1 Kings Chapter 18 Read as one passage

1 Kings 18:28–29

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

28So they shouted louder and cut themselves with knives and lances, as was their custom, until the blood gushed over them. 29Midday passed, and they kept on raving until the time of the evening sacrifice. But there was no response; no one answered, no one paid attention.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this verse did three things:

  1. It identified the act as forbidden, foreign worship. The verb was the one their own law used for the banned practice of gashing oneself (Deut 14:1). Hearers would recognise Baal-worship doing what Israel was told not to do. They would also know that some Israelites had been doing it too (Hos 7:14).

  2. It mocked through excess. The narrator stacks up loud shouting, swords, spears and blood "poured out" over the worshippers. The more effort the rite shows, the more empty it looks against the silence that follows. Their "custom" (mišpāṭ) runs perfectly and gets no response. The irony is that mišpāṭ is the word Israel used for the ordinances of its own God.

  3. It set up the contrast with Elijah. Baal's prophets give their own blood and frenzy. Elijah repairs Yahweh's altar with twelve stones for the twelve tribes, soaks it with water, prays a short prayer at the hour of the regular offering, and fire falls (vv.30–38). For a people "limping between two opinions" (v.21), the story was meant to settle the question of which god is real, and the answer would be shown by who answers.

From the study of 1 Kings 18:28.

Verse by verse

  1. 28So they shouted louder and cut themselves with knives and lances, as was their custom, until the blood gushed over them.

    So they cried out to Baal at the top of their voices, doing exactly what Elijah had mockingly told them to do ("Call louder! He's a god, isn't he?"). Then they turned their blades on themselves, gashing their own bodies again and again. This was not a moment of panic. It was their prescribed rite, the regular practice of Baal's cult. In the same way, the gods at Ugarit gashed their skin in mourning when Baal died, and Hosea's Israelites cut themselves when pleading for grain and wine. They used swords or knives and war spears. They kept it up until blood was poured out over them, streaming down their bodies the way sacrificial blood is poured at the foot of an altar. But this blood was their own and ran over their own skin, and no fire came. The narrator piles up the noise, the effort and the blood so that the next line can land: "there was no voice, no one answering, no one paying attention" (v.29).

    Full study →
  2. 29Midday passed, and they kept on raving until the time of the evening sacrifice. But there was no response; no one answered, no one paid attention.

    Noon came and went: the hour of brightest sun, the hour when Elijah had mocked them that their god must be asleep or away. Baal's prophets kept going all through the afternoon. They were in a state of prophetic frenzy, shouting, cutting themselves and throwing themselves into ecstatic trance. That was the recognised way to break through to a god. They kept at it until the hour everyone in Israel knew by heart, the time when the regular afternoon offering went up in smoke from the LORD's altar.

    And then the verdict, in three flat blows: no sound (not even a rumble of thunder from the god whose "voice" was supposed to be the thunder), no one answering (and "the god who answers" was the agreed test of who is God), no one even listening. The last phrase uses the words that describe a dead child elsewhere ("no voice, no attention", 2 Kings 4:31). After a whole day of noise from the worshippers, the silence from the other side is complete. And it is at exactly this hour, the hour of Israel's own offering, that Elijah steps forward.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v28

    lancets (KJV)

    rəmāḥîm

    What we hear
    Small, fine surgical blades used for pricking or bloodletting.
    What they heard
    Spears or lances: thrusting weapons of war, like the one Phinehas used in Num 25:7.
  • in v28

    cut themselves

    wayyitgōdədû

    What we hear
    Private self-injury, usually driven by personal distress.
    What they heard
    A public, recognised religious rite of gashing the body, used in mourning and in desperate pleading with a god, done by a group as their set practice.
  • in v29

    prophesied (KJV, WEB)

    hitnabbe' (vayyitnabbe'u)

