1 Samuel Chapter 14 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 14:36–42

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

36And Saul said, “Let us go down after the Philistines by night and plunder them until dawn, leaving no man alive!” “Do what seems good to you,” the troops replied. But the priest said, “We must consult God here.” 37So Saul inquired of God, “Shall I go down after the Philistines? Will You give them into the hand of Israel?” But God did not answer him that day. 38Therefore Saul said, “Come here, all you leaders of the troops, and let us investigate how this sin has occurred today. 39As surely as the LORD who saves Israel lives, even if it is my son Jonathan, he must die!” But not one of the troops said a word. 40Then Saul said to all Israel, “You stand on one side, and I and my son Jonathan will stand on the other side.” “Do what seems good to you,” the troops replied. 41So Saul said to the LORD, the God of Israel, “Why have You not answered Your servant this day? If the fault is with me or my son Jonathan, respond with Urim, but if the fault is with the men of Israel, respond with Thummim.” And Jonathan and Saul were selected, but the people were cleared of the charge. 42Then Saul said, “Cast the lot between me and my son Jonathan.” And Jonathan was selected.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the Saul stories, this verse is a small, telling moment in a chapter about a king who acts first and asks later. Saul's speech has the sound of holy-war victory: pursuit, plunder, 'no survivor'. But the order is wrong. In Israel's understanding of war, the LORD decided whether the battle was to be fought (compare Judg 20; 1 Sam 23; 30), and a king was expected to ask before charging.

The scene sets three voices against each other. The king plans. The army defers to the king ('whatever is good in your eyes'). The priest is the only one who brings God into the decision. Hearers would notice that this kind of initiative should have come from the king. They would also notice the sound-play on Saul's name: Sha'ul, 'the asked-for one', the king the people asked for (8:5–10; 12:13), has to be prompted to ask God (14:37), and when he does, God is silent. The silence leads to the lot that falls on Jonathan and shows how rash Saul's oath was. All of this prepares the reader for the contrast with David, who asks God through the priest again and again and is answered.

The verse is not condemning plunder or night fighting as such. It shows that zeal for victory, without first seeking God's ruling, is not the obedience Israel's king owed.

From the study of 1 Samuel 14:36.

Verse by verse

  1. 36And Saul said, “Let us go down after the Philistines by night and plunder them until dawn, leaving no man alive!” “Do what seems good to you,” the troops replied. But the priest said, “We must consult God here.”

    Saul spoke with a commander's urgency: "Down after the Philistines, tonight! We'll strip them as they run until the first light of morning, and not leave a single man of them standing." Three times he says "let us": let us go down, let us plunder, let us leave no one. The plan sounds like the old accounts of total victory. His troops are exhausted and have just broken the food laws by eating meat with the blood, but they give him free rein: "Whatever looks good in your eyes, do it." Nobody asks how it looks in God's eyes. Then the priest Ahijah, who carries the ephod (the priestly garment through which Israel asked God for rulings), cuts in with a "let us" of his own that turns the king's plan around: "Let us draw near, here, to God." Saul wanted to go down after the enemy. The priest says first come near to God, to this altar where Saul had just sacrificed, and get a ruling before anyone moves. This is not a call to private devotion. It is a call to the formal procedure Israel was expected to follow before battle. The next verse shows why it matters: Saul asks, and God gives no answer.

    Full study →
  2. 37So Saul inquired of God, “Shall I go down after the Philistines? Will You give them into the hand of Israel?” But God did not answer him that day.

    So Saul, whose name means “asked-for,” asked. He did not say a quick prayer. He formally consulted God through the priest Ahijah, who carried the ephod and its sacred lots. The questions were framed in the clipped yes-or-no form such an oracle could answer: “Shall I go down after the Philistines, chasing them downhill through the night? Will you hand them over into Israel’s power?” This was the same promise of handing the enemy over that had already come true for Jonathan that morning. But no answer came. God gave no yes and no no, nothing at all. On that day, the very day the LORD had saved Israel, the God who had acted for Jonathan stayed silent toward the king. Everyone involved understood silence from the oracle as a sign that something was wrong between God and the camp. That is why the next verse turns straight to a hunt for the “sin” behind it.

