). The closest parallel use of 'mother' is 2 Sam 20:19, where a town is called 'a mother in Israel' because it shelters and gives counsel to the surrounding region. Judges 4 presents Deborah as a prophet who was 'judging Israel' and who summons Barak to war.
So the title means she was the one Israel depended on: protector, counselor and leader of the people. The common reading is partly right, because care and protection are part of the word. But the care described is the rescue of a nation, not a household. The verse also says nothing about whether she had children.
- Where the English feeds it
- Modern English 'mother' points almost entirely to the home and to children, and English has no obvious title-use of 'mother' the way it once used 'father' for clergy. So 'a mother in Israel' reads as a description of personality, not a title of standing.
Every word
-
בִּימֵ֞י
bîmê · H3117
in the days of · v6
The preposition "in" joined to "days of". "The days of X" is the ordinary Hebrew way to name an era by the person who marked it. It sets the scene before Deborah arose (v. 7).
-
שַׁמְגַּ֤ר
šamgar · H8044
Shamgar · v6
The fighter of Judges 3:31 who killed 600 Philistines with an ox-goad. The name is not Hebrew in form and is often explained as Hurrian (a people of northern Mesopotamia and Syria). That suggests a non-Israelite or mixed background.
-
בֶּן־
ben- · H1121
son of · v6
Normally means "son of" and gives a father's name. "Son of" can also mark membership in a group or a type ("son of strength" = a strong man), and this matters for the next word.
-
עֲנָת֙
ʿănāt · H6067
Anath · v6
The name of the Canaanite warrior goddess Anat, well known from texts at Ugarit (an ancient city on the Syrian coast). Here it may be a parent's name, a hometown (Beth-anath), or a warrior title. See debates.
-
יָעֵ֔ל
yāʿēl · H3278
-
חָדְל֖וּ
ḥādlû · H2308
they ceased · v6, v7
"Stopped, left off, came to an end." The roads did not vanish. The traffic on them stopped. The same verb opens verse 7 twice ("ceased … ceased"), so it is a refrain of things grinding to a halt.
-
אֳרָח֑וֹת
ʾŏrāḥôt · H734
ways, roads · v6
Beaten routes between towns. The same consonants could also be read ʾōrəḥôt, "caravans". Either way, the picture is that regular travel and trade stopped.
-
וְהֹלְכֵ֣י
wəhōləkê · H1980
and the walkers of · v6
"Those who walk", i.e. people who regularly travel. Joined to the next word: "the walkers of paths".
-
נְתִיב֔וֹת
nətîbôt · H5410
paths · v6
A word for a path or track found mostly in poetry. "Walkers of paths" means ordinary travellers: people whose business took them along the routes.
-
עֲקַלְקַלּֽוֹת׃
ʿăqalqallôt · H6128
crooked, winding · v6
A doubled form of the root ʿql, "bend, twist". The doubling strengthens it, something like "twisty-twisting". These were roundabout, hidden routes that kept travellers away from danger on the open roads.
-
פְרָז֛וֹן
pərāzôn · H6520
open-country population; village life (possibly 'warriors') · v7
A rare word, found only here and in v. 11. Most likely it means the people of the unwalled farming hamlets, Israel's highland peasantry, as a group. A minority reading takes it as 'champions' or 'warriors'. See the study below.
-
בְּיִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל
bəyiśrāʾēl · H3478
in Israel · v7, v8
"Israel" here is the alliance of tribes, not a state with a king. The phrase opens the verse, and the same phrase closes it.
-
עַ֤ד
ʿad · H5704
until · v7
The turning point of the verse: the collapse lasted up to the moment someone rose.
-
שַׁקַּ֙מְתִּי֙
šaqqamtî · H6965
that I arose · v7
Two parts: a short northern, archaic 'that/when' (ša-), then 'qamti', 'I arose'. That ending can also be an old form meaning 'you (woman) arose'. Either way, it is the verb of a leader stepping up to act.
-
דְּבוֹרָ֔ה
dəbôrāh · H1683
Deborah ("bee") · v7
The name sits between the two "arose"s, so the line hangs on her. The name means "bee", but the poem does nothing with that.
