2 Maccabees Chapter 9 Read as one passage
2 Maccabees 9:1–3
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1Now about that time, Antiochus retreated in disorder from the region of Persia. 2For he had entered into the city called Persepolis, and he attempted to rob a temple and to control the city. Therefore the multitudes rushed in and the people of the country turned to defend themselves with weapons; and it came to pass that Antiochus was put to flight by the people of the country and broke his camp with disgrace. 3While he was at Ecbatana, news was brought to him about what had happened to Nicanor and the forces of Timotheus.
What the first hearers heard
2 Maccabees was written for Greek-speaking Jews, including those in Egypt, as the festival letters in chapters 1–2 show. It aimed to explain and promote the festival of the temple's purification (Hanukkah) and the later Day of Nicanor. Its readers knew Antiochus Epiphanes as the arch-persecutor. Chapters 6–7, with the deaths of Eleazar and the mother and her seven sons, had left them asking whether God would act.
This verse begins the answer. The book's theology, stated in 6:12–16, is that God disciplines his people quickly but lets the nations fill up their sins before judging them. Antiochus's measure is now full. By opening with a retreat "without order" and with disgrace, the writer tells an honour-conscious audience that the king's prestige, the basis of a Hellenistic monarch's power, has already collapsed.
The link to chapter 8 ("about that time") would also have registered. At the same moment as the Jews' victory over Nicanor, and as the Jews were proven to have a divine champion (8:36), their oppressor was being humiliated a thousand miles away. A temple-robber in Jerusalem had now been caught robbing temples in the east. The irony points toward the vivid poetic justice of the rest of the chapter: the man who thought he could "touch the stars of heaven" (9:10) is carried on a litter, rotting.
From the study of 2 Maccabees 9:1.
Verse by verse
-
1Now about that time, Antiochus retreated in disorder from the region of Persia.
Full study →Around that same time, it so happened that Antiochus had already pulled out of the districts of Persis. His army was in disarray and his retreat was unworthy of a king.
The verse opens the death story of Antiochus IV Epiphanes, the king who had banned the Jewish law, defiled the Jerusalem temple and tortured the martyrs of chapters 6–7. "That time" ties his eastern disaster to the defeat of his general Nicanor in Judea, told just before (8:34–36). There Nicanor threw off his fine clothes and slipped home "like a runaway slave", and admitted that the Jews had God fighting for them. Now the king himself is shown in the same state.
The Greek says he "happened to have withdrawn". The withdrawal is already over, and the phrasing hints that the timing is more than chance. The key word, akosmōs, means "without order". It describes broken ranks and lost dignity at once: an army in confusion and a king in disgrace. Verse 2 confirms both readings. He had tried to rob a temple, the local people took up arms, and he was routed and made a "shameful retreat".
So the man who had plundered God's temple in Jerusalem (5:15–21) is first seen in his final chapter caught trying the same thing elsewhere, and running.
-
2For he had entered into the city called Persepolis, and he attempted to rob a temple and to control the city. Therefore the multitudes rushed in and the people of the country turned to defend themselves with weapons; and it came to pass that Antiochus was put to flight by the people of the country and broke his camp with disgrace.
Full study →This verse is a flashback that explains why the king was fleeing Persia "in disorder" (9:1). Antiochus had already marched into the famous city the Greeks called Persepolis, the old royal capital of Persia. There he set his hand to temple-robbery, a single Greek word for the recognised and notorious crime of stripping a sanctuary of its sacred treasure, and tried to get the city itself into his grip. That provoked the response you would expect: the whole population surged out and turned to armed defence. And so it came about that Antiochus, the self-styled "god made manifest," was routed by the locals, ordinary people of the land rather than a rival king's army, and had to break camp and pull his army out in a retreat that was disgraceful and stripped of all royal dignity.
The narrator's wording sets up an irony. The king who had plundered the Jerusalem temple (5:15–21) tries the same sacrilege elsewhere and is beaten by the people whose temple it is. In 2 Maccabees, temple robbers do not go unpunished, and this shameful retreat begins the fall that the rest of chapter 9 describes.
-
3While he was at Ecbatana, news was brought to him about what had happened to Nicanor and the forces of Timotheus.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v1
the country of Persia
hē Persis (tōn kata tēn Persida topōn)
- What we hear
- 'Persia' sounds like the Persian Empire or the modern nation of Iran, a foreign land Antiochus had invaded.
- What they heard
- Persis, the province in southwest Iran (Fars). In 165–164 BC it was a nominal part of Antiochus's own Seleucid empire, run partly through local rulers. The Persian Empire had ended with Alexander more than 160 years earlier.
-
in v1
came … out of (KJV, Brenton)
analelykōs
- What we hear
- A neutral 'came from', as if Antiochus was simply travelling back.