    Full study →
  3. 38Therefore Saul said, “Come here, all you leaders of the troops, and let us investigate how this sin has occurred today.

    God had refused to answer (v. 37), so Saul called a formal inquiry: "Step forward, over here, all you cornerstones of the army, every man the people rest on, and find out, establish the facts: what is it in which this offence lies, the one that has come to stand among us today?"

    The Hebrew conveys several things in this short command:

    • A summons to judgment. "Draw near" is the language of stepping forward before a judge. "Here" echoes the priest's "let us draw near here to God" (v. 36). The place where they asked God for an oracle has become the place where they look for the guilty.
    • The leaders as load-bearing stones. Literally Saul calls them "the corners of the people," the cornerstones that hold the structure together. If the fault is in one of them, the whole army is affected.
    • An order, not a suggestion. "Know and see" is a fixed phrase meaning "investigate and reach a finding," and it is addressed to the leaders.
    • A sin that already exists, but unnamed. Saul speaks of "this sin" as a fact, since God's silence has proved it to him. He asks "in what", not yet "who." The offence is an objective breach that leaves the whole camp exposed before God, whether or not the offender knew about it.
    • "Today." The word ties the offence to this one day of battle: Saul's oath, Jonathan's honey, and the people eating meat with the blood.

    Readers already know what Saul does not: the oath-breaker is his own son, who never heard the oath.

    Full study →
  4. 39As surely as the LORD who saves Israel lives, even if it is my son Jonathan, he must die!” But not one of the troops said a word.

    Saul has just ordered his officers to find out how "this sin" came about, since God has refused to answer his inquiry (v.37). Now he puts himself under a solemn oath: "For — by the very life of YHWH, the God who is delivering Israel — I swear that if this sin is found lodged in Jonathan, my own son, he will die. He will certainly die."

    Each part of the sentence carries weight:

    • "By the life of YHWH" is an oath. Saul stakes God's honour, and his own life (compare v.44, "God do so to me and more"), on the outcome.
    • "Who delivers Israel" names God by the victory he had just given that day (v.23). That victory came through Jonathan's two-man raid. So Saul is swearing by the rescue in order to condemn the rescuer.
    • "If it is in Jonathan" treats the unknown sin as something hidden inside a person that has to be found and cut out, the way Achan's sin was found and removed in Joshua 7.
    • "Dying, he will die" is the language of a death sentence, handed down before anyone knows who is guilty.

    Then the narrator adds one quiet line: "And there was no one answering him, out of all the people." God had not answered Saul (v.37), and now neither do his troops. Some of them know Jonathan ate the honey. They say nothing, and their silence is not neutral: Saul stands alone, cut off from heaven and from his own men.

    Full study →
  5. 40Then Saul said to all Israel, “You stand on one side, and I and my son Jonathan will stand on the other side.” “Do what seems good to you,” the troops replied.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 41So Saul said to the LORD, the God of Israel, “Why have You not answered Your servant this day? If the fault is with me or my son Jonathan, respond with Urim, but if the fault is with the men of Israel, respond with Thummim.” And Jonathan and Saul were selected, but the people were cleared of the charge.

    Saul turns to Yahweh, the God bound by covenant to Israel, and demands an answer through the sacred lots. The longer and probably original wording, preserved in Greek, runs like this:

    "Why have you not answered your servant today? If this guilt lies in me or in Jonathan my son, Yahweh God of Israel, give Urim. But if this guilt lies in your people Israel, give Thummim."

    The traditional Hebrew text keeps only the end of that prayer: "Give Thummim!" Later readers took that word as "Give [what is] whole / perfect!"

    The lot comes out against the king's side. Jonathan and Saul are caught, the same word used for a city taken in war or for Achan caught by lot after he stole from the plunder at Jericho. The army comes out clear: they are excused and left outside the guilty group.

    Ancient hearers would have felt how tense the moment was. Saul has already sworn that the guilty man will die "even if it is Jonathan my son" (v. 39). The same lot that once singled Saul out to be king now closes in on him and his heir. The narrowing does not end until the next verse picks out Jonathan alone.

