1 Samuel Chapter 19 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 19:23–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23So Saul went to Naioth in Ramah. But the Spirit of God came upon even Saul, and he walked along prophesying until he came to Naioth in Ramah. 24Then Saul stripped off his robes and also prophesied before Samuel. And he collapsed and lay naked all that day and night. That is why it is said, “Is Saul also among the prophets?”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this was both a dramatic and a comic scene, with a clear point: no human power, not even the king's, can override God's protection of the one he has chosen. Saul's arresting parties fail three times, and when the king steps in himself the result is worse. The same spirit that once confirmed him as king (ch. 10) now turns him into a helpless spectacle before Samuel.

Several things would have landed:

  • Prophet over king. Naioth was Samuel's ground. The scene confirms the order the book has been building: the prophet who anointed and rejected Saul still has the upper hand, and God's power works through the prophetic community.
  • David's legitimacy. This section of Samuel defends David's rise to the throne, showing that he did not grab power and that God himself kept him safe from Saul. Here God shields David without David lifting a hand.
  • A proverb explained. The episode accounts for (or comments on) a saying everyone knew, 'Is Saul also among the prophets?' (v. 24; compare 10:11–12). Told here, the saying has a bitter, mocking edge: Saul 'among the prophets' means Saul overcome, stripped and lying on the ground.
  • Spirit as power, not reward. Hearers would not have taken the spirit's coming as a sign that God approved of Saul or that he had been restored. In their world, divine possession could build up or tear down, and here it disables.

From the study of 1 Samuel 19:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 23So Saul went to Naioth in Ramah. But the Spirit of God came upon even Saul, and he walked along prophesying until he came to Naioth in Ramah.

    Saul set out for the prophets' compound at Ramah, Samuel's home ground, where David had taken refuge. But before he got there, God's spirit, the same power that had already stopped three squads of his men, came over him too, the king himself. From then on he was no longer marching to make an arrest. He walked on and on, all the way to the dwellings at Ramah, acting like a man possessed by God, swept into the visible, uncontrolled behaviour of the prophetic band. That behaviour is not preaching or predicting, and no words are reported. The verse opens and closes with the same place name, 'Naioth in Ramah', so the whole road to David is framed as ground under God's control. The man who came to seize David arrives seized himself, and the next verse shows how far it goes: stripped of his royal garments and lying helpless before Samuel through a day and a night.

    Full study →
  2. 24Then Saul stripped off his robes and also prophesied before Samuel. And he collapsed and lay naked all that day and night. That is why it is said, “Is Saul also among the prophets?”

    Saul came to Ramah to drag David away from Samuel's protection. Instead, he too, like the three squads of men he had sent ahead, was seized. He pulled off his clothes, the garments that marked who he was. He too was thrown into the same overpowering prophetic frenzy as the band of prophets, and it happened right in front of Samuel, the man who had once anointed him and later told him God had rejected him. Then he fell: he did not choose to lie down, he collapsed. He stayed there stripped and exposed (fully naked, or at least down to his undergarment) for the whole of that day and the whole night that followed. Meanwhile David slipped away.

    The narrator adds that this is why people still ask, half in amazement and half in mockery, "Is even Saul among the prophets?" It is the kind of thing you say when someone turns up in company they don't belong in. Earlier the same saying had greeted the young Saul when God's Spirit first came on him as a sign that he would be king (10:11–12). Now it greets a king lying flat and stripped. The Spirit does not commission him here. It stops him.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    prophesied / prophesying

    wayyitnabbēʾ (Hitpael of nbʾ)

    What we hear
    Predicting future events, or speaking an inspired message or sermon from God.
    What they heard
    Showing the outward signs of being overtaken by divine power: ecstatic, uncontrolled behaviour recognised as 'prophet-like'. No message is reported here, and in v. 24 it ends in Saul stripping and collapsing.
  • in v23

    the Spirit of God came upon him

    wattəhî ʿālāyw … rûaḥ ʾĕlōhîm

    What we hear
    The Holy Spirit as a divine Person filling a believer, a sign of God's favour, salvation, or spiritual renewal.
    What they heard
    God's invisible power coming over a person from outside for a moment, here to overpower and stop a hostile king. It says nothing about his standing with God, which the narrative has already settled against him (15:26–28; 16:14).
  • in v24

    prophesied

    hitnabbe'

    What we hear
    Predicted the future or spoke an inspired message from God.
    What they heard
    Behaved as a prophet: was seized by an overpowering, ecstatic state like the prophetic band's. No message is reported.
  • in v24

    the prophets

    nevi'im

    What we hear
    Great named prophets like Isaiah, Jeremiah or Elijah.
    What they heard
    The communal band of ecstatic prophets around Samuel at Ramah, a recognisable and somewhat marginal group.
  • in v24

    lay down naked

    vayyippol 'arom

    What we hear
    He calmly lay down, completely nude.
    What they heard
    He fell, i.e. collapsed, and lay exposed. 'Arom can mean fully nude or stripped to the undergarment, and either way it means public shame.
Every word
  1. וַיֵּ֣לֶךְ

    wayyēlek · H1980G

    and he went · v23

    The usual verb for moving the story along. Saul is the subject, carried over from v. 22: after three failed squads of messengers, the king goes himself.

