Sirach Chapter 31 Read as one passage

Sirach 31:5–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

5He who loves gold won’t be justified. He who follows destruction will himself have his fill of it. 6Many have been given over to ruin for the sake of gold. Their destruction meets them face to face. 7It is a stumbling block to those who sacrifice to it. Every fool will be taken by it. 8Blessed is the rich person who is found blameless, and who doesn’t go after gold. 9Who is he, that we may call him blessed? For he has done wonderful things among his people. 10Who has been tried by it, and found perfect? Then let him boast. Who has had the power to transgress, and has not transgressed? And to do evil, and has not done it? 11His prosperity will be made sure. The congregation will proclaim his alms.

What the first hearers heard

Ben Sira's students were young men of Jerusalem's scribal and well-to-do classes, being trained for public life, the courts and dealings with powerful people. To them the verse said four things:

  • Wealth is a test, not a reward. Having money does not prove God's favour. It is a furnace that shows what a man is made of, and most come out as dross (vv. 5–7).
  • Virtue is measured by opportunity. The man worth praising is the one who could have bent the law, taken bribes or exploited the poor, and refused. Ben Sira is talking about real power held back.
  • Honour is real and public. In an honour-and-shame society he does not tell such a man to hide his integrity. It is his rightful 'boast', and the assembly (ekklēsia, the gathered community of Israel, v. 11) will tell of his almsgiving.
  • It is rare. The rhetorical questions, 'Who is he?', 'Who has been tested…?', make his students feel how uncommon this is, and so how much it is worth aiming for.

The verse echoes the Torah's ideal of the person who is 'whole' (tamim) before God, like Noah and Abraham, whom Ben Sira later praises as 'found perfect' and 'found faithful in testing' (44:17, 20).

From the study of Sirach 31:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 5He who loves gold won’t be justified. He who follows destruction will himself have his fill of it.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 6Many have been given over to ruin for the sake of gold. Their destruction meets them face to face.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 7It is a stumbling block to those who sacrifice to it. Every fool will be taken by it.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 8Blessed is the rich person who is found blameless, and who doesn’t go after gold.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  5. 9Who is he, that we may call him blessed? For he has done wonderful things among his people.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 10Who has been tried by it, and found perfect? Then let him boast. Who has had the power to transgress, and has not transgressed? And to do evil, and has not done it?

    Ben Sira has just called blessed the rich man 'who was found blameless and did not go chasing after gold' (v. 8), and then asked, as if such a person can hardly exist, 'Who is he? We will call him blessed!' (v. 9). Now he spells out what that man went through and what he earned:

    Who has been put to the assay by gold, the way a smelter tests metal in the fire, and come out whole and sound, with his integrity intact? Then let that be his rightful honour, something he may hold his head up about. Who had it in his power to step over the line of God's commands, and did not step over it? Who could have done harm to others, and did not do it?

    There are two pictures. The first is the furnace. Gold is usually the thing being tested, but here gold does the testing and the man is the metal. 'Found perfect' means he came out complete and genuine, not that he was flawless. The second is the line he could have crossed. Wealth gave him the means to bribe, cheat or crush the weak with nobody to stop him, and he held back. The questions are meant to be answered 'very few', and that rarity is why the honour is real. In a world run on honour and shame, Ben Sira grants such a man legitimate public glory. The next verse says what it looks like: his prosperity will stand firm, and the assembly will tell of his generosity to the poor.

    Full study →
  7. 11His prosperity will be made sure. The congregation will proclaim his alms.

    Therefore the good he has (his wealth, and with it his good name) will be made to stand firm. The whole gathered community will tell, and keep telling, the story of the mercy he showed to the needy.

    This verse completes a short portrait (31:8–11) of something Ben Sira thinks is rare: a rich man who comes through his wealth with clean hands. He 'did not go after gold'. He had the power to break the law and do harm, and he did not (31:10). The verse names his reward in two parts:

    • Security. In the rest of the chapter wealth eats at the body, steals sleep, and trips up those who love it (31:1–7). This man's wealth is made firm. The passive wording suggests God, or the moral order of the world, is what holds it steady. He does not have to clutch it.
    • Honour. His generous deeds become public memory. The assembly, meaning the gathered people of Jerusalem and Israel and not a church, recounts them in full. He is not the one advertising them. In a world run on honour, this was the highest outcome a life could have: a name praised among the people.