    What we hear
    Predicting the future, or delivering a spoken message from God.
    What they heard
    Acting in a prophetic frenzy: ecstatic, trance-like, physically wild behaviour (here alongside shouting and self-cutting), not necessarily speaking any message.
  • in v29

    evening sacrifice

    minchah

    What we hear
    A sacrifice at dusk or after sunset, so that the prophets carried on into the night.
    What they heard
    The regular afternoon offering, made 'between the evenings'. By later Jewish reckoning this was around mid-afternoon (about the ninth hour), which still leaves daylight for Elijah's altar-building and the events after it. The Hebrew does not say 'evening' at all. It says 'the minchah'.
Every word
  1. וַֽיִּקְרְאוּ֙

    wayyiqrəʾû · H7121

    and they called out · v28

    The key verb of the whole Carmel contest: in v.24 each side is to "call on the name" of its god. Here it means crying out to Baal for an answer. The verb form moves the story along: they did this next.

  2. בְּק֣וֹל

    bəqôl · H6963

    with a voice · v28, v29

    "With a voice": the sound of their shouting. In v.29 the same word comes back in "there was no voice": their voice gets no answering voice.

  3. גָּד֔וֹל

    gādôl · H1419

    great, loud · v28

    "With a great voice" means loudly. These are the exact words of Elijah's mocking order in v.27 ("call with a great voice"), so the prophets end up doing just what he jeered at them to do.

  4. וַיִּתְגֹּֽדְדוּ֙

    wayyitgōdədû · H1413

    and they gashed themselves · v28

    This verb form means doing something to oneself, here gashing or slashing one's own skin. Elsewhere it names a known rite of mourning and petition, the one Deuteronomy 14:1 forbids Israel. Its g-d sounds echo gādôl ("great") just before it.

  5. כְּמִשְׁפָּטָ֔ם

    kəmišpāṭām · H4941

    according to their custom · v28

    "According to their mishpat": their set practice or prescribed rite. This was not a spur-of-the-moment frenzy but standard procedure for their cult. The word usually means justice or the rulings of Israel's God, so applying it to Baal's rite is quietly ironic.

  6. בַּחֲרָב֖וֹת

    baḥărābôt · H2719

    with the swords / knives · v28

    Ḥereb is the ordinary word for a sword but covers any blade, including knives (Josh 5:2, flint knives for circumcision). The "the" may point to the blades they used for this rite.

  7. וּבָֽרְמָחִ֑ים

    ûbārəmāḥîm · H7420

    and with the spears · v28

    Rōmaḥ is a thrusting spear or lance, a weapon of war (Num 25:7; Judg 5:8). It is a weapon, not a small medical blade, which adds to the violence of the scene.

  8. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    until · v28, v29

    Marks how far the cutting went: they kept going until the result described next.

  9. שְׁפָךְ־

    šəpāk · H8210

    pouring out · v28

    A verb used as a noun: "a pouring out." The same verb is used for shedding blood in killing (Gen 9:6) and for pouring sacrificial blood at the altar (Lev 4:7). Here the blood is their own.

  10. דָּ֖ם

    dām · H1818

    blood · v28

    Blood, which in Israel's thinking carried life (Lev 17:11). They are spending their own life-force to get their god's attention.

  11. עֲלֵיהֶֽם׃

    ʿălêhem · H5921

    upon them · v28

    The blood ran down over their own bodies, not onto an altar: an image of bodies streaming with blood and no fire from heaven.

  12. וַֽיְהִי֙

    vayhi · H1961

    and it was / and it came to pass · v29

    The usual Hebrew storytelling opener that moves the plot forward. Here it sets up a new stage of the contest: time keeps running and nothing happens.

  13. כַּעֲבֹ֣ר

    ka'avor · H5674A

    when (it) passed · v29

    'As/when the passing of', meaning once noon had gone by. The prophets had already called from morning until noon (v. 26), so this marks the afternoon session.

  14. הַֽצָּהֳרַ֔יִם

    hatsohorayim · H6672A

    noon, midday · v29

    The hottest, brightest point of the day. The word has a dual ending ('-ayim', the form for pairs), perhaps 'double light' or the peak between morning and afternoon. Noon is when Elijah mocked them (v. 27), and now even that point has passed.

