1 Kings Chapter 20 Read as one passage

1 Kings 20:30–32

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

30The rest of them fled into the city of Aphek, where the wall fell on twenty-seven thousand of the remaining men. Ben-hadad also fled to the city and hid in an inner room. 31Then the servants of Ben-hadad said to him, “Look now, we have heard that the kings of the house of Israel are merciful. Let us go out to the king of Israel with sackcloth around our waists and ropes around our heads. Perhaps he will spare your life.” 32So with sackcloth around their waists and ropes around their heads, they went to the king of Israel and said, “Your servant Ben-hadad says, ‘Please spare my life.’” And the king answered, “Is he still alive? He is my brother.”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers the verse finishes a story about whose God is really God. Aram had said YHWH was a local hill-god and would be powerless on the plain. On the plain, Aram's army is destroyed, and the last part of it is killed by a city wall that falls with no human cause named, just as at Jericho. The sevens (seven days, the seventh day) and the wording 'the wall fell' would recall Israel's founding story of holy war, where God fights and the victory is his.

The verse also makes a figure of fun of a proud foreign king. Ben-hadad, 'son of the storm god', who had threatened to grind Samaria to dust and gave orders over his drinks, ends up doing just what his routed soldiers did, and hiding 'room in a room'. Hearers would know the phrase from the related story in 1 Kings 22:25, where a false prophet hides in exactly the same way once the true word comes to pass. It is the image of a man whose confidence has collapsed along with his walls.

Finally, the verse sets up the moral crisis of the chapter. God has put the enemy king in Israel's hands. Everything now depends on what Ahab does with him. The audience is being prepared to hear, by verse 42, that sparing him was a failure of loyalty to the God who gave the victory.

From the study of 1 Kings 20:30.

Verse by verse

  1. 30The rest of them fled into the city of Aphek, where the wall fell on twenty-seven thousand of the remaining men. Ben-hadad also fled to the city and hid in an inner room.

    The survivors (the men left over after a hundred thousand of their comrades were cut down in a single day) ran for the walled town of Aphek, the one place on that open plain that offered shelter. Then the city wall itself came down on them, on twenty-seven thousand of these 'survivors'. The narrator repeats the word on purpose: the ones who had escaped the battle did not escape after all. No attacker is named. The wall simply fell, in the same words the book of Joshua uses for Jericho. That echo is hard to miss after seven days of standoff and a battle on the seventh day.

    As for Ben-hadad, the 'son of Hadad' whose men had claimed Israel's God was only a god of the hills, he fled too, just like his broken troops. He got inside the same doomed city and went 'room in a room': through one inner room into another, into the deepest hiding place a house could offer. The king who had boasted that Samaria's dust would not fill his soldiers' hands is now hiding at the back of someone else's house. The scene is set for his servants to go out in sackcloth and beg the king of Israel for his life.

    Full study →
  2. 31Then the servants of Ben-hadad said to him, “Look now, we have heard that the kings of the house of Israel are merciful. Let us go out to the king of Israel with sackcloth around our waists and ropes around our heads. Perhaps he will spare your life.”

    Ben-hadad, king of Aram (Syria), has lost a second war against Israel. His army has been broken at Aphek, a city wall has collapsed on the survivors, and he is hiding in an inner room. His court officials come to him with a careful proposal. "Look, please — word has reached us that the kings of Israel's royal house are kings who keep faith: rulers known for chesed, loyal goodness. They do not simply kill a defeated king who throws himself on their goodwill. So let us put sackcloth on our waists, where our sword belts used to be, and ropes on our heads, and walk out of this city to the king of Israel as men already captured and as good as dead. Maybe he will let you live."

    "Merciful" in most English versions catches the hope, but the Hebrew points to a reputation for honour and keeping faith among kings. That is why the next verse moves straight to Ahab calling Ben-hadad "my brother," the word treaty partners used, and then to a treaty. "Spare your life" means physically keeping him alive, the opposite of executing a defeated enemy. And "perhaps" leaves it as a gamble.

    The narrator is setting a trap. In verse 42 a prophet condemns Ahab's "kindness," because Ben-hadad was a man the LORD had marked for destruction.

