1 Samuel Chapter 24 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 24:4–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4So David’s men said to him, “This is the day about which the LORD said to you, ‘Behold, I will deliver your enemy into your hand, that you may do with him as you wish.’” Then David crept up and stealthily cut off a corner of Saul’s robe. 5Afterward, David’s conscience was stricken because he had cut off the corner of Saul’s robe.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this scene answered a pressing question: how did David become king while Saul's house fell, and did David seize the throne by violence? The narrator shows David with Saul completely helpless in front of him, his own men quoting God's word as permission, and David not killing him.
The verse also teaches discernment. The men read an opportunity as a divine command: 'This is the day Yahweh spoke of.' Only days earlier in the story, Saul had said the same kind of thing about David ('God has handed him over to me', 23:7) and was wrong. Ancient hearers would notice that an enemy being 'in your hand' does not by itself tell you what Yahweh wants done.
The robe-cutting works on two levels. It is a compromise: David acts, but does not kill. It is also a sign: the future king now holds a piece of the royal robe, recalling Samuel's words that the kingdom had been torn from Saul. Yet the next verse says David's 'heart struck him'. Even this symbolic act against the anointed king felt to him like a violation. The scene presents David as someone who will receive the kingdom from Yahweh and not grab it, and in doing so it defends his dynasty.
From the study of 1 Samuel 24:4.
Verse by verse
-
4So David’s men said to him, “This is the day about which the LORD said to you, ‘Behold, I will deliver your enemy into your hand, that you may do with him as you wish.’” Then David crept up and stealthily cut off a corner of Saul’s robe.
Full study →David's men, crouched with him in the dark back of the cave, whisper urgently: "Look! This is the day! This is what Yahweh told you: 'Look, I myself am handing your enemy over into your power, and you will do to him whatever seems good to you.'" They speak of Saul only as your enemy, not as the king or the LORD's anointed. They take a familiar battle promise, God 'giving' an enemy 'into your hand', and treat it as a divine command for this moment. The words 'whatever seems good to you' are left open, but everyone knows what the men mean: kill him.
David rose, and for a moment the hearer expects a killing. The word for 'stealthily' is the one used for Jael creeping up on Sisera. But he cut off the wing of Saul's robe, the corner or hem of the king's long outer cloak, and nothing else. The verb is 'cut off', the same verb used for cutting off a man or his family line. The men wanted David to cut off Saul. He cut off a piece of fabric. Even this small act carried weight, because a robe's hem stood for its owner's identity and authority. This robe in particular recalls the one Saul once tore from Samuel when he heard that the kingdom had been torn from him and given to someone better. David now holds a piece of the king's robe, and the very next verse says his heart struck him for it.
-
5Afterward, David’s conscience was stricken because he had cut off the corner of Saul’s robe.
Full study →Some time after this (and the story reads it as right afterward), David's own heart struck him. The verb is the one used for blows in battle. His men had urged him to strike his enemy, and he had not struck Saul. Now the blow landed on David himself. The "heart" here is the whole inner person who thinks, chooses and judges right from wrong, not just feelings. David's judgment turned on what his hands had just done.
The reason was that he had cut off the kanaf of Saul's robe: its hem or corner, the edge of the king's garment of rank. To an Israelite a hem was not a scrap of cloth. It could stand for the wearer's identity and authority. Years earlier, when Saul tore the hem of Samuel's robe, Samuel had answered that the LORD had torn the kingdom from Saul and given it to someone better. Now David holds a piece of the king's robe. The verse ends on the owner's name: the hem belonged to Saul. It was the reigning king's, the man David is about to call "the LORD's anointed."
So the cut was a symbolic grab at Saul's person and office, a step toward the killing his men wanted. David's heart judged it so before he spoke a word.
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
skirt (KJV, WEB)
kanaf
- What we hear
- A woman's garment hanging from the waist.
- What they heard
- The corner, hem or 'wing' of a garment, the part that stood for the wearer's identity and authority.
-
in v4
robe
me'il
- What we hear
- A loose garment for lounging, such as a bathrobe or dressing gown.
- What they heard
- A long outer cloak worn by people of rank or sacred office (priests, prophets, princes). In 1 Samuel it is a recurring symbol of who holds the kingdom.
-
in v5
skirt (KJV, WEB, YLT)
kanaf
- What we hear
- A woman's garment hanging from the waist, which makes the verse sound odd or comic.
