1 Chronicles Chapter 4 Read as one passage

1 Chronicles 4:27–31

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

27Shimei had sixteen sons and six daughters, but his brothers did not have many children, so their whole clan did not become as numerous as the sons of Judah. 28They lived in Beersheba, Moladah, Hazar-shual, 29Bilhah, Ezem, Tolad, 30Bethuel, Hormah, Ziklag, 31Beth-marcaboth, Hazar-susim, Beth-biri, and Shaaraim. These were their cities until the reign of David.

What the first hearers heard

For readers in post-exilic Judah, this short note did several things:

  • It honoured a remembered ancestor. Shimei's twenty-two children were remembered as a mark of blessing within his line.
  • It explained a known fact. Simeon was small and had largely merged into Judah. The genealogy gives the reason: apart from a few households like Shimei's, Simeon's clans never grew large.
  • It placed Simeon within "all Israel". Though small, Simeon still gets its own genealogy and list of towns (vv. 24–43). That fits Chronicles' concern to include every tribe in the people of God, while showing Judah, the tribe of David, as the dominant one.
  • It echoed the patriarchal promise. The verb "multiply" reminded readers of the promise to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and that its fulfilment had been uneven among the tribes.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 4:27.

Verse by verse

  1. 27Shimei had sixteen sons and six daughters, but his brothers did not have many children, so their whole clan did not become as numerous as the sons of Judah.

    Shimei, one of Simeon's descendants, was unusually blessed with children: sixteen sons and six daughters, twenty-two in all. The writer counts the daughters too, which makes the household look even more fruitful. His brothers and kinsmen did not share that fruitfulness; they had few children. So the clan system of Simeon as a whole never "multiplied", the word of the old blessing "be fruitful and multiply". It never reached the size of the people of Judah, the great tribe whose territory surrounded Simeon's towns. The verse sets one flourishing household against a tribe that stayed small, and it prepares for the next verses, which list the towns where Simeon lived inside Judah's land.

    Full study →
  2. 28They lived in Beersheba, Moladah, Hazar-shual,

    "And so they settled in Beersheba ('Well of the Oath'), in Moladah, and in Hazar-shual ('Fox Village')."

    The subject is the clan of Simeon, the small tribe described in the verse before, which 'did not become as numerous as the sons of Judah'. The verse opens a list of the towns where Simeon actually lived (vv. 28–33). It starts with Beersheba. For an Israelite that name called up the wells Abraham and Isaac dug and the oaths they swore there, and it marked the southern edge of the land ('from Dan to Beersheba'). Moladah and Hazar-shual were Negev settlements. The second name pictures an unwalled herders' camp at the edge of the wilderness, where foxes and jackals prowled. The list says, in effect: this weak tribe had a real place in the land, beginning at the patriarchs' own well. The verb tells it as past history, and verse 31 adds that these were their towns 'until David reigned', so the Chronicler is recording what was, not making a present claim.

    Full study →
  3. 29Bilhah, Ezem, Tolad,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 30Bethuel, Hormah, Ziklag,

    "…and they lived in Bethuel, and in Hormah, and in Ziklag…"

    The verse continues the list begun in verse 28 ("They lived in Beersheba, Moladah…") of the towns where the clans of Simeon settled in the Negev, the dry southern country around Beersheba. In Hebrew each name carries "and in", so the list moves along steadily, one place after another.

    The names would not have sounded empty to the first hearers:

    • Bethuel was a small southern town, probably the "Bethel" of 1 Samuel 30:27. Its name ends with El, "God".
    • Hormah sounds like ḥerem, "devoted to destruction". Israel's stories connected it with a defeat in the wilderness and with a Canaanite city that Judah and Simeon destroyed together.
    • Ziklag was the frontier town that a Philistine king gave to David when David was an outlaw. Through David it came to belong to the kings of Judah.

    That last name prepares for the comment that closes the list in the next verse: these were Simeon's towns until David reigned. After that, Simeon's small territory inside Judah merged into the kingdom of Judah.

    Full study →
  5. 31Beth-marcaboth, Hazar-susim, Beth-biri, and Shaaraim. These were their cities until the reign of David.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v27

    family (KJV, WEB: "all their family")

    mishpaḥah

    What we hear
    A household of parents and children, or close relatives.
    What they heard
    A clan: a large kin group within a tribe, made up of several extended households, sharing ancestry, land and identity.
Every word
  1. וּלְשִׁמְעִ֞י

    uləShimʿi · H8096

    and to Shimei · v27

    Hebrew has no verb 'to have'; it says 'to Shimei [there were]'. Shimei is the last man named in verse 26 (son of Zaccur, in the line of Mishma), a Simeonite. The name, a common one, comes from the root 'to hear'.