- What they heard
- 'Having broken camp and withdrawn': a military pullback, here a rout. Together with akosmōs it describes a beaten king in retreat, not a journey.
-
in v2
to rob the temple
hierosylein
- What we hear
- To steal from the temple, and with KJV's 'the,' easily taken to mean the Jerusalem temple.
- What they heard
- One technical verb with no object: 'to commit temple-robbery.' It names a recognised category of sacrilege (stripping a sanctuary's sacred treasure), treated in the Greek world as a capital crime. Here the temple is a local sanctuary in Persia, not Jerusalem.
Every word
-
Περὶ
peri · G4012
about, around · v1
With the accusative of time it means 'around' or 'about': a loose time marker, not an exact date.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, now, but · v1
A light connecting word that moves the story to a new scene. Here it turns from Nicanor's defeat in Judea (ch. 8) to the king in the far east.
-
τὸν
ton · G3588
the · v1, v2
The article with 'time'.
-
καιρὸν
kairon · G2540
time, season, moment · v1
'That time' means the same period as Nicanor's humiliating flight (8:34–36). The writer is linking the two events on purpose.
-
ἐκεῖνον
ekeinon · G1565
that · v1
Points back to the events just told. The king's defeat is set beside his general's.
-
ἐτύγχανεν
etynchanen · G5177
happen, chance to be · v1
Paired with a participle in good literary Greek, it means 'it so happened that he had…' or 'just then he had…'. It marks a timing that comes together, and the writer lets the reader see more than chance in it.
-
Ἀντίοχος
Antiochos · G490
Antiochus · v1
Antiochus IV Epiphanes, the Seleucid king who banned Jewish law and defiled the temple (ch. 5–6). The whole book has been heading toward his end.
-
ἀναλελυκὼς
analelykōs · G360
loosen, depart, break camp, return · v1
A perfect participle: 'having withdrawn' or 'having pulled out'. The withdrawal is already done and its result still holds. In military use the word means striking camp and moving off.
-
ἀκόσμως
akosmōs
in disorder; unseemly, disgracefully · v1
Literally 'without order (kosmos)'. It points both to a disordered army and to a retreat unfit for a king. Verse 2 spells it out: a 'shameful retreat'.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v1
Marks the region he left.
-
κατὰ
kata · G2596
throughout, in the area of · v1
'The places throughout Persis' means the districts of that region generally, not one city.
-
Περσίδα
Persida
Persis · v1
The province of Persis (modern Fars, in southwest Iran), the old Persian homeland and in this period an eastern part of the Seleucid realm. (Strong's G4069 is the same word used as a woman's name in Rom 16:12, so it is not applied here.)
-
τόπων
topōn · G5117
place, region · v1
'Places' or 'districts'. The vague plural fits a writer far away in Judea who is not trying to map the campaign.
-
Εἰσεληλύθει
eiselēlythei · G1525
had entered · v2
The tense is pluperfect: 'he had entered.' It looks back from the disorderly retreat of 9:1 to explain what had happened before it.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v2
Signals that this verse explains 9:1, telling why Antiochus was retreating from Persia 'in disorder.'
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into · v2
Movement into the city. He had actually got inside, not merely camped nearby.
-
λεγομένην
legomenēn · G3004
called, named · v2
'The [city] called Persepolis.' This is a standard way of introducing a foreign place name to Greek readers who might not know it.
-
Περσέπολιν
Persepolin
Persepolis · v2
The old ceremonial capital of the Persian kings, burned by Alexander in 330 BC. The name was famous, but other accounts place this episode at a temple in Elymais (see setting and debates).
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v2
Links the entry to what he then tried to do.
-
ἐπεχείρησεν
epecheirēsen · G2021
attempted, set his hand to · v2
Literally 'put his hand to.' It means he undertook the robbery. The verb does not say the attempt failed, but the story shows that it did.
-
ἱεροσυλεῖν
hierosylein · G2416
to rob temples, commit sacrilege · v2
A single word for the recognised crime of plundering a sanctuary. The Greek has no object, so 'the temple' or 'a temple' is supplied by translators. In 2 Maccabees, temple robbery is the crime that brings divine punishment.
-
πόλιν
polin · G4172
city · v2
The city itself, as distinct from its sanctuary. He wanted both the treasure and control of the place.
-
συνέχειν
synechein · G4912
to hold fast, grip, control · v2
'To hold the city in his grip': to occupy it and keep it under his control. It suggests force rather than lawful government.
-
διὸ
dio · G1352
therefore · v2
Presents the uprising as the direct result of his sacrilege and attempted seizure.