- What they heard
- The hem, edge or corner of a man's outer robe, here the king's robe of rank.
-
in v5
heart (KJV, ESV, WEB)
lev
- What we hear
- Emotions, so "his heart smote him" is heard as a pang of sadness or sentiment.
- What they heard
- The inner person as thinker, decision-maker and moral judge. Here David's own judgment turns against what he has done.
-
in v5
conscience bothered him (NASB, NLT)
vayyakh lev
- What we hear
- Mild unease or a nagging feeling of guilt.
- What they heard
- "His heart struck him": a blow, using the verb for striking in battle. It mirrors the strike against Saul that David refused to make. "Conscience" is a fair label for what is happening, but "bothered" turns a blow into discomfort.
-
in v5
the corner of Saul's robe
kanaf asher le-Sha'ul
- What we hear
- A trivial scrap of cloth, so David's remorse looks oversensitive.
- What they heard
- The hem of the king's garment of rank. Readers of 1 Samuel had already seen a torn hem stand for the kingdom being torn from Saul (15:27–28). The cut was a symbolic act against the king himself.
Every word
-
וַיֹּאמְרוּ
vayyomru · H0559
and they said · v4
The usual verb that carries a story forward. Here it brings in the men's eager whisper in the dark cave.
-
אַנְשֵׁי
anshei · H0582
men of · v4
David's band of fighters, the debtors, malcontents and outlaws who had gathered round him (22:2). Their view of what 'God's day' means is the view of men who have been hunted for months.
-
דָוִד
David · H1732
David · v4, v5
The anointed but not yet ruling future king, at this point a fugitive hiding in the back of the cave.
-
אֵלָיו
elav · H0413
to him · v4
Spoken to David alone, presumably in a whisper, since Saul is only a few metres away.
-
הִנֵּה
hinneh · H2009
look! / here! · v4
An excited 'Look!' that points at the moment in front of them: this is it.
-
הַיּוֹם
hayyom · H3117
the day · v4
'The day' as a moment set aside for something, here the moment of deliverance and victory over an enemy. The men treat it as a day God appointed.
-
אֲשֶׁר־
asher · H0834
which / about which · v4, v5
Ties the present moment to a word God supposedly spoke before: 'the day about which Yahweh said'.
-
יְהוָה
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh (the LORD) · v4
Israel's God, called by his personal name. The men invoke his authority for the killing they are urging.
-
אָנֹכִי
anokhi · H0595
I · v4
An emphatic 'I myself', the voice of God in the quoted promise.
-
נֹתֵן
noten · H5414
giving / about to give · v4
A participle (a verb form that describes something under way or just about to happen): 'I am giving' or 'I am about to give'. Joined with 'into your hand' it is a standard phrase from battle oracles.
-
אֶת־
et · H0853
[object marker] · v4, v5
Marks the next word as the direct object. It has no English equivalent.
-
אֹיִבְךָ
oyivkha · H0341
your enemy · v4
The men call Saul simply 'your enemy'. They do not call him king or Yahweh's anointed. That is the very label David refuses in verse 6.
-
בְּיָדֶךָ
beyadekha · H3027
into your hand · v4
'Hand' stands for power and control. To 'give into someone's hand' means to put a person at their mercy, usually so they can kill or conquer them.
-
וְעָשִׂיתָ
ve'asita · H6213
and you will do · v4
This could be read as a promise ('you will do') or a permission ('you may do'). The men take it as a green light.
-
לּוֹ
lo · H9033
to him · v4
'To him', the person on the receiving end of whatever David decides to do.
-
יִטַב
yitav · H3190
it is good / pleasing · v4
'Seems good, pleases'. Taken with the next word, the idiom means 'whatever you think best'.
-
בְּעֵינֶיךָ
be'eineikha · H5869
in your eyes · v4
'In your eyes' means in your own judgment. The open wording is a hint: everyone in the cave knows what the men think David should do.
-
וַיָּקָם
vayyaqom · H6965
and he arose · v4
David gets up from where he was crouching. The verb says nothing about stealth, but it marks the start of decisive action, and it builds suspense: is he going to kill Saul?
-
וַיִּכְרֹת
vayyikhrot · H3772
and he cut off · v4, v5
'Cut off', the same verb used for cutting off a person or a family line (24:21). David cuts cloth when his men expected him to cut off Saul.