  15. וַיִּֽתְנַבְּא֔וּ

    vayyitnabbe'u · H5012

    and they prophesied / raved / acted as prophets · v29

    The reflexive-intensive form of the verb 'to prophesy', used for frenzied behaviour that looks like prophecy: shouting, dancing, being 'beside oneself'. It does not mean predicting or preaching here. It means they worked themselves into an ecstatic frenzy, continuing the shouting and self-cutting of v. 28.

  16. לַעֲל֣וֹת

    la'alot · H5927I

    to go up / to offer up · v29

    'The going up' or 'the offering up' of the offering. Sacrifices 'go up' because the smoke rises from the altar. The phrase works as a clock time: the hour when the regular afternoon offering was made.

  17. הַמִּנְחָ֑ה

    haminchah · H4503G

    the offering, the gift (grain offering) · v29

    'The minchah', the regular afternoon offering that went with the daily lamb (Exod 29:38–41). Calling it 'the' offering assumes every hearer knew which one and what time it was, in the way we would say 'teatime'.

  18. וְאֵֽין־

    ve'ein · H0369

    and there was not · v29

    The first of three blunt 'there was none' statements. The word means flat nonexistence: not 'a faint sound' but nothing at all.

  19. עֹנֶ֖ה

    'oneh · H6030B

    one answering · v29

    'An answerer'. This is the key word of the whole contest: 'the god who answers by fire, he is God' (v. 24). The prophets cried 'Baal, answer us!' (v. 26), and there is no answerer.

  20. קָֽשֶׁב׃

    qashev · H7182

    attentiveness, attention, heeding · v29

    An uncommon word for paying attention, as when someone pricks up their ears. Not only did no answer come; nobody was even listening. The same pairing 'no voice, no attention' describes a dead child in 2 Kings 4:31, and the picture here is close to that.

The world behind it

The contest. In the 9th century BC, under King Ahab and his Phoenician queen Jezebel (daughter of the king of Sidon, 1 Kgs 16:31), the worship of Baal was promoted at the royal court in Israel. After a three-year drought (17:1; 18:1), Elijah challenged 450 prophets of Baal on Mount Carmel, a ridge on the border between Israelite and Phoenician territory. Each side would prepare a bull and "call on the name" of its god, and "the god who answers by fire, he is God" (18:24).

Why it mattered who answered. Baal was the storm god, "Rider of the Clouds" in the texts from Ugarit, who sends rain, lightning and fertility. A drought was therefore a direct embarrassment to him, and fire from heaven (lightning) was his own speciality. The contest was set up on Baal's home ground.

Ritual cutting in the region. Gashing one's body was a known religious act in the ancient Near East:

  • In the Ugaritic Baal myths (around the 14th–13th centuries BC), when Baal dies, El and Anat mourn by cutting their cheeks and chin and "ploughing" their chests and arms. In the cycle of the seasons, Baal's death matched the dry season, so mourning him belonged to the hope of his return with the rains.
  • Israel's law forbade gashing oneself "for the dead" (Deut 14:1; compare Lev 19:28; 21:5). Jeremiah and Hosea show that people kept doing it anyway (Jer 16:6; 41:5; Hos 7:14 in many manuscripts and the Septuagint).
  • Much later, Greek and Roman writers describe the devotees of the Syrian Goddess cutting their arms with blades in ecstatic processions (Lucian; Apuleius). Herodotus (2.61) mentions Carians in Egypt cutting their foreheads with knives at a festival.

Time of day. The cutting comes after noon (v.27), when the sun was at its peak and Baal was being mocked as asleep or away. It continues "until the offering of the minḥâ" (v.29), the late-afternoon offering. The day is being measured by Israel's temple timetable while Baal's prophets exhaust their rite.

From the study of 1 Kings 18:28.

Where scholars differ

in v28

What was the purpose of the self-gashing in Baal worship?

  • A mourning rite: Baal was treated as dead or absent in the dry season, and his worshippers mourned him to bring about his return.

    At Ugarit, El and Anat gash themselves when Baal dies (KTU 1.5 VI; 1.6 I). In the Bible the verb is used for mourning the dead (Deut 14:1; Jer 16:6; 41:5). The setting is a drought, and Elijah jokes that Baal may be asleep or away (v.27).

  • A blood offering: life-blood given to move or compel the god, or to strengthen him.

