Psalms Chapter 94 Read as one passage

Psalm 94:9–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9He who affixed the ear, can He not hear? He who formed the eye, can He not see? 10He who admonishes the nations, does He not discipline? He who teaches man, does He lack knowledge? 11The LORD knows the thoughts of man, that they are futile.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelite worshippers, especially the poor and powerless who suffered under corrupt officials and the strong (compare v. 20, "the throne of destruction that frames injustice by statute"), this verse was both comfort and warning.

  • For the oppressed: the cry of the widow, the foreigner and the orphan does not go unheard. The God who made their ears and eyes hears and sees what is done to them, as the Torah promised (Exod 22:22–24).
  • For the oppressors and the careless "among the people": acting as if God were absent is foolish. He is the craftsman of human senses, so their hidden schemes are fully known to him (v. 11), and his "vengeance", meaning his restoring justice, is coming (v. 23).
  • For Israel's view of God: the verse sets the LORD apart from idols with painted eyes and carved ears. Israel's God is alive, attentive and active, and his care for the weak follows from his being their Maker.

Sung regularly in the Temple liturgy, the psalm kept alive the conviction that no wrong done in secret escapes the notice of the One who made the watching eye.

From the study of Psalm 94:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9He who affixed the ear, can He not hear? He who formed the eye, can He not see?

    Two pointed questions, each expecting an obvious "Of course!":

    "The One who planted the ear: will he not hear? Or the One who shaped the eye: will he not look?"

    God is given two titles from crafts everyone knew. He is the Planter of the ear, who set it into the head like a gardener setting a shoot in soil. He is the Shaper of the eye, who moulded it the way a potter moulds clay, as he shaped the first human from the ground. The argument runs from the lesser to the greater: whoever designed hearing and sight cannot be without them. Hearing and looking here mean more than taking in sound and light. To "hear" is to hear a cry and act on it. To "look" is to look closely and take note. The questions answer the oppressors in verse 7, who say "The LORD does not see; the God of Jacob pays no attention" while they crush widows, foreigners and orphans. The psalmist calls them fools (v. 8) and tells them that the Maker of every ear hears the cry of their victims, and the Maker of every eye is watching what they do. The God they picture as deaf and blind is not a lifeless idol. He invented ears and eyes, and he will act.

    Full study →
  2. 10He who admonishes the nations, does He not discipline? He who teaches man, does He lack knowledge?

    "The One who trains and corrects whole nations — will He not call you to account? The One who teaches humankind everything it knows — …?"

    The psalmist has just mocked the oppressors' claim that "the LORD does not see" (v. 7). Now he continues the argument he began in verse 9. The maker of the ear hears and the shaper of the eye sees. In the same way, God is the great trainer of nations. The word means correcting and shaping, the way a parent or teacher disciplines, not just punishing. Can such a God fail to rebuke? That verb comes from the law court. It means to expose the wrong, convict the guilty and settle the case. No object is named, but the people in view are the scoffers who crush God's people and kill the widow, the stranger and the orphan (vv. 5–6).

    There is wordplay. In verse 9 God is yōṣēr, "the one who formed" the eye. Here he is yōsēr, "the one who disciplines" the nations. The two words sound almost alike, so the Creator and the Corrector are heard as the same God.

    The second line is left deliberately unfinished: "He who teaches humankind knowledge —". The Hebrew stops on the word "knowledge" and lets the hearer fill in the obvious end: does he himself not know? Verse 11 then says it plainly: "The LORD knows the thoughts of humankind, that they are a mere breath." The idea that God does not notice is not just wrong but ridiculous. All human knowing is something God taught, so its source cannot be blind. In verse 12 the same two verbs, discipline and teach, return as a blessing on the person who accepts God's instruction.

    Full study →
  3. 11The LORD knows the thoughts of man, that they are futile.

    Yahweh, the very God the oppressors claim "does not see", knows every scheme people work out. He knows them all the time and all the way through, and he knows they are only breath: a puff of vapor, there for a moment, weighing nothing, already passing away.

    The verse closes an argument. In verses 8–10 the psalmist asks a string of questions. Can the one who planted the ear not hear? Can the one who formed the eye not see? Can the one who teaches humankind knowledge lack it? Then comes the plain conclusion. The God who gives humans their knowledge knows humans. The "thoughts" are calculations, plans and plots, like those of the men in verses 4–7 who crush widows and orphans and tell themselves no one is watching.