-
δὴ
dē · G1211
indeed, then · v2
A small particle that adds emphasis: 'and so, naturally…'
-
πληθῶν
plēthōn · G4128
multitudes, masses · v2
The plural, 'the masses' or 'the crowds,' pictures the whole population turning out, not a trained army.
-
ὁρμησάντων
hormēsantōn · G3729
rushed, surged · v2
A sudden, violent rush, the same verb used of the pigs charging down the slope in the Gospels. It describes a spontaneous popular surge.
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
to, toward · v2
Marks what they turned to: armed defence.
-
ὅπλων
hoplōn · G3696
weapons, arms · v2
'The help of weapons': they took up arms to defend their sanctuary and city.
-
βοήθειαν
boētheian · G996
help, aid, rescue · v2
Literally 'running to a cry for help.' Combined with 'weapons,' it means they rushed to armed defence.
-
ἐτράπησαν
etrapēsan
they turned · v2
'They turned to' armed help. The subject is most naturally the crowds, who resorted to arms. The same verb can also mean 'they were turned back,' and this is part of why older English versions blur the clause (see textual notes).
-
συνέβη
synebē · G4819
it happened, it came about · v2
'It turned out that…' The narrator states the outcome flatly, but irony is coming.
-
τροπωθέντα
tropōthenta
having been routed · v2
A military word for an army broken and turned to flight. It comes from the same root as Greek tropaion, 'trophy,' the monument the victors set up where the enemy turned and ran.
-
Ἀντίοχον
Antiochon
Antiochus · v2
Antiochus IV, who called himself 'Epiphanes' ('God made manifest'). He is the king who plundered and defiled the Jerusalem temple. His name stands at the centre of the sentence as the one who was routed.
-
ὑπὸ
hypo · G5259
by · v2
Names who routed him.
-
ἐγχωρίων
enchōriōn
natives, local inhabitants · v2
'The people of the land.' These were ordinary locals defending their own place, not a rival king's army, which makes the defeat more humiliating.
-
ἀσχήμονα
aschēmona · G809
shameful, unseemly, disgraceful · v2
'Without proper form.' The retreat was undignified and dishonouring, the opposite of how a king was supposed to appear. It echoes 'in disorder' in 9:1.
-
ἀναζυγὴν
anazygēn
breaking camp, withdrawal · v2
Literally 'yoking up again': harnessing the pack animals to march away. It is a military term for an army's withdrawal, and here the withdrawal is a forced one.
-
ποιήσασθαι
poiēsasthai · G4160
to make · v2
'He made his withdrawal a shameful one.' The verb form puts Antiochus himself as the one carrying out the humiliating retreat.
The world behind it
The king and the campaign. Antiochus IV Epiphanes ruled the Seleucid empire, one of the Greek kingdoms carved out of Alexander's conquests, from 175 to 164 BC. In 165 BC he went east to restore royal control and, above all, to raise money. Seleucid finances had been strained since Rome imposed a huge war payment on his father, Antiochus III (the Peace of Apamea, 188 BC). Temple treasuries were a tempting source. Antiochus III had himself died in 187 BC while plundering a temple of Bel in Elymais.
What other sources say. The Greek historian Polybius (31.9) reports that Antiochus IV tried to rob a wealthy temple (of "Artemis", probably the goddess Nanaia) in Elymais, was driven off by the local people, and died soon afterwards at Tabae in Persis, "in a fit of madness" according to some. 1 Maccabees 6:1–16 tells much the same story: the attempt at Elymais, the retreat, news of Jewish victories, and death from grief. 2 Maccabees 9:2 names Persepolis instead, the old Persian royal city burned by Alexander. A Babylonian king list dates his death to the month of Kislev, year 148 of the Seleucid era (late 164 BC).
Persis in this period. Persis (Fars, in southwest Iran) was the homeland of the old Persian kings. Under the Seleucids it was a province governed partly through local rulers who were increasingly independent. Antiochus was not invading a foreign "Persian empire". He was trying to squeeze wealth out of the edges of his own realm and failing.
The literary pattern. Chapter 9 follows a well-known ancient story type: the gruesome death of the one who fought against God. It includes worms, rotting flesh, unbearable stench, and a late, self-serving confession (9:5–28). The same pattern appears in Josephus on Herod the Great's death and in Acts 12:23 on Herod Agrippa, "eaten by worms". Christian writers later used it for persecuting emperors, as in Lactantius, On the Deaths of the Persecutors. Verse 1 is the opening move: before God strikes the king's body, his dignity is already broken.
From the study of 2 Maccabees 9:1.
Where scholars differ
in v1
Where and how did Antiochus IV's last campaign fail?
-
At a temple in Elymais (the region of Susa), as Polybius and 1 Maccabees report. 2 Maccabees' 'Persepolis' is a mistake or a loose use of a famous Persian name.
