Job Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Job 9:14–16
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
14How then can I answer Him or choose my arguments against Him? 15For even if I were right, I could not answer. I could only beg my Judge for mercy. 16If I summoned Him and He answered me, I do not believe He would listen to my voice.
What the first hearers heard
The first hearers knew how disputes were settled: people stated their cases, answered each other, and someone gave a verdict. They also knew the old poetry of God defeating the sea monster. Job's line joins the two worlds. The God who flattened the chaos monsters is the one Job would have to face in court.
The verse makes three points:
- Job does not doubt God's power. He takes it for granted, more completely than his friends do.
- Power makes justice impossible to get. Job's complaint is not that he lacks arguments. It is that no argument could get a hearing when the other party is overwhelming and also sits as judge.
- It answers the friends with their own kind of argument. Eliphaz (4:19) and later Bildad (25:6) argue that if heavenly beings fall short, "how much less" a human being can be pure. Job uses the same "how much less" form to say something else: the problem is not his guilt but that he cannot get a fair trial.
Ancient hearers would have felt the boldness of this. Job does not say "I have no case". He says he cannot get his case heard. The book will keep building that tension until God himself answers out of the whirlwind (chs. 38–41).
From the study of Job 9:14.
Verse by verse
-
14How then can I answer Him or choose my arguments against Him?
Full study →Verse 13 has just pictured God's anger, which nothing turns back, and the mighty helpers of Rahab, the chaos monster of the sea, lying flat beneath him. Job now draws the conclusion, starting from the greater case to reach the lesser one:
"How much less could I (I, of all people!) answer him in court? How could I pick out my arguments to set against him?"
"Answer" is the word for answering in a lawsuit: making your defence or giving your reply to a charge. "Choose my words" does not mean speaking tactfully. It pictures a litigant going through possible arguments to find ones that might hold up. "With him" here means face to face as opponents. The extra "I" in the Hebrew points to how small Job is: if cosmic powers lie flat before this God, a single suffering man has no chance of being heard. The next verse finishes the thought: even if Job were in the right, he could not answer. He could only beg his judge for mercy.
-
15For even if I were right, I could not answer. I could only beg my Judge for mercy.
Full study →"Even if I had the just case, even with my innocence established, I could not get my defence out. All I could do is beg for favour from the very one who is taking me to court."
Job is picturing a lawsuit with God. "Right" here is a courtroom word. It means having the winning case or being innocent of the charge, not being sinless. "Answer" means replying to the charge in court. The word translated "Judge" is a rare form that most likely means my opponent-at-law: the other party in the case, who in Job's situation is also the one deciding it. The last verb is the plea of the powerless before the powerful: I would have to throw myself on His favour.
There is also an edge here. Job's friend Bildad had just told him to "plead for mercy with the Almighty" (8:5). Job uses the same word, but turns it into a complaint. He might well end up begging, but not because he is guilty. The court would be decided by overwhelming power, not by who is in the right. The next verse sharpens this: even if God responded to Job's summons, Job does not believe God would really listen.
-
16If I summoned Him and He answered me, I do not believe He would listen to my voice.
Full study →"Suppose I summoned him to court, called on him as a sufferer calls on God, and he actually came and answered me. Even then I could not be convinced that he was really bending his ear to my voice, that my plea counted with him at all."
Each part matters:
- The opening words borrow a line from worship. "I called, and he answered me" is what grateful worshippers said once God had rescued them (Ps 120:1; Jonah 2:2). Job takes up that happy formula and imagines it coming true.
- It is also courtroom language. Throughout ch. 9, Job pictures a lawsuit with God. To "call" is to summon, and to "answer" is to respond to the summons.
- Even so, the result is still "no". "I would not believe" means Job could not count on it or feel sure of it. His doubt concerns whether God would really give ear, that is, attend to his case and weigh it. He does not doubt that God could hear.
- The reason follows straight away (vv.17–18). God, as Job experiences him, "would crush me with a tempest and multiply my wounds without cause". An "answer" from that God would feel like another blow, not a hearing.
The verse is a cry of hopelessness about getting a fair hearing from someone who is both your opponent and your judge. The book later turns it into dramatic irony: God does answer Job, and he answers "out of the storm" (38:1).
Where the English drifted
-
in v14
choose my words
ʾebḥărâ dəbāray
- What we hear
- Speaking carefully or tactfully to avoid giving offence.
- What they heard
- Selecting arguments or pleadings for a legal case: marshalling a defence against an opponent in court.
-
in v15
righteous / right
ṣādaqtî
- What we hear
- Morally holy or sinless before God, so the verse can sound like Job claiming perfection, or admitting nobody is truly righteous.
- What they heard
- 'I am in the right in this case', 'I have the just case', 'I am innocent of the charge'. It is a legal standing in a particular dispute.
-
in v15
my Judge
mᵉshōpheṭî
- What we hear
- A neutral, rightful magistrate to whom one respectfully appeals.
- What they heard
- Most likely 'my opponent-at-law', the party contending with me in court, who in Job's case also holds the judge's seat.
