1 Chronicles Chapter 2 Read as one passage

1 Chronicles 2:22–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

22Segub was the father of Jair, who had twenty-three cities in the land of Gilead. 23But Geshur and Aram captured Havvoth-jair, along with Kenath and its sixty surrounding villages. All these were descendants of Machir the father of Gilead.

What the first hearers heard

Chronicles was written for Judeans in the small Persian-era province of Yehud, probably in the 4th century BC. By then Gilead and Bashan had been out of Israelite hands for centuries.

For these readers the genealogies did several things:

  • They kept 'all Israel' in view. Even in Judah's own genealogy, the Chronicler weaves in clans east of the Jordan. Judah's family tree reaches across the river through Hezron's marriage into Machir's house.
  • They preserved claims and memories of land. Naming Havvoth-jair and Kenath recorded that these places once belonged to Israelite clans, with ancestors whose names were on the land.
  • They faced loss honestly. The note that Geshur and Aram took the towns 'from them' does not hide the loss. A community that had lost land, king and independence heard its own story in that admission.
  • They gave identity through belonging. 'All these were sons of Machir' answers the question genealogies existed to answer: whose are these people? Clan placement shaped inheritance, status and place in the people of Israel.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 2:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 22Segub was the father of Jair, who had twenty-three cities in the land of Gilead.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 23But Geshur and Aram captured Havvoth-jair, along with Kenath and its sixty surrounding villages. All these were descendants of Machir the father of Gilead.

    Verse 22 has just said that Jair, grandson of Judah's ancestor Hezron through a daughter of Machir, controlled twenty-three settlements in Gilead. Now the record adds a frank note: Geshur and Aram, the Aramean neighbours to the north and east, took Jair's tent-villages away from his people. They also took Kenath, the hill-town with the cluster of farming villages that depended on it (in Hebrew, 'her daughters'). In all, sixty settlements passed out of Israelite hands. These were small highland towns and hamlets, not 'cities' as we picture them.

    The last line places all these people in their clan. They were counted as descendants of Machir, the founding ancestor of Gilead. They belonged to Manasseh's house through their mother, even though their father's line ran back to Judah.

    The verse holds both pride and loss. It remembers a territory named after an Israelite forefather, and it admits openly that foreigners took that territory.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    cities (KJV, WEB: "sixty cities")

    'ir

    What we hear
    Sixty sizable urban centres.
    What they heard
    Sixty permanent settlements, mostly small highland towns and villages of a few hundred people, some walled.
  • in v23

    father of Gilead

    'ăvi gil'ād

    What we hear
    Machir was the biological father of a man named Gilead, and nothing more.
    What they heard
    Machir was the ancestor and founding chief of the Gileadite clans and, by extension, of the land of Gilead. Gilead is both a person's name and a region.
Every word
  1. וַיִּקַּ֣ח

    vayyiqqaḥ · H3947

    take, seize · v23

    "And (he/it) took." In a military setting this means 'captured'. The verb is singular, but in Hebrew a verb placed before a compound subject often agrees only with the first noun. So it fits 'Geshur and Aram took' perfectly well.

  2. גְּשֽׁוּר־

    gəshur · H1650

    Geshur · v23

    A small Aramean kingdom in the Golan, east and northeast of the Sea of Galilee. Grammatically it is the first half of the subject: the Geshurites are the ones who captured the towns.

  3. וַ֠אֲרָם

    va'ăram · H758

    Aram (the Arameans) · v23

    "And Aram": the Aramean states to the north, most likely the power centred on Damascus. Paired with Geshur, it names the northern neighbours who pushed Israel out of Bashan.

  4. אֶת־

    'et · H853

    [direct-object marker] · v23

    Untranslatable particle that marks what follows as the object. Because it stands before 'Havvoth-jair' and not before 'Geshur', the towns are what was taken and Geshur and Aram are the takers.

  5. חַוֹּ֨ת

    ḥavvot · H2334

    tent-villages, encampments · v23

    Plural 'havvoth of', the first part of the place-name Havvoth-jair. The word probably first meant a ring of tents or an encampment, later the settlements that grew out of them.

  6. מֵאִתָּ֛ם

    mē'ittām · H854

    from with them · v23

    "From them", meaning from Jair's people, the Israelite clan that held the towns. The phrase marks the event as a loss: the towns were taken away from their owners.

  7. קְנָ֥ת

    qənāt · H7079

    Kenath · v23

    A town in eastern Bashan that Nobah captured and renamed after himself (Numbers 32:42). It is usually identified with Qanawat in the Hauran hills of southern Syria, the later Canatha.

  8. בְּנֹתֶ֖יהָ

    bənōteyhā · H1323

    daughters; dependent villages · v23

    Literally 'her daughters'. This is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying the smaller villages that depended on a main town, which is pictured as their mother.

  9. שִׁשִּׁ֣ים

    shishshim · H8346

    sixty · v23

    Sixty, the same total that Joshua 13:30 and 1 Kings 4:13 give for Jair's towns in Bashan. Here it seems to cover the whole territory lost, Kenath's district included.

