Psalms Chapter 50 Read as one passage

Psalm 50:16–17

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

16To the wicked, however, God says, “What right have you to recite My statutes and to bear My covenant on your lips? 17For you hate My instruction and cast My words behind you.

What the first hearers heard

Israelites gathered at the sanctuary, probably at a festival where the covenant was renewed and its commandments recited, would have heard this as God speaking to them. The psalm shuts off two comfortable assumptions. The first, dealt with in vv. 7–15, is that sacrifice satisfies God. The second, dealt with here, is that knowing and reciting the law makes someone a loyal member of the covenant. The rāšāʿ is defined by the gap between a fluent mouth and a lawless life, not by ignorance or by being an outsider.

For the first hearers this was serious. In the ancient world a broken treaty oath brought the curses of the treaty on the oath-breaker, and the psalm ends with that threat: "lest I tear you apart, with none to deliver" (v. 22). It also leaves a way open: "whoever offers thanksgiving honors me, and to the one who orders his way rightly I will show the salvation of God" (v. 23). The verse worked as an examination of conscience before taking the covenant words on one's lips. It made the same point the prophets made: speaking God's commandments while breaking them is itself a breach of covenant.

From the study of Psalm 50:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 16To the wicked, however, God says, “What right have you to recite My statutes and to bear My covenant on your lips?

    Then God, sitting as judge, turns to the guilty party in the case. These are not foreigners but members of his own people, and he challenges their right to speak at all: "What business do you have reciting my statutes, telling over my commandments line by line, and taking up my covenant on your lips as though you had sworn to it and it were yours?"

    The force of the verse is the contrast between the mouth and the life. These people know the law well enough to recite it. They speak the covenant oath that bound Israel to God (v. 5: "those who made a covenant with me by sacrifice"). But as the following verses spell out, they hate his discipline, throw his words behind them, join with thieves, keep company with adulterers, and use the same mouth for deceit against their own brother (vv. 17–20). Taking God's covenant "on the lips" like this echoes the commandment not to "lift up" his name emptily. Their recital is a broken oath, and God, whose words they are ("my statutes, my covenant"), denies them the right to speak them.

    Full study →
  2. 17For you hate My instruction and cast My words behind you.

    "But you, who stand there reciting my statutes and mouthing my covenant: you have set yourself against my correction. You refuse to be disciplined by the very words you repeat, and you have flung those words over your shoulder, out of sight, like something you never mean to look at again."

    The verse finishes the question of v. 16 ("What right have you to recite my statutes...?") by giving God's grounds for asking it. The emphatic "you" points at the reciter. "Hate" here is not a feeling the person would admit to. It is covenant language for rejection that shows in conduct, and vv. 18–20 spell that conduct out: siding with thieves, sharing in adultery, slander. What is rejected is mûsār, a father's corrective discipline, not mere "instruction" in the sense of information. The second line pictures the rejection: God's words, the core commands of the covenant, are thrown away behind the back. The Bible uses that idiom elsewhere for Israel's outright abandoning of God (1 Kgs 14:9; Neh 9:26). The bite of the verse is that someone who has thrown God's words behind them still has those words in their mouth.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v16

    the wicked

    rāšāʿ

    What we hear
    Notorious evildoers, the openly godless, people outside the community of faith.
    What they heard
    The guilty party in a legal case, here a covenant member and worshipper who recites God's law but breaks it in practice.
  • in v16

    take my covenant in thy mouth / on your lips

    nāśāʾ bərîtî ʿălê-pîkā

    What we hear
    Merely talking about God or quoting religious things.
    What they heard
    Lifting up the covenant on the lips: solemnly professing or swearing to God's covenant, the same idiom as 'lifting up' the divine name in an oath (Exod 20:7).
  • in v17

    instruction

    mûsār

    What we hear
    Teaching or directions: information someone hands on to you.
    What they heard
    Corrective discipline, the way a father trains and chastens a son. It includes rebuke and sometimes punishment, and it aims at changing the person.
  • in v17

    hate

    śānē'

    What we hear
    An intense inner feeling of loathing, which the person would know they have.
    What they heard
    Covenant rejection: repudiating something and acting against it. It is visible in behavior and can coexist with outwardly respecting the words.
Every word
  1. וְלָרָשָׁע

    wəlārāšāʿ · H7563

    and to the wicked · v16

    Literally 'and to the guilty one'. This is the party found in the wrong in a legal case. In this psalm it is a member of God's own covenant people, not an outsider, and the court setting of the psalm brings out the legal sense of the word.

