Deuteronomy Chapter 23 Read as one passage

Deuteronomy 23:18–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

18You must not bring the wages of a prostitute, whether female or male, into the house of the LORD your God to fulfill any vow, because both are detestable to the LORD your God. 19Do not charge your brother interest on money, food, or any other type of loan.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites gathered at the sanctuary to pay their vows, the law drew a bright line around what could become holy. God's house could not be financed by sexual commerce, whatever happened in the shrines of neighbouring peoples, or later in Israel's own shrines (Mic 1:7). A worshipper could not reason that a desperate vow justified any way of raising the payment. Nor could the gift be 'cleaned up' by the act of offering it: the source of the gift stayed attached to it.

The verse sits in a run of laws (23:17–25) about the boundaries of Israel's community and worship. It immediately follows the ban on any Israelite becoming a qedeshah or qadesh and precedes the laws on interest and vows. Hearers would have understood it as protecting two things at once: the holiness of YHWH's house, and Israel's identity as a people whose sexual life was not to be turned into a source of income for religion. The double 'YHWH your God' made it personal. The God who is yours is the one who refuses this gift.

From the study of Deuteronomy 23:18.

Verse by verse

  1. 18You must not bring the wages of a prostitute, whether female or male, into the house of the LORD your God to fulfill any vow, because both are detestable to the LORD your God.

    You, each Israelite, must never carry into the house of YHWH your God, as payment for any vow you have made to him, the fee a woman earned by selling sex, or the 'price of a dog'. That second phrase most likely means the earnings of a male prostitute, called by the contemptuous name 'dog', though some ancient readers took it as the money from selling an actual dog. It makes no difference how sincere the vow is, or that the gift is a perfectly good lamb or a perfectly good piece of silver: if it came to you as payment for sex, it cannot become a holy gift. The reason is that YHWH, your God, rejects both of these payments equally. They belong in the same category as a blemished sacrifice or a dishonest scale. They violate his order, and they have no place in his house.

    Full study →
  2. 19Do not charge your brother interest on money, food, or any other type of loan.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v18

    abomination (KJV, WEB)

    toʿevah

    What we hear
    The very worst, most disgusting kind of sin; a term reserved for maximum moral outrage.
    What they heard
    Something YHWH categorically rejects as incompatible with him and his order. Deuteronomy uses the same label for blemished sacrifices, unclean food and dishonest weights. It is strong language, but it marks a category, not a ranking.
  • in v18

    price of a dog / male prostitute

    meḥir kelev

    What we hear
    Either (KJV) the money from selling a pet, which seems odd, or (NIV, WEB, BSB) a clearly identified male prostitute.
    What they heard
    'Dog' was a contemptuous term, and in context it most likely refers to a male counterpart of the prostitute. The Hebrew does not spell this out, though, and ancient Jewish interpretation read it as a literal dog. The text is less explicit than the confident modern renderings suggest.
Every word
  1. לֹא־

    lo · H3808

    not · v18

    Paired with the imperfect verb that follows, it makes a standing, permanent prohibition: 'you shall never bring', the same form used in the Ten Commandments.

  2. תָבִיא֩

    tavi · H935

    bring, cause to come · v18

    The causative form of 'come': to bring something in. It is the ordinary verb for bringing offerings to the sanctuary (Deut 12:6, 11). Addressed to 'you' singular, each Israelite individually.

  3. אֶתְנַ֨ן

    ʾetnan · H868

    hire, payment, gift · v18

    The payment a prostitute receives for sex. It could be silver, but also goods or an animal (Judah promises Tamar a young goat in Gen 38:17), things that could be offered at the sanctuary.

  4. זוֹנָ֜ה

    zonah · H2181

    to commit sexual immorality; prostitute · v18

    A participle used as a noun, 'a woman who engages in sex outside marriage', and here plainly a woman who does it for pay. This is the everyday word for a prostitute, not the special term qedeshah used in v. 17.

