Psalms Chapter 50 Read as one passage

Psalm 50:17–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17For you hate My instruction and cast My words behind you. 18When you see a thief, you befriend him, and throw in your lot with adulterers. 19You unleash your mouth for evil and harness your tongue to deceit. 20You sit and malign your brother; you slander your own mother’s son.

What the first hearers heard

The psalm was sung or proclaimed in the temple. To worshippers gathered there, these lines were an uncomfortable mirror. Being present at worship, bringing sacrifices and knowing the covenant words by heart did not prove you were faithful. God, speaking as judge in his own court, says that someone who recites "you shall not steal" and then befriends thieves has already rejected his correction and thrown his words away.

For Israel, this kept the covenant from shrinking into liturgy alone. The first speech (vv. 7–15) had already said God does not need sacrifices. This one says God is not satisfied by recitation either. The psalm closes with the alternative: "to the one who orders his way rightly I will show the salvation of God" (v. 23). Loyalty is judged by keeping the words, not by saying them. The tone is a warning, not yet a final sentence. God has kept silent so far (v. 21), and the call to "consider this" (v. 22) leaves room to accept the correction before judgment falls.

From the study of Psalm 50:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17For you hate My instruction and cast My words behind you.

    "But you, who stand there reciting my statutes and mouthing my covenant: you have set yourself against my correction. You refuse to be disciplined by the very words you repeat, and you have flung those words over your shoulder, out of sight, like something you never mean to look at again."

    The verse finishes the question of v. 16 ("What right have you to recite my statutes...?") by giving God's grounds for asking it. The emphatic "you" points at the reciter. "Hate" here is not a feeling the person would admit to. It is covenant language for rejection that shows in conduct, and vv. 18–20 spell that conduct out: siding with thieves, sharing in adultery, slander. What is rejected is mûsār, a father's corrective discipline, not mere "instruction" in the sense of information. The second line pictures the rejection: God's words, the core commands of the covenant, are thrown away behind the back. The Bible uses that idiom elsewhere for Israel's outright abandoning of God (1 Kgs 14:9; Neh 9:26). The bite of the verse is that someone who has thrown God's words behind them still has those words in their mouth.

    Full study →
  2. 18When you see a thief, you befriend him, and throw in your lot with adulterers.

    God, speaking as both judge and the wronged covenant partner, lays out evidence against a worshipper who recites his laws but has thrown his words behind his back (v. 17):

    "Whenever you caught sight of a thief, you warmed to him and made common cause with him (or, as the oldest translations read it, "you ran along with him"), and your allotted share, your lot and your fellowship, was with men who commit adultery."

    The verse cites two of the Ten Commandments by name. "You shall not steal" and "You shall not commit adultery" use the same roots as "thief" and "adulterers," and the next verse adds deceit and slander, the commandment against false witness. The charge is not only that the man sins. It is that he is pleased with sinners. The Hebrew verb is the word used when God "accepts" an offering, so the man God will not accept is quick to accept the thief. And "portion" is the word for an inherited allotment, the same word the faithful use when they say "the LORD is my portion." This man has chosen a different portion: his lot, his partners and, by implication, his end are with the covenant-breakers.

    Full study →
  3. 19You unleash your mouth for evil and harness your tongue to deceit.

    "Your mouth: you send it out to do harm, you turn it loose. And your tongue: you hitch it, like an ox under the yoke, to treachery."

    The verse is two balanced lines. Each begins with the organ of speech ("your mouth… your tongue"), placed first so that it sticks out. The point of the emphasis comes from verse 16: this is the very mouth that recites God's statutes and "takes my covenant on your lips." Now God turns to what that same mouth does the rest of the week.

    The two lines use opposite farm pictures that end in the same place. In the first, the mouth is released: sent off on errands of harm, with nothing to hold it back. In the second, the tongue is harnessed: yoked to deceit like a draft animal to a plow, the two pulling together in steady partnership. Loose or yoked, the speaker controls both, and both are put to the same use. The verbs describe habit, not a single lapse. The first is a past-tense form for something already settled ("you have made a practice of"). The second is an ongoing form ("you keep on hitching").