    Full study →
  3. 32So with sackcloth around their waists and ropes around their heads, they went to the king of Israel and said, “Your servant Ben-hadad says, ‘Please spare my life.’” And the king answered, “Is he still alive? He is my brother.”

    The Aramean officers did exactly what they had planned. They wrapped coarse goat-hair cloth around their hips, the clothing of mourners and ruined men, and put ropes on their heads like prisoners already tied for leading away. Dressed like this, they went over to the victorious king of Israel. They spoke in the formal style of envoys passing on their master's exact words: "Your servant Ben-hadad says: 'Please, I beg you, let me live.'"

    "Your servant" was not just politeness. It was the language a subject king used to his overlord. The great king of Damascus, whose name means "son of Hadad" (the Aramean storm god), was offering to become Ahab's vassal in exchange for his life.

    Ahab's reply comes at once, and it sounds surprised, even relieved: "Is he still alive? He is my brother!" He picks up their word live and answers with alive. He also refuses the overlord's role they had held out to him. In the diplomacy of that world, kings who called each other "brother" were equal partners in a treaty. So with one word Ahab lifted the beaten enemy from "servant" to "equal", with no consultation recorded, prayer or prophet. The Aramean envoys were watching for exactly this kind of sign, and in the next verse they grab the word "brother" and repeat it back to him.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v31

    merciful (kings)

    malkhei chesed

    What we hear
    Soft-hearted, compassionate rulers inclined to pity.
    What they heard
    Kings known for loyal goodness and keeping faith in dealings between rulers. In practice this meant sparing a defeated king who surrendered humbly, and being willing to treat him as a 'brother' and treaty partner.
  • in v31

    save thy/your life (KJV, WEB)

    yechayyeh et-nafshekha

    What we hear
    For church readers, 'save' can sound like salvation, and 'life' or 'soul' like the inner spiritual self.
    What they heard
    'Let you live,' that is, not execute you. Ben-hadad's physical life is at stake.
  • in v32

    He is my brother

    achi hu

    What we hear
    An expression of personal affection or human kinship. Ahab sounds warm-hearted or forgiving.
    What they heard
    A diplomatic formula: 'he is my equal treaty partner.' Ahab was recognising Ben-hadad as a fellow king of equal standing and opening the way to an alliance (v.34). It was a political act, not an outburst of feeling.
  • in v32

    Your servant

    'avdekha

    What we hear
    A polite, humble way of referring to oneself, or a household servant.
    What they heard
    The self-designation of a vassal king. It formally offers political submission and subject status to the victor.
Every word
  1. וַיָּנֻ֨סוּ

    vayyanusu · H5127

    and they fled · v30

    The ordinary verb for running away from danger, especially soldiers breaking from battle. It moves the story straight on from the slaughter of verse 29: the Aramean line has collapsed and the survivors run.

  2. הַנּוֹתָרִ֥ים

    hannotarim · H3498

    the ones remaining · v30

    Literally 'the left-over ones', the survivors of the 100,000 struck down in verse 29. They are the subject of the fleeing: whatever was left of the army.

  3. אֲפֵקָה֮

    'Aphekah · H0663I

    toward Aphek · v30

    Aphek with the Hebrew ending -ah, which marks direction ('Aphek-ward'). This is very probably the Aphek on the Golan plateau east of the Sea of Galilee, where Aram chose to fight on flat ground (v. 23–26).

  4. אֶל־

    'el- · H0413

    to, into · v30, v31, v32

    Marks where they were heading. With 'the city' it says they went inside the walled town looking for safety.

  5. הָעִיר֒

    ha'ir · H5892B

    the city · v30

    A walled settlement, the usual refuge for a beaten army. The walls they ran to for protection are about to become what kills them.

  6. וַתִּפֹּל֙

    vattippol · H5307G

    and it fell · v30

    The plain verb 'fall'. Nobody is named as the cause. The narrator states the collapse without explaining it, and that leaves room for the reader to see God's hand behind it, as verse 28 has prepared.

  7. הַחוֹמָ֔ה

    hachomah · H2346G

    the wall · v30

    A city's defensive wall, the massive fortification around a town, not a house wall. 'The wall' with the definite article means Aphek's own wall.