    Full study →
  7. 42Then Saul said, “Cast the lot between me and my son Jonathan.” And Jonathan was selected.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v36

    Let us draw near hither unto God (KJV, WEB, ESV)

    niqrevah halom el-ha'elohim

    What we hear
    An invitation to personal closeness with God in prayer or worship, like 'draw near to God and he will draw near to you'.
    What they heard
    A call to approach God formally, at the altar where the priest and the ephod were, in order to get an oracle (a ruling from God) about whether to attack. Verse 37 shows exactly that: Saul 'asked of God'.
  • in v36

    spoil them (KJV)

    navozzah (bazaz)

    What we hear
    Ruin them, or (oddly) pamper them. 'Spoil' today means food going bad or a child overindulged.
    What they heard
    Plunder them: strip the fleeing army of goods, livestock and gear.
  • in v37

    inquired of God / asked counsel of God

    shaʾal be-ʾelohim

    What we hear
    Saul prayed to God about what to do, or sought God’s advice in a general way.
    What they heard
    Saul formally consulted God through a priestly oracle, the ephod with Urim and Thummim, using questions built to get a yes or no. It was a public, procedural act carried out by the priest, not a private prayer.
  • in v38

    sin

    chatta't

    What we hear
    A deliberate moral wrong that a person chooses and feels guilty about.
    What they heard
    An offence or breach, especially against a sacred obligation like an oath. It creates real liability that can affect the whole community, and it can be committed without knowing. Here it is the breach shown by God's silence.
  • in v39

    who saves Israel

    hammôšîaʿ ʾet-yiśrāʾēl

    What we hear
    God as Saviour from sin, spiritual salvation.
    What they heard
    God as the one who rescues Israel in war and gives victory over enemies, here the Philistine rout that had just happened through Jonathan (14:23).
  • in v39

    As surely as the LORD lives / as the LORD lives

    ḥay-YHWH

    What we hear
    A pious statement that God is alive, or a loose religious exclamation.
    What they heard
    A binding oath. The speaker calls on God's own life as guarantee and as enforcer, with an implied curse on himself if he fails to keep it (spelled out in v.44).
  • in v41

    Give a perfect lot (KJV) / Give perfection (YLT)

    havah tamim (originally probably havah tummim)

    What we hear
    A request for a flawless or morally perfect outcome, or a plea that God judge perfectly.
    What they heard
    "Give Thummim": a command to produce one particular result from the sacred lots. Even if you take the Hebrew as it stands, tamim here would mean "a complete, true answer", not moral perfection.
  • in v41

    the people escaped

    ha'am yatsa'u

    What we hear
    The soldiers fled, or guilty men got away with something.
    What they heard
    The people "came out" clear of the lot. They were excluded from the guilty group and declared not liable.
  • in v41

    were chosen / selected

    vayyillakhed

    What we hear
    Picked for something, possibly an honour.
    What they heard
    "Caught" or "captured" by the lot: singled out as the side carrying the guilt.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֣אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v36, v38, v41

    The ordinary narrative verb 'and he said', moving the story on directly from Saul's altar-building in 14:35 to his next plan.

  2. שָׁא֡וּל

    Sha'ul · H7586G

    Saul · v36, v37, v38, v41

    Israel's first king. His name means 'asked (for)'. The sound of the name runs through this scene, which turns on 'asking' God (14:37, vayyish'al).

  3. נֵרְדָ֣ה

    nerdah · H3381

    let us go down · v36, v37

    An 'urging' form (cohortative: 'let us…'). Saul's army stands on the highlands near Michmash and Aijalon, so pursuing means literally going down toward the coastal plain where the Philistines are fleeing.

  4. אַחֲרֵי֩

    acharei · H0310A

    after · v36, v37

    'After, behind': in pursuit of a fleeing enemy.

  5. פְלִשְׁתִּ֨ים׀

    Phelishtim · H6430G

    Philistines · v36, v37

    The Philistines, the dominant military power over Israel at this time (13:19–22). There is no article here: 'after Philistines', which reads like a battle cry.

  6. לַ֜יְלָה

    laylah · H3915

    night · v36

    Used as a time expression, 'by night'. Saul wants to keep fighting through the dark, straight after a day in which his men had fought without food because of his oath (14:24).