    "Harm" (ra'ah) means injury done to others, not abstract wickedness. "Deceit" (mirmah) is the word for rigged scales, Jacob's stolen blessing, and testimony that twists the truth. Read with the theft and adultery of verse 18 and the slander of a brother in verse 20, the verse completes a sequence that echoes the Ten Commandments: stealing, adultery, and false witness against one's neighbour. The man knows the commandments well enough to recite them and breaks them in the same breath.

    Full study →
  4. 20You sit and malign your brother; you slander your own mother’s son.

    "You settle in and sit, and what comes out is talk against your own brother. Against the son your own mother bore, you fasten a flaw."

    The Hebrew describes a habit, not a slip. The verbs picture someone who keeps doing this. "You sit" is the scene-setter: a comfortable, deliberate posture. It may be among companions, or in the town gate, the public square where people talked and where reputations and lawsuits were settled. "Speak against" uses the plainest word for talking, made hostile by the word "against." Then the line tightens. "Your brother" (which could mean any fellow Israelite) becomes "your mother's son," the full brother who came from the same womb, the closest bond a man had.

    The last phrase is unusually concrete. Literally, "you give a blemish," using a rare word found only here in the Bible, meaning a defect or flaw. The same pattern ("put a blemish on") is used in Leviticus for physically injuring someone. The slanderer does something like that with words: he leaves a mark on his brother's name that the brother cannot wash off. The early Greek translators heard it as "you set a stumbling block" against him. Both pictures agree that this speech is meant to damage and bring down. In this psalm the charge falls on someone who also recites God's commandments and claims his covenant (v. 16). The sin is the breaking of the commandment against false witness, committed against one's own flesh and blood.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    instruction

    mûsār

    What we hear
    Teaching or directions: information someone hands on to you.
    What they heard
    Corrective discipline, the way a father trains and chastens a son. It includes rebuke and sometimes punishment, and it aims at changing the person.
  • in v17

    hate

    śānē'

    What we hear
    An intense inner feeling of loathing, which the person would know they have.
    What they heard
    Covenant rejection: repudiating something and acting against it. It is visible in behavior and can coexist with outwardly respecting the words.
  • in v18

    consentedst / consented with (KJV, WEB)

    wattireṣ ʿimmô

    What we hear
    Gave permission to, said yes to something, as in "consent" today: a passive or legal agreement.
    What they heard
    Was pleased with him and on good terms with him (or, on the ancient versions' reading, ran with him): warm approval and active partnership.
  • in v18

    adulterers

    mənāʾăp̄îm

    What we hear
    Anyone, husband or wife, who is sexually unfaithful to a spouse.
    What they heard
    Men who have sexual relations with another man's wife (or betrothed). Israelite law defined adultery by the woman's married status. The prophets also used the word for covenant unfaithfulness to God.
  • in v19

    thy tongue frameth deceit (KJV; also WEB, ESV, NASB "frames")

    tatsmid

    What we hear
    To "frame" suggests putting a border around something, or "framing" an innocent person for a crime.
    What they heard
    To yoke or harness together, as a pair of oxen is hitched to a plow. The tongue and deceit are a working team.
  • in v19

    evil

    ra'ah

    What we hear
    Abstract, near-demonic wickedness, or general bad talk.
    What they heard
    Harm or injury done to other people: speech used as a weapon against a neighbour.
  • in v20

    You sit and speak against

    tēshēv ... tĕdabbēr bĕ-

    What we hear
    Throwaway scene-setting, or idle couch-side gossip: the sin is mainly "saying unkind things."
    What they heard
    A settled, habitual posture, the posture of people who "sit" together in a company (Ps 1:1) or in the gate where public talk and legal testimony happened (Ps 69:12; Ruth 4:1–2). Set beside verses 18–19 it echoes the commandment against false witness: deliberate speech that damages a person's standing.
Every word
  1. וְאַתָּה

    we'attāh · H859

    and you · v17

    Hebrew verbs already show who is acting, so adding the pronoun puts weight on it: "but *you*." It points straight at the person of v. 16, who recites God's statutes. The contrast is between what that person says and who that person is.