  2. בָּנִ֨ים

    banim · H1121

    sons · v27

    Here clearly 'sons' in the strict sense, because daughters are counted separately right after.

  3. שִׁשָּׁ֤ה

    shishshah · H8337

    six · v27

    First half of the number sixteen, which Hebrew builds as 'six-ten'.

  4. עָשָׂר֙

    ʿasar · H6240

    ten · v27

    The '-teen' element: together with the previous word, 'sixteen'.

  5. וּבָנ֣וֹת

    uvanot · H1323

    and daughters · v27

    Daughters are counted, which genealogies seldom do. Including them makes Shimei's household look even more fruitful.

  6. וּלְאֶחָ֕יו

    ulə'eḥav · H251

    and to his brothers · v27

    'And to his brothers [there were]', the same construction as 'to Shimei'. The two clauses stand side by side to make a contrast. 'Brothers' can mean full brothers or, more loosely, kinsmen of the same clan line.

  7. אֵ֖ין

    'ein · H369

    there is not · v27

    The usual Hebrew word for denying that something exists: 'there were not'.

  8. רַבִּ֑ים

    rabbim · H7227

    many · v27

    'Not many sons': the brothers had some children, but few.

  9. וְכֹל֙

    vəkhol · H3605

    and all · v27

    'And all', the whole of the group. This widens the focus from one household to the clan as a whole.

  10. מִשְׁפַּחְתָּ֔ם

    mishpaḥtam · H4940

    their clan · v27

    Their clan: a kinship group larger than a household and smaller than a tribe. 'Their' most naturally means the Simeonites whose genealogy is being traced (vv. 24–27).

  11. לֹ֥א

    lo · H3808

    not · v27

    Negates the verb that follows.

  12. הִרְבּ֖וּ

    hirbu · H7235

    they increased · v27

    'They became many, increased'. This is the verb of the creation and patriarch blessings ('be fruitful and multiply'). Saying the clan did not 'multiply' quietly marks where that blessing fell short.

  13. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    up to, as far as · v27

    Literally 'up to' or 'as far as'. Here it makes a comparison: they did not increase to the level of Judah.

  14. יְהוּדָֽה׃

    Yəhudah · H3063

    Judah · v27

    The tribe of Judah. It was the largest tribe, Chronicles puts it first, and Simeon's land lay inside its territory. The verse ends with a paragraph marker (ס) in the Hebrew manuscripts.

  15. וַיֵּֽשְׁב֛וּ

    wayyēšəḇû · H3427

    and they dwelt / settled · v28

    The ordinary Hebrew verb for sitting down, settling and living somewhere. Its subject is the descendants of Simeon (v. 24–27). The verb form tells the next step in a story, so it means 'and so they settled', not 'they live there now'.

  16. בִּבְאֵֽר־

    biḇ'ēr- · H884

    in Beer- (well) · v28

    The preposition 'in' joined to be'er, 'well'. It is the first half of the place name Beersheba, the 'well' that made life possible at this spot on the dry southern frontier.

  17. וּמוֹלָדָ֖ה

    ûmôlāḏâ · H4137

    and Moladah · v28

    A town in the Negev, the dry southern region. The name probably comes from the root for 'birth' or 'begetting', though no story explains it. Where exactly it stood is disputed.

  18. וַחֲצַ֥ר

    waḥăṣar · H2705

    and Hazar- (enclosure, settlement) · v28

    Ḥaṣar means an enclosure or an unwalled settlement: the kind of village with pens for flocks found in the semi-desert south. It is the first part of the name Hazar-shual.

  19. וּבִבְתוּאֵ֥ל

    u-vivtu'el · H1328B

    and in Bethuel · v30

    A town in the Negev, the dry south, settled by Simeon. Each word in the verse begins with 'and in', carrying on the verb 'they lived' from verse 28, so this is the next item in a list of the places where Simeon's clans lived. The same name belongs to Rebekah's father (Genesis 22:22), but here it is a place.

  20. וּבְחָרְמָ֖ה

    u-veḥormah · H2767

    and in Hormah · v30

    A Negev town whose name sounds like ḥerem, 'something devoted to destruction'. In Israel's stories it was the site of an early defeat (Numbers 14:45) and later of a city that was 'devoted' (Numbers 21:3; Judges 1:17). An Israelite listener would hear that history in the name.