  7. וְֽנָבֹ֥זָה

    venavozzah · H0962

    and let us plunder · v36

    A second 'let us'. The verb is the normal one for stripping a defeated enemy of goods, livestock and gear. In Israel's world this was the expected reward of victory.

  8. בָהֶ֣ם׀

    vahem · H9038

    among them / in them · v36

    'Plunder among them': loot their camp and their columns as they flee.

  9. עַד־

    ad- · H5704

    until · v36

    Sets the limit: the raid would go on all night. It echoes, in reverse, Saul's earlier 'until evening' oath (14:24).

  10. א֣וֹר

    'or · H0216

    light · v36

    'The light of the morning', or (as the supplied data tags it) 'the morning's growing light'. Either way it means first light at dawn.

  11. הַבֹּ֗קֶר

    habboqer · H1242

    the morning · v36

    Daybreak. Together with the previous word: 'until dawn'.

  12. וְלֹֽא־

    velo- · H3808

    and not · v36, v37

    A firm negative attached to the next verb: 'and let us not leave…'

  13. נַשְׁאֵ֤ר

    nash'er · H7604

    we will leave (remaining) · v36

    The causative form, 'leave remaining, let survive'. 'Not leaving a survivor' is stock language for total destruction in Israel's war accounts (e.g. Josh 10:28–40).

  14. אִ֔ישׁ

    'ish · H0376I

    man, anyone · v36

    'A man', meaning not a single one. In context these are the Philistine soldiers in flight.

  15. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v36, v38, v39

    'All, whatever': they place no limits on what Saul may decide.

  16. הַטּ֥וֹב

    hattov · H2896A

    the good · v36

    'What is good', meaning what seems best or right. Here it is a judgment of usefulness, not moral goodness.

  17. בְּעֵינֶ֖יךָ

    be'eineikha · H5869I

    in your eyes · v36

    'In your eyes', a Hebrew idiom for 'in your judgment'. The decision is left wholly to Saul's own view.

  18. עֲשֵׂ֑ה

    'aseh · H6213A

    do! · v36

    A command form used as consent: 'Do it!' The soldiers are deferring to the king, not ordering him. A paragraph marker (ס) follows in the Hebrew manuscripts, setting off what the priest says next.

  19. הַכֹּהֵ֔ן

    hakkohen · H3548

    the priest · v36

    Ahijah son of Ahitub, of the house of Eli. He was with Saul's army carrying the ephod (14:3), the priestly garment through which God was consulted.

  20. נִקְרְבָ֥ה

    niqrevah · H7126G

    let us draw near · v36

    A third speaker's 'let us', which matches Saul's 'let us' in form but turns his direction around: not 'let us go down after the Philistines' but 'let us come near to God'. 'Drawing near' is the regular verb for formally approaching God at a sacred place or object.

  21. הֲלֹ֖ם

    halom · H1988

    here, hither · v36, v38

    'Here, to this spot': most likely the altar Saul had just built (14:35), where the priest and the ephod were.

  22. אֶל־

    el- · H0413

    to, toward · v36, v41

    Direction toward: approach to God.

  23. הָאֱלֹהִֽים׃

    ha'elohim · H0430G

    God · v36, v37, v41

    'The God', with the article. This form is common in scenes of consulting God for a ruling (Judg 18:5; 20:18; 1 Sam 14:37), much like saying 'the divine authority'.

  24. וַיִּשְׁאַ֤ל

    vayyishʾal · H7592

    to ask · v37

    With the preposition ב (“of/by God”) this is the set phrase for formally consulting God through a priestly oracle, not just saying a prayer. The verb also echoes Saul’s name, since both come from the same root.

  25. הֲתִתְּנֵ֖ם

    hatittenem · H5414G

    give · v37

    “Will you give them?” This is the second yes-or-no question, put straight to God. The two questions sit side by side with no linking word, which is how oracle questions are usually framed (compare 23:2–4; 30:8).

  26. בְּיַ֣ד

    beyad · H3027H

    hand; power · v37

    “Into the hand of,” meaning into the power or control of. Together with “give,” it forms the standard holy-war promise that God hands an enemy over.

  27. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    yisraʾel · H3478

    Israel · v37, v39, v41

    Israel as a fighting people. Saul asks about victory for the nation, not only for himself.

