1 Samuel Chapter 10 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 10:20–21
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
20Thus Samuel had all the tribes of Israel come forward, and the tribe of Benjamin was selected. 21Then he had the tribe of Benjamin come forward by its clans, and the clan of Matri was selected. Finally, Saul son of Kish was selected. But when they looked for him, they could not find him.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse did several things.
- It settled the question of who chose the king. The people had demanded a king, but the lot showed that the choice belonged to God. That gave Saul a legitimacy no tribe could challenge, at least at first. It also kept the king under God, since he was "caught" by God and not raised up by the crowd.
- It sounded like a trial. Anyone who knew the Achan story (Joshua 7) would recognize the same verbs and the same steps of the procedure. Coming right after Samuel's charge that the people had rejected God (v. 19), the scene has a solemn, even judicial, feel. Israel stands before God to receive what it asked for.
- It was surprising. Benjamin was the least of the tribes and had a disgraced history. The lot falling there fit a theme already announced in Hannah's song (2:7–8): the LORD brings low and raises up.
- It prepared for what came later. Later hearers knew that Saul's house would fall and kingship would pass to Judah through David. For them, a Benjaminite king chosen by lot was the start of a story whose end they already knew. That gave the scene both legitimacy and a sense of tragedy.
From the study of 1 Samuel 10:20.
Verse by verse
-
20Thus Samuel had all the tribes of Israel come forward, and the tribe of Benjamin was selected.
Full study →Samuel presented every tribe of Israel before the LORD, one after another, and the lot caught Benjamin.
The first verb is the one used for bringing an offering or a person into God's presence at the sanctuary. Samuel is not chairing an election. He is putting the whole nation before God for a ruling. The second verb is the word for capturing a town or catching an animal in a trap. In lot-casting it means "singled out." The point of the passive is that no human picks Benjamin. Samuel doesn't and the people don't. The lot falls, and the lot was understood to be God's decision (Prov 16:33).
The verse is the first step of a narrowing that continues in v. 21: tribe, then clan, then one man, Saul son of Kish. The tribe that gets caught is Benjamin. It was the smallest, and it had barely survived the civil war after the outrage at Gibeah (Judges 19–21). Saul himself had already called it the least of Israel's tribes (9:21).
This comes straight after Samuel's charge that the people have "rejected your God" by demanding a king (v. 19). So the scene holds two things together. Israel gets the king it asked for, but it does not choose him. God does, by a procedure that the earlier history of Israel had last used to uncover a guilty man, Achan (Joshua 7).
-
21Then he had the tribe of Benjamin come forward by its clans, and the clan of Matri was selected. Finally, Saul son of Kish was selected. But when they looked for him, they could not find him.
Full study →Samuel presented the tribe of Benjamin before the LORD clan by clan, and the sacred lot caught the clan of the Matrites. Then it caught Saul, son of Kish. They went looking for him, and he was nowhere to be found.
The verb behind "selected" or "taken" is the word for capturing a city or snaring an animal. The lot does not pick a willing candidate. It closes in on one man, step by step: nation, then tribe, then clan, then individual. Israelites knew this procedure from the story of Achan (Joshua 7), where the same narrowing-down, in nearly the same words, exposed the man who had brought disaster on Israel. Here it is used to find a king the people demanded and Samuel has just called a rejection of God (vv. 18–19). The choice really is God's, and the echo makes it uneasy.
The verse ends in anticlimax. The newly chosen king cannot be found. The words "sought" and "found" are the ones that ran through Saul's search for his father's lost donkeys in chapter 9. The searcher has become the one searched for. His name, Sha'ul, means "asked for", and the people now have to "ask" the LORD again (v. 22) to find the man they asked for.
Where the English drifted
-
in v20
was selected / was chosen (BSB, WEB)
vayyillakhed (from lakhad)
- What we hear
- Someone weighed the options and picked Benjamin, the way a committee selects a candidate.
- What they heard
- Benjamin was 'caught' or 'captured' by the lot. The tribe is passive, no human makes the choice, and the result is understood as God's ruling. It is the same verb used for a city captured or an animal trapped, and for Achan being exposed in Joshua 7.
-
in v21
families (KJV, WEB)
mishpachah
- What we hear
- A household of parents and children.
- What they heard
- A clan: a large group of related households inside a tribe, often sharing land and a district.
-
in v21
selected / chosen (BSB, WEB)
nilkad (from lakad)
- What we hear
- Picked or preferred, as in an election or appointment, with a sense of being favoured.
- What they heard
- Caught or seized by the sacred lot. It is the same verb used for capturing cities and the term used when lots exposed Achan and Jonathan. The choice is God's verdict landing on someone, not a vote of approval.
Every word
-
וַיַּקְרֵ֣ב
vayyaqrev · H7126
bring near, present · v20, v21
The causative form: Samuel made the tribes come close, that is, presented them 'before the LORD' (v. 19). It is the same verb used for presenting offerings and people at the sanctuary, so the assembly is a sacred proceeding, not a vote.
-
שְׁמוּאֵ֔ל
Shemu'el · H8050
Samuel · v20
The prophet-judge who has just accused the people of rejecting God (v. 19). He runs the procedure, but he does not pick the king; he only brings the tribes forward.
