4 Maccabees Chapter 18 Read as one passage
4 Maccabees 18:11–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11He used to read to you about the slaying of Abel by Cain, the offering up of Isaac, and the imprisonment of Joseph. 12He used to tell you of the zealous Phinehas, and informed you of Ananias, Azarias, and Misael in the fire. 13He used to glorify Daniel, who was in the den of lions, and pronounce him blessed. 14He used to remind you of the scripture of Esaias, which says, “Even if you pass through the fire, it won’t burn you.” 15He chanted to you David, the hymn writer, who says, “Many are the afflictions of the just.” 16He declared the proverbs of Solomon, who says, “He is a tree of life to all those who do His will.” 17He used to confirm what Ezekiel said: “Will these dry bones live?” 18For he didn’t forget the song which Moses taught, proclaiming, “I will kill, and I will make alive.” 19This is our life and the length of our days.
What the first hearers heard
For Greek-speaking Jews of the first century, this verse took a familiar proverb about wisdom and made it a promise for people under persecution.
- Torah is wisdom. Swapping "those who hold fast to her" for "those who do his will" puts into practice a conviction shared by Sirach 24 and Baruch 3–4: true wisdom is obedience to God's Law. The audience lived among Greek philosophy, and 4 Maccabees argues that the Jewish Law is the highest philosophy.
- Life beyond death. The image of Eden's tree of life, set in a list running from "many are the afflictions of the righteous" to "shall these dry bones live?" and "I kill and I make alive", told them that faithfulness is not cancelled by a martyr's death. God gives the obedient a life that a tyrant cannot reach.
- Family and teaching. The scene shows a model Jewish household. The father teaches Scripture again and again, and the mother passes his teaching on at the decisive moment. The book presents this home teaching as what made the brothers' courage possible, and so as an example for its readers' own families.
- Identity. The audience lived as a minority under pressure to conform. To them, "all who do his will" meant those who stay loyal to the Law when giving it up would be easier.
From the study of 4 Maccabees 18:16.
Verse by verse
-
11He used to read to you about the slaying of Abel by Cain, the offering up of Isaac, and the imprisonment of Joseph.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
12He used to tell you of the zealous Phinehas, and informed you of Ananias, Azarias, and Misael in the fire.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
13He used to glorify Daniel, who was in the den of lions, and pronounce him blessed.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
14He used to remind you of the scripture of Esaias, which says, “Even if you pass through the fire, it won’t burn you.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
15He chanted to you David, the hymn writer, who says, “Many are the afflictions of the just.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
16He declared the proverbs of Solomon, who says, “He is a tree of life to all those who do His will.”
Full study →The mother of the seven martyred brothers is remembering her late husband. Over and over, at home, he used to recite Solomon's proverbs to the family, and one saying in particular: "A tree of life it is, for everyone who does what God wills."
The words come from Proverbs 3:18, where Wisdom is "a tree of life to all who hold fast to her." The father, or the author telling his story, has changed the saying in two ways:
- "Hold fast to her (Wisdom)" becomes "do his will", meaning God's will as written in the Law.
- The feminine "her" becomes the masculine "his", so the promise now points to God himself and to obedience.
"Tree of life" brings Eden to mind: the tree whose fruit gives life that does not end. Proverbs had used it as a picture of a long, flourishing life. In this chapter it means more. The saying sits between "Many are the afflictions of the righteous" and "Shall these dry bones live?", and the series ends with God's words in Deuteronomy: "I kill and I make alive." In that order the lessons tell the sons that obeying God may cost them their lives, but those who obey are promised life that death cannot take away.
The Greek does not say who or what "is" the tree of life. It can be read "there is a tree of life for those who do his will" or "it/he is a tree of life". Either way, the promise rests on faithfully doing what God commands.
-
17He used to confirm what Ezekiel said: “Will these dry bones live?”
Full study →The mother of the seven martyred brothers is remembering her late husband, the boys' father, and how he taught them Scripture at home. One of the passages he returned to again and again was Ezekiel's vision of the valley of bones: "Will these dry bones live?"
The verb does not mean he checked Ezekiel. It means he made Ezekiel's word credible to them. He kept affirming it and pressing it on his sons until they trusted it. The tense describes a habit: "he would keep assuring us of Ezekiel."
