Job Chapter 35 Read as one passage
Job 35:15–16
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15and further, that in His anger He has not punished or taken much notice of folly! 16So Job opens his mouth in vain and multiplies words without knowledge.”
What the first hearers heard
Ancient readers of Job would have recognised this as the hardest version of the question the book keeps raising: if God is a just king, why does he not deal with wrong? Elihu puts Job's complaint in its sharpest form: God's anger does nothing, and he seems not to care about human folly or arrogance. He then dismisses it as "words without knowledge" (v. 16). For the first hearers the verse worked inside a debate, not as a statement of doctrine. It sets out the charge that the book will let God himself answer from the whirlwind (chs. 38–41). There God does not explain why he delays, but shows a wisdom and an order in creation far larger than the categories Job and his friends were using. Elihu's own position is that apparent delay is no proof that God is indifferent.
From the study of Job 35:15.
Verse by verse
-
15and further, that in His anger He has not punished or taken much notice of folly!
Full study →"And further: [you complain] that his anger has not come round to call anyone to account, and that he hardly takes any notice of wrongdoing at all."
Elihu is finishing his summary of what he thinks Job is really saying. Job has said he cannot see God, that his case is lying before God, and that he is left waiting (v. 14). Now comes the last part of the charge: God's anger, which ought to step in and settle accounts with wrongdoers, sits idle, and God does not seem to pay attention to human wrong. The Hebrew "know" here means taking notice and doing something, not simply having the information. The wrong in question is named by a word that occurs nowhere else in the Bible. It may mean "folly", "arrogance", or "transgression". Whichever it is, it means human wrong that seems to go unpunished. The next verse gives Elihu's verdict: so Job "opens his mouth in vain". Read another way (as in KJV and WEB), the verse gives the reason Job talks so much: because God's anger has not yet fallen, Job assumes God does not care, and so he keeps piling up words.
-
16So Job opens his mouth in vain and multiplies words without knowledge.”
Full study →"And so Job keeps opening his mouth wide, and what comes out is breath. Lacking any real understanding, he keeps heaping up words."
This is Elihu's closing verdict on Job at the end of his third speech. He delivers it about Job, in the third person, to the circle of listening wise men, like an advocate summing up a case.
Both lines put the charge first for emphasis: breath in the first line, without knowledge in the second. The word for "breath", hevel (vapor, a puff of air), is the word Job himself had used for his fleeting life (7:16) and for his friends' useless comfort (21:34). Elihu throws it back at him: Job's speeches have no more substance than air.
The verb "opens" suggests a mouth gaping wide. Both verbs describe continuing action. Job does not just slip once: he goes on opening his mouth and goes on piling up words. "Multiplies" comes from a root meaning "to be great or much". Bildad had already called Job's words "a mighty wind" (8:2), and Elihu now has Job producing a great mass of words made of breath.
"Without knowledge" means without true understanding of how God governs the world, not simply without the facts. The phrase will return almost word for word in God's own first question from the whirlwind: "Who is this that darkens counsel by words without knowledge?" (38:2). Job will echo it again in his reply (42:3). Readers are left to weigh whether Elihu has spoken truly, or whether this young man, "full of words" (32:18) and delivering one of the longest speeches in the book, is open to his own charge.
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
visited (KJV, WEB)
pāqad
- What we hear
- Paid a social call; came to see.
- What they heard
- Came to inspect and call to account. Here it means punished.
-
in v15
he knoweth it not (KJV)
lōʾ yādaʿ
- What we hear
- God is unaware or ignorant.
- What they heard
- God does not take notice of it or act on it. The complaint is about indifference, not ignorance.
-
in v16
in vain (KJV, BSB); vanity (YLT)
hevel
- What we hear
- "In vain" usually means "unsuccessfully, without result". "Vanity" usually means conceit or self-admiration.
- What they heard
- "Breath, vapor": something without substance. Here it means Job's words are empty air. The sense of futility ("to no purpose") is partly present, but the main picture is insubstantiality. Conceit is not in view at all.
Every word
-
וְעַתָּ֗ה
wəʿattāh · H6258
and now · v15
Marks a move in the argument rather than a point in time: 'and now', 'and further', 'and as things stand'. Elihu adds one more point to the complaint he is answering.
