1 Samuel Chapter 18 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 18:7–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7And as the women danced, they sang out: “Saul has slain his thousands, and David his tens of thousands.” 8And Saul was furious and resented this song. “They have ascribed tens of thousands to David,” he said, “but only thousands to me. What more can he have but the kingdom?” 9And from that day forward Saul kept a jealous eye on David.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this was a familiar scene: the women's victory chant, a short, rhythmic, easily repeated couplet sung back and forth during the homecoming dance. They would have recognised the thousand/myriad pairing as standard poetic language, the kind used in blessings and war songs (Deut 32:30; 33:17).

In the story, the verse marks a turning point. Up to here the David story has been a rise of public favour. From here Saul begins to watch David with suspicion (v. 9: 'Saul eyed David from that day on'). Hearers would catch the irony. The women came out to honour 'King Saul' (v. 6), but their song gives the climax to David. The crowd in effect announces what Samuel had foretold, that the kingdom was passing to someone 'better than you' (15:28). The song's later return in Philistine mouths (21:11; 29:5) shows how far David's fame has gone beyond his status. Even foreigners treat him as 'the king of the land'.

The verse also shows how public praise could make or break a leader. It invites hearers to see that Saul's problem was less the song than his reaction to it.

From the study of 1 Samuel 18:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7And as the women danced, they sang out: “Saul has slain his thousands, and David his tens of thousands.”

    The women of Israel's towns had come out with drums and dancing to meet the returning army (v. 6). Now, as they danced and celebrated, they sang the song in answering halves, one group calling out a line and the other answering it:

    "Saul has struck down his thousands — and David his ten thousands!"

    The verb for "sang" is the Hebrew word for answering. It pictures the call-and-response singing of a victory celebration, the way Miriam led the women after the crossing of the Sea (Exod 15:21). "As they danced" translates a word for festive play and merrymaking. It is the word used for David celebrating before the LORD (2 Sam 6:5). "Struck down" is the battlefield verb the narrator has just used for David killing Goliath (v. 6), so the song takes that single fight and inflates it.

    The couplet uses a stock pair from Hebrew (and older Canaanite) poetry: thousand in the first line, myriad in the second. In that kind of poetry the second line repeats the first and heightens it, and the pair could simply mean "a great many, and even more". So the women were probably not giving an exact tally. But the heightened line, and the last word, belonged to David. The king who had come out to be honoured heard himself placed beneath his own young warrior. The next verse records his reaction: "They have given David myriads, and to me only the thousands. What more is left for him but the kingdom?"

    The verse holds both things together: joyful public praise, and a comparison that becomes the seed of Saul's jealousy.

    Full study →
  2. 8And Saul was furious and resented this song. “They have ascribed tens of thousands to David,” he said, “but only thousands to me. What more can he have but the kingdom?”

    Anger flared up in Saul like a fire, and it burned hot. The women's song looked wrong to him, offensive in his eyes. The narrator is careful to say this is how Saul saw it. He brooded aloud: "They have handed David the myriads, countless tens of thousands, and to me they have handed the thousands. All that is left for him now is the throne itself."

    The women had sung a standard piece of victory poetry. In Hebrew and older Canaanite verse, "thousands" in one line is regularly answered by "ten thousands" in the next, a conventional way to say "a great multitude" in rising tones. Saul hears it as a scoreboard, with David on top. His final words are not a full sentence in Hebrew, just a clipped, bitter "and still for him only the kingship". They show the fear underneath his anger. Samuel had already told him the kingship would be torn from him and given to "a neighbour who is better than you" (15:28). Without knowing it, Saul has guessed correctly who that neighbour is. The next verse gives the result: from that day on he kept a suspicious eye on David.

    Full study →
  3. 9And from that day forward Saul kept a jealous eye on David.

    And from that day on, Saul became a man who never stopped eyeing David.

    The Hebrew verb is built from the word eye. Saul "eyed" David, and the grammar makes it continuous: not one sour look but a settled habit of watching him. Just before this, the women's victory song ("Saul has struck down his thousands, and David his tens of thousands") was "evil in Saul's eyes" (v. 8). So the eyes that saw the song as an insult now fix on David with suspicion and grudging envy, the kind of look the Bible elsewhere calls an "evil eye". Saul has already said what he fears: "What more can he have but the kingdom?" His watching is the look of a king who sees a rival in his own court, measuring every success the young man has as a loss to himself.