  2. שָׁ֔ם

    shām · H8033G

    there · v23

    'There', pointing ahead to Naioth. The Greek translation seems to have read 'from there' (from Secu), which would make this a note of departure rather than of destination.

  3. אֶל־

    ʾel- · H0413

    to, toward · v23

    Marks where he was heading. It does not say he arrived; the end of the verse shows he did not reach the place in his own control.

  4. נָי֖וֹת

    Nāyôt · H5121

    Naioth · v23

    The spot inside Ramah where Samuel and his band of prophets lived and where David had taken refuge (v. 18). The name probably means something like 'dwellings' or 'encampment', not a separate town.

  5. בָּרָמָ֑ה

    bā-Rāmāh · H7414J

    in Ramah · v23

    Samuel's home town (1 Sam 7:17). The name means 'the height' and takes the article, 'the Ramah'. It is the prophet's home ground, where the king has no authority.

  6. וַתְּהִי֩

    wattəhî · H1961

    and it was / came to be · v23

    'And there came to be': feminine to agree with rûaḥ 'spirit', which is grammatically feminine. Unlike 10:10, where the spirit 'rushed' on Saul, the verb here is plain: the spirit simply was on him, and Saul had no say.

  7. עָלָ֨יו

    ʿālāyw · H5921A

    upon him · v23, v24

    'Upon him'. The spirit comes over a person from outside and takes hold of him. It is not pictured as an inner state he grows into.

  8. גַּם־

    gam- · H1571

    also, even · v23, v24

    'Also / even'. It sets Saul in line with the three groups of messengers who had already been overcome (vv. 20–21). The word recurs twice in v. 24 and in the proverb 'Is Saul *also* among the prophets?'

  9. ה֜וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he · v23, v24

    An extra 'he', added for emphasis: 'him too', 'the king himself'. The man who sent the arresting party ends up under the same force.

  10. ר֣וּחַ

    rûaḥ · H7307G

    spirit, wind, breath · v23

    God's active, invisible power, imagined like a wind that sweeps over and moves a person. Here it takes over Saul and stops him.

  11. אֱלֹהִ֗ים

    ʾĕlōhîm · H0430G

    God · v23

    'Spirit of God' rather than 'spirit of the LORD (YHWH)'. The same general divine title appears in 18:10, where a 'harmful spirit of God' made Saul rave, so the source is God but the phrase is less personal.

  12. וַיִּתְנַבֵּ֔א

    wayyitnabbēʾ · H5012

    and he prophesied / behaved as a prophet · v23, v24

    Reflexive-intensive form: 'acted the prophet', showing the visible, often ecstatic signs of being possessed by God. No words or predictions are reported. This is behaviour, not a message.

  13. עַד־

    ʿad- · H5704

    until · v23

    Marks how long the state lasted: the whole distance to Samuel's compound.

  14. בֹּא֖וֹ

    bōʾô · H0935G

    his coming · v23

    'His arriving' (a verb used as a noun, with 'his'). He does arrive, but as someone overcome, not as the king coming to seize David.

  15. וַיִּפְשַׁט

    vayyifshat · H6584

    to strip off, take off · v24

    Saul pulls off his own clothing. The verb is used of removing garments (and of stripping a defeated enemy or a sacrificial animal), so it suggests a sudden, undignified shedding of what marked his status.

  16. בְּגָדָיו

    begadav · H899

    garment, clothing · v24

    "His garments": the ordinary word for clothes, especially outer clothing. In a story where Saul's robe keeps showing up (torn in 15:27, cut in 24:4), stripping his garments carries a symbolic charge.

  17. לִפְנֵי

    lifnei · H6440

    before, in the presence of · v24

    Literally "to the face of". It all happens in front of Samuel, the prophet who anointed Saul and later announced his rejection, which makes the humiliation more pointed.

  18. שְׁמוּאֵל

    Shemu'el · H8050

    Samuel · v24

    The prophet who stands over the prophetic band at Ramah (v. 20) and who is sheltering David.