-
כִּי־
kî · H3588A
that, because, for · v15
Either 'that' (continuing what Job is said to claim, linking back to 'when you say' in v. 14) or 'because' (giving the reason Job talks as he does). BSB takes it as 'that'; KJV, WEB and YLT take it as 'because'.
-
אַ֭יִן
ʾayin · H0369
there is not, nothing · v15
A negative that means 'there is none / is not'. It normally goes with nouns and participles, so pairing it with a past-tense verb here is unusual. That is why translators handle it so differently: KJV makes it a clause on its own ('because it is not so'), while most read it simply as 'not'.
-
פָּקַ֣ד
pāqad · H6485H
to attend to, visit, call to account, punish · v15
A superior turning their attention to someone in a way that has consequences. Here it means calling someone to account, that is, punishing. The point is that God's anger has not (yet) stepped in.
-
אַפּ֑וֹ
ʾappô · H0639G
his nose; his anger · v15
Literally 'his nose' (the flaring, reddening face of anger). It is most naturally the subject: 'his anger has not punished'. YLT and KJV take it as the object or means instead: 'he has appointed / visited (in) his anger'.
-
וְלֹֽא־
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v15
The ordinary negative, which here negates 'he has known'.
-
יָדַ֖ע
yādaʿ · H3045
to know · v15
Not simply having the information. It means taking notice, paying attention to something and acting on it. The complaint is not that God is ignorant but that he does not seem to care or do anything.
-
בַּפַּ֣שׁ
bappaš · H6580
folly? arrogance? (meaning uncertain) · v15
This word occurs only here in the Hebrew Bible, so its meaning is uncertain. Proposed senses: 'folly', 'arrogance', or 'transgression' (if it is a shortened or miscopied form of pešaʿ). In every option it means human wrongdoing that God seems to let pass.
-
מְאֹֽד׃
məʾōd · H3966
very, greatly · v15
Intensifies 'know/take notice': God does not 'much' notice. KJV attaches it to the noun instead ('great extremity').
-
וְ֭אִיּוֹב
ve'iyyov · H0347
-
הֶ֣בֶל
hevel · H1892
breath, vapor; emptiness, futility · v16
Placed before the verb for emphasis, and used like an adverb: Job opens his mouth "with breath", "emptily". What comes out is vapor: it has no substance and achieves nothing. Job himself used this word for his own short life (7:16) and for his friends' comfort (21:34). Elihu turns it back on him.
-
יִפְצֶה־
yiftseh · H6475
he opens (wide), gapes · v16
The Hebrew verb form points to something ongoing or habitual: Job keeps opening his mouth. This verb for opening the mouth often suggests opening it wide or rashly, the way the earth gapes or lions open their jaws. It is stronger than simply beginning to speak.
-
פִּ֑יהוּ
pihu · H6310
his mouth · v16
A longer form of "his mouth" found mostly in poetry. The mouth stands for speech in general, and the image of a mouth opened on nothing but breath is deliberately physical.
-
בִּבְלִי־
bivli · H1097
without; in the absence of · v16
Literally "in not-having". Combined with "knowledge" it describes how Job speaks: from a lack of understanding. Like "breath" in the first line, this phrase comes before its verb for emphasis.
-
דַ֝֗עַת
da'at · H1847
knowledge, understanding · v16
In wisdom writing this means discerning understanding, here especially an understanding of how God governs the world. It is more than having the facts. Elihu's charge is that Job judges God's justice without grasping it. God's own first words in 38:2 nearly repeat this phrase.
-
מִלִּ֥ין
millin · H4405
words, speeches · v16
A poetic word for "words" with an Aramaic-style plural ending (-in). Most of its uses in the Bible are in Job, and Elihu uses it constantly. Here it means Job's long speeches.
-
יַכְבִּֽר׃
yakhbir · H3527
he makes many, multiplies, heaps up · v16
From a root meaning "to be great, much". The verb form means "he makes them many", and it is ongoing like "opens": Job keeps piling up words. The sense is quantity without weight, many words built out of breath. The verse closes the speech, and the scribal section mark (פ) follows it.