    "From that day and onward" marks a permanent turning point. The next verse moves straight from Saul's eyeing to an "evil spirit" and a thrown spear. Seeing wrongly comes first, and violence follows.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    answered (KJV)

    'anah

    What we hear
    Replied to someone's question or remark.
    What they heard
    Sang in alternating parts, with one group singing a line and another singing the reply. It is a musical term for antiphonal singing.
  • in v7

    played (KJV, WEB, NASB)

    məśaḥaqot

    What we hear
    Played games, or played instruments.
    What they heard
    Celebrated, made merry, danced: festive public rejoicing with drums and dance, as in 2 Sam 6:5 and Jer 31:4.
  • in v8

    the kingdom

    ha-melukhah

    What we hear
    A territory or realm; in church use it may also suggest 'the kingdom of God'.
    What they heard
    The kingship: the royal office and the right to rule Israel, the throne Saul now holds.
Every word
  1. וַֽתַּעֲנֶ֛ינָה

    vatta'aneynah · H6030C

    to sing, to answer in song · v7

    The women sang back and forth to each other, one group taking up a line and another answering it. The same root means 'to answer', and here the two senses meet: call-and-response singing.

  2. הַנָּשִׁ֥ים

    hannashim · H0802G

    women · v7

    The women from 'all the cities of Israel' (v. 6). In Israel, women traditionally came out to meet returning warriors with song. In practice they were the people who announced and settled a victor's public reputation.

  3. הַֽמְשַׂחֲק֖וֹת

    hamsaḥaqot · H7832

    laugh; play; make merry, dance · v7

    The verb's intensive form (participle): 'the women who were celebrating', meaning dancing, drumming and festive play. It is the word used when David 'celebrated' before the LORD in 2 Sam 6:5, 21, not children's games.

  4. וַתֹּאמַ֑רְןָ

    vattomarna · H0559

    to say · v7, v8

    'And they said.' This is the usual Hebrew way of opening a quotation. It brings in the words of the song itself.

  5. הִכָּ֤ה

    hikkah · H5221

    to strike, strike down, defeat, kill · v7

    'Has struck down.' This is the standard verb for beating or killing enemies in battle. It is the same verb used in v. 6 for David 'striking' the Philistine (Goliath), so the song picks up the narrator's own word.

  6. שָׁאוּל֙

    sha'ul · H7586G

    Saul · v7, v8, v9

    The reigning king, who stands first and gets the first half of the couplet. The women came out to meet 'King Saul' (v. 6).

  7. בַּאֲלָפָ֔יו

    ba'alafav · H0505G

    thousand; also a clan or military unit · v7, v8

    Literally 'in/by/among his thousands.' Most take it to mean 'his thousands' of slain enemies. The word can also mean a fighting unit, so the line might picture Saul striking with his troops. The small preposition is hard to pin down (see debates).

  8. וְדָוִ֖ד

    vedavid · H1732

    and David · v7, v8, v9

    The young warrior, placed second. In Hebrew poetry the second line is where the parallel gets heightened, and that is where David's name falls.

  9. בְּרִבְבֹתָֽיו׃

    berivevotav · H7233

    myriad, ten thousand, a vast number · v7, v8

    'In/by his myriads.' Revavah is the usual poetic partner of 'thousand', meaning ten thousand or simply 'countless'. It is the bigger number, and Saul hears it as the bigger praise (v. 8).

  10. וַיִּ֨חַר

    vayyiḥar · H2734

    to burn, be hot (with anger) · v8

    Anger pictured as heat that flares up. The verb is impersonal, literally 'it burned', so the anger comes over Saul as something that ignites inside him rather than a calm decision.

  11. מְאֹ֗ד

    me'od · H3966

    very, exceedingly · v8

    Intensifies the burning: this is not irritation but fury.

  12. וַיֵּ֤רַע

    vayyera' · H7489

    to be bad, evil, displeasing · v8

    Literally 'it was bad'. Together with 'in his eyes' it is a fixed idiom for something a person judges wrong and finds offensive, not a statement that the song was morally evil.

  13. בְּעֵינָיו֙

    be-'einav · H5869

    eye(s) · v8

    'In his eyes', meaning 'in his judgment, from his point of view'. The phrase stresses that this is how Saul saw it; the narrator does not say the women meant it as an insult.

  14. הַדָּבָ֣ר

    ha-davar · H1697

    word, saying, matter, thing · v8

    'The word/saying': here the women's song line just quoted in v. 7, though davar can also mean 'the whole affair'.