  19. וַיִּפֹּל

    vayyippol · H5307

    to fall · v24

    "And he fell": he collapsed, not a deliberate lying down. The image is a man knocked flat and unable to get up.

  20. עָרֹם

    'arom · H6174

    naked, bare · v24

    Naked. In Hebrew usage this can mean fully nude or stripped of the outer garment, down to the undergarment. Either way it means exposure and loss of dignity, which is shocking for a king.

  21. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, whole · v24

    "All (that day)": the whole length of time, not a passing moment.

  22. הַיּוֹם

    hayyom · H3117

    day · v24

    "The day": the daylight hours during which Saul lay helpless.

  23. הַלָּיְלָה

    hallaylah · H3915

    night · v24

    "The night": with "all the day" it marks a full day-and-night of helplessness.

  24. כֵּן

    ken · H3651

    so, thus · v24

    With 'al, "that is why". This is the narrator's formula for explaining where a saying or name came from.

  25. יֹאמְרוּ

    yom'ru · H559

    to say · v24

    "They say" or "people keep saying". The verb form describes ongoing, habitual speech, so the proverb was still in use when the story was written down.

  26. שָׁאוּל

    Sha'ul · H7586

    Saul · v24

    The king, son of Kish, a man of standing from a wealthy Benjaminite family. That background is what makes his place among the prophets surprising.

  27. בַּנְּבִיאִם

    bannevi'im · H5030

    prophets · v24

    "Among the prophets": the band of ecstatic prophets gathered around Samuel at Ramah, a recognisable and somewhat marginal group, not the later literary prophets like Isaiah.

The world behind it

The manhunt. Chapter 19 is a series of escapes. Jonathan talks Saul down (vv. 1–7). Saul's spear misses David (vv. 9–10). Michal lets David out through a window (vv. 11–17). David then flees to Samuel at Ramah and stays with him at Naioth (v. 18). Saul sends messengers three times to take him. Each time they see 'the company of prophets prophesying, with Samuel standing as head over them', the spirit of God comes on them, and they 'prophesy' too (vv. 20–21). Finally Saul goes himself, by way of 'the great cistern at Secu' (v. 22), a site that has not been identified.

Prophetic bands. Early Israel had groups of prophets living and acting together: a 'band' (ḥebel, 10:5) or 'company' (lahăqâ, 19:20) linked to shrines and led by a senior figure like Samuel. They used music (10:5) and fell into states of possession that onlookers recognised and that could spread to others. Similar figures are known elsewhere in the ancient Near East. At Mari (18th century BC) there were ecstatics (muḫḫûm). In the Egyptian Report of Wenamun (c. 1100 BC), a god seizes a young man at Byblos and he delivers an oracle in a frenzy.

Saul's history with the spirit. At his anointing, God's spirit 'rushed' on Saul and he prophesied with a band of prophets, as a sign confirming his kingship (10:6–13). After his rejection the spirit of the LORD left him and a 'harmful spirit' tormented him (16:14). In 18:10 he 'prophesied' (raved) while trying to kill David. So by ch. 19 the reader already knows that 'prophesying' on Saul's lips can mean collapse as much as calling.

Clothing and honour. In v. 24 Saul strips off his garments (in this book, royal clothing stands for royal identity; compare 15:27–28; 18:4; 24:4–5) and lies 'naked', probably meaning stripped to his undergarment. For a king this is a deep public shame, and it happens in front of the prophet who anointed him and then rejected him.

From the study of 1 Samuel 19:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

Is the 'spirit of God' here a good, empowering spirit or the same harmful force that tormented Saul?

  • It is God's spirit acting in its normal prophetic way, the same one that came on the messengers and had once confirmed Saul (ch. 10). The point is simply that it overrules a human king.

    The same phrase and the same effect on the messengers (vv. 20–21), with no word 'harmful' attached, unlike 16:14–16, 18:10 and 19:9.

  • For Saul in particular it works as a disabling, shaming force, in line with the 'harmful spirit' episodes. Its effect on him is judgment rather than empowerment.

    18:10 uses *rûaḥ ʾĕlōhîm* with 'prophesied' for Saul's violent raving. In v. 24 the episode ends with Saul stripped and lying helpless. His status has already been forfeited (16:14).

  • The narrator deliberately leaves it ambiguous. The same spirit raises up and tears down depending on its purpose.

    The plain verb ('there came to be') and the general title 'God' rather than 'the LORD' set this scene against the empowering 'rushed' of 10:6, 10.

in v23

How does this scene relate to the other explanation of 'Is Saul also among the prophets?' in 10:10–12?