  2. שָׂנֵאתָ

    śānē'tā · H8130

    to hate, reject · v17

    "You have hated": a settled stance that is still in force, so "you hate." In covenant language this means refusing and repudiating. It shows up in conduct (vv. 18–20) more than in feeling. The person may well be fond of reciting the words.

  3. מוּסָר

    mûsār · H4148

    discipline, correction · v17

    Correction that is meant to form a person, the kind a father gives a son. Sometimes it stings. What is rejected here is being corrected at all, not just a piece of information.

  4. וַתַּשְׁלֵךְ

    wattašlēḵ · H7993

    to throw, cast, fling · v17

    "And you threw." This is a forceful, physical verb for flinging something away, used of throwing stones, corpses or rubbish. The verb form describes the act that follows from the hatred: first the hatred, then the throwing away.

  5. דְּבָרַי

    dəḇāray · H1697

    my words · v17

    God's spoken words, here the covenant stipulations the person recites (v. 16). The sins listed in vv. 18–20 (theft, adultery, false speech) echo the Ten Commandments, which Hebrew calls "the Ten Words." So "my words" probably points to that core.

  6. אַחֲרֶיךָ

    'aḥărêḵā · H310

    behind you · v17

    "Behind you," that is, out of sight. This is a short form of the idiom "cast behind one's back": to discard something deliberately and refuse to look at it again.

  7. אִם־

    ʾim · H0518A

    if, when · v18

    Opens a condition that is really a description of habit: "if ever you saw…" means "whenever you saw." God is not imagining a possibility. He is laying out a pattern of conduct as evidence.

  8. רָאִ֣יתָ

    rāʾîtā · H7200G

    see · v18

    "You saw": the moment of noticing. The charge is not that the man stole but that the theft was in plain view and his response was to warm to it rather than recoil.

  9. גַ֭נָּב

    gannāḇ · H1590

    thief · v18

    A thief, someone who takes by stealth. The word recalls the commandment "You shall not steal" (lōʾ tignōḇ, same root), which in Israel's law also covered kidnapping (Exod 21:16).

  10. וַתִּ֣רֶץ

    wattireṣ · H7521

    be pleased with, accept, be on good terms · v18

    As the Hebrew is vowelled, "and you were pleased / took up with" him: approval and friendly alliance. The ancient translations read the same consonants as "you ran with him," meaning joined him in what he did. Either way it is complicity, not mere acquaintance.

  11. עִמּ֑וֹ

    ʿimmô · H5973A

    with him · v18

    "With him": association and partnership. With rāṣāh it gives the idiom "be on good terms with" (compare Job 34:9).

  12. מְנָאֲפִ֣ים

    mənāʾăp̄îm · H5003

    adulterers · v18

    "Men who commit adultery" (an intensive participle describing ongoing practice). The verb is the one in the commandment "You shall not commit adultery" (lōʾ tinʾāp̄).

  13. חֶלְקֶֽךָ׃

    ḥelqekā · H2506A

    portion, share, lot · v18

    "Your share/lot." Your allotted portion, the group whose fate and spoils you share. A word heavy with the idea of an inherited allotment, so it implies belonging, not just occasional company.

  14. פִּ֭יךָ

    pikha · H6310G

    mouth (your) · v19

    Placed first for emphasis: "your mouth" is the object of the verb that follows. It is the same mouth that, three verses earlier, recites God's laws and "takes my covenant on your mouth" (v. 16). The irony is deliberate.

  15. שָׁלַ֣חְתָּ

    shalachta · H7971H

    send, stretch out, let go · v19

    "You have sent out / let loose." The mouth is pictured as something sent off on an errand of harm, or turned loose with nothing to hold it back. The Hebrew past-tense form is used here for a habit already set, not a single past act: this is what the man does.

  16. בְרָעָ֑ה

    vera'ah · H7451I

    evil, harm, trouble · v19

    "In / for harm." Ra'ah here means less an abstract moral evil and more concrete damage done to other people: speech that wounds, ruins reputations, and decides court cases unjustly.

  17. וּ֝לְשׁוֹנְךָ֗

    ulshonkha · H3956G

    tongue (and your) · v19

    "And your tongue" is the second half of the pair mouth/tongue, which Hebrew poetry uses together for a person's whole speech. Like "your mouth," it is placed first in its line.