-
כְּנַף־
kenaf · H3671
wing; corner, hem, edge (of a garment) · v4, v5
The 'wing' of the robe, meaning its corner or hem. In Israel and the wider ancient Near East this part of a garment stood for the wearer's identity and authority.
-
הַמְּעִיל
hamme'il · H4598
the robe (outer cloak of rank) · v4
A long outer robe worn by people of standing: Samuel, Jonathan, the high priest, royal daughters. It recalls the robe Saul tore from Samuel in 15:27–28.
-
לְשָׁאוּל
leSha'ul · H7586
belonging to Saul · v4, v5
Literally 'which was to Saul', that is, Saul's own robe. The wording puts weight on whose it was, and so on the king's person.
-
בַּלָּט
ballat · H3909
secretly, quietly · v4
'In secret, quietly, softly': Saul does not notice. The narrator gives this as a fact, without praising or blaming it.
-
וַֽיְהִי֙
vayhi · H1961
and it was / and it came to pass · v5
The standard opener for a new step in a Hebrew story. It marks a pause after the tense moment of the cutting in verse 4: something now happens inside David.
-
אַֽחֲרֵי־
acharei · H0310A
after, behind · v5
"After". Together with the next word it makes the ordinary expression for "afterward".
-
כֵ֔ן
khen · H3651C
so, thus · v5
"After this". It does not say how long afterward. The story reads most naturally as "right after": the remorse comes before David speaks to his men in verse 6.
-
וַיַּ֥ךְ
vayyakh · H5221
to strike, smite, wound, kill · v5
"And it struck". This is the ordinary verb for a physical blow, often a deadly one in battle. Its subject is "the heart". David did not strike Saul, so the blow lands on David himself.
-
לֵב־
lev · H3820A
heart, mind, inner self · v5
"The heart of". In Hebrew the heart is the inner person who thinks, decides and judges right from wrong. Feeling is only part of it. Here it is the part of David that judges what he has just done.
-
עַ֚ל
al · H5921A
upon, over, on account of · v5
Followed by the next word, it means "because" and gives the reason for the blow.
The world behind it
Where: The 'strongholds of Engedi' (23:29) are on the western shore of the Dead Sea: limestone cliffs full of caves, with springs and wild goats. Shepherds closed off cave mouths with low stone walls to make sheepfolds (v.3). These caves can be deep and dark, so men sitting far inside can see a figure in the bright entrance without being seen.
What Saul was doing: Verse 3 says Saul went in 'to cover his feet', a Hebrew euphemism for relieving himself (compare Judg 3:24). A man squatting in a long robe would have the skirts of the garment spread or gathered around him. That explains how David could cut off a corner unnoticed, and it shows how completely exposed the king was.
The robe and the hem: In Israel and its neighbours a garment, and its hem above all, stood for the person who wore it. The hem bore the tassels (Num 15:38). Spreading one's hem over someone meant protection or marriage (Ruth 3:9). In Mesopotamian documents a hem could be sent in place of a person, and cutting a hem could mark the dissolving of a legal tie. In 1 Samuel the me'il robe has already been made a symbol of kingship: Saul tore Samuel's robe and was told the kingdom was torn from him (15:27–28), and Jonathan gave his robe to David (18:4).
The king's person: Saul had been anointed by Yahweh's prophet. To strike him was to strike someone Yahweh had marked out, a point David makes in the very next breath (v.6: 'Yahweh's anointed'). To David's men, Saul was simply the man trying to kill them.
From the study of 1 Samuel 24:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
What 'word of Yahweh' are David's men quoting?
-
An oracle that was really given but is not recorded in the book.
David consulted Yahweh often through the ephod and the prophet Gad (22:5; 23:2–4, 9–12), so many of the answers he received are not reported. The men speak as if David would recognise the words.
-
The men are paraphrasing or stretching earlier promises: David's anointing (16:13), Jonathan's 'you will be king' (23:17), and especially the battle oracle of 23:4 ('I am giving the Philistines into your hand').
The wording closely matches 23:4. No oracle about Saul in these terms appears anywhere. The narrator has just shown Saul misreading events in the same way (23:7), and David's reply in v.6 corrects the men's theology without disputing the quote. Many commentators (e.g. Alter, Bergen, Klein) favour this reading.
in v4
Is the order of verses 4b–7 original?