  5. וּמְחִ֣יר

    u-meḥir · H4242

    and price, purchase-money · v18

    'And the price of.' Meḥir is usually the price paid in a sale (2 Sam 24:24; 1 Kgs 21:2), which is why some read the phrase as the money from selling a dog. Parallel with ʾetnan, it can also mean the fee a 'dog' earns.

  6. כֶּ֗לֶב

    kelev · H3611

    dog · v18

    Literally 'dog'. Many scholars take it as a contemptuous name for a male prostitute, pairing with the female prostitute just before it and with qadesh in v. 17. Others take it as a literal dog. The Hebrew does not settle it.

  7. בֵּ֛ית

    beit · H1004

    house · v18

    'The house of', meaning the sanctuary, the place where God's presence lived and where offerings and vows were paid. In Deuteronomy that is the place God chooses (Deut 12).

  8. יְהוָ֥ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (divine name) · v18

    Israel's God named personally. The house belongs to him, so he decides what may come into it.

  9. אֱלֹהֶ֖יךָ

    ʾeloheikha · H430

    your God · v18

    'Your God': the covenant relationship is personal and appears twice in the verse. The God who is yours is the one this money offends.

  10. לְכָל־

    le-khol · H3605

    for any, for all · v18

    'For any': no kind of vow is an exception. However sincere the promise, this money cannot pay it.

  11. נֶ֑דֶר

    neder · H5088

    vow, votive offering · v18

    A promise to give God something, usually on condition that he grant a request (Gen 28:20–22; 1 Sam 1:11). Paying it meant bringing the promised gift to the sanctuary. Vows are the topic of vv. 21–23.

  12. כִּ֧י

    ki · H3588

    for, because · v18

    Introduces the reason. Deuteronomy usually explains its laws instead of only commanding them.

  13. תוֹעֲבַ֛ת

    toʿavat · H8441

    abomination, abhorrent thing · v18

    'Abhorrent thing of', something YHWH categorically rejects because it violates his order. It is the same label Deuteronomy gives to blemished sacrifices (17:1) and dishonest weights (25:16).

  14. גַּם־

    gam · H1571

    also, even · v18

    'Even' or 'indeed': it makes clear that neither payment is less objectionable than the other.

  15. שְׁנֵיהֶֽם׃

    shneihem · H8147

    the two of them, both · v18

    'Both of them': the prostitute's hire and the 'dog's' price are rejected equally. This pairing is the main reason many readers take 'dog' as the male counterpart of the prostitute.

The world behind it

Vows created debts. In Israel a person in trouble might promise God a gift if he answered: a sacrifice, silver, even a child's service (Hannah, 1 Sam 1:11). Once the prayer was answered, the gift was owed and had to be brought to the sanctuary. Deuteronomy insists on prompt payment just three verses later (23:21–23). For someone without independent means, especially a woman whose property and vows were controlled by a father or husband (Num 30), raising the payment could be hard. Proverbs 7:14 shows a woman behaving like a prostitute who announces, 'today I paid my vows'. On that basis some scholars (notably Karel van der Toorn) argue that prostitution to pay vows was a real practice this law addresses.

Payment in kind. A prostitute's fee was not always coins. Judah promises Tamar 'a young goat from the flock' (Gen 38:17). Animals and goods received this way could easily be presented as offerings, which explains why the law speaks of 'bringing' them into God's house.

Temples and sexual commerce. The prophets accuse Samaria of funding its idols with 'the hire of a prostitute' (Mic 1:7). Older scholarship assumed that Canaanite temples practised organised 'sacred prostitution' and read vv. 17–18 against that background. Recent studies (e.g. Westenholz 1989; Budin 2008) have seriously challenged whether such an institution existed at all. Verse 18 itself uses the ordinary word for a commercial prostitute (zonah), not the 'consecrated' term of v. 17.