  18. תַּצְמִ֥יד

    tatsmid · H6775

    yoke, bind, fasten together · v19

    From the word for a yoked pair of oxen (tsemed). "You harness / hitch" the tongue to deceit, as a farmer hitches an ox to a plow, so that the two pull together. This verb form occurs only here in the Bible. The present-future form describes ongoing, repeated action.

  19. מִרְמָֽה׃

    mirmah · H4820

    deceit, treachery, fraud · v19

    Calculated deception used to get ahead at someone else's cost. It is the word for rigged scales and for Jacob's trick on Isaac. In a setting of covenant law, it points toward false testimony.

  20. תֵּ֭שֵׁב

    tēshēv · H3427

    to sit, dwell, remain · v20

    "You sit." It stands alone at the head of the line, setting the scene: a settled, unhurried posture. The verb form describes something ongoing or habitual ("you sit, again and again"), not a single slip of the tongue.

  21. בְּאָחִ֣יךָ

    bĕ'āḥîkhā · H251

    brother, kinsman, fellow Israelite · v20

    "Against your brother." With the verb "speak," the small prefix bĕ- means "against" (as in Numbers 12:1, where Miriam and Aaron "spoke against Moses"). "Brother" can mean a full sibling or a fellow member of the covenant people. The next line narrows it to the closest kin.

  22. תְדַבֵּ֑ר

    tĕdabbēr · H1696

    to speak · v20

    "You speak." On its own this is the ordinary word for speaking. Joined to "against" it means hostile talk. Like "sit," the form points to an ongoing habit.

  23. בְּבֶֽן־

    bĕven- · H1121

    son, child · v20

    "Against the son of." The same "against" prefix repeats, matching the first half of the line.

  24. אִ֝מְּךָ֗

    'immĕkha · H517

    mother · v20

    "Your mother." "Your mother's son" means a full blood brother, born of the same womb. In households where a man might have more than one wife, this was the tightest family bond there was. The phrase makes "brother" sharper and more shameful.

  25. תִּתֶּן־

    tittēn- · H5414

    to give, put, set, lay · v20

    "You give, you put." Here it means to place or fasten something on someone, as in Leviticus 24:19–20, where a person "puts a blemish" (that is, inflicts an injury) on his neighbour. The slanderer pins a flaw onto his brother.

  26. דֹּֽפִי׃

    dōfî · H1848

    blemish, fault, slander · v20

    "A blemish, a fault." This is the only place the word appears in the Hebrew Bible. Later Hebrew uses it for a defect or flaw. Here it is a stain on a brother's name, put there by talk. The early Greek translation read it as a "stumbling block."

The world behind it

A covenant lawsuit in the temple. Psalm 50 is attributed to Asaph, the head of a Levitical guild of temple singers. It is built like a courtroom case brought under a treaty. God appears in fire at Zion (vv. 1–3), summons heaven and earth as witnesses (v. 4; compare Deut 32:1; Isa 1:2; Mic 6:1–2), and calls in "my faithful ones, who made a covenant with me by sacrifice" (v. 5). Ancient Near Eastern treaties were commonly sworn before divine witnesses, and Israel's prophets borrowed this form to bring charges against the people for breaking covenant.

Two speeches. The first (vv. 7–15) corrects worshippers who treat sacrifice as feeding God. The second (vv. 16–21) is aimed at "the wicked" who recite God's statutes. That suggests an occasion of public worship where the covenant law was read or chanted aloud. Deuteronomy 31:10–13 commands a reading of the law at the Feast of Booths every seventh year. Many scholars imagine some festival of covenant renewal behind the psalm, though how it actually worked is uncertain.

Who is speaking to whom. The person accused is not a pagan outsider. They are an insider who knows the covenant words well enough to recite them. In a culture of oral recitation, having the law "on your lips" (v. 16) was a mark of belonging. The psalm says that belonging is void when conduct contradicts the words. Verses 18–20 deliberately follow the order of the Ten Commandments: theft (8th), adultery (7th), deceit and slander against a brother (9th).

From the study of Psalm 50:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Who are "the wicked" addressed in vv. 16–21?

  • Insiders within the worshipping community: Israelites, perhaps including those who lead the recitation, whose conduct contradicts the covenant they recite.