-
אֵ֖ם
ʾēm · H517
mother · v7
Used here as a title, the female counterpart of "father" for a prophet, counselor or protector of a community. It says she was the one the people looked to for guidance and rescue. It says nothing about her having children.
-
יִבְחַר֙
yivchar · H0977
to choose · v8
Singular verb ('he/it chose', or 'used to choose'). Most read the subject as Israel taken collectively ('they chose'); others make 'God' (the next word) the subject. Bachar is the verb of deliberate, committed selection, often used of choosing whom to serve (Josh 24:15, 22).
-
אֱלֹהִ֣ים
elohim · H0430
God / gods · v8
Plural in form; with the plural adjective 'new' it most naturally means 'gods'. If read as the subject of the singular verb, it would be Israel's God ('God chose new …'). The ambiguity is real in the unpointed consonants.
-
חֲדָשִׁ֔ים
chadashim · H2319
new · v8
'New ones'. Applied to gods, 'new' is an accusation: upstart deities unknown to the ancestors (Deut 32:17). On the minority reading it is a noun, 'new ones', i.e. new leaders or fighters God chose.
-
אָ֖ז
'az · H0227
then · v8
Marks consequence or sequence: 'then', at that time, as a result. It ties the choosing of new gods to what followed.
-
לָחֶ֣ם
lachem · H3901
war, fighting · v8
Occurs only here; usually linked to lacham, 'to fight', hence 'fighting/war'. The same consonants spell lechem, 'bread', which is how one Greek tradition read it. The supplied data glosses it both 'war' and 'bread'.
-
שְׁעָרִ֑ים
she'arim · H8179
gates · v8
City gates: the fortified entrance and also the town's public square, court and market. War 'at the gates' means the enemy at the town's very heart and defenses. (Vocalized se'orim it would mean 'barley'.)
-
מָגֵ֤ן
magen · H4043
shield · v8
The small round hand-shield of an ordinary infantryman. Placed first for emphasis: 'A shield — was one seen?'
-
אִם־
'im · H0518
if / surely not · v8
Introduces a question expecting the answer 'No', close to an oath formula: 'if a shield was seen…!' = not one was seen.
-
יֵֽרָאֶה֙
yera'eh · H7200
to be seen · v8
Passive, 'was seen / could be found'. The picture is of looking through the ranks and seeing no weapons at all.
-
וָרֹ֔מַח
varomach · H7420
and a spear · v8
A thrusting spear or lance, the basic weapon of the foot soldier. Shield and spear together make the pair of a soldier's standard kit, i.e. 'no arms at all'.
-
בְּאַרְבָּעִ֥ים
be'arba'im · H0705
among forty · v8
'Forty' is a round, often symbolic number in Hebrew (a full measure); with 'thousand' it gives the impression of the whole fighting strength of Israel.
-
אֶ֖לֶף
'elef · H0505
thousand; clan, military unit · v8
Usually 'thousand', but in early texts 'elef also names a clan or the contingent a clan sent to war. 'Forty thousand' may therefore be 'forty units', a much smaller literal number.
The world behind it
An old victory song. Judges 5, the Song of Deborah, is widely held to be one of the oldest pieces of Hebrew poetry, with archaic grammar and vocabulary. It probably comes from Iron Age I, around the 12th–11th century BC. It celebrates the defeat of the Canaanite general Sisera in the Jezreel Valley.
Roads and who controlled them. The great north–south trade route, often called the Via Maris, and its branches ran through the Jezreel Valley past fortified Canaanite cities such as Megiddo and Taanach (both named in 5:19). Early Israel lived mostly in small, unwalled hill villages. The power that controlled the valley roads with chariots (4:3, "900 chariots of iron") controlled who could trade, travel and gather. For hill villagers, using the main roads meant risking raids, seizure of goods or worse. The wider region was also unsettled: the Late Bronze Age system of trade had collapsed, and Philistine and other groups were pressing in (Shamgar's enemies in 3:31 are Philistines).