Dogs. Dogs in Israel were mainly half-wild scavengers, linked with carrion and impurity (1 Kgs 14:11; 21:19). Calling a person a 'dog' was a strong insult. Calling oneself 'your dog' was a grovelling form of politeness in letters.

From the study of Deuteronomy 23:18.

Where scholars differ

in v18

What does 'the price of a dog' mean?

  • A male prostitute (or male cult functionary), called a 'dog' in contempt.

    It stands in parallel with 'the hire of a prostitute', and 'both of them' implies a matching pair. V. 17 pairs the female qedeshah with the male qadesh. The Phoenician Kition tariff (KAI 37) lists klbm, 'dogs', among temple personnel. Rev 22:15 groups 'dogs' with the sexually immoral. This is the majority modern view (reflected in NIV, WEB, BSB, NLT).

  • A literal dog: money received from selling a dog, or an animal taken in exchange for one.

    Meḥir normally means a sale price. The Septuagint's allagma ('exchange') and the Vulgate's pretium canis read it literally. Mishnah Temurah 6:3 defines it as a lamb exchanged for a dog. Dogs were unclean animals, so their price could be considered unfit for the altar.

  • A self-deprecating term for a temple servant or devotee, not necessarily sexual.

    'Dog' as a servant's humble self-description is well attested (Amarna, Lachish letters, 2 Kgs 8:13). The klbm of Kition could be menial temple staff. Whether they were sexual workers is not stated.

in v18

Is this verse about cultic ('sacred') prostitution or ordinary prostitution?

  • Cultic: the verse continues v. 17's ban on qedeshah/qadesh, sexual functionaries at shrines, and forbids their income from funding YHWH's temple.

    The two verses sit side by side. 1 Kgs 14:24, 15:12 and 2 Kgs 23:7 link qedeshim with illicit worship. Mic 1:7 links prostitutes' hire with idol shrines. Older scholarship assumed Canaanite fertility cults involved ritual sex.

  • Ordinary: the verse concerns commercial prostitution in general, and 'sacred prostitution' as an institution is doubtful.

    V. 18 uses zonah, the ordinary word. In Gen 38 a qedeshah and a zonah can be the same woman. Studies of Mesopotamian and classical sources (Westenholz 1989; Bird; Budin 2008) find no clear evidence of sex as a temple ritual and show that later Greek reports such as Herodotus 1.199 are unreliable. Prov 7:14 suggests individuals raising money for vows.

in v18

Why is this money specifically rejected?

  • Because it would launder sinful income into holiness: the source taints the gift.

    Toʿevah is used the same way for blemished sacrifices (17:1). Prophetic texts treat prostitution-funded shrines as corrupt (Mic 1:7).

  • To stop people raising money for vows through prostitution (a practical, social target).

    The wording 'for any vow', Prov 7:14, and women's limited control of property (Num 30) suggest this happened. This is argued by van der Toorn (JBL 108, 1989).

  • To keep Israel's worship distinct from neighbouring cults that tolerated or profited from sexual commerce.

    The placement with v. 17 and the other boundary laws of Deut 23, and Deuteronomy's general concern to separate Israel's worship from Canaanite practice (Deut 12:29–31).

Sources
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. אֶתְנַן, זָנָה, מְחִיר, כֶּלֶב, נֶדֶר, תּוֹעֵבָה
  • Mishnah Temurah 6:3
  • Septuagint, Deut 23:18–19 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Deut 23:19
  • KAI 37 (Kition tariff inscription)
  • K. van der Toorn, 'Female Prostitution in Payment of Vows in Ancient Israel', JBL 108 (1989) 193–205
  • J. G. Westenholz, 'Tamar, Qĕdēšā, Qadištu, and Sacred Prostitution in Mesopotamia', HTR 82 (1989) 245–265
  • S. L. Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (Cambridge, 2008)
  • J. H. Tigay, Deuteronomy (JPS Torah Commentary, 1996)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Deut 23:17–18

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.