-
in v15
beg for mercy
ʾetḥannān
- What we hear
- Confessing guilt and asking forgiveness.
- What they heard
- Pleading for favour as someone with no power, which can be done by an innocent person. Here it means having to grovel despite being in the right.
Every word
-
אַ֭ף
ʾap · H0637
also, even, indeed · v14
Together with the next word it forms a fixed phrase that builds an argument from the greater to the lesser. On its own it adds weight: 'even', 'so then'.
-
כִּֽי־
kî · H3588A
for, that, indeed · v14, v16
Joined to ʾap it makes ʾap kî, 'how much more' or (after a negative point, as here) 'how much less'. It ties this verse to verse 13: if the monster's helpers lie flat before God, how much less can Job stand up.
-
אָנֹכִ֣י
ʾānōkî · H0595
I · v14
A separate pronoun. Hebrew verbs already show who is acting, so adding 'I' puts the stress on it: 'I, of all people', set against the cosmic monsters of verse 13. YLT keeps the stress: 'do I — I answer Him?'
-
אֶֽעֱנֶ֑נּוּ
ʾeʿĕnennû · H6030B
to answer, respond · v14, v15, v16
'I answer him' or 'could I answer him'. In Job 9 this is courtroom language: to give a reply in a legal case or make one's defence. Here the incomplete-action form of the verb carries the sense 'could I / would I be able to'.
-
אֶבְחֲרָ֖ה
ʾebḥărâ · H0977
to choose, select · v14
A form that expresses the speaker's own resolve or deliberation ('let me choose', 'should I choose'), here inside a rhetorical question. It pictures a litigant picking out arguments to build a case, not someone being careful to stay polite.
-
דְבָרַ֣י
dəbāray · H1697G
word, matter, case · v14
'My words'. In a legal setting these are pleadings or arguments, and dābār can mean the legal matter itself (Exod 18:16; 22:9). BSB's 'my arguments' gets the sense right.
-
עִמּֽוֹ׃
ʿimmô · H5973A
with · v14
'With him'. With words for speaking or disputing, 'with' means facing an opponent: arguing with someone means arguing against them. Hence 'against Him' (BSB) or 'to argue with him' (WEB).
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăsher · H0834A
who, which, that · v15
A relative word that ties this line back to verse 14. It can point to 'I' ('I, who even if I were in the right…') or to God ('Him, whom even if I were in the right I could not answer', as KJV and YLT take it). Either way it carries on the thought of v.14: how could I ever argue with Him?
-
אִם־
ʾim · H0518A
if, though · v15, v16
Sets up a condition Job treats as real: 'even if', 'granted that'. Job is not saying he might be guilty. He is saying that even with a winning case, the outcome would be the same.
-
צָ֭דַקְתִּי
ṣādaqtî · H6663
be in the right, be just, be innocent · v15
A courtroom word: 'I am in the right', 'I have the just case', 'I am innocent of the charge'. The perfect form presents it as an established fact: suppose my innocence is settled. It is not a claim to be morally flawless.
-
לֹ֣א
lōʾ · H3808
not · v15, v16
Flat negation of the next verb: 'I would not / could not answer.'
-
לִ֝מְשֹׁפְטִ֗י
limshōpheṭî · H8199
judge; (this form) opponent-at-law · v15
'To my judge/adversary.' This is a rare verb form, found nowhere else in the Bible, and it likely means 'the one who goes to law with me': my opponent in the case. Job's bitter point is that God is the other party and the judge at the same time.
-
אֶתְחַנָּֽן׃
ʾetḥannān · H2603A
plead for favor, implore, beg for mercy · v15
'I would have to beg for favor': the humiliating appeal of someone with no power to someone with all of it. It echoes Bildad's advice in 8:5 to 'plead with the Almighty for mercy'. Job turns that advice into a complaint: he would have to beg even though he is innocent.
-
קָרָ֥אתִי
qārāʾtî · H7121G
-
אַ֝אֲמִ֗ין
ʾaʾămîn · H0539
to believe, trust, be convinced · v16
"I would believe" (with the negative: "I could not believe / could not be sure"). The verb means to count something as solid and reliable. Job says he could not accept as true that God was really attending to him.
-
יַאֲזִ֥ין
yaʾăzîn · H0238
-
קוֹלִֽי׃
qôlî · H6963A
voice, sound · v16
"My voice": Job's own spoken plea, his case put into words. The issue is not whether God can hear sound. It is whether Job's voice would actually count in front of him.
The world behind it
An imagined lawsuit with God. In Job 9 Job answers Bildad (ch. 8) in the language of an Israelite legal dispute, which was usually settled at the town gate. Two parties stated their cases, each "answered" the other, and a judge or arbiter declared one of them "in the right" (ṣaddîq). Job asks how a person can be in the right with God (v. 2) and pictures bringing a case (rîb, v. 3). He sees the problem: the opposing party is also the judge (v. 15), and no arbiter stands between them (v. 33).