The quotation is the question God asks the prophet in Ezekiel 37:3, with "dry" taken from the next verse. The bones are bleached and lifeless, the most hopeless picture of death there is. In Ezekiel the answer is that God breathes life into them. The family heard the question already knowing that answer. The next line in the mother's speech gives it outright: "I kill and I make alive" (Deuteronomy 32:39). So the sense is:
"Ezekiel too — he used to make us sure of him, the prophet who asks, 'Can these bones, these dried-up bones, live again?' — and we learned that God's answer is yes."
Placed just after the sons have been tortured to death, the question points to their bodies. What a father taught at the family table is what gave his sons the nerve to die rather than break God's law.
-
18For he didn’t forget the song which Moses taught, proclaiming, “I will kill, and I will make alive.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
19This is our life and the length of our days.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v16
his will
to thelēma autou
- What we hear
- God's private plan for an individual's choices (career, marriage, guidance) that a believer tries to discover.
- What they heard
- What God has openly commanded, above all in the Torah. "Doing his will" means keeping the Law, here even under threat of death.
-
in v16
He is a tree of life
xylon zōēs estin
- What we hear
- That God himself is the tree of life, a statement about God's nature.
- What they heard
- The Greek gives no subject. It can mean "there is a tree of life for those who obey", or refer back to wisdom or the Law, as in Proverbs. The point is the promise to the obedient, not a description of what God is.
-
in v17
verify (Brenton: "He used to verify Ezekiel")
epistopoieito (pistopoieō)
- What we hear
- He checked whether Ezekiel was correct, testing the prophet's claim against evidence.
- What they heard
- He affirmed Ezekiel as trustworthy and kept impressing that reliability on his sons; he made them sure of it.
Every word
-
Τὸν
ton · G3588
the · v16, v17
The article marks Solomon as the direct object of the verb. The father "proverbed Solomon", meaning he recited Solomon's sayings.
-
Σαλομῶντα
Salomōnta · G4672
Solomon · v16
Solomon was the traditional author of Proverbs. Each verse in this list pairs a scriptural figure with the kind of writing linked to him: David the hymn-writer, Solomon the proverb-maker, Ezekiel the prophet.
-
ἐπαροιμίαζεν
eparoimiazen
to speak in proverbs, quote a proverb · v16
"He used to recite proverbs". The Greek past tense used here describes repeated, habitual action, so the father did this regularly while teaching his sons at home. The verb is built from paroimia, "proverb", to match Solomon, just as verse 15 uses "he sang" for David the hymn-writer.
-
ἡμῖν
hēmin · G1473
to us · v16
"To us": the mother counts herself among the hearers. The verses around it say "to you" (the sons), and the two pronouns were easily confused in copying (see textual notes).
-
λέγοντα
legonta · G3004
saying · v16, v17
"Who says". The present tense presents Solomon as still speaking through his written words. The same phrase introduces each quotation in verses 15–19.
-
ξύλον
xylon · G3586
wood, tree · v16
"Tree". Its basic meaning is wood or timber, but in the fixed phrase "tree of life" it is the word the Greek Bible uses for the tree in Eden (Genesis 2:9; 3:22–24).
-
ζωῆς
zōēs · G2222
life · v16
"Of life": the tree that gives life. In Proverbs this means a long, full life under God's blessing. In 4 Maccabees, which is about men dying for the Law, it points beyond death to the life the martyrs have with God.
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v16
"Is", with no subject stated. Proverbs supplied "she" (Wisdom), but this verse removes it. The clause can be read as "there is a tree of life" or "it/he is a tree of life" (see debates).
-
πᾶσιν
pasin · G3956
all · v16
"To all". This is taken over from Proverbs 3:18 in the Greek Bible and stresses that no one who obeys is left out.
-
ποιοῦσιν
poiousin · G4160
do, make, carry out · v16
"Doing": ongoing, practical obedience. This replaces Proverbs' "those who hold fast to her". The change moves the focus from clinging to wisdom to actually carrying out what God commands.
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G846
his · v16
"His", masculine. It refers to God. In Proverbs the pronoun was feminine ("her", Wisdom), so the adaptation turns the saying from Wisdom to God himself.