-
אֵ֖ת
et · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v20, v21
Untranslatable marker showing that 'all the tribes of Israel' is what Samuel brought near.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all, every · v20
Every tribe without exception is presented. The whole nation is put in front of God, so the outcome cannot be called one region's choice.
-
שִׁבְטֵ֣י
shivtei · H7626
tribes of (also: rod, staff, scepter) · v20, v21
The tribes as the largest units of Israel's kinship structure. The same Hebrew word means 'staff' or 'scepter', the leader's rod that stood for the tribe.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל
Yisra'el · H3478
Israel · v20
The people as one family descended from Jacob-Israel, gathered at Mizpah as a single body.
-
וַיִּלָּכֵ֖ד
vayyillakhed · H3920
be captured, caught, taken · v20, v21
Passive: 'was caught.' The ordinary verb for capturing a city or trapping an animal is also the technical verb for being picked out when lots are cast. Nobody chooses Benjamin; Benjamin is caught.
-
בִּנְיָמִֽן׃
Binyamin · H1144
Benjamin ('son of the right hand' / 'son of the south') · v20, v21
The smallest tribe, and one with a disgraced past (Judges 19–21). Saul himself had called it 'the smallest of the tribes of Israel' (9:21), so the lot lands where nobody would have expected.
-
לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָ֔יו
lĕmišpĕḥōtāyw · H4940
clan, kin-group · v21
"By its clans": the tribe comes forward in its sub-groups. A mishpachah is a clan, a group of related households, bigger than a household but smaller than a tribe.
-
הַמַּטְרִ֑י
hammaṭrî · H4309
Matrite, (of) Matri · v21
"The Matrite" clan. It appears only here and is missing from the Benjaminite clan lists in Genesis 46, Numbers 26 and 1 Chronicles 7–8, and from Saul's family tree in 9:1.
-
שָׁא֣וּל
šāʾûl · H7586
-
בֶּן־
ben- · H1121
son · v21
"Son of": identifies Saul by his father, the normal way of naming a man in a kinship-based society.
-
קִ֔ישׁ
qîš · H7027
Kish · v21
Saul's father, introduced in 9:1 as a Benjaminite of standing, "a mighty man of wealth/valor".
-
וַיְבַקְשֻׁ֖הוּ
wayḇaqšuhû · H1245
seek, search for · v21
"And they sought him": the crowd searches for the man just chosen. The verb repeats the key word of chapter 9, where Saul spent days "seeking" his father's lost donkeys.
-
וְלֹ֥א
wĕlōʾ · H3808
not · v21
Plain negation: "and not".
-
נִמְצָֽא׃
nimṣāʾ · H4672
find; (passive) be found · v21
"He was found". With the negative: he was not to be found. The king God has just picked is missing at the moment he is chosen. This sets up v. 22, where the LORD reveals he is hiding among the baggage.
The world behind it
The Mizpah assembly. Mizpah was a hilltop gathering place in Benjamin's territory, north of Jerusalem. Samuel had held a national assembly there before (1 Sam 7:5–6). Here he calls the people together after they have demanded "a king like all the nations" (8:5, 20). In 10:18–19 he gives a short prophetic indictment: God saved them from Egypt and from their oppressors, and they have rejected him. Then he orders them to stand "before the LORD by your tribes and by your thousands" (that is, clans).
How the lot worked. Israel was organized in nested kinship groups: tribe (shevet), clan (mishpachah, also called "thousand"), father's household, and individual man. A lot was used to move down this ladder. Each group was "brought near," the lot was cast, and the group "taken" moved on to the next round. The text does not say what object was used. Options include the priestly Urim and Thummim (compare the Greek text of 1 Sam 14:41) or marked stones or sticks. In Israel, as across the ancient Near East, the lot was not chance. It was a way of getting a decision from the deity in front of witnesses, so the result could not be blamed on any faction.
Why public selection was needed. Saul had already been anointed privately by Samuel (9:27–10:1). Nobody else knew. A private anointing could not make a man king over tribes who had never had one. The lot made the choice public and placed it beyond dispute, and Saul's victory at Jabesh-gilead (ch. 11) then proved him in battle.
Benjamin's standing. Benjamin was a small tribe caught between Ephraim to the north and Judah to the south. Its town Gibeah was linked with one of the darkest stories in Israel's memory (Judges 19–21), after which the tribe almost ceased to exist. A king from Benjamin was an unlikely choice. It also had one political advantage: it did not belong to either of the two big rival tribes.
From the study of 1 Samuel 10:20.
Where scholars differ
in v20
Does the echo of Achan's exposure (Joshua 7) cast a shadow over Saul's selection?
-
Yes. The echo is deliberate and points toward judgment. The narrator uses the same verbs and the same tribe-clan-man procedure that once exposed a guilty man, so the king is found the way a culprit is found. This fits Samuel's indictment just before (v. 19) and Saul's later failure.