  8. עַל־

    'al- · H5921A

    upon, on · v30

    The wall fell 'upon' the men. They were crushed or buried, not merely left without cover.

  9. עֶשְׂרִ֨ים

    'esrim · H6242

    twenty · v30

    The first part of the number 'twenty-seven'.

  10. וְשִׁבְעָ֥ה

    veshiv'ah · H7651

    and seven · v30

    Completes 'twenty-seven'. Sevens run through the scene: seven days of camping and the battle on the seventh day (v. 29).

  11. אֶ֛לֶף

    'elef · H0505G

    thousand · v30

    Normally 'thousand'. The same word can also mean a clan or a military unit, which is why some scholars debate how large biblical battle figures really are (see debates).

  12. אִ֖ישׁ

    'ish · H0376G

    man · v30

    Singular used collectively after a number, as Hebrew usually does: '27,000 man' = 27,000 men. In a battle report it means fighting men.

  13. וּבֶן־

    uVen- · H1130G

    and Ben- · v30, v32

    'Son of', the first part of the Aramean king's throne name. The 'and' here starts a new line of the story that turns attention to the king himself.

  14. וַיָּבֹ֥א

    vayyavo · H0935G

    and he came/went in · v30, v32

    'Came in' or 'entered'. He gets inside the same city whose wall has just killed his men.

  15. חֶ֥דֶר

    cheder · H2315

    room, chamber · v30

    An inner, private room of a house: a bedroom or storeroom, away from the street and the gate.

  16. וַיֹּאמְר֣וּ

    vayyomru · H0559

    and they said · v31, v32

    The usual verb that moves a story forward. It brings in the advice of Ben-hadad's court right after the report of his hiding (v. 30).

  17. עֲבָדָיו֒

    avadav · H5650

    his servants · v31, v32

    Not household slaves. These are the king's officials and counsellors, his court. An eved is anyone placed under a superior: a slave, a minister, or a vassal king. The same word comes back in v. 32 when Ben-hadad calls himself Ahab's 'servant.'

  18. הִנֵּֽה־

    hinneh · H2009

    look, behold · v31

    A word that grabs attention: 'Look,' 'Listen here.' It introduces a new idea in an emergency.

  19. נָ֣א

    na · H4994

    please, now · v31, v32

    A softening particle. Advisers are proposing something humiliating to their king, and they say it politely: 'Look, please…'

  20. שָׁמַ֔עְנוּ

    shamanu · H8085

    we have heard · v31

    The plan rests on reputation, on what is said about Israel's kings in the courts of the region. It is hearsay, not a promise.

  21. כִּ֗י

    ki · H3588

    that · v31

    Brings in what they heard.

  22. מַלְכֵי֙

    malkhei · H4428

    kings of · v31, v32

    Plural. The claim is about the dynasty, or Israelite kingship in general, not only Ahab.

  23. בֵּ֣ית

    beit · H1004

    house of · v31

    'House of Israel' here means the kingdom and royal line of the northern state, as foreign courts knew it.

  24. יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל

    Yisrael · H3478

    Israel · v31, v32

    The northern kingdom ruled by Ahab, as opposed to Judah.

  25. חֶ֖סֶד

    chesed · H2617

    loyal kindness, faithfulness · v31

    The key word. In the world of kings it means a ruler who keeps faith and treats others with loyal kindness, so he can be expected to spare a defeated man who throws himself on his goodwill instead of killing him. Here it means clemency within the rules of honour between kings.

  26. הֵ֑ם

    hem · H1992

    they · v31

    'They are.' It ends the first half of the speech: the report about Israel's kings.

  27. נָשִׂ֣ימָה

    nasimah · H7760

    let us put · v31

    A 'let us' form. The advisers will make the gesture themselves on the king's behalf, so Ben-hadad does not have to appear first.

  28. שַׂקִּ֨ים

    saqqim · H8242

    sackcloth · v31, v32

    Coarse cloth, usually goat hair, worn by mourners and people pleading for mercy. Wearing it shows the 'death' of your status. You come as someone who has lost everything.

  29. בְּמָתְנֵ֜ינוּ

    bemotneinu · H4975

    on our loins/waists · v31, v32

    Sackcloth was tied around the waist like a loincloth or kilt. That is where a warrior would normally buckle on his sword belt, so the picture is also of men disarmed.