-
θέλημα
thelēma · G2307
will, what one wants, command · v16
God's declared will, meaning what he has commanded in the Law. In 4 Maccabees doing God's will means keeping the Torah (the Law of Moses), even when a tyrant's torture is the price.
-
Ἰεζεκιὴλ
Iezekiēl
Ezekiel · v17
The prophet of the Babylonian exile (6th century BC). Here the name stands for the book that carries his name, the way we say 'Isaiah says…'. Placed first, it continues the list of Scripture 'witnesses' the father taught: Isaiah, David, Solomon, now Ezekiel.
-
ἐπιστοποιεῖτο
epistopoieito
to confirm, make credible, give assurance of · v17
Literally 'make trustworthy'. The father did not check whether Ezekiel was right; he drove home to his sons that Ezekiel's word could be relied on. The tense (imperfect) describes a repeated habit: 'he used to', 'he would keep affirming'.
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if; (here) introduces a direct question · v17
Normally 'if', but in the Greek of the Septuagint (the Greek Old Testament) it often simply opens a direct question, copying a Hebrew habit. Here it is copied straight from the Greek of Ezekiel 37:3.
-
ζήσεται
zēsetai · G2198
will live · v17
Future: 'will they live (again)?' In this setting, beside the martyrs' deaths and the next quotation ('I kill and I make alive', 18:18), 'live' means life given back by God after death.
-
ὀστᾶ
ostā · G3747
bones · v17
The bones that fill the valley in Ezekiel's vision: the remains of people long dead, as dead as it is possible to be.
-
ξηρὰ
xēra · G3584
dry · v17
Bleached and dried out, with no flesh or moisture left. The word stresses that all ordinary hope of life is gone. In Greek Ezekiel 'dry' belongs to the next verse (37:4); our author has folded it into the question.
-
ταῦτα
tauta · G3778
these · v17
'These' bones: in Ezekiel, the ones lying in front of the prophet. On the mother's lips it lets the hearer think of the bodies of her seven tortured sons.
The world behind it
The book. 4 Maccabees is a Greek speech written by a Jew of the first century AD, probably somewhere in the eastern Roman world; Antioch and Asia Minor are often suggested. Its thesis is philosophical: "devout reason" (eusebēs logismos) is master of the passions. The proof is the story of the priest Eleazar, seven brothers and their mother, who were tortured to death under the Seleucid (Greek-Syrian) king Antiochus IV around 167 BC for refusing to eat pork. The story is also told in 2 Maccabees 6–7.
This passage. In 18:6–19 the mother speaks to her sons. She tells of her own chastity and of her husband, who "taught you the Law and the Prophets while he was still with you" (18:10). What follows is a list of passages a devout Jewish father would teach at home:
- Abel, Isaac, Joseph and Phinehas
- the three young men in the furnace, and Daniel
- Isaiah ("when you pass through fire")
- David (Psalm 34:19)
- Solomon (this verse)
- Ezekiel's dry bones
- Moses' Song (Deuteronomy 32)
Teaching sons Scripture was a father's duty under Deuteronomy 6:7. The list also works as a short training course for martyrdom: stories of the righteous who suffered or were threatened, followed by promises that God gives life.
Why a proverb about life fits a story about death. For Jews living under Greek and then Roman rule, Proverbs' promise that wisdom brings long life faced an obvious objection: faithful people died young at a tyrant's hands. 4 Maccabees answers that the righteous "live to God" (7:19; 16:25) and receive immortal souls (18:23). Read in that light, the old proverb points to life beyond death.
From the study of 4 Maccabees 18:16.
Where scholars differ
in v16
Who or what "is" the tree of life?
-
"He": God himself is the tree of life (Brenton, WEB).
The nearest masculine reference is "his" (God). Translators often supply a subject from context.
-
"There is a tree of life": a statement that such a tree exists (NRSV).
*Estin* without a subject can naturally mean "there is". Life is promised as a gift to the obedient, which suits the eschatological use of the tree of life in 1 Enoch 25 and Revelation 22.
-
"It": the Law or wisdom, left unstated, is the tree of life, as in the source text.