  • Two separate traditions explaining the same proverb have been kept side by side, one favourable (ch. 10) and one unfavourable (ch. 19).

    Both passages end with the same saying, 'therefore it became a proverb' (10:12) / 'therefore they say' (19:24).

  • The narrator intends the repetition as a deliberate reversal. The sign that once marked Saul's rise now marks his fall.

    Parallel elements: a band of prophets, the spirit of God, Saul prophesying, the proverb. The outcome, though, flips from confirmation of kingship to public humiliation.

in v23

What exactly was Naioth?

  • A compound or set of 'dwellings' within Ramah where Samuel's prophetic community lived.

    The likely link to *nāweh*, 'abode, pasture', and the phrase 'Naioth *in* Ramah'.

  • A school or centre of instruction for prophets.

    The Targum's 'house of instruction', and Samuel's presiding role in v. 20. Critics note this may read later institutions back into the text.

in v24

Why does the proverb "Is Saul also among the prophets?" get two different origin stories (10:11–12 and 19:24)?

  • Two separate traditions about the saying's origin were preserved side by side by the editor of Samuel.

    The scenes differ in setting and tone (Gibeah or the hill of God in ch. 10, Ramah in ch. 19). Doublets elsewhere in Samuel (e.g. two accounts of David entering Saul's service, 16:14–23 and 17:55–58) suggest the editor combined sources (McCarter, Klein).

  • The two scenes are a deliberate pair: the proverb arose in ch. 10 and was renewed and given a bitter twist in ch. 19.

    The almost identical wording and the reversal (Spirit as sign of kingship, then Spirit as restraint on a rejected king) read as intentional literary design, framing Saul's reign (Alter, Tsumura).

in v24

What tone does the proverb carry: admiration, surprise, or contempt?

  • Surprised wonder that a man of Saul's standing should join the prophetic band.

    In 10:11–12 bystanders are astonished at "the son of Kish" among the prophets, and the saying looks like a general expression for someone unexpectedly in unlikely company.

  • Derision, both of Saul and of the ecstatic prophets.

    "Who is their father?" (10:12) suggests the bands had low or uncertain status, and the humiliation in 19:24 makes the proverb sound like a taunt (Wilson, Prophecy and Society).

in v24

Was Saul fully nude?

  • Fully naked.

    'Arom normally means naked (Gen 2:25; Job 1:21), and ecstatic behaviour could include total stripping. The point is extreme loss of dignity.

  • Stripped of his outer garments, down to his undergarment.

    'Arom is used of people without their outer cloak (Isa 20:2–4; Job 22:6; 24:7), and the verb "stripped off his garments" fits removing outer clothes. Several commentators prefer this sense.

in v24

How does this fit 15:35, "Samuel did not see Saul again until the day of his death"?

  • It reflects a different source or tradition that the editor left unharmonised.

    The tension is real, and the Septuagint's reported "before them" may show early unease with it.

  • There is no real contradiction: 15:35 means Samuel never again went to see Saul or received him as king, while here Saul came uninvited and was overcome in Samuel's presence.

    "See" can mean visiting or meeting with someone on purpose. Saul's ecstatic state is not a meeting, and Samuel takes no action toward him (Tsumura, Bergen).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נָבָא, רוּחַ, נָיוֹת
  • HALOT s.v. נבא (hitp.), רוּחַ, נָיוֹת
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., *I Samuel* (Anchor Bible 8), notes on 19:18–24
  • Ralph W. Klein, *1 Samuel* (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • Robert Alter, *The David Story*
  • Robert R. Wilson, 'Prophecy and Ecstasy: A Reexamination', *Journal of Biblical Literature* 98 (1979)
  • Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, *IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament*, on 1 Sam 10 and 19
  • Report of Wenamun (Egyptian, c. 1100 BC), Byblos ecstatic episode
  • Mari prophetic texts (muḫḫûm), in M. Nissinen, *Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East*
  • Targum Jonathan to 1 Samuel 19:18–23
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Reigns 19:23
  • BDB s.v. נָבָא (Hithpael), עָרוֹם, בֶּגֶד, נָפַל
  • HALOT s.v. נבא hitp., עָרוֹם
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • Robert R. Wilson, Prophecy and Society in Ancient Israel
  • Robert D. Bergen, 1, 2 Samuel (New American Commentary)
  • Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (on 1 Sam 10 and 19, ecstatic prophecy)
  • Mari prophetic letters (muḫḫûm ecstatics); Tale of Wenamun (Byblos ecstatic)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).