-
4b–5 were moved: originally David restrained his men first (v.6–7a), then cut the robe, then felt remorse.
It seems odd for David to feel remorse (v.5) before he rebukes his men (v.6), and 'Afterward' in v.5 fits better later on (McCarter, Anchor Bible; Klein, Word Biblical Commentary).
-
The order is deliberate.
David's own conscience after the robe-cutting is what gives him the moral authority to restrain his men. It is his remorse that moves him to speak. No textual witness supports the transposition (Gordon, Bergen, Alter).
in v4
What did cutting the robe signify?
-
A symbolic act against the king's authority, a 'cutting off' of his royal status, which is why David felt guilt.
The hem stood for the wearer's identity and authority in Israel and the ancient Near East (Ruth 3:9; Mari texts). The me'il echoes 15:27–28. And David's heart struck him (v.5).
-
Mainly a token of proof that David could have killed Saul.
In 24:11 David holds up the piece of the robe as evidence: 'see the corner of your robe in my hand… I did not kill you.'
-
An act of humiliation (and possibly an insult to the king's manhood), given the setting.
Saul was relieving himself, and damaging someone's clothing could shame them (compare 2 Sam 10:4, where David's envoys have their garments cut). This reading is more speculative.
in v5
Why exactly did cutting Saul's robe trouble David?
-
Symbolic usurpation: cutting the royal hem was a sign of taking the kingdom or stripping Saul of his status.
1 Sam 15:27–28, where a torn hem means the kingdom is torn from Saul. Saul's own response in 24:20 ("now I know that you will surely be king"). Near Eastern evidence that a hem stood for a person's identity and legal standing.
-
Assault on the king's dignity and person: even without a coded message, damaging the anointed king's garment amounted to laying a hand on him.
David's words in the next verse focus on not doing "this thing" to "my lord, the LORD's anointed" and not stretching out his hand against him (v. 6). The robe was a garment of rank (me'il).
-
A step toward murder: David realised he had begun to yield to his men's urging, and the cut was a rehearsal of the killing blow.
The men's interpretation of a divine promise (v. 4). The striking verb turned on David himself. Saul's later plea not to have his descendants "cut off" (v. 21). These views are not exclusive, and many interpreters combine them.
in v5
Is the verse in its original position?
-
Verses 4b–5 have been displaced. Originally David restrained his men (vv. 6–7a) and only then cut the robe.
The Hebrew of verse 7 ("David restrained his men") seems to some to follow awkwardly after the robe has already been cut. Proposed in critical commentary such as McCarter's Anchor Bible volume. No manuscript evidence.
-
The received order is original and deliberate: an impulsive act, instant remorse, then speech and restraint.
All manuscripts and ancient versions agree. The order makes psychological and narrative sense. The scribal paragraph break after verse 5 isolates the remorse as its own beat. Defended by many literary readers (e.g., Robert Alter).
Sources
- BDB s.v. כָּנָף, מְעִיל, לָט, כָּרַת
- HALOT s.v. כָּנָף; לָט
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), on 24:4–8
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- Robert Alter, The David Story / The Hebrew Bible, notes on 1 Sam 24
- Robert P. Gordon, I & II Samuel: A Commentary
- Robert D. Bergen, 1, 2 Samuel (New American Commentary)
- R. A. Brauner, '"To Grasp the Hem" and 1 Samuel 15:27', JANES 6 (1974)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 24
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Masora at 1 Sam 24:5 (Ketiv/Qere)
- BDB s.v. לֵב, כָּנָף, נָכָה, כָּרַת
- HALOT s.v. לֵב, כָּנָף, נכה (hiphil), כרת
- H. W. Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (on lēb as the seat of reason and will)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8, 1980)
- Robert Alter, The David Story (1999)
- R. A. Brauner, "'To Grasp the Hem' and 1 Samuel 15:27," JANES 6 (1974)
- Mari prophetic letters (ARM), on the hair and hem as a prophet's token
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (Reigns) 24:6 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, 1 Kings (1 Samuel) 24:6
- Parallel uses: 1 Sam 15:27–28; 18:3–4; 20:15–16; 24:20–21; 25:31; 26:8–11; 2 Sam 24:10; Num 15:38; Deut 22:12; Ruth 3:9
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).