Naming an era. People in the ancient Near East often dated events "in the days of" a well-known figure. The two figures here are both outsiders in some sense. Shamgar has a non-Hebrew name, linked to the goddess Anat. Jael is the wife of a Kenite, a clan allied with Israel but not part of it. The poem uses them to mark the time of crisis just before Deborah's rise.
From the study of Judges 5:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
What does "son of Anath" mean?
-
An ordinary parent's name: Shamgar's father or mother was named Anath.
"Ben X" is the normal form for giving a parent, and personal names containing divine names were common across Canaan.
-
A place of origin: someone from Beth-anath (or Anathoth).
Beth-anath was a Canaanite town in Naphtali's area (Josh 19:38; Judg 1:33), close to the setting of the story.
-
A warrior title or the name of a military group: "son of Anat" = a devotee or soldier of the warrior goddess, possibly a mercenary.
Arrowheads from el-Khadr (12th–11th c. BC) are read by many as "son of Anat", and "son of" + a quality is a common Semitic idiom. This view is associated with P. C. Craigie and others. Critics say the inscriptions could just as easily be family names.
in v6
Why is Jael named as a marker of the dark time?
-
The text is original. Jael lived during the oppression, and naming her sets up the irony that the obscure woman of that era becomes the deliverer.
Supported by all the manuscripts. It fits the song's interest in surprising women (Deborah, Jael, Sisera's mother) and in reversal.
-
The name is a later addition or a corruption (e.g. of Jair), or refers to an otherwise unknown leader also named Jael.
Jael is never called a leader or judge, and "the days of X" usually names a ruler. These proposals are guesses with no support in any manuscript.
in v6
Did the "roads" or the "caravans" cease?
-
Roads: read ʾŏrāḥôt as in the traditional Hebrew text.
The Masoretic vowels and the deliberate repetition at the end of the verse ("roads … crooked roads"). The Septuagint reads "roads".
-
Caravans: reread the first occurrence as ʾōrəḥôt.
The same consonants are used for "caravans" elsewhere (Job 6:19; Isa 21:13), and "caravans ceased" pairs well with "travellers" in the next line.
in v7
What does pərāzôn mean: village life / villagers, or warriors / leaders?
-
Open-country population, village life, or the peasantry (BSB, KJV, ESV, NASB, NIV; most modern lexicons).
The clearly related words *pərāzôt* and *pərāzî* consistently mean unwalled settlements and their inhabitants (Deut 3:5; 1 Sam 6:18; Ezek 38:11; Esth 9:19; Zech 2:4). The verse follows v. 6's picture of abandoned roads, a natural chain from trade stopping to rural life stopping.
-
Warriors or champions: Israel's fighting men held back.
A possible link to an Arabic root for 'going out to single combat'. Hab 3:14 uses a related form in a battle context. The verse fits v. 8 (no shield or spear) and v. 11, where the *pərāzôn* perform 'righteous acts', i.e. victories.
-
Rulers or mighty ones (older lexicons, ASV/WEB).
Based mainly on the ancient Greek 'mighty ones' and the Latin 'the strong'. Little support from the Hebrew word family itself, so fewer scholars hold it today.
in v7
Who is speaking: 'until I arose, Deborah' or 'until you arose, Deborah'?
-
First person: Deborah speaks of herself (Masoretic vowels; KJV, BSB, ESV, NIV, NASB).
Judg 5:1 introduces the song as sung by Deborah and Barak. The Masoretic tradition reads the ending as 'I'.
-
Second person: the singers address Deborah (NRSV; many commentators).
The ending *-tî* is a known archaic 'you (feminine)' ending, and this poem is full of archaic forms. Verse 12 addresses her directly ('Awake, awake, Deborah!'). Reading the verse as praise sung *to* her avoids an otherwise unusual moment of self-praise.
-
Third person: 'until Deborah arose' (ancient Greek, Latin).
Probably an interpretive smoothing by the ancient translators, not a different Hebrew text.
in v8
Who chose, and what was chosen, in the first line?
-
Israel chose new (foreign) gods, which caused the crisis.