    The Greek says the assembly recounts his acts of mercy (eleēmosynai): concrete giving to the poor, which Judaism of the time counted as righteousness itself. The surviving Hebrew seems to have said the assembly recounts his praise. The two readings are close. The praise is for what he did with his money.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    found perfect

    eteleiōthē (teleioō)

    What we hear
    Sinless and flawless, with no moral fault at all.
    What they heard
    Brought to completion, proven whole and sound. He came through the test with his integrity intact, like metal that comes out of the furnace genuine.
  • in v10

    let him boast / glory

    kauchēsis

    What we hear
    Bragging, arrogant self-promotion that the Bible disapproves of.
    What they heard
    A legitimate ground of honour, a rightful claim to public esteem in a society governed by honour and shame.
  • in v11

    congregation (Vulgate/Douay: "church of the saints")

    ekklēsia (Hebrew qahal)

    What we hear
    A church congregation, or Christians gathered for worship.
    What they heard
    The assembled community of Israel, or the local public assembly in Jerusalem, where a man's reputation was spoken and judged.
  • in v11

    alms

    eleēmosynai

    What we hear
    Small, occasional handouts to beggars. An old-fashioned word for minor charity.
    What they heard
    Concrete acts of mercy and generosity to the poor, which Judaism of the time counted as righteousness (ṣedaqah) and valued highly before God.
Every word
  1. τίς

    tis · G5101

    who? · v10

    A rhetorical question that expects the answer 'hardly anyone'. It picks up v. 9's 'Who is he, that we may call him blessed?' and stresses how rare such a person is.

  2. ἐδοκιμάσθη

    edokimasthē · G1381

    test, assay, prove · v10

    A metalworker's word for testing ore or coin to see if it is genuine. Here it is passive: the man has been put to the test. The irony is that gold, which is normally the thing tested, here does the testing.

  3. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, by · v10

    Means 'by means of' or 'in the matter of'. The test is carried out through the thing named next.

  4. αὐτῷ

    autō · G846

    it / him · v10, v11

    Most naturally points back to the gold (chrysion) of v. 8, which the blameless rich man 'did not go after'. Wealth is the furnace he was tested in.

  5. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v10, v11

    Joins the test to its outcome: he was tested and came through.

  6. ἐτελειώθη

    eteleiōthē · G5048

    bring to completion, make whole · v10

    He was shown to be complete, whole and sound, with nothing missing. It means integrity that has been proven, not flawless sinlessness.

  7. ἔστω

    estō · G1510

    let it be · v10

    A command form: 'let it be'. It grants permission or approval. Some witnesses read the future ἔσται, 'it will be', which turns it into a promise.

  8. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, for · v10

    'For' in the sense of 'serving as': let it serve him as a ground of honour.

  9. καύχησιν

    kauchēsin · G2746

    boasting, ground of pride · v10

    A legitimate claim to honour, something a person may rightly take pride in. In this context it is positive.

  10. ἐδύνατο

    edynato · G1410

    be able · v10

    He had the means and the opportunity. Wealth gives a man the power to bribe, cheat and oppress, and to get away with it.

  11. παραβῆναι

    parabēnai · G3845

    step over, transgress · v10

    Literally 'to step across' a line, meaning to break a commandment or covenant obligation. It is a picture of crossing a boundary.

  12. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v10

    A flat statement of fact: he did not.

  13. ποιῆσαι

    poiēsai · G4160

    to do · v10

    'To do', still governed by 'was able': he was able to do harm.

  14. κακὰ

    kaka · G2556

    bad things, harms · v10

    A plural meaning concrete wrongs and injuries to others, such as the harm a powerful man can do to the weak.

  15. στερεωθήσεται

    stereōthēsetai · G4732

    make firm, make solid, establish · v11

    Future passive: 'will be made firm'. The rich man's wealth will stand solid and not collapse. Sirach treats it as something secured for him, not something he anxiously holds onto (compare the sleepless worry over wealth in 31:1–2). The Hebrew is generally read as yeḥezaq, 'will be strong'.

  16. τὰ

    ta · G3588

    the · v11

    Neuter plural article that makes 'good' into a noun: 'the good things'.

  17. ἀγαθὰ

    agatha · G18

    good; (pl.) goods, property, prosperity · v11

    'The good things' is the usual Greek idiom for possessions and wealth (as in Luke 12:18–19). Behind it the Hebrew ṭûbô can mean both 'his prosperity' and 'his goodness', so the original may be deliberately two-sided: his good fortune and his good character both hold firm.

  18. ἐλεημοσύνας

    eleēmosynas · G1654

    mercy shown, charitable deed, alms · v11

    The plural means concrete deeds of generosity, especially giving to the poor. In Judaism of this period such giving was a central form of righteousness. The Hebrew probably had 'his praise' here instead (see variants).