    God's verdict on those plans is hebel, "breath". The word does not only mean "wrong" or "failed". It means flimsy and short-lived, like the steam of a breath in cold air. The pronoun "they" is masculine and the word "thoughts" is feminine, so the line probably also means that the schemers themselves are breath. Other psalms say exactly this about human beings ("ʾādām is like a breath," Ps 144:4). Both the plotters and their plots are vapor before the God who sees them.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v9

    can He not hear? … can He not see?

    hălōʾ yišmāʿ … hălōʾ yabbîṭ

    What we hear
    A question about God's ability or general all-knowing awareness, as if the point were the abstract doctrine that God perceives everything.
    What they heard
    A question about God's attention and response. 'Hear' in Hebrew means hear and act; 'look' means look closely and take note. The wicked's claim (v. 7) is not that God is unable to perceive but that he does not pay attention. The answer is that he does, and judgment follows (v. 23).
  • in v10

    heathen (KJV)

    gôyim

    What we hear
    Uncivilized, irreligious or savage people. It carries a moral and cultural put-down.
    What they heard
    Nations or peoples as political and ethnic groups, usually those other than Israel. The word itself makes no comment on how civilized they are.
  • in v10

    chastiseth / disciplines / punish

    yōsēr … yôkîaḥ

    What we hear
    Handing out penalties: God as the enforcer.
    What they heard
    Yāsar is training and correction aimed at shaping, the way a parent or teacher disciplines. Yākaḥ is exposing and convicting in a legal dispute. Together they picture God as teacher and judge, not only as the one who hands out penalties. Verse 12 calls this same discipline a blessing.
  • in v11

    vanity (KJV, YLT)

    hebel

    What we hear
    Conceit; excessive pride in one's looks or achievements.
    What they heard
    Breath, vapor: something transient, insubstantial, coming to nothing. The verse says nothing about self-admiration.
  • in v11

    thoughts

    maḥšəbôt

    What we hear
    Private feelings, fleeting ideas, whatever passes through one's mind.
    What they heard
    Reckonings, plans, designs, often deliberate schemes. Here it means the calculations of oppressors who assume God is not watching.
Every word
  1. הֲנֹ֣טַֽע

    hanōṭaʿ · H5193

    (the one) planting · v9

    The question marker ha- attached to a participle used as a title: 'the Planter of'. The verb is a farming word, used for setting trees and vines in the ground. Here God 'planted' the ear in the head the way a farmer sets a shoot in soil: deliberately, carefully, so it stays put and works.

  2. אֹ֭זֶן

    ʾōzen · H241

    ear · v9

    The physical ear, but in Hebrew also the organ of attention and response ('incline your ear'). No article: 'ear' in general, every ear that exists.

  3. הֲלֹ֣א

    hălōʾ · H3808

    not? · v9, v10

    Question marker plus 'not', which expects the answer 'Yes, of course'. It turns the line into a challenge the hearer cannot honestly answer with a no.

  4. יִשְׁמָ֑ע

    yišmāʿ · H8085

    he hears · v9

    An unfinished-action verb form: 'does he / will he hear'. In the Psalms 'hear' regularly means hear and respond, especially to the cry of the oppressed. The wicked are counting on God not hearing.

  5. אִֽם־

    ʾim · H518

    or · v9

    Introduces the second half of a paired question: 'or…?' It ties the two lines into one argument rather than two separate points.

  6. יֹ֥צֵֽר

    yōṣēr · H3335

    (the one) forming · v9

    Participle used as a title: 'the Shaper of'. The word is the potter's verb (a potter is a yōṣēr), the same verb used when God shapes the human from the ground in Genesis 2:7. It pictures handcrafted precision.

  7. עַ֝֗יִן

    ʿayin · H5869

    eye · v9

    The eye, the organ of sight and of attention ('the eyes of the LORD are on…'). Again no article: every eye.

  8. יַבִּֽיט׃

    yabbîṭ · H5027

    he looks · v9

    An unfinished-action form of a verb meaning to look at, look closely, pay attention to. It is more than having eyesight: it is directing one's gaze at something and taking note of it. It answers the boast of verse 7, 'The LORD does not see.'

  9. הֲיֹסֵ֣ר

    hayōsēr · H3256

    to discipline, instruct, correct · v10

    The prefixed ha- marks a question. The verb is a participle, 'the one who disciplines', used as a title for God. Yasar is the language of training and correction, how a parent or teacher shapes someone, often painfully. It is more than punishment. It also sounds almost the same as yōṣēr, 'the one who formed', in verse 9, so the poet is playing on the sound.