  28. עָנָ֖הוּ

    ʿanahu · H6030B

    to answer · v37, v39

    “He answered him.” The subject is God, understood rather than named. Joined to “not,” it states plainly that the oracle gave no answer, neither yes nor no.

  29. בַּיּ֥וֹם

    bayyom · H3117G

    day · v37, v38

    “On the day.” This ties the silence to this particular day, the day of the victory and of Saul’s oath.

  30. הַהֽוּא׃

    hahuʾ · H1931

    that · v37

    “That (day).” It points back to the day the chapter keeps marking: “the LORD saved Israel that day” (v. 23), and Saul’s curse on anyone eating “until evening” (v. 24).

  31. גֹּ֣שֽׁוּ

    goshu · H5066

    draw near, approach · v38

    A plural command: 'come close!' It is the formal word for stepping forward before a leader, a judge or God. It picks up the same verb in this chapter: Saul had the ephod 'brought near' (v. 18) and the oxen 'brought near' (v. 34). Now the leaders themselves are summoned forward for investigation.

  32. פִּנּ֣וֹת

    pinnot · H6438

    corners; cornerstones · v38

    Literally 'corners'. The image is of cornerstones that hold a building together, so it means the chief men, the ones the people rest on. Translations rightly say 'chiefs' or 'leaders', but the picture of load-bearing stones is lost.

  33. הָעָ֑ם

    ha'am · H5971

    the people · v38, v39, v41

    'The people' here means the fighting men of Israel gathered for battle, the people as an army. That is why BSB says 'troops'.

  34. וּדְע֣וּ

    uda'u · H3045

    and know · v38

    A plural command, 'and know'. Joined to the next word it forms a set phrase meaning 'find out, work it out' (see below).

  35. וּרְא֔וּ

    ur'u · H7200

    and see · v38

    'And see.' Together, 'know and see' is a standard Hebrew phrase for 'investigate and establish the facts' (as in 1 Sam 23:22–23, 24:11, 25:17). It does not ask for vague awareness. It asks for a verdict.

  36. בַּמָּ֗ה

    bammah · H4100

    in what? how? by what? · v38

    Literally 'in what'. It can ask where the offence lies, how it came about, or through what or whom it happened. WEB's 'in whom' reads ahead to the lot-casting that follows. The Hebrew form itself is neutral ('what', not 'who').

  37. הָֽיְתָ֛ה

    hayetah · H1961

    has been, has come about · v38

    'Has come to be.' Saul treats the sin as an established fact, already present among them. God's silence has convinced him that something has gone wrong. What he does not know is where.

  38. הַחַטָּ֥את

    hachatta't · H2403

    sin, offence; guilt · v38

    'The offence.' Here it means a breach that leaves a real liability hanging over the whole camp and cuts off God's answer. It is not mainly a private moral failing. It can be committed without knowing, as Jonathan's eating of honey was.

  39. הַזֹּ֖את

    hazzot · H2063

    this · v38

    'This' sin, the particular one shown by God's refusal to answer. Saul points at it as something that clearly exists, though nobody can yet name it.

  40. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588A

    for · v39

    Links the oath to Saul's command in v.38 to find out 'how this sin happened today'. It gives the reason for the search: whoever is guilty will die.

  41. חַי־

    ḥay · H2416A

    alive, life · v39

    Opens the standard Israelite oath, 'by the life of YHWH'. The speaker stakes his word on God's own life. This is a solemn vow, not a remark about God's existence.

  42. יְהוָ֗ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    the LORD (divine name) · v39, v41

    Israel's God, named by his personal name. Swearing by the name calls him in as witness to the oath and as the one who will enforce it.

  43. הַמּוֹשִׁ֙יעַ֙

    hammôšîaʿ · H3467

    to save, deliver · v39

    'The one who delivers', a participle naming God by an ongoing action. In context it means military rescue: v.23 has just said 'YHWH delivered Israel that day', and he did it through Jonathan's raid.

  44. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v39

    Marks Israel as the object of the delivering. It has no English equivalent.

  45. אִם־

    ʾim · H0518B

    if · v39

    Sets up the condition: 'if it turns out that…'. English versions render it 'even if' or 'though', which brings out how far Saul is willing to go.