The vocabulary in Josh 7:14–18 and 1 Sam 10:19–21 is closely parallel (bring near / be taken, by tribes and clans). Verse 19 frames the assembly as following the people's rejection of God. Saul hiding among the baggage (v. 22) and his later rejection (chs. 13, 15) also count. Argued by literary readers such as Robert Polzin (*Samuel and the Deuteronomist*) and noted by Robert Alter (*The David Story*).
-
No. This is simply the standard vocabulary for lot-casting and carries no negative meaning of its own.
The same verbs describe any lot procedure. In 1 Sam 14:41–42 the lot 'takes' Jonathan, who has done nothing morally wrong. Elsewhere in the chapter Saul's selection is presented positively (10:1, 6–7, 24, 'Do you see the one the LORD has chosen?'). Many commentators (e.g. Tsumura, NICOT) read the lot mainly as a public confirmation of God's choice.
in v20
How does this public lot relate to Saul's private anointing (9:1–10:16) and his military victory (ch. 11)?
-
These are originally separate traditions about how Saul became king. An editor placed them side by side.
Classic source criticism (Wellhausen; P. Kyle McCarter, *I Samuel*, Anchor Bible) points to the different tone of each account. The anointing is favorable to kingship, while the Mizpah speech is critical. Saul's anointing seems unknown at Mizpah, and 11:14–15 speaks of 'renewing' the kingdom.
-
They form one ordered sequence: secret designation, public confirmation, proving in battle, and confirmation by the people.
Baruch Halpern (*The Constitution of the Monarchy in Israel*) and Diana Edelman argue for a pattern known from ancient Near Eastern and Israelite accounts of how a leader came to power: designation, demonstration of ability, confirmation. A private anointing could not make a man king of the tribes, so a public, God-given sign like the lot was needed.
in v20
What device was used to cast the lot?
-
The priestly Urim and Thummim.
These were Israel's official means of asking God for yes/no answers. The Greek text of 1 Sam 14:41 explicitly mentions Urim and Thummim in a similar 'taking' scene.
-
Ordinary lots (stones, sticks, or similar), or the text simply does not say.
Verse 20 names no device and no priest. Lots were widely used for allotting land (Josh 18–19), and Prov 16:33 speaks of the lot cast into the lap. The narrator only cares that God decided.
in v21
Why does Saul hide, and why is he "not found" (vv. 21–22)?
-
Modesty or humility: Saul feels unworthy of the office.
In 9:21 Saul protests that he comes from the smallest tribe and the least clan. In 10:16 he keeps the anointing secret. In 15:17 Samuel recalls a time when Saul was "little in his own eyes".
-
Fear, reluctance or insecurity, an early sign of the instability that will undo him.
Hiding "among the baggage" is undignified. Later Saul acts out of fear of the people (15:24) and hesitates at key moments (13:8–12). The narrator often depicts Saul in ambiguous or comic terms.
-
The narrator deliberately leaves it ambiguous.
The text gives no motive. The same features (shyness, hiding, a reluctant hero) can be read either way, much like Gideon's protests in Judges 6.
in v21
How does this public lot relate to Saul's private anointing (9:1–10:16) and his military acclamation (ch. 11)?
-
Separate traditions about Saul's rise, combined by an editor.
Three different accounts of how Saul became king (anointing, lot, victory), with no cross-references in 10:17–27 to the earlier anointing. The scholarly theory of a pro-monarchy and an anti-monarchy source has traditionally been used to explain the tension.
-
A deliberate sequence in the story: private designation, then public confirmation, then proof in action.
Ancient Near Eastern and Israelite parallels for designation followed by public acknowledgement. 11:14–15 frames Gilgal as a "renewal" of the kingdom, which presupposes the earlier steps.
in v21
Does the Achan-like lot procedure signal judgment on Saul or on the people?
-
Yes: the echo of Joshua 7 is deliberately ominous.
The vocabulary (hiqriv, nilkad) and the nested sequence are the same. The scene follows Samuel's accusation of rejecting God (10:19). The same procedure singles out Jonathan in 14:41–42.
-
No: the lot is simply the standard way of getting God's decision.
Lots were also used for neutral purposes such as dividing land (Joshua 14–19). The text affirms God's choice in v. 24: "Do you see the one the LORD has chosen?"
Sources
- BDB s.v. לָכַד, קָרַב, שֵׁבֶט, בִּנְיָמִין
- HALOT s.v. לכד (Niphal, 'be taken' by lot); s.v. קרב (Hiphil)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist
- Baruch Halpern, The Constitution of the Monarchy in Israel
- J. Lindblom, 'Lot-Casting in the Old Testament', Vetus Testamentum 12 (1962)
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 10:19–21 (Rahlfs)
- Parallel texts: Joshua 7:14–18; 1 Samuel 9:21; 14:41–42; Proverbs 16:33; Judges 19–21; Genesis 35:18; 49:10
- BDB and HALOT s.v. לָכַד (niphal "be taken" by lot)
- HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּחָה
- BDB s.v. קָרַב (hiphil "bring near, present")
- Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 10:21
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 10:17–27
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Robert Alter, The David Story (on seek/find wordplay and Saul's name)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on lot-casting and Mizpah assembly
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).