  15. הַזֶּ֔ה

    ha-zeh · H2088

    this · v8

    Points back to the refrain of v. 7: 'this saying'.

  16. נָתְנ֤וּ

    natenu · H5414

    to give · v8

    'They gave', meaning they assigned or credited. Saul hears the song as the people handing out honour, and handing out more of it to David.

  17. וְלִ֥י

    ve-li

    and to me · v8

    'And to me', placed first in its clause to set Saul against David: David this, but me that.

  18. וְע֥וֹד

    ve-'od · H5750

    still, yet, more, besides · v8

    'And still / and what remains'. It points to the one thing David has not yet received.

  19. ל֖וֹ

    lo

    to him, for him · v8

    'For him': David. The Hebrew has no verb here, a clipped, brooding remark.

  20. אַ֥ךְ

    'akh · H389

    only, surely, nothing but · v8

    'Only': all that is left for David to get is the kingship itself.

  21. הַמְּלוּכָֽה׃

    ha-melukhah · H4410

    kingship, royal rule · v8

    'The kingship': the office and right to rule, the same word used when Saul 'took the kingship over Israel' (14:47). Saul sees his throne itself at stake.

  22. וַיְהִ֥י

    wayhî · H1961

    and he was · v9

    Combined with the participle that follows ('was ... eyeing'), it describes an ongoing, settled state rather than one glance. Saul became someone who was always watching David.

  23. עוֹיֵ֣ן

    ʿôyēn · H5770

    to eye, look at (with suspicion or envy) · v9

    A verb formed from the noun 'eye' (ʿayin), found only here in the Bible. It is a participle, so the action is continuous: Saul 'was eyeing' David. In context this is a hostile, suspicious, envious watching, picking up 'the thing was evil in his eyes' from v. 8.

  24. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H853

    [direct object marker] · v9

    Untranslatable marker showing that David is the one being eyed.

  25. מֵהַיּ֥וֹם

    mēhayyôm · H3117

    from the day · v9

    'From' marks a turning point. The day of the victory song is when Saul's attitude toward David changed for good.

  26. הַה֖וּא

    hahûʾ · H1931

    that · v9

    Points back to the specific day of the women's song in vv. 6–8.

  27. וָהָֽלְאָה׃

    wāhālᵊʾāh · H1973

    and onward, beyond · v9

    Literally 'and further on'. With 'from that day' it is a fixed phrase meaning 'from then on' (compare Lev 22:27; Num 15:23; Ezek 39:22). It stresses that this was permanent, not a passing mood.

The world behind it

Women's victory songs. In ancient Israel, as across the ancient Near East, women traditionally went out from the towns to meet a victorious army with hand-drums (tof), dancing and song. Compare Miriam (Exod 15:20-21), Deborah's song (Judg 5), Jephthah's daughter coming out 'with tambourines and dances' (Judg 11:34) and the processions of Ps 68:25. Archaeologists have found many clay figurines of women holding frame-drums. Carol Meyers has argued that such women's performance groups were a recognised public role.

Public praise as reputation. In an honour-based society, what the crowd sang about a man was his reputation. The women's song worked like a public verdict, and it spread. The Philistine servants of Achish quote it (21:11), and so do the Philistine commanders years later (29:5). For a king whose position rested on military success (8:20, 'to go out before us and fight our battles'), being given the smaller number in a popular song felt like a political threat. Saul says so outright in v. 8.

Within the story. By this point Samuel has already told Saul that the kingdom will go to 'a neighbour of yours, who is better than you' (15:28). David has been secretly anointed (16:13). So when the women's verdict ranks David above Saul, readers recognise what Saul only fears.

From the study of 1 Samuel 18:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

Did the women intend to rank David above Saul, or was the thousand/myriad pair a conventional compliment to both?

  • The pairing was a stock poetic formula and not meant as a slight. Saul read an insult into it.

    Thousand//myriad is a fixed pair in Hebrew (Deut 32:30; 33:17; Ps 91:7; Mic 6:7) and in Ugaritic poetry (alp//rbt). In such pairs the second, larger term is a matter of form, not a literal ratio (argued e.g. by S. Gevirtz, Patterns in the Early Poetry of Israel).

  • The song, at least as the narrator presents it, does exalt David over Saul.