  10. גּ֭וֹיִם

    gôyim · H1471A

    nation, people · v10

    'Nations' means whole peoples. Usually it points to peoples other than Israel, but here it may also mean humanity in its peoples, alongside 'humankind' in the next line. The point is scale: God corrects entire nations.

  11. יוֹכִ֑יחַ

    yôkîaḥ · H3198

    to rebuke, reprove, argue a case, convict · v10

    'Will he not rebuke / call to account?' Yakach comes from legal disputes and correction: exposing wrong, proving someone guilty, setting things right. The verb has no object. The person being rebuked is left open, but in context it points at the scoffing oppressors of verses 4–8.

  12. הַֽמְלַמֵּ֖ד

    hamlammēd · H3925G

    to teach · v10

    'The one who teaches' is another participle used as a title for God. The verb is lamad in its 'cause to learn' form, the root behind later words for disciple and study. God is pictured as humanity's teacher.

  13. אָדָ֣ם

    ʾādām · H0120G

    human being, humankind · v10, v11

    This is the general word for humans, not males in particular: 'humankind'. It looks ahead to verse 11, 'the LORD knows the thoughts of ʾādām.'

  14. דָּֽעַת׃

    dāʿat · H1847

    knowledge, understanding, perception · v10

    'Knowledge' is what God teaches humankind. The sentence stops here with no main verb. The listener is left to finish it: the source of all human knowing surely knows. Verse 11 then says it outright: 'The LORD knows (yōdēaʿ)…'.

  15. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD, Yahweh · v11

    Israel's God, named by his personal name. In verse 7 the wicked said 'Yah does not see.' Here the psalmist answers with the full name: Yahweh is exactly the one who does see.

  16. יֹדֵעַ

    yōdēaʿ · H3045

    knowing · v11

    A participle, so it describes an ongoing state: Yahweh is always knowing, right now. It picks up the word 'knowledge' (daʿat) at the end of verse 10. The God who teaches humans knowledge is the God who knows humans.

  17. מַחְשְׁבוֹת

    maḥšəbôt · H4284

    thoughts, plans, schemes · v11

    Not stray feelings but calculations and designs, the plans people work out in their heads. In this psalm that means the scheming of the oppressors in verses 4–7.

  18. כִּי־

    kî · H3588

    that; for, because · v11

    Most likely 'that', introducing what God knows about these thoughts (compare 'God saw the light, that it was good,' Gen 1:4). It could also mean 'for': God sees through them because they are only breath.

  19. הֵמָּה

    hēmmâ · H1992

    they (masculine) · v11

    An emphatic 'they'. It is masculine while 'thoughts' is feminine, so it may point back to the humans (ʾādām as a group) as well as, or instead of, their thoughts. See debates.

  20. הָבֶל

    hābel · H1892

    breath, vapor; futility · v11

    Literally a puff of breath or vapor: something real but passing and without weight. The plotters and their plans are this kind of thing in God's sight, gone as soon as they appear.

The world behind it

The quarrel behind the verse. Psalm 94 opens by calling on the "God of vengeance", meaning God as the judge who sets wrongs right, not as someone with a personal grudge (v. 1–2). The wicked "crush your people", "kill the widow and the sojourner, murder the fatherless" (v. 5–6). These were the three groups with no male protector and no land, whom the Torah placed under God's direct care (Exod 22:21–24; Deut 10:18; 24:17–21). The oppressors do not deny that God exists. Their view is practical: "Yah does not see; the God of Jacob does not take notice" (v. 7). For them God is distant, unconcerned or easily ignored.

Who is being addressed. Verse 8 speaks to "the senseless among the people" (bāʿām), which most likely means Israelites, not foreign enemies. The words used, "brutish" (like cattle) and "fools", are wisdom-literature words for people who live as if there will be no accounting. Verses 8–11 read like a wise teacher's rebuke.

The kind of argument. Verses 9–10 argue from lesser to greater, a form later Jewish teachers called qal wahomer, "light and heavy": if a creature can hear, how much more its Maker. Verse 10 continues: the One who disciplines nations and teaches humans knowledge cannot lack knowledge.

The idol contrast. Israel's poets mocked idols as objects with "ears, but they do not hear; eyes, but they do not see" (Ps 115:5–6; 135:16–17), and said their makers become like them. Psalm 94:9 reverses the picture: the LORD is not a made object with dead senses but the one who makes senses. Acting as if he cannot see quietly treats him like an idol.