  21. וּבְצִֽיקְלָֽג׃

    u-vetsiqlag · H6860

    and in Ziklag · v30

    The town that the Philistine king Achish gave to David, from which David raided while he was an outlaw (1 Samuel 27:6). Its mention here sets up verse 31's remark that these were Simeon's towns 'until David reigned'.

The world behind it
  • Simeon, the shrinking tribe. In the first census in Numbers, Simeon has 59,300 fighting men (Num 1:23). In the second census it has 22,200 (Num 26:14), the smallest of all the tribes. Moses' blessing in Deuteronomy 33 does not mention Simeon at all. Jacob's words in Genesis 49:7 had said of Simeon and Levi, "I will scatter them in Jacob."
  • Living inside Judah. Joshua 19:1–9 says Simeon's inheritance lay "in the midst of" Judah's, because Judah's share was too large for it. The towns listed in 1 Chr 4:28–33 (Beersheba, Moladah, Hazar-shual…) mostly reappear among Judah's towns in Joshua 15. In practice Simeon was gradually absorbed into Judah.
  • The Chronicler's audience. Chronicles was written after the exile, probably in the 4th century BC, for a community centred on Judah. Its genealogies set out who belongs to "all Israel" and where. For these readers, the note that Simeon "did not multiply like the sons of Judah" explained why Simeon existed mainly as a remnant within Judah.
  • Children as blessing. In ancient Israel many sons meant labour, security, the survival of the family name and a hold on the land. A note about fertility in a genealogy is a note about blessing and survival, not mere statistics.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 4:27.

Where scholars differ

in v27

Whose clan is meant by 'all their clan'?

  • The tribe of Simeon as a whole

    The section is Simeon's genealogy (v. 24), and the comparison with Judah, a whole tribe, implies a tribe-level comparison. This fits Num 26:14 and Josh 19:1–9.

  • Only Shimei's brothers' line (the Mishma branch)

    Grammatically 'their' can point back to 'his brothers' just mentioned, which would make the remark more local.

in v28

Why do Simeon's towns overlap with Judah's?

  • Simeon was absorbed into Judah historically, so the same towns could be counted under either tribe.

    Josh 19:1, 9 (Simeon's share 'within Judah'); Gen 49:7 ('scatter them in Israel'); 1 Chr 4:27, 31 (Simeon small; these towns were theirs 'until David reigned'). After David, Judah's royal administration took over the region.

  • The two lists come from different administrative sources, possibly from the time of the kings, which tribal-geography writers later assigned to different tribes.

    The lists in Josh 15 and 19 and 1 Chr 4 have different numbers, order and spellings. Scholars of historical geography (e.g. Aharoni, Na'aman) connect the Negev town lists with royal Judahite districts.

in v28

Where were Moladah and Hazar-shual?

  • Moladah = Tel Malhata (Tell el-Milh), east of Beersheba, the later Idumean fortress Malatha.

    The names are similar, and Josephus mentions Malatha in Idumea (Antiquities 18.147). Eusebius's Onomasticon places Malatha in the south.

  • Moladah is somewhere else (e.g. Khirbet el-Waten or Khirbet Kuseifeh), and Tel Malhata is another biblical town (often suggested: Baalath-beer or Arad of the Negev).

    The name match is not exact, and there are archaeological and textual problems in matching the lists. Hazar-shual has no firmly agreed site.

in v30

Where was Ziklag?

  • Tel Sera' (Tell esh-Shari'a), in the western Negev

    A long-standing identification, based on its position between Philistine and Judahite territory and on settlement through the Iron Age.

  • Khirbet al-Ra'i, near Kiryat Gat

    Excavators announced it in 2019 after finding a Philistine-period layer followed by an early Iron Age IIA (roughly 10th-century BC) layer, which fits the David story. Others dispute it because the site lies farther north than the Joshua lists seem to require.

  • Tel Halif or other Negev sites

    Proposed from the town's place in the lists, between southern Judah and the Philistine plain.

in v30

Where was Hormah?

  • Tel Masos (Khirbet el-Meshash), east of Beersheba

    A major early Iron Age settlement in the right area, close to Arad as Numbers 21 suggests.

  • Tel Malhata, Tel Ira or Tel Halif

    Each fits the general region near Arad and Beersheba. No inscription confirms any of them.

in v30

Are Bethuel, Bethul, Chesil and the southern Bethel one town?

  • Yes, these are variant forms of one name

    They hold the same position next to Hormah in Joshua 15:30, 19:4, 1 Chronicles 4:30, and the David spoil list in 1 Samuel 30:27–30.

  • Chesil may be a separate town

    Chesil differs from the others by more than one letter, and Judah's and Simeon's lists do not match exactly in other places either.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.