The plural adjective 'new' agrees naturally with elohim as 'gods'; Deut 32:16–17 uses the same phrase of apostasy; Josh 24:15 and Judg 10:14 use bachar for choosing gods; the Targum, the LXX and most English versions read it so; and it fits the Judges cycle (2:11–15).
-
God chose new ones (leaders or fighters such as Deborah and Barak).
The verb is singular, which suits elohim as Israel's God; the verse would then lead into v. 9's praise of leaders and volunteers. Adopted in the NIV text and by some commentators. Its weakness is that 'leaders/men' must be supplied.
-
The line is corrupt and needs emendation (e.g. a reading about war or about the people's lack of preparedness).
The Vulgate ('new wars'), the divergent LXX forms and the hapax lachem suggest an early scribal difficulty. Various reconstructions have been offered, none commanding agreement.
in v8
Is it 'war at the gates' or 'barley bread'?
-
'Then there was fighting at the gates' (Masoretic Text).
Lachem is linked to lacham 'to fight'; the gates return in v. 11; the context is military.
-
'Barley bread' (LXX Vaticanus vocalization lechem se'orim).
The same consonants; barley bread as an image of something poor or contemptible (Judg 7:13). Some read it as 'they chose new gods, [worthless] as barley bread' or as a picture of famine. It is a minority view.
in v8
What does 'forty thousand' ('arba'im 'elef) mean?
-
A round literal figure, 'forty thousand', standing for Israel's full manpower.
'Elef as 'thousand' is its usual sense; forty is a conventional round number.
-
'Forty units/clans', a much smaller force.
'Elef means 'clan' in Judg 6:15 and similar texts; early tribal militias were small; argued by Mendenhall, Humphreys and others.
in v8
Why were there no shields or spears?
-
The oppressors had deliberately disarmed Israel.
A parallel with 1 Sam 13:19–22 (the Philistine control of smiths).
-
A poetic description of unpreparedness or loss of will, not a literal arms count.
The poem's hyperbole; it contrasts with the volunteers of v. 9 and the idea that God, not weapons, won the battle (vv. 20–21).
Sources
- HALOT s.v. אֹרַח, אֹרְחָה, חדל, עֲקַלְקַל
- BDB s.v. אֹרַח, חָדַל, עֲקַלְקַל, נְתִיבָה
- P. C. Craigie, "A Reconsideration of Shamgar ben Anath (Judg 3:31 and 5:6)," JBL 91 (1972)
- F. M. Cross & J. T. Milik, "A Typological Study of the El Khadr Javelin- and Arrow-heads," BASOR (1954)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC)
- B. Lindars, Judges 1–5 (ICC)
- T. J. Butler, Judges (WBC)
- L. E. Stager, "Archaeology, Ecology, and Social History: Background Themes to the Song of Deborah" (VTSup 40, 1988)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 5
- BDB s.v. פְּרָזוֹן, פְּרָזוֹת, חָדַל
- HALOT s.v. פְּרָזוֹן; חדל I/II
- Septuagint, Judges 5:7 (Codex Alexandrinus and Codex Vaticanus traditions)
- Vulgate, Judges 5:7
- R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
- D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
- L. E. Stager, 'Archaeology, Ecology, and Social History: Background Themes to the Song of Deborah' (VTSup 40)
- S. Ackerman, Warrior, Dancer, Seductress, Queen: Women in Judges and Biblical Israel
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 4–5
- BDB s.v. לָחֶם (H3901), בָּחַר, חָדָשׁ, אֶלֶף
- HALOT s.v. לָחֶם, אֶלֶף, מָגֵן
- Septuagint, Judges 5:8 (Codices Alexandrinus and Vaticanus)
- Vulgate, Judges 5:8
- Targum Jonathan to Judges 5:8
- Deuteronomy 32:16–17; Joshua 24:15; Judges 2:11–19; 6:15; 10:14; 1 Samuel 13:19–22
- G. E. Mendenhall, 'The Census Lists of Numbers 1 and 26', JBL 77 (1958)
- Commentaries on Judges: R. G. Boling (Anchor Bible), D. I. Block (NAC), B. Lindars
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).