The world behind it
Job 32–37 contains the speeches of Elihu, a younger man who speaks after Job's three friends have fallen silent. In chapter 35 he argues that human righteousness or sin cannot affect God (vv. 5–8). He says God does not answer some cries because of the pride of those crying out (vv. 12–13), and that Job's complaint that God is silent and unjust is empty talk (vv. 14–16). In verse 15 Elihu turns Job's own grievances back on him. Job had said that God lets the wicked prosper and "does not charge them with wrongdoing" (24:12; compare 21:7–34). Behind this lies an assumption all the speakers share, that a just king acts against wrongdoing within a reasonable time. A delay in punishment could therefore be read either as indifference (Job's complaint) or as patience (the way Elihu's argument seems to read it).
From the study of Job 35:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
What does the one-time word paš mean?
-
'Transgression' (read as or related to pešaʿ)
The Septuagint (paraptōma) and the Vulgate (scelus). It fits the parallel with God punishing in anger, and Job's complaint in 24:12.
-
'Arrogance, insolence'
Comparison with an Arabic root meaning to boast or be puffed up, and the link to 'the pride of the wicked' in 35:12.
-
'Folly'
Guessed from context and from 'in vain' and 'without knowledge' in v. 16. Listed as a possibility in BDB and followed by BSB.
-
'Abundance/extremity'
A root meaning 'spread out'. Followed by some medieval Jewish interpreters and behind KJV's 'great extremity'. Little followed today.
in v15
Is v. 15 Job's claim as Elihu reports it, or Elihu's explanation of why Job speaks?
-
It continues the summary of Job's complaint begun in v. 14 ('when you say… that…')
It is the natural continuation of 'you say' in v. 14 and matches Job's actual statements in 21:7–34 and 24:12. BSB reads it this way.
-
It gives the reason for v. 16: because God has not yet punished, Job talks recklessly
It takes kî as 'because' and 'and now' as introducing a conclusion. KJV and WEB read it this way. Elihu would then be presenting God's restraint toward Job himself as the occasion of Job's empty words.
in v16
How does this verse follow from v. 15: why are Job's words "empty"?
-
God's patience has emboldened Job. Because God has not yet fully punished Job's arrogance, Job presumes and talks on emptily.
Reads 35:15 as Elihu's own statement ("because his anger has not yet punished"), followed by the conclusion in v. 16. This fits Elihu's view of suffering as discipline that God may hold back for a time (33:14–30; 36:8–12).
-
Elihu is quoting or summarizing Job's complaint, that God ignores wrongdoing, and then dismisses that complaint as empty.
The BSB and others take v. 15 as continuing Job's alleged claims from vv. 14–15. Job did complain that God lets the wicked go unpunished (21:7–34; 24:1–12).
in v16
Does the book endorse Elihu's verdict that Job speaks "words without knowledge"?
-
Yes. Elihu prepares the way for God, and God confirms his charge.
God's first words (38:2) nearly repeat this verse. Job concedes "I spoke of what I did not understand" (42:3). Elihu's storm imagery (36:27–37:24) leads straight into the whirlwind (38:1), and God never rebukes Elihu.
-
No, or only ambiguously. Elihu is himself a windy speaker whose verdict the book frames with irony.
God says Job spoke rightly (42:7). Elihu is absent from the prologue and the epilogue. He calls himself "full of words" (32:18) and claims to be "perfect in knowledge" (36:4). Some commentators suggest the "Who is this…?" of 38:2 could even be aimed at the speaker who has just finished. Many scholars also regard the Elihu speeches as a later addition, because of their absence from the frame story and their distinct style, including more Aramaic-like words.
Sources
- BDB s.v. פַּשׁ, פָּקַד, יָדַע, אַף
- HALOT s.v. פַּשׁ
- Septuagint, Job 35:15
- Vulgate, Job 35:15
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- S. R. Driver & G. B. Gray, Job (International Critical Commentary)
- BDB s.v. הֶבֶל, כָּבַר, פָּצָה, מִלָּה, דַּעַת
- HALOT s.v. הֶבֶל, כבר, פצה
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15)
- J. E. Hartley, The Book of Job (NICOT)
- R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
- Instruction of Amenemope (Egyptian wisdom text), on the 'silent' vs. 'heated' man
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).