  46. יֶשְׁנ֛וֹ

    yešnô · H3426

    there is (+ 'it') · v39

    Literally 'it-is-there'. The 'it' refers back to 'this sin' in v.38. Saul pictures the sin as something lodged inside a person that must be found.

  47. בְּיוֹנָתָ֥ן

    bîhônātān · H3129N

    in Jonathan · v39, v41

    'In Jonathan.' The name means 'YHWH has given', which is ironic, because God has just given victory through him. The 'in' matters: the guilt is pictured as residing in him.

  48. בְּנִ֖י

    bĕnî · H1121A

    my son · v39

    Saul names his own heir as the extreme case. It shows how far he will go, and it also points the reader toward who is actually guilty.

  49. מ֣וֹת

    môt · H4191

    to die (infinitive) · v39

    An intensifying infinitive placed before the verb: 'dying he will die', meaning 'he will certainly die'. It is the language of a death sentence.

  50. וְאֵ֥ין

    wĕʾên · H0369

    and there is not · v39

    'And there was none…' This brings in the narrator's comment: total silence.

  51. הָבָה

    havah · H3051

    give! · v41

    An urgent imperative with an added ending for emphasis ("come, give!"). It is blunt, and here it amounts to "produce the answer" through the sacred lots.

  52. תָמִים

    tamim (likely originally tummim) · H8549

    perfect, whole / Thummim · v41

    As pointed in the Hebrew text it is the adjective "whole, perfect, blameless". Most scholars think it was originally Tummim (Thummim), one of the two sacred lots. The longer Greek text supports that reading.

  53. וַיִּלָּכֵד

    vayyillakhed · H3920

    and was taken (captured) · v41

    Literally "was captured". The verb is used for cities and animals caught in a trap, and it is the technical term for being singled out by lot, as in Achan's case (Josh 7:16–18) and Saul's own selection as king (1 Sam 10:20–21).

  54. יָצָאוּ

    yatsa'u · H3318

    they went out · v41

    Literally "went out". Here it means they came out clear of the lot: they were exempted and left out of the guilty group. It does not mean they ran away.

The world behind it

The battle. This is the evening of the battle of Michmash, in the late 11th century BC. Jonathan's surprise raid (14:1–15) set the Philistine garrison running, and Israel chased them west from Michmash to Aijalon (14:31), down from the central highlands toward the coastal plain. Saul's force was small, about 600 men (14:2), and poorly armed, because the Philistines controlled metalworking (13:19–22).

Saul's oath. Saul had bound the army under a curse: no food until evening, "until I have avenged myself on my enemies" (14:24). Jonathan did not know of the oath and ate honey (14:27). At evening the starving troops slaughtered captured animals on the ground and ate them with the blood (14:32), which broke the law in Lev 17:10–14 and Deut 12:23–24. Saul set up a large stone so the animals could be slaughtered properly, and built an altar, "the first altar he built to the LORD" (14:35). That altar is almost certainly the "here" of this verse.

Asking God before battle. In Israel, as across the ancient Near East, armies sought a divine ruling before they fought. In Israel this was done through a priest with the ephod and the Urim and Thummim (Num 27:21). These were lot-like objects that gave yes/no answers, and God could also give no answer at all (1 Sam 28:6). Compare David, who repeatedly has the priest bring the ephod before he moves against an enemy (23:9–12; 30:7–8). Earlier that same day Saul had broken off a consultation in mid-procedure (14:18–19). The priest's words here put the procedure back in place, and the silence that follows (14:37) leads to the lot-casting that exposes Jonathan (14:38–42).

From the study of 1 Samuel 14:36.

Where scholars differ

in v36

Is the priest's intervention a rebuke of Saul, or simply routine?

  • A pointed correction: the narrator shows the king about to act without consulting God, and the priest has to supply the piety Saul lacks.

    Saul had already cut off a consultation (14:19). His rash oath and the army's blind deference ('whatever is good in your eyes') frame the scene, and in the wider story the contrast with David, who asks God constantly, is sharp (23:2–12; 30:7–8).

  • A normal procedural step: priests went with armies precisely to make sure God was consulted, and Saul complies at once.