  2. אָמַר

    ʾāmar · H0559

    he says / has said · v16

    The perfect form marks a formal pronouncement: the Judge now turns to address a second party in the hearing.

  3. אֱלֹהִים

    ʾĕlōhîm · H0430

    God · v16

    The usual divine title in this part of the Psalter. Here it names the God who has summoned heaven and earth as witnesses (v. 1–6) and who speaks as judge.

  4. מַה־

    mah- · H4100

    what? · v16

    Opens an indignant question. It is not a request for information.

  5. לְּךָ

    ləkā · H9031

    to you · v16

    Together with 'what', this forms the idiom 'what is it to you?', meaning 'what business, what claim, do you have?' (compare Jer 2:18; Judg 11:12). It denies that the speaker has any standing.

  6. לְסַפֵּר

    ləsappēr · H5608

    to recount, recite · v16

    This form of the verb means to tell out item by item, to rehearse or recite. Most likely it refers to reciting God's laws aloud in worship or teaching.

  7. חֻקָּי

    ḥuqqāy · H2706

    my statutes · v16

    God's fixed, stated requirements. The verses that follow show which ones: the commandments against theft, adultery and false witness.

  8. וַתִּשָּׂא

    wattiśśāʾ · H5375

    and you lifted up / took up · v16

    'Lift up' on the mouth is the language of uttering a solemn name or oath (compare Exod 20:7; Ps 16:4). The verb form continues the question: 'and that you have taken up…'

  9. בְרִיתִי

    bərîtî · H1285

    my covenant · v16

    God's binding, sworn relationship with Israel, together with its obligations. It recalls verse 5: 'those who made a covenant with me by sacrifice'.

  10. עֲלֵי־

    ʿălê- · H5921

    upon · v16

    A poetic, longer form of 'upon'. The covenant sits 'on' the mouth, present in speech but not in conduct.

  11. פִיךָ

    pîkā · H6310

    your mouth · v16

    The mouth is the organ of oath, profession and recitation. Verses 19–20 use the same word to say this mouth is 'let loose for evil'.

  12. וְאַתָּה

    we'attāh · H859

    and you · v17

    Hebrew verbs already show who is acting, so adding the pronoun puts weight on it: "but *you*." It points straight at the person of v. 16, who recites God's statutes. The contrast is between what that person says and who that person is.

  13. שָׂנֵאתָ

    śānē'tā · H8130

    to hate, reject · v17

    "You have hated": a settled stance that is still in force, so "you hate." In covenant language this means refusing and repudiating. It shows up in conduct (vv. 18–20) more than in feeling. The person may well be fond of reciting the words.

  14. מוּסָר

    mûsār · H4148

    discipline, correction · v17

    Correction that is meant to form a person, the kind a father gives a son. Sometimes it stings. What is rejected here is being corrected at all, not just a piece of information.

  15. וַתַּשְׁלֵךְ

    wattašlēḵ · H7993

    to throw, cast, fling · v17

    "And you threw." This is a forceful, physical verb for flinging something away, used of throwing stones, corpses or rubbish. The verb form describes the act that follows from the hatred: first the hatred, then the throwing away.

  16. דְּבָרַי

    dəḇāray · H1697

    my words · v17

    God's spoken words, here the covenant stipulations the person recites (v. 16). The sins listed in vv. 18–20 (theft, adultery, false speech) echo the Ten Commandments, which Hebrew calls "the Ten Words." So "my words" probably points to that core.

  17. אַחֲרֶיךָ

    'aḥărêḵā · H310

    behind you · v17

    "Behind you," that is, out of sight. This is a short form of the idiom "cast behind one's back": to discard something deliberately and refuse to look at it again.

The world behind it

A covenant trial. Psalm 50, a psalm "of Asaph" (the guild of temple singers), is staged as a court hearing. God appears in fire from Zion (vv. 1–3), calls heaven and earth as witnesses (v. 4), and gathers "my faithful ones, who made a covenant with me by sacrifice" (v. 5). The prophets use the same courtroom form to accuse Israel of breaking covenant (Isa 1:2; Mic 6:1–2; Hos 4:1).