  10. עִ֑יר

    'ir · H5892

    town, settlement · v23

    Singular after the number, as Hebrew normally writes it: 'sixty town(s)'. An 'ir was any permanent settlement, often small. It does not mean a 'city' in the modern sense.

  11. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all · v23

    "All". It sums up the group just listed.

  12. אֵ֕לֶּה

    'ēlleh · H428

    these · v23

    "These". It most naturally points back to the people of verses 21–23 (Segub, Jair and their clan), possibly together with the settlements they held.

  13. בְּנֵ֖י

    bənē · H1121

    sons, descendants, members of · v23

    "Sons of", in the broad sense: descendants, or members of a clan. There is no verb 'were' in the Hebrew. The point is which clan these people are counted under.

  14. מָכִ֥יר

    mākhir · H4353

    Machir · v23

    Machir, Manasseh's son, the leading clan of eastern Manasseh. Hezron had married Machir's daughter (v. 21), so her descendants are reckoned to Machir.

  15. אֲבִי־

    'ăvi · H1

    father (of) · v23

    "Father of". In these genealogies it often means founder, chief or ancestor of a clan or region, not only a biological father (compare 'Ashhur the father of Tekoa' in v. 24).

  16. גִלְעָֽד׃

    gil'ād · H1568

    Gilead · v23

    Gilead is both the name of Machir's son (Numbers 26:29) and the name of the hill country east of the Jordan. 'Father of Gilead' presents Machir as the ancestor and founder of the Gileadite clans and their land.

The world behind it

Where this is. Havvoth-jair and Kenath lay in Bashan and northern Gilead, the fertile highlands east of the Jordan and the Sea of Galilee (today's Golan, northern Jordan and the Hauran of southern Syria). Kenath is usually identified with Qanawat, which later became Canatha, one of the Decapolis cities of New Testament times.

Who took it. Geshur was a small Aramean kingdom in the Golan. David married Maacah, daughter of Talmai king of Geshur, and Absalom fled to Geshur (2 Samuel 3:3; 13:37–38). Aram means the Aramean states, especially Aram-Damascus. Damascus was a constant rival for these borderlands: Rezon in Solomon's day (1 Kings 11:23–25), Ben-hadad, and Hazael, who took 'all the land of Gilead… and Bashan' from Israel (2 Kings 10:32–33). The verse does not say when the loss happened.

The earlier traditions. Numbers 32:41–42 and Deuteronomy 3:14 tell how Jair and Nobah of Manasseh conquered these areas and named them after themselves. Judges 10:3–4 mentions thirty towns of Jair, and Joshua 13:30 and 1 Kings 4:13 mention sixty. Chronicles brings these traditions together: Jair's 23 towns (v. 22), plus Kenath and its villages, make up the sixty lost.

Mixed lineage. In verse 21, the elderly Hezron (a Judahite) marries Machir's daughter. Ancient Israel normally traced descent through the father. In frontier settings, though, a family could be counted under the mother's clan when it lived on that clan's land. That is how Jair is 'son of Manasseh' in Numbers and part of Judah's genealogy in Chronicles.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 2:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

Who took what: did Geshur and Aram capture Jair's towns, or did Jair capture Geshur and Aram?

  • Geshur and Aram are the subjects. They took the towns from Jair's people. (Septuagint, Vulgate, most modern versions and commentaries)

    The object marker 'et stands before Havvoth-jair. A singular verb before a compound subject is ordinary Hebrew. 'From them' only makes sense if Israelites lost the towns. Historically, the Arameans repeatedly took Bashan.

  • 'He' (Jair or Segub) is the subject and took Geshur and Aram along with the towns. (KJV, YLT)

    The singular verb continues from v. 22, where Jair is the subject. Numbers 32:41 and Deuteronomy 3:14 tell of Jair's conquests. But this reading struggles with the position of 'et and with 'from them'.

in v23

When was the territory lost?

  • Under Solomon or soon after, when Aram-Damascus rose under Rezon.

    1 Kings 11:23–25 describes Rezon as an adversary to Israel. 1 Kings 4:13 still lists the sixty towns under Solomon's administration, so the loss would come after that.

  • In the 9th century BC wars with Hazael of Damascus.

    2 Kings 10:32–33 says Hazael struck Israel 'in all the land of Gilead… and Bashan'.

  • The time cannot be fixed. The note may combine several losses.

    The verse gives no date, and control of these borderlands changed hands many times.

in v23

What does 'all these' refer to?

  • The people of vv. 21–23 (Segub, Jair and their clan), counted as Machir's descendants.

    'Sons of' is a genealogical formula. The line explains why Judahite Hezron's offspring are counted under Manasseh.

  • The settlements, as belonging to Machir's clans.

    KJV and YLT add '[belonged to]'. The nearest thing just mentioned is the 'sixty towns'.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.