    Saul accepts immediately and asks God (14:37). He has just built an altar (14:35), and priests accompanying armies were part of standard holy-war practice (Deut 20:2–4). On this view the narrative weight falls on God's silence, not on Saul's neglect.

in v36

Why did God not answer (v. 37), the result this verse sets up?

  • Because of the guilt incurred when Jonathan broke the oath, which is the explanation the story itself goes on to give.

    Saul concludes there is sin in the camp, and the lot falls on Jonathan (14:38–42). This matches the pattern of Achan in Josh 7.

  • Because the problem lay with Saul: his rash oath, or the army's eating with the blood that his oath had caused.

    Jonathan criticises the oath (14:29–30). The people rescue Jonathan (14:45), which suggests the narrator does not fully back Saul's verdict. Many commentators (e.g. Alter, Klein) read the episode as exposing Saul's misjudgment more than Jonathan's guilt.

in v37

Why did God not answer Saul?

  • Because of Jonathan’s breach of the oath. The silence reveals that the curse Saul pronounced had been violated, and the lot then exposes Jonathan.

    This is the logic inside the story: v. 38 calls it “this sin,” the lot falls on Jonathan (v. 42), and Jonathan admits eating (v. 43). It matches the Achan pattern in Josh 7.

  • Because of Saul’s own conduct. The rash oath, which led the troops to eat meat with the blood (vv. 24, 32–33), and Saul’s rule-bound piety are the real problem. The narrator undercuts Saul’s reading of events.

    Jonathan criticises the oath (“my father has troubled the land,” v. 29, using the Achan verb ʿakar). The troops say Jonathan “worked with God this day” and ransom him (v. 45). The silence also anticipates 28:6. This reading is taken by many literary readers (e.g. Polzin, Alter, Klein).

  • Both. The narrator leaves the tension unresolved on purpose.

    The narrator never says outright whose sin caused the silence. Saul’s sacral reasoning is presented as plausible but leads toward killing the man God had used for the victory.

in v37

How did the oracle work, and what did “no answer” look like?

  • The Urim and Thummim were two lots giving yes/no (or one of two options), and there was some way of getting a non-answer, perhaps a third outcome or a refusal procedure.

    1 Sam 28:6 lists Urim as a channel that could give no answer. The paired questions in 23:9–12 and 30:7–8. The LXX of 14:41.

  • The mechanism is unknown. Some (e.g. Van Dam) argue the Urim involved a light or a prophetic word linked to the high priest, not simple lots.

    The Old Testament never describes the procedure. Answers sometimes go beyond yes/no (Judg 20:18; 1 Sam 10:22; 2 Sam 5:23–24).

in v38

Where does the real 'sin' of the day lie?

  • In Jonathan's breach of the oath, as the lot indicates.

    The lot falls on Jonathan (v. 42). Oaths bound the community even when broken unknowingly, and Lev 4–5 treats unintentional offences as real.

  • In the people's eating meat with the blood.

    Verse 33 explicitly calls this 'sinning against the LORD' (ḥ-ṭ-ʾ). It happened that same day, just before the oracle fell silent.

  • In Saul's own rash oath, with the narrator quietly blaming the king.

    Jonathan says 'my father has troubled the land' (v. 29), using the same verb as Achan's 'troubling' of Israel (Josh 7:25). The people later reject Saul's sentence and ransom Jonathan (v. 45), and the narrative around this chapter steadily presents Saul's religious acts as misjudged (13:8–14; 15).

in v39

Was Jonathan actually guilty, and is the narrator endorsing Saul's oath?

  • Jonathan technically broke a binding oath, so the lot rightly falls on him. The story is about how sacred and dangerous oaths are.

    The lot takes Jonathan (v.42) and he admits the act (v.43). Oaths in God's name were held binding even when rash (Judg 11; Josh 9:19–20).

  • The narrator presents the oath itself as Saul's folly. Jonathan acted in ignorance, and the people's oath and ransom correct an unjust sentence.

    Jonathan had not heard the oath (v.27). He says Saul 'troubled the land' (v.29). The people declare Jonathan 'worked with God' (v.45). Saul's repeated rash death sentences (22:16) fit a negative portrait of him.

in v39

Why does no one answer Saul?

  • Fear: no one dares contradict a king who has just sworn by God's life.