  30. וַחֲבָלִ֣ים

    vachavalim · H2256

    and ropes/cords · v31, v32

    Ropes or cords. The exact meaning of the gesture is not certain. Most likely it shows readiness to be led away as captives or put to death. It is a sign of total surrender.

  31. בְּרֹאשֵׁ֗נוּ

    beroshenu · H7218

    on our head · v31, v32

    Literally 'on our head' (singular, used for the group). Whether the ropes went around the head or around the neck is debated.

  32. וְנֵצֵא֙

    veneitse · H3318

    and let us go out · v31

    'Go out' from the city where they are trapped, a common word for surrendering a besieged city (compare 2 Kings 18:31; 24:12).

  33. אוּלַ֖י

    ulai · H0194

    perhaps · v31

    'Maybe.' Nothing is guaranteed. Their hope rests only on reputation and on a show of humility.

  34. יְחַיֶּ֥ה

    yechayyeh · H2421

    he will let live, preserve alive · v31, v32

    This form of 'to live' means 'keep someone alive, spare.' It is the technical opposite of executing a defeated enemy. It does not mean 'save' in any spiritual sense.

  35. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    (object marker) · v31

    Not translated. It marks the object of the verb.

  36. נַפְשֶֽׁךָ׃

    nafshekha · H5315

    your life, your self · v31, v32

    'Your nefesh' means 'your life,' that is, 'you, alive.' Nefesh is the living person, not a separate immortal soul. Ben-hadad repeats the phrase in v. 32: 'Let my nefesh live.'

  37. וַיַּחְגְּרוּ

    vayyachgeru · H2296

    and they girded · v32

    To tie a garment or belt around the waist. The same men who proposed the plan in v.31 now carry it out exactly; the verb pictures them binding coarse cloth on themselves like mourners or prisoners.

  38. הַעוֹדֶנּוּ

    ha'odennu · H5750

    is he still · v32

    A question marker plus 'still' plus 'he'. It means 'Is he still…?' and sounds surprised, possibly relieved: Ahab thought Ben-hadad had died in the rout.

  39. חַי

    chai · H2416A

    alive · v32

    'Alive'. It picks up the plea 'let me live' (same root): the envoys ask for life, and Ahab answers with the same word.

  40. אָחִי

    achi · H0251I

    my brother · v32

    'My brother'. In ancient royal diplomacy this meant a treaty partner of equal rank. Ahab turns down the role of overlord that 'your servant' had offered him and treats the defeated king as an equal.

  41. הוּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v32

    'He [is]'. Placed last, after 'my brother', it rounds off a short, emphatic statement: 'my brother, that's what he is'.

The world behind it

The Aramean wars. 1 Kings 20 tells of two campaigns by Ben-hadad, king of Aram-Damascus, against the northern kingdom of Israel, which the chapter places under Ahab. In the first (vv. 1–21) Ben-hadad besieges Samaria with overbearing demands and boasts (vv. 10–11), then gives orders while drinking in the field booths (vv. 12, 16), and is routed.

A theology of territorial gods. His advisers explain the defeat in terms common in the ancient Near East: every god has a home ground. 'Their gods are gods of the hills… let us fight them on the plain' (v. 23). A man of God answers that, because Aram said this, YHWH will hand over the whole army 'so that you will know that I am YHWH' (v. 28). The second battle is therefore a test of whose God rules where. Aphek, very likely the Aphek on the Golan plateau east of the Sea of Galilee where Aram again meets Israel in 2 Kgs 13:17, sits on just the kind of open ground Aram chose.

Walled cities and inner rooms. In Iron Age warfare a beaten army ran to the nearest fortified town. A city's chomah (defensive wall) could be several metres thick. Its collapse, whether through earthquake, undermining, or something the narrator wants seen as God's act, would be catastrophic for men crowded in and against it. Ordinary houses had front rooms opening onto a courtyard and smaller rooms behind. 'Room in a room' means the rearmost, windowless space, where a hunted man might hide.