    They "recite my statutes" and "take my covenant on your lips" (v. 16), which is insider activity. The psalm's whole court scene is addressed to "my people" (v. 7), and the sins listed are covenant breaches.

  • A distinct group set apart from the "faithful ones" of v. 5: the openly wicked, as opposed to sincere but mistaken worshippers.

    V. 16 opens with a new address ("But to the wicked God said"), and the two speeches deal with different faults: wrong ideas about sacrifice in vv. 7–15, moral corruption in vv. 16–21.

in v17

Is the line introducing v. 16 ("But to the wicked God said") original?

  • It is a later editorial addition, inserted to keep the faithful of vv. 7–15 from being read as the target of the harsh charges.

    Some commentators (e.g. H.-J. Kraus) note that it disturbs the poetic rhythm, and that without it vv. 16–21 could read as addressed to the same "people" as v. 7.

  • It is original and marks the turn to the psalm's second charge.

    No manuscript lacks it, and the Septuagint has it. Prophetic lawsuits often change addressee within one oracle.

in v18

Did the speaker originally say "you were pleased with" the thief or "you ran with" him?

  • "You were pleased with / on good terms with him" (Masoretic rāṣāh).

    Masoretic vowels. The idiom rāṣāh ʿim, "be in accord with," is attested in Job 34:9. Possible ironic echo of rāṣāh as the word for God accepting worship, in a psalm about acceptable worship.

  • "You ran with him" (rûṣ, revocalised).

    Septuagint, Vulgate and Syriac all read "ran." It parallels the wisdom warning against running with sinners (Prov 1:15–16) and gives a vivid picture of action that matches "portion" in the second line. Favoured by a number of modern commentators.

in v18

Whom does God address in vv. 16–21?

  • Israelites in general who worship outwardly but break the covenant.

    The psalm addresses "my people… Israel" (v. 7). The prophetic parallels (Hos 4:2; Jer 7:9) indict the whole nation.

  • A distinct group within Israel, perhaps those who teach or recite the law (priests, Levites or other leaders).

    v. 16 "what right have you to recite my statutes?" suggests people with an official role in proclaiming the covenant. The separate heading "to the wicked" sets them apart from the "faithful ones" of v. 5.

in v19

Do verses 18–20 deliberately echo the Ten Commandments?

  • Yes: the charges follow the second tablet of the Decalogue (theft, adultery, false witness).

    Verse 16 explicitly mentions reciting God's statutes and covenant. The verbs and nouns line up with the eighth, seventh and ninth commandments, and Psalm 50 is widely read as a liturgy of covenant renewal (e.g. Kraus; Craigie, WBC). Hosea 4:2 and Jeremiah 7:9 use similar Decalogue lists in prophetic lawsuits.

  • Partly: they are general covenant ethics drawn from shared legal and wisdom vocabulary, not a structured citation.

    The order differs from Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5, the wording is not quoted, and words like mirmah and slander belong just as much to the language of Proverbs and the Psalms.

in v20

What exactly is dōfî, a word found only here?

  • A blemish, flaw or fault, which the slanderer attributes to his brother.

    Later Hebrew uses dofi for a defect or flaw. The phrase "give/put X on" matches Leviticus 24:19–20, "put a blemish (mum) on his neighbour." Standard lexicons (BDB, HALOT) give "blemish, fault."

  • Something that makes a person fall: a thrust, a stumbling block.

    The Septuagint renders it skandalon and the Vulgate scandalum. Some connect the word to a root meaning "push, thrust." The ancient translators may simply have been translating by sense.

in v20

Does "you sit" point to a legal or public setting, or simply to a habit?

  • It evokes sitting in the gate or in a company, where public talk and testimony shaped reputations and verdicts.

    The psalm is a covenant lawsuit. Verses 18–20 follow the commandments, ending with false witness. Psalm 69:12 and Ruth 4:1–2 associate "sitting" with the gate. Psalm 1:1 has "sitting" in a settled company of scoffers.

  • It mainly expresses settled, leisurely, habitual behaviour, with no specific setting in view.

    The verb is very common and the line gives no location. The ongoing verb forms stress habit more than place.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).