    Hebrew parallel lines normally heighten in the second line, and David gets that line and the last word. Saul's reaction in v. 8 states the comparison. The Philistines treat the song as proof of David's fame (21:11; 29:5). The narrator has already said the kingdom is passing to one 'better than you' (15:28). Many commentators (e.g. Alter, McCarter, Klein) see a deliberate ambiguity that Saul resolves in the worst way.

in v7

What does 'in/by his thousands' (ba'alafav) mean?

  • 'His thousands' of slain enemies: the preposition marks what was struck, or works like 'by the thousands'.

    This is the natural reading, adopted by all major English versions, and it is supported by Saul's paraphrase in v. 8: 'they have given David myriads, and to me the thousands'.

  • 'With/among his thousands', meaning his military units: Saul struck the enemy at the head of his regiments.

    'Elef often means a clan-based fighting unit (1 Sam 8:12; 17:18; 18:13; Judg 6:15). The preposition be- commonly means 'with' or 'among', as YLT and the Greek render it. This is a minority view and harder to fit with the singular combat of David.

in v8

Did the women's song intend to rank David above Saul?

  • No. The 'thousands … ten thousands' pairing is a fixed poetic formula honouring both men equally, and Saul misreads it.

    The same pairing appears as a stock formula in Ugaritic and biblical poetry (KTU 1.4 I 28–29; Deut 33:17; Ps 91:7; Mic 6:7). The narrator says the saying was bad 'in his eyes', marking it as Saul's perception (argued e.g. by S. Gevirtz, *Patterns in the Early Poetry of Israel*).

  • Yes, at least on the narrator's level. Whatever the convention, the story uses the rising numbers to signal that David really is greater.

    The Philistines repeat the couplet and call David 'king of the land' (21:11). The surrounding chapter stresses that 'all Israel and Judah loved David' (18:16), and 15:28 already promised the kingship to a 'better' man. Many narrative critics (e.g. Alter, *The David Story*) see deliberate double meaning.

in v9

Does the verb mean envious looking, suspicious watching, or both?

  • Envy: the 'evil eye' of begrudging another's success.

    V. 8 says the song was 'evil in his eyes', and Hebrew elsewhere uses 'evil eye' for grudging envy (Deut 15:9; Prov 28:22). Saul is upset that David gets more credit.

  • Suspicion: a king watching a possible usurper.

    Saul's own words in v. 8 ('What more can he have but the kingdom?') and Samuel's prophecy in 15:28 make it fear for the throne. The Greek renders it 'looking askance' and NASB translates 'with suspicion'.

  • Both, inseparably.

    The verb, found only here, is built only from 'eye', so it does not itself specify the emotion. The context supplies both wounded honor and political fear, and the two feed each other in vv. 8–15.

in v9

Was v. 9 part of the earliest form of the story?

  • No: it belongs to a later expansion found in the longer Hebrew text.

    The shorter Old Greek (Vaticanus) apparently lacks vv. 9–11. Some scholars (e.g. following Tov and McCarter) see the longer Hebrew as combining two versions of the David–Saul story.

  • Yes: the Greek abridged a longer original.

    Others argue the Greek translator or its source shortened the narrative to smooth repetitions and tensions. On that view the Hebrew is the original.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. עָנָה IV ('sing'), שָׂחַק, נָכָה, אֶלֶף, רְבָבָה
  • HALOT s.v. ענה IV, שׂחק (Piel 'play, dance, make merry')
  • S. Gevirtz, Patterns in the Early Poetry of Israel (1963), on the thousand//myriad pair
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • Carol Meyers, work on women's drum-dance-song ensembles in ancient Israel
  • Emanuel Tov, on the shorter Septuagint text of 1 Samuel 17–18
  • Ugaritic Baal Cycle (alp//rbt parallelism)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. חָרָה, רָעַע, רְבָבָה, מְלוּכָה
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible, 1980), on 1 Sam 18:6–9
  • S. Gevirtz, Patterns in the Early Poetry of Israel (1963), on the 'thousands // ten thousands' word pair
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (1999)
  • D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
  • Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.4 I 28–29
  • Vulgate, 1 Regum 18:8
  • BDB s.v. עִין (denominative from עַיִן)
  • HALOT s.v. עין
  • Masoretic Ketiv/Qere note at 1 Sam 18:9 (BHS)
  • Rahlfs Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 18 (shorter text of Codex Vaticanus)
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 18:9
  • P. Kyle McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • E. Tov, 'The Composition of 1 Samuel 16–18 in the Light of the Septuagint Version'

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).