Two charges. The first speech (vv. 7–15) corrects a misunderstanding of sacrifice: God does not need their bulls; he wants thanksgiving, kept vows, and to be called on in trouble. The second speech (vv. 16–21), which this verse opens, deals with moral hypocrisy. Its specific charges (theft, adultery, deceitful and slanderous speech against a brother) follow the second half of the Ten Commandments, the same list Hosea (4:2) and Jeremiah (7:9, the Temple Sermon) bring against worshippers who still came to the sanctuary.

Reciting the law. Israel's worship included public recital of the covenant law. Deuteronomy 31:10–13 commands it every seventh year at the Festival of Booths, and Psalms 15 and 24 set moral conditions for anyone entering the temple. The person addressed here takes part in that recital. The question is whether that speech is honest.

From the study of Psalm 50:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

Who is 'the wicked' addressed here?

  • Ordinary worshippers in general: the same covenant people addressed in vv. 7–15, looked at from a moral rather than a ritual angle.

    Verse 7 addresses 'my people… Israel'. The charges are everyday sins of ordinary people. Prophetic parallels (Jer 7:9; Hos 4:2) accuse the whole nation of the same things.

  • A distinct group inside the community: hypocrites singled out from the 'faithful ones' of v. 5, as the heading in v. 16a makes them.

    The present Hebrew text explicitly turns 'to the wicked'. The two speeches differ in tone, the first correcting and the second condemning.

  • Cult officials, priests or Levites, whose role included reciting and teaching the statutes.

    'Recount my statutes' fits teaching or liturgical duties (Deut 31:9–13; 33:10; Mal 2:7–8). This view is suggestive but not required by the wording.

in v16

Does the psalm reflect an actual covenant-renewal festival?

  • Yes: it echoes a liturgy in which God appeared, the Decalogue was recited, and the people were examined.

    The appearance of God at Zion, the summoning of witnesses, the gathering of covenant members, the commandment-based charges and the 'recite my statutes' language (argued by Weiser and Mowinckel's school, and by Kraus in modified form).

  • It is a literary, prophetic-style composition using the courtroom form, without being tied to one festival.

    The same courtroom form appears in prophetic books with no liturgical setting (Isa 1; Mic 6). Direct evidence for a regular covenant-renewal festival is limited.

in v17

Who are "the wicked" addressed in vv. 16–21?

  • Insiders within the worshipping community: Israelites, perhaps including those who lead the recitation, whose conduct contradicts the covenant they recite.

    They "recite my statutes" and "take my covenant on your lips" (v. 16), which is insider activity. The psalm's whole court scene is addressed to "my people" (v. 7), and the sins listed are covenant breaches.

  • A distinct group set apart from the "faithful ones" of v. 5: the openly wicked, as opposed to sincere but mistaken worshippers.

    V. 16 opens with a new address ("But to the wicked God said"), and the two speeches deal with different faults: wrong ideas about sacrifice in vv. 7–15, moral corruption in vv. 16–21.

in v17

Is the line introducing v. 16 ("But to the wicked God said") original?

  • It is a later editorial addition, inserted to keep the faithful of vv. 7–15 from being read as the target of the harsh charges.

    Some commentators (e.g. H.-J. Kraus) note that it disturbs the poetic rhythm, and that without it vv. 16–21 could read as addressed to the same "people" as v. 7.

  • It is original and marks the turn to the psalm's second charge.

    No manuscript lacks it, and the Septuagint has it. Prophetic lawsuits often change addressee within one oracle.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. רָשָׁע, נשׂא, חֹק
  • BDB s.v. סָפַר (Piel), בְּרִית
  • Hans-Joachim Kraus, Psalms 1–59 (Continental Commentary)
  • Peter C. Craigie, Psalms 1–50 (Word Biblical Commentary 19)
  • Artur Weiser, The Psalms (Old Testament Library)
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Ps 49:16
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Ps 49:16
  • BDB s.v. מוּסָר, שָׂנֵא, שָׁלַךְ
  • HALOT s.v. מוּסָר; שׂנא
  • W. L. Moran, "The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy," CBQ 25 (1963)
  • H.-J. Kraus, Psalms 1–59 (Continental Commentary)
  • M. E. Tate / P. C. Craigie, Word Biblical Commentary: Psalms
  • Septuagint Psalm 49:17 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate Psalm 49:17 (Gallican Psalter)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).