What follows. The next verse turns on the reputation of Israel's kings as malkhei chesed, 'kings who keep loyal faith' (v. 31). Ben-hadad's men come out in sackcloth with ropes on their heads, signs of submission. Ahab calls him 'my brother' and makes a treaty with him (vv. 32–34). A prophet then condemns Ahab for releasing the man God had devoted to destruction (v. 42). The king's hiding in verse 30 is the low point from which that treaty begins.

From the study of 1 Kings 20:30.

Where scholars differ

in v30

How should the figure of 27,000 (with the 100,000 of v. 29) be understood?

  • Literal count of men.

    The plain sense of *'elef* as 'thousand'. The Masoretic text, the Septuagint and the Vulgate agree. Traditional commentators (e.g. Keil & Delitzsch) take the figures at face value and stress the scale of God's victory.

  • *'Elef* here counts military units or clan contingents, so the real numbers were much smaller.

    *'Elef* clearly means 'clan' or 'contingent' elsewhere (Judg 6:15; 1 Sam 10:19), and units could be well under a thousand strong. Proposed for large biblical numbers by Mendenhall (1958), Wenham (1967) and others. Critics note the method is hard to apply consistently here, where the figure is 'twenty and seven' with 'man'.

  • Conventional, deliberately large numbers typical of ancient victory reports.

    Ancient Near Eastern battle accounts (e.g. Assyrian royal annals) regularly use large, stylised figures to express total victory (studied by K. L. Younger, *Ancient Conquest Accounts*). The sevens and round numbers in vv. 29–30 fit a crafted narrative.

in v30

What made the wall fall?

  • God acted directly (miracle), in the Jericho pattern.

    There is no human agent. The prophetic promise in v. 28 that God will hand the army over. The seven days and seventh day of v. 29 plus the phrase 'the wall fell' echo Josh 6:20.

  • A natural or military cause (an earthquake, or a collapse under assault or overcrowding), which the narrator presents as providential.

    Earthquakes are well attested in the Jordan Rift and Golan region. Ancient walls of mudbrick on stone foundations could fail under stress. The Hebrew simply says 'it fell' and does not rule out a natural mechanism.

in v30

Which Israelite king and which Ben-hadad does this chapter originally concern?

  • Ahab and a Ben-hadad of his day, as the text now stands (Ahab is named in vv. 2, 13–14).

    The final form of the text. 'Ben-hadad' may be a throne title borne by more than one Damascene king. Ahab and Damascus could have fought before they became allies against Assyria.

  • The stories first concerned a later Israelite king (e.g. Jehoahaz or Joash) and Ben-hadad son of Hazael, and were later attached to Ahab.

    Assyrian records show Ahab allied with Hadad-ezer of Damascus at Qarqar (853 BC). In 2 Kgs 13:17–25 Elisha predicts victory 'at Aphek' over Aram under Joash against Ben-hadad son of Hazael. In much of the chapter the king is unnamed ('the king of Israel'). Proposed by a number of critical scholars (e.g. J. M. Miller).

in v31

What does 'kings of chesed' mean here?

  • A reputation for clemency: Israel's kings were known to spare enemies who surrendered.

    The context is all about sparing a life ('perhaps he will let you live'). The Septuagint translates eleos (mercy).

  • A reputation for keeping faith in treaties: Israel's kings honoured agreements and treated rulers who submitted as partners.

    Glueck's influential study tied chesed to obligations within a relationship. Ahab's 'my brother' and the treaty in v. 34 fit. 2 Sam 10:2 shows chesed passing between kings.

  • Chesed is a loyal kindness freely given by the stronger party, which cannot be demanded (Sakenfeld), so the advisers can only hope ('perhaps').

    Aram had no existing treaty with Israel to appeal to. The 'perhaps' shows they are throwing themselves on goodwill, not invoking a right.

in v31

What did the ropes on the head signify?

  • Ropes around the neck: readiness to be led away as captives or executed.

    Assyrian depictions of captives led by ropes. In Hebrew, 'head' can loosely include the neck area.

  • A cord or band worn on the head as a recognised sign of submission or supplication.

    The text says 'on' the head, not 'on the neck.' Such a band would be a sign alongside mourning dress rather than real binding.

in v32

What did the ropes on the envoys' heads signify?