Rahab's helpers. Verse 13, which this verse builds on, mentions "the helpers of Rahab". Rahab is a name for the sea monster of chaos (cf. Job 26:12; Isa 51:9; Ps 89:10). Ancient Near Eastern stories told of a storm god defeating the sea and its allied monsters. The best-known example is the Babylonian Enuma Elish, where Marduk defeats Tiamat and her band of helpers. Israelite poets used this imagery for the God of Israel. Job's point depends on that picture: the mightiest powers of chaos already lie beaten under God, so a mortal standing up to argue his case is unthinkable.
From the study of Job 9:14.
Where scholars differ
in v14
In Job 9, does Job picture himself as the defendant answering God's charges or as the plaintiff bringing a case against God?
-
Job is chiefly the defendant: God questions or accuses him, and he cannot answer.
Verse 12 ('who can say to him, What are you doing?') and verse 15 ('I could not answer… I must plead with my judge') picture Job as the one under scrutiny. ʿānâ often means responding to a question or charge.
-
Job pictures himself starting a lawsuit, but the trial falls apart because the opposing party is also the judge.
Verse 3 ('if one wished to bring a case [rîb] with him') and verse 16 ('if I summoned him and he answered me') make Job the one who takes action. Habel and Clines read ch. 9 as Job thinking through a lawsuit that could never be fair. Later Job does demand a hearing (13:3, 18–22; 31:35).
in v15
What does limshōpheṭî mean: 'my judge', 'my opponent-at-law', or 'my case'?
-
'My opponent-at-law / adversary / accuser'
The rare verb stem often describes action directed against or with another person, and BDB and HALOT list this sense. It fits the lawsuit picture of ch. 9, where God is the opposing party, and Job's lament that there is no umpire (9:33). Followed by ESV, NRSV and many commentators.
-
'My judge'
The root ordinarily means 'judge'. The Vulgate (*iudicem meum*) and KJV tradition read it this way, as do NIV and BSB. God as judge also fits the trial setting.
-
Repoint to 'my case/right' (mishpāṭî)
This removes the unique form. YLT renders it this way, and the Septuagint's 'his judgment' points in a similar direction. Against it: it requires changing the vowels of the Masoretic text, and a unique form is not in itself an error.
in v15
Who is the subject of 'answer': Job not answering, or Job not being answered?
-
Job cannot answer (make his defence)
The Masoretic text has an active first-person verb ('I will answer'), and this continues v.14's 'How can I answer Him?'
-
Job would not be answered or heard
The Septuagint has 'he will not listen to me', and some propose a passive vowel pattern. This would anticipate v.16, but it is less supported by the Hebrew.
in v16
Is Job "calling" God as a legal summons, or as prayer?
-
A legal summons: Job pictures calling God to court as a party to a lawsuit.
The surrounding chapter is full of court language: "be in the right" (9:2), "contend" (9:3), "answer" (9:14–15), "my opponent at law" (9:15), "who will summon me?" (9:19), "arbiter" (9:33). Compare 13:22, "call, and I will answer". Most modern versions accordingly use "summoned".
-
Prayer: Job means calling on God for help, as in the psalms.
"I called and he answered me" repeats the thanksgiving formula of Ps 120:1 and Jonah 2:2 word for word. "Give ear to my voice" is psalm language (Ps 5:1; 140:6). The Vulgate reads *invocantem*, "calling upon".
-
Both at once: Job deliberately blends worship language with courtroom language.
The book often turns psalm phrases into legal complaint (compare 7:17–18 with Ps 8:4). Here the legal setting and the psalm formula are both clearly present, so many commentators hear both.
in v16
What exactly would Job "not believe"?
-
That God would truly attend to his case. God's overwhelming power means any encounter would crush Job, not hear him.
The next verses explain the doubt: "he would crush me with a tempest… he would not let me catch my breath" (9:17–18). Compare the earlier complaint that Job could not answer God (9:14–15).
-
Job describes his own inability to trust: an answer would feel too unreal to accept, like Jacob's disbelief in Gen 45:26.
The verb is first person ("I would not believe") and describes Job's state of mind. Elsewhere it is used of news too overwhelming to take in (Gen 45:26; Job 29:24; 39:24).
Sources
- BDB s.v. אַף, עָנָה, בָּחַר, דָּבָר, עִם
- HALOT s.v. ענה I, בחר
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch-Cowley) §133a, on אַף כִּי in arguments from greater to lesser
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary 17), on Job 9
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library), on the legal metaphor in Job 9
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15), on Rahab and her helpers
- L. C. L. Brenton, The Septuagint with Apocrypha: English (Job 9:14)
- Enuma Elish, Tablet IV (Tiamat's helpers)
- BDB s.v. שָׁפַט (Poel 'opponent-at-law', Job 9:15)
- HALOT s.v. שׁפט, צדק, חנן, ענה
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Job 9:15
- Vulgate, Job 9:15
- BDB s.v. אָמַן, אָזַן, עָנָה, קָרָא
- HALOT s.v. אמן (hif.), אזן (hif.), ענה I, קרא
- C. L. Seow, Job 1–21 (Illuminations)
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Job 9:16
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Job 9:16
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).