    The verse uses "pouring out blood," the phrase for altar blood (Lev 4:7), and blood carries life (Lev 17:11). Their offering had gone unanswered, so they escalate to their own blood.

  • A way of reaching an ecstatic, prophetic frenzy.

    The next verse says they "prophesied" or "raved" (wayyitnabbəʾû, v.29) until evening. Later accounts of the Syrian Goddess's priests combine frenzied dancing with self-cutting (Lucian, De Dea Syria 50; Apuleius, Met. 8.27–28).

  • A plea for pity, showing the god how much his worshippers were suffering.

    In Hos 7:14 (in many manuscripts) people gash themselves while crying for grain and wine, and the act sits alongside shouting and wailing as a show of extreme need. These explanations can overlap, and the text does not choose between them.

in v29

What exactly does 'they prophesied' (hitnabbe') describe here?

  • Ecstatic frenzy: trance-like, physically wild behaviour, continuous with the dancing and self-cutting of vv. 26–28.

    The same verb form describes Saul's ecstatic states (1 Sam 10:10–13; 19:23–24) and his 'raving' (1 Sam 18:10). The context is a single escalating ritual. Ancient Near Eastern parallels include the Mari ecstatics and the Wenamun frenzy at Byblos. This is the majority view and underlies 'raved' in most modern versions.

  • Performing the role of prophets: carrying out set oracle-seeking rites, with possible chanting or speaking in the god's name, not necessarily mere frenzy.

    The verb is built on navi', 'prophet', and these men are called 'prophets of Baal'. Ancient prophets in neighbouring cultures did deliver oracles. The hitpael can simply mean 'act as a prophet' (1 Kgs 22:8 uses it of Micaiah's true prophesying).

  • Feigning or pretending to be prophets.

    YLT reads the reflexive form as 'make oneself out to be'. The verb is not used this way elsewhere, so this mostly reflects the narrator's negative view, not the grammar.

in v29

Why does a story set in the northern kingdom tell time by 'the minchah'?

  • It reflects the Judean narrator's standpoint and the Jerusalem temple's daily offerings, which hearers would recognise as a fixed hour.

    Kings was edited from a Judean, Jerusalem-centred perspective. 2 Kgs 16:15 uses 'the evening minchah' of the Jerusalem temple.

  • The daily offering times were older and wider-spread than Jerusalem, a common Israelite way of marking the day, and Elijah's offering at that hour deliberately ties his act to lawful LORD-worship.

    v. 36 repeats the phrase at the moment Elijah offers. 2 Kgs 3:20 (a northern setting) uses the morning minchah as a time marker. Elijah restores an existing altar of the LORD on Carmel (v. 30).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. גָּדַד
  • HALOT s.v. גדד II (hitpael)
  • HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּט
  • HALOT s.v. רֹמַח
  • KTU 1.5 VI 11–22; 1.6 I 2–5 (Ugaritic Baal Cycle)
  • Lucian, De Dea Syria 50
  • Apuleius, Metamorphoses 8.27–28
  • Herodotus, Histories 2.61
  • Mordechai Cogan, 1 Kings (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Kings 18
  • Septuagint, 3 Kingdoms 18:28
  • Vulgate, 3 Regum 18:28
  • Deut 14:1; Lev 19:28; 21:5; Jer 16:6; 41:5; 47:5; 48:37; Hos 7:14
  • BDB s.v. נָבָא (Hithpael)
  • HALOT s.v. נבא, מִנְחָה, קֶשֶׁב
  • BDB s.v. מִנְחָה
  • BDB s.v. קוֹל
  • KTU 1.4 VII 29–35 (Ugaritic Baal Cycle, Baal's 'holy voice')
  • KTU 1.5 VI (El's mourning rites for Baal)
  • Mari prophetic texts (muhhûm), as surveyed in M. Nissinen, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East
  • Tale of Wenamun (ecstatic at Byblos)
  • Mishnah Pesachim 5:1 (hour of the afternoon daily offering)
  • Septuagint, 3 Kingdoms 18:26–29
  • Mordechai Cogan, 1 Kings (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • John H. Walton et al., IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Kgs 18

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).