  19. ἐκδιηγήσεται

    ekdiēgēsetai · G1555

    tell in detail, recount fully · v11

    Future: 'will recount in full'. The prefixes ek- and dia- give the sense of telling the whole story through to the end. His generosity becomes a story the community keeps telling. It is not something he announces about himself.

  20. ἐκκλησία

    ekklēsia · G1577

    assembly, gathering · v11

    The gathered community of Israel, or the local public assembly where reputations were made and judged. It stands for the Hebrew qahal. It is not a church.

The world behind it

Who wrote it and when. Yeshua ben Eleazar ben Sira was a Jerusalem scribe and teacher of wisdom. He wrote in Hebrew around 180 BC. His grandson translated the book into Greek in Egypt after 132 BC. Ben Sira wrote under Hellenistic rule (the Greek-speaking kingdoms that followed Alexander the Great), just as Judea passed from the Ptolemies of Egypt to the Seleucids of Syria. Fortunes were being made through tax-farming and trade; the Tobiad family is the famous example. The gap between the wealthy elite and the poor was a live issue.

The passage. Sirach 31:1–11 is a short unit on wealth. Worrying over money ruins sleep (vv. 1–2). The rich labour to pile up more (vv. 3–4). 'One who loves gold will not be justified' (v. 5). Many have been ruined by gold (vv. 6–7). Against this background vv. 8–11 describe the rare exception: a rich man found blameless. Ben Sira does not condemn wealth as such; elsewhere he says 'riches are good if they are free from sin' (13:24). What he insists on is that wealth is a test and most people fail it.

The furnace image. Testing gold in fire was a familiar picture in Israelite wisdom (Proverbs 17:3; 27:21) and in Ben Sira's own book (2:5). By making gold the tester, he turns a stock image upside down.

Survival of the text. This part of the book survives in Greek and also in a medieval Hebrew manuscript from the Cairo Genizah, the storeroom of an old Cairo synagogue (Manuscript B). This study rests on the Greek. The Hebrew is broadly parallel, but its exact wording is not reproduced here.

From the study of Sirach 31:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

What does 'by it' (en autō) refer to?

  • Gold or wealth: he was tested by gold.

    The nearest suitable noun is chrysion, 'gold', in v. 8 ('did not go after gold'), and the whole unit 31:1–11 is about wealth. The furnace image with gold (Sirach 2:5) fits. This is the majority reading, reflected in KJV 'thereby' and WEB 'by it'.

  • 'In him / in this matter': tested in his own person or in the situation just described.

    Grammatically αὐτῷ could be masculine or neuter, and some interpreters read it more generally. But the context makes gold the natural reference, and the difference in meaning is small.

in v11

Did the original say the assembly recounts his 'acts of mercy' or his 'praise'?

  • 'His praise' is original. The Greek translator interpreted it as almsgiving.

    The Hebrew manuscript B reading. Sirach's repeated formula 'the assembly will proclaim his praise' (39:10; 44:15). NABRE follows the Hebrew.

  • 'His acts of mercy' reflects a real Hebrew reading or the intended sense.

    It is the unanimous Greek witness. Almsgiving is a major theme in Sirach (3:30; 29:12), and the context is a rich man's use of wealth. NRSV and most translations from the Greek follow it.

Sources
  • Septuaginta, ed. A. Rahlfs (Sirach 34:10 in Rahlfs' numbering)
  • Septuaginta Gottingensis XII/2, Sapientia Iesu Filii Sirach, ed. J. Ziegler
  • BDAG s.v. δοκιμάζω, τελειόω, καύχησις, παραβαίνω
  • LSJ s.v. δοκιμάζω
  • P. W. Skehan & A. A. Di Lella, The Wisdom of Ben Sira (Anchor Bible 39)
  • P. C. Beentjes, The Book of Sirach in Hebrew (Manuscript B)
  • Vulgate, Sirach 31:10
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Sirach 34:11 (= 31:11 in Hebrew order)
  • Ziegler, Sapientia Iesu Filii Sirach (Göttingen Septuagint)
  • Skehan & Di Lella, The Wisdom of Ben Sira (Anchor Bible 39)
  • Beentjes, The Book of Sirach in Hebrew (MS B)
  • BDAG s.v. ἐλεημοσύνη, ἐκκλησία, στερεόω, ἐκδιηγέομαι
  • Muraoka, Greek-English Lexicon of the Septuagint s.v. ἐλεημοσύνη
  • Vulgate, Sirach 31:11; Douay-Rheims

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

5 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.