The Bible · Old Testament

Esther

Esther tells how a Jewish woman became queen of Persia and, with her cousin Mordecai, stopped a royal order to wipe out the Jews of the empire. Jews read it every year at the festival of Purim, and readers value it as a story of courage and of God working out of sight, since the Hebrew text never names God.

  • Hebrew (with some Aramaic)
  • In every Bible

Why it's in the Bible, and the doubts

The case for

  1. Esther has been part of the Jewish Bible and of Jewish worship for more than two thousand years.

    The evidence

    It is one of the five Megillot (festival scrolls) and is read aloud in full at Purim, a festival already called "Mordecai's day" in 2 Maccabees 15:36 (2nd century BC). The Talmud (Megillah 7a) settles the rabbinic debate in its favour, and Josephus' count of 22 sacred books (Against Apion 1.38–41) most likely includes it.

  2. Its picture of the Persian court fits what is known from outside sources.

    The evidence

    The Hebrew name Ahasuerus matches the Persian Khshayarsha (Xerxes), and details such as the royal couriers, the gate as the place of court officials, and the palace at Susa match Herodotus and the French digs at Susa. Persepolis tablets name an official called Marduka working at Susa in this period, which some scholars link to Mordecai, though the link is debated.

  3. The church received it widely, and its quiet theology of providence fits a known biblical pattern.

    The evidence

    Esther is in the canon lists of the councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397), in the great Greek codices, and in every major Christian Bible today. Like the Joseph story, it shows God working through ordinary events, as in Mordecai's words that help "will arise from another place" and "who knows whether you have come to the kingdom for such a time as this?" (4:14).

The case against

  1. The Hebrew text never mentions God, prayer, the covenant, the Law or the Temple.

    The evidence

    It is the only book of the Hebrew Bible that never names God, and its only religious act is fasting (4:16). This is probably why the Greek version adds 107 verses of prayers and references to God, and why Martin Luther said he wished it did not exist (Table Talk; Bondage of the Will).

  2. Its place in the canon was questioned by both early Jews and early Christians.

    The evidence

    It is the only Hebrew Bible book with no copy among the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the Talmud records rabbis who doubted it (Megillah 7a). Melito of Sardis (c. 170) and Gregory of Nazianzus leave it out of their lists, and Athanasius (367) puts it with books to be read but not counted as canon.

  3. Several details are hard to square with known Persian history, so many scholars read it as a historical novella.

    The evidence

    Herodotus names Xerxes' queen as Amestris, and no outside source mentions Vashti or Esther; the 127 provinces (1:1) far exceed the roughly 20–30 known satrapies. Esther 2:5–6 can be read as saying Mordecai was exiled in 597 BC, which would make him very old under Xerxes, and the killing of 75,000 enemies (9:16) raises ethical as well as historical questions.

Both sides are written as strongly as the honest evidence allows, so you can decide for yourself. Researched by claude-opus-5-5.

When, where and by whom

Jewish tradition gives the book to Mordecai (based on Esther 9:20) or to the Men of the Great Assembly (Talmud, Bava Batra 15a), writing in Persia soon after the events in Xerxes' reign (486–465 BC). Most scholars date the Hebrew book to the late Persian or early Greek period (about 400–200 BC) and see it as the work of an unknown Jewish writer in the eastern diaspora, while the Greek version with its six additions was finished by about 114–48 BC.

Jesus, the New Testament and this book
  • Herod's oath to Herodias' daughter, "up to half of my kingdom" (Mark 6:23), uses the same words as the Persian king's offer to Esther (Esther 5:3, 5:6, 7:2). (likely link)
  • The unnamed "feast of the Jews" in John 5:1 has sometimes been identified as Purim, the festival that comes from Esther. (possible link)
  • Esther is never quoted directly in the New Testament, though its theme of God protecting his people through hidden providence is echoed in passages like Romans 8:28. (possible link)
How it came down to us

The Hebrew text survives in the medieval Masoretic manuscripts, especially the Leningrad Codex (1008 AD); the Esther pages of the Aleppo Codex were lost after 1947, and no copy was found at Qumran. Jews kept copying it as a handwritten scroll (megillah) for Purim. The Greek survives in two forms, the Septuagint text (Codex Vaticanus, Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus, 4th–5th centuries, with an earlier fragment in Papyrus 967) and the shorter \"Alpha Text\", both with the six additions. It also survives in Old Latin, Jerome's Vulgate (which moved the additions to the end), Syriac and two Aramaic Targums.

  • Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex)
  • Septuagint and Alpha Text of Greek Esther, including the colophon (Addition F 11)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls (absence of Esther among the Qumran finds)
  • Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 7a and Bava Batra 15a
  • Josephus, Against Apion 1.38–41 and Antiquities 11
  • 2 Maccabees 15:36
  • Herodotus, Histories (on Xerxes, Amestris and the Persian satrapies)
  • Persepolis Fortification Tablets (the name Marduka)
  • Canon lists: Melito of Sardis, Athanasius' 39th Festal Letter (367), Gregory of Nazianzus, councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397), Council of Trent
  • Martin Luther, Table Talk and The Bondage of the Will
  • Modern commentaries (e.g. Michael V. Fox, Adele Berlin, Jon Levenson, Karen Jobes)

Chapters

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10