Liturgical use. The Greek Septuagint heading assigns the psalm to the fourth day of the week, and the Mishnah (Tamid 7:4) lists Psalm 94 as the Levites' Wednesday psalm in the Second Temple. It was sung regularly in worship, not only in times of crisis.

From the study of Psalm 94:9.

Where scholars differ

in v10

How should the unfinished second line ('He who teaches humankind knowledge —') be read?

  • A deliberate break-off for effect. The listener supplies 'does he not know?', and verse 11 gives the answer.

    The ancient versions (Greek and Latin) show the same short text. Verse 11 opens with 'The LORD knows (yōdēaʿ)', which completes the thought, and its verb comes from the same root as dāʿat. ESV and KJV both treat the line this way.

  • Words like 'shall he not know?' have dropped out of the text.

    Verse 9 sets up a firm pattern of 'He who X, does he not Y?' and the first half of verse 10 follows it. A missing verb would complete the pattern. Against this, no manuscript or ancient version has the extra words.

  • The line is not a question. It is a title that runs into verse 11: 'He who teaches humankind knowledge, the LORD, knows the thoughts of humankind.'

    YLT takes it roughly this way. It needs no change to the text, but it breaks the question-and-answer pattern of verses 9–10a.

in v10

Who are the 'nations' God disciplines?

  • Foreign nations judged in history. The argument runs from the greater to the lesser: if God corrects whole peoples, he will surely correct these individual oppressors.

    'Nations' (gôyim) in the plural usually means non-Israelite peoples. The oppressors seem to be within Israel ('you senseless among the people', v. 8), so the comparison works from nations down to individuals.

  • Humanity at large, in parallel with 'humankind' (ʾādām) in the next line. God is the universal teacher and corrector of all peoples.

    The parallel 'nations' / 'humankind' in verse 10. Job 35:11 and Isaiah 28:26 speak of God teaching people in general. The Septuagint's paideuō suggests education as much as punishment.

  • The 'nations' are the oppressors themselves, foreign rulers crushing 'your people' (v. 5).

    Verse 5 speaks of God's 'people' and 'inheritance' being crushed, which fits foreign domination. But verse 8's 'among the people' points to Israelites, so most commentators prefer the first or second view.

in v11

Who or what is 'they' that is 'a breath': the thoughts, or the humans who think them?

  • The thoughts/plans are hebel.

    This is the most natural reading of the 'knows X, that X is…' construction (compare Gen 1:4, 'God saw the light, that it was good'). The Septuagint and Paul (1 Cor 3:20) both read it this way. Hebrew does sometimes use a masculine pronoun for a feminine noun, so the mismatch is not decisive.

  • The humans (ʾādām, taken as a group) are hebel.

    The pronoun hēmmâ is masculine plural, matching people rather than the feminine 'thoughts'. The Psalms repeatedly call humans hebel (39:5, 11; 62:9; 144:4). Read this way, kî can also mean 'for': God knows human schemes because humans are only breath and easily seen through.

  • Deliberately both.

    In poetry the ambiguity may be intended. The schemers and their schemes share the same nature, and the overall sense (transient, weightless, seen through by God) is the same either way.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נָטַע, יָצַר, נָבַט, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. נבט (hiphil: look at, regard)
  • LXX Psalm 93:9 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate Psalm 93:9
  • Mishnah Tamid 7:4 (Levitical psalms of the week)
  • Cross-references: Exod 4:11; Exod 22:22–24; Prov 20:12; Ps 33:13–15; Ps 115:5–6; Ps 135:16–17; Isa 29:15–16
  • BDB s.v. יָסַר, יָכַח, לָמַד, דַּעַת
  • HALOT s.v. יסר, יכח
  • Septuagint, Psalm 93:10 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Psalm 93:10 (Gallican Psalter)
  • Mishnah Tamid 7:4
  • M. E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • H.-J. Kraus, Psalms 60–150
  • F.-L. Hossfeld & E. Zenger, Psalms 2 (Hermeneia)
  • J. Goldingay, Psalms vol. 3 (Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms)
  • BDB s.v. הֶבֶל, מַחֲשָׁבָה, יָדַע
  • HALOT s.v. הֶבֶל; s.v. מַחֲשָׁבָה
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch–Cowley), on masculine pronouns referring to feminine nouns
  • Septuagint, Psalm 93:11 (Rahlfs); NETS
  • 1 Corinthians 3:20 (NA28)
  • Vulgate, Psalm 93:11
  • Mishnah Tamid 7:4 (Levitical psalm for the fourth day)
  • F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Psalms

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).