  • A sign of captivity: the men present themselves as prisoners already bound, perhaps with halters around their necks, ready to be led away or executed.

    Assyrian reliefs show captives led by ropes. The Hebrew 'on their heads' can loosely include the neck. It fits the logic of offering oneself up completely.

  • A conventional sign of supplication or mourning, without any literal meaning of being tied up.

    Josephus explains it as the ancient manner of suppliants among the Syrians. It is paired with sackcloth, a mourning garment, and the gesture appears nowhere else in the Bible to show a clear captive meaning.

in v32

Which kings are involved in this chapter?

  • The story is as the text presents it: Ahab of Israel and Ben-hadad (often labelled Ben-hadad II) of Damascus, in the 850s BC.

    The chapter names Ahab (20:2, 13–14). The narrative connects directly with Ahab's death fighting Aram in ch. 22.

  • The Aramean war stories originally concerned a later Israelite king (e.g. Jehoahaz or Joash of the Jehu dynasty) and were later attached to Ahab.

    The king is usually unnamed in ch. 20. Assyrian records show Ahab fighting *alongside* Damascus, whose king is named Hadad-ezer, at Qarqar in 853 BC. A later Ben-hadad son of Hazael is known to have fought Israel (2 Kgs 13:3, 24–25).

in v32

Is Ahab's 'He is my brother' presented as mercy or as political calculation?

  • Mainly political: Ahab sees a chance for an alliance and economic gain (cities and trading quarters in Damascus, v.34), perhaps with an eye on the rising Assyrian threat.

    'Brother' is treaty language. A treaty (berit) with concrete terms follows immediately.

  • It also reflects genuine royal magnanimity, the 'chesed' the Arameans had heard of, which the narrator nonetheless condemns as misplaced because God had handed this enemy over for destruction.

    The Arameans appeal to Israel's kings as 'kings of chesed' (v.31). The prophet's objection in v.42 is not to mercy in general but to releasing 'the man of my cherem'.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חֶדֶר
  • HALOT s.v. חֶדֶר
  • HALOT s.v. אֶלֶף
  • BDB s.v. אַלּוּף
  • HALOT s.v. חוֹמָה
  • BDB s.v. יָתַר
  • M. Cogan, 1 Kings (Anchor Bible 10), on 1 Kgs 20:26–30
  • C. F. Keil & F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Old Testament: Kings, on 1 Kgs 20:30
  • G. E. Mendenhall, 'The Census Lists of Numbers 1 and 26', JBL 77 (1958)
  • J. W. Wenham, 'Large Numbers in the Old Testament', Tyndale Bulletin 18 (1967)
  • K. L. Younger, Ancient Conquest Accounts (1990)
  • J. M. Miller, 'The Elisha Cycle and the Accounts of the Omride Wars', JBL 85 (1966)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Kgs 20
  • Septuagint, 3 Kingdoms 21:30
  • Vulgate, 3 Regum 20:30
  • HALOT s.v. חֶסֶד, חֶבֶל, חיה (piel), נֶפֶשׁ
  • BDB s.v. חֶסֶד, שַׂק
  • Nelson Glueck, Hesed in the Bible
  • Katharine Doob Sakenfeld, The Meaning of Hesed in the Hebrew Bible
  • Mordechai Cogan, 1 Kings (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Montgomery & Gehman, Kings (International Critical Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 1 Kings 20
  • Kurkh Monolith of Shalmaneser III (Battle of Qarqar)
  • Sefire treaty inscriptions (Aramaic treaty language)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. אָח (diplomatic 'brother'), עֶבֶד, שַׂק, חֶבֶל, נֶפֶשׁ
  • Amarna letters (W. L. Moran, The Amarna Letters, 1992): 'brother' between great kings vs. 'servant' for vassals
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities book 8 (retelling of the Aphek episode)
  • Septuagint, 3 Kingdoms 21 (= MT 1 Kings 20); Vulgate, 3 Kings 20
  • M. Cogan, 1 Kings (Anchor Bible), commentary on 20:31–34
  • J. A. Montgomery and H. S. Gehman, Kings (ICC)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Kings 20
  • Kurkh Monolith of Shalmaneser III (Battle of Qarqar, 853 BC)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).