In Proverbs 3:18 the subject is Wisdom, and Jewish tradition identified wisdom with the Torah (Sirach 24; Baruch 4:1). Doing God's will is keeping the Law, so the Law would be the life-giving tree.
in v16
Is the life promised here long earthly life or life beyond death?
-
Mainly life after death.
The context is martyrdom. The quotations around this verse point to God restoring life (Ezekiel 37; Deuteronomy 32:39), and 4 Maccabees repeatedly promises the martyrs immortality (14:5–6; 16:25; 17:12; 18:23).
-
The proverb keeps its traditional sense of a blessed life, and the hope of life after death comes from the surrounding verses rather than from this one.
In its source (Proverbs 3:16–18) the tree of life goes with "length of days". The father taught these proverbs during ordinary family life, before any persecution.
in v16
Is the mother's speech (18:6–19) original to 4 Maccabees?
-
It is a later insertion.
18:20 seems to continue from 18:5. The scriptural quotations, including Ezekiel's dry bones, which suggest bodily resurrection, sit somewhat awkwardly with the book's usual language of immortal souls. The style of the speech also differs from the rest.
-
It is the author's own work.
It develops themes found elsewhere in the book: the mother's virtue, the Law and the Prophets, and Daniel and the three young men (cf. 13:9; 16:3, 21). The book already blends Greek and Jewish ideas about life after death. Commentators such as David deSilva lean toward its integrity, or at least treat the evidence as inconclusive.
in v17
Is the mother's speech in 18:6–19, which includes this verse, original to 4 Maccabees or a later addition?
-
It is a later insertion.
Several older scholars (e.g. J. Freudenthal, A. Dupont-Sommer) noted that 18:6–19 breaks the flow between 18:5 and 18:20. Its homely, Scripture-quoting tone differs from the book's philosophical argument, and its stress on God 'making alive' fits bodily resurrection better than the book's usual language of immortal souls (e.g. 18:23).
-
It is original.
Others (e.g. D. A. deSilva in his commentary) argue that a closing speech by the mother suits the rhetoric of the book. The list of biblical heroes matches earlier lists in 4 Maccabees (13:12; 16:20–21), and the theme of training in the Law fits the book's claim that devout reason is formed by the Law.
in v17
What kind of life after death does the Ezekiel quotation point to here?
-
Bodily resurrection.
Ezekiel 37 is about bodies (bones, sinews, flesh). Contemporary Jewish readings such as Pseudo-Ezekiel at Qumran treat it as the raising of the righteous dead. The neighbouring quotation 'I kill and I make alive' was a standard resurrection text, and 2 Maccabees 7, the older telling of the same martyrdom, is clearly about bodily resurrection.
-
Life after death in general, reframed by the book as immortality of the soul.
Elsewhere 4 Maccabees speaks of the martyrs receiving 'pure and immortal souls' (18:23) and living to God (7:19; 16:25) without ever describing bodies being raised. On this view the author uses traditional resurrection texts as Scripture's witness that the faithful dead live, without committing to how.
Sources
- Septuagint (Rahlfs/Brenton), 4 Maccabees 18 and Proverbs 3:18
- BDAG s.v. ξύλον, ζωή, θέλημα, παροιμία
- LSJ s.v. παροιμιάζω
- D. A. deSilva, 4 Maccabees: Introduction and Commentary on the Greek Text in Codex Sinaiticus (Brill, 2006)
- H. Anderson, "4 Maccabees", in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 2
- Psalms of Solomon 14:2–3; 1 Enoch 24–25; 2 Maccabees 1:3; 7:9–36
- Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta (4 Maccabees 18; Ezekiel 37:3–4)
- Brenton, The Septuagint with Apocrypha (1851)
- LSJ (Liddell-Scott-Jones Greek-English Lexicon) s.v. πιστοποιέω
- D. A. deSilva, 4 Maccabees: Introduction and Commentary on the Greek Text in Codex Sinaiticus (Septuagint Commentary Series, 2006)
- H. Anderson, '4 Maccabees', in J. H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 2
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 4Q385 (Pseudo-Ezekiel)
- A. Dupont-Sommer, Le quatrième livre des Machabées (1939)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
7 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.