    The king's oath raises the stakes for anyone who speaks. The troops' compliant reply in v.40 ('do what seems good to you') suggests intimidation.

  • Quiet solidarity with Jonathan: some knew he ate the honey and would not betray him.

    A soldier told Jonathan of the oath (v.28), so the eating was witnessed. The people later intervene openly for him (v.45). The narrator's echo of God's silence (v.37) makes the people's silence pointed.

in v41

Is the longer text in the Greek original, or did the Greek add to the Hebrew?

  • The longer text is original, and the Hebrew lost it through a copying slip.

    There is an obvious trigger for the eye to skip (the repeated "Israel"). The surviving "give tamim" fits naturally as the end of the longer prayer. The Greek's Urim/Thummim pairing reads like a translation of real Hebrew. Driver, McCarter, Klein and most modern versions take this view.

  • The short Hebrew is original, with tamim meaning "give a true or complete answer". The Greek expanded it to explain.

    Ancient translators sometimes fill out a terse text. The Hebrew as it stands is grammatical. The KJV, NASB 1995 and older Jewish translations ("Declare the right") keep it.

in v41

What were the Urim and Thummim, and how did they give answers?

  • Two lots, giving yes/no or A/B answers.

    This verse sets up a two-way choice. 1 Sam 14:37 and 28:6 show the oracle could also give no answer. Other ancient Near Eastern cultures used binary lots in divination.

  • Gemstones or objects that gave a sign through light or some other marker.

    Josephus (Antiquities 3.214–218) and some later Jewish tradition say the high priest's stones shone. The possible link of Urim with 'or, "light", is cited in support. Cornelis Van Dam's monograph (1997) argues for a stone that lit up to confirm a priest's spoken word. The evidence for all of these is thin.

in v41

Does the narrator approve of the lot's verdict and of Saul's oath?

  • The lot works correctly: Jonathan did technically break the oath, and Saul was the one who imposed it.

    The lot falls accurately on the side that includes both the man who broke the oath and the man who made it. The verb echoes Joshua 7.

  • The episode exposes Saul's rash oath as the real problem.

    Jonathan calls the oath harmful (14:29). The people overrule Saul and rescue Jonathan, saying he "worked with God" (14:45). God's silence comes before Jonathan is identified and is never explained only by what Jonathan did.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. קָרַב, בָּזַז, שָׁאַר, הֲלֹם
  • HALOT s.v. קרב, בזז, שׁאר
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (on 14:18, 36)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible) on 14:18–46
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 14 (oracular consultation, ephod, Urim and Thummim)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 14:18, 36, 41
  • Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'spoil' (historical senses)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. שׁאל (consulting a deity/oracle with ב)
  • HALOT s.v. ענה I
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible, 1980), on 14:18, 36–42
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary, 1983)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (1999), notes on 1 Sam 14
  • Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist (1989)
  • Cornelis Van Dam, The Urim and Thummim: A Means of Revelation in Ancient Israel (1997)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) 1 Kingdoms 14:18, 37, 41
  • BDB s.v. פִּנָּה
  • HALOT s.v. פִּנָּה
  • HALOT s.v. חַטָּאת
  • BDB s.v. נָגַשׁ
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 14:36–46
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary), on 14:36–46
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 14
  • Joshua 7; Judges 20:2; Isaiah 19:13; Zechariah 10:4 (parallel usage)
  • BDB s.v. חַי, יָשַׁע, יֵשׁ, עָנָה
  • HALOT s.v. חַי (oath formula), יָשַׁע hiphil
  • Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew, on כִּי in oaths and the intensifying infinitive
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 14:36–46 and the LXX
  • Lachish Ostraca, Letter 3 (ḥy YHWH oath formula)
  • Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), line 4 (root yšʿ)
  • Septuagint, 1 Reigns (1 Samuel) 14:39, 41 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 14:39
  • BDB s.v. תָּמִים, תֻּמִּים, לָכַד, יָצָא
  • HALOT s.v. תֻּמִּים and אוּרִים
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (2nd ed., 1913), on 1 Sam 14:41
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8, 1980)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • Septuagint, 1 Reigns (1 Samuel) 14:41; NETS translation
  • Josephus, Antiquities 3.214–218
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 14:41

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.