Polybius 31.9 (a near-contemporary Greek historian) and 1 Macc 6:1–4 agree on Elymais. Persepolis had been largely ruined since 330 BC.
-
The two accounts can be reconciled: the campaign covered several places in Persis and Elymais, and 2 Maccabees names the best-known city.
The vague plural 'the places throughout Persis' in 9:1 suggests a wide region. Some settlement went on near Persepolis in Hellenistic times, and Antiochus died at Tabae in Persis (Polybius).
in v1
Did Antiochus die before or after the temple was rededicated?
-
After, as in 1 Maccabees. 2 Maccabees moved his death earlier for theological and literary reasons, so that the persecutor's fall comes before the restoration.
1 Macc 4–6 order. 2 Maccabees' clear thematic shaping. The Babylonian king list dates the death to Kislev 164 BC, which may be after 25 Kislev.
-
Before, or at about the same time, so 2 Maccabees' order may reflect real timing. The epitomist's 'about that time' is deliberately loose.
The same Babylonian date allows a death early in Kislev. News would have taken weeks to reach Judea, which explains 1 Maccabees' order of reports.
in v1
Does akosmōs here mean military disorder or moral disgrace?
-
Mainly military: a disorganised retreat (WEB, NRSV).
Analyō is a military verb ('break camp') and verse 2 describes a rout by armed locals.
-
Mainly disgrace: an unseemly, dishonourable retreat (Vulgate, KJV).
Verse 2 restates it as an 'unseemly' or 'shameful' (aschēmona) withdrawal, and the book is built on honour and shame and on reversal.
-
Both at once, which is the most natural Greek reading.
Kosmos means order and fitting display together. For a king, losing one meant losing the other.
in v2
Was the failed temple raid at Persepolis or at Elymais?
-
Elymais is historically correct, and 'Persepolis' is the narrator's or his source's error, or a deliberate use of a famous name.
Polybius 31.9 (sanctuary of Artemis in Elymais), 1 Maccabees 6:1–4 ('Elymais in Persia'), and the Nanea/Artemis temple of 2 Maccabees 1:13 all point to Elymais. Persepolis had been burned in 330 BC and lay in a region held by local Persian rulers. Antiochus III's death while robbing a temple in Elymais shows the region's temples were targets. This is the majority view in commentaries (e.g., Goldstein, Doran, Schwartz).
-
'Persepolis' may preserve a broader or loosely used tradition and need not be a simple blunder.
Persepolis was not completely abandoned after Alexander, and Persis held sanctuaries. Greek writers sometimes used 'Persepolis' or 'Persis' loosely for the Persian heartland. Even 1 Maccabees' 'Elymais in Persia' shows imprecise geography among ancient writers, so the difference may be one of labelling rather than of event.
in v2
How does this account relate to the death story in 2 Maccabees 1:13–16?
-
Two separate traditions about Antiochus IV were preserved side by side.
The opening letter (1:10–2:18) was attached to the epitome and was not written by the epitomist. It reports a version in which the king dies in the Nanea temple. Chapter 9 follows Jason of Cyrene's narrative, in which he is driven off and dies later on the road. The epitomist did not harmonise them.
-
The letter's story may originally concern a different king, possibly Antiochus III, or be a garbled early report.
Antiochus III was killed while plundering a temple in Elymais (187 BC), which fits 1:13–16 better than the illness-and-retreat story of chapter 9. An early, inaccurate report of Antiochus IV's death could also explain it.
Sources
- LSJ (Liddell–Scott–Jones) s.v. ἀκόσμως, ἄκοσμος, ἀναλύω
- BDAG s.v. ἀναλύω, τυγχάνω
- Polybius, Histories 31.9
- 1 Maccabees 6:1–16
- 2 Maccabees 1:13–16; 6:12–16; 8:34–36; 9:2–29
- Appian, Syriaca 66
- Babylonian Seleucid king list (BM 35603), Sachs & Wiseman, Iraq 16 (1954)
- J. A. Goldstein, II Maccabees (Anchor Bible 41A)
- R. Doran, 2 Maccabees (Hermeneia)
- D. R. Schwartz, 2 Maccabees (Commentaries on Early Jewish Literature)
- Vulgate, 2 Machabaeorum 9:1
- Lactantius, De mortibus persecutorum
- Septuagint, 2 Maccabees 9:1–3 (Brenton's edition; Hanhart, Göttingen Septuagint)
- LSJ s.v. ἱεροσυλέω, ἀναζυγή, ἐγχώριος, τροπόω
- BDAG s.v. ἱεροσυλέω, ἀσχήμων, ἐπιχειρέω, συνέχω
- T. Muraoka, A Greek-English Lexicon of the Septuagint, s.v. ἀναζυγή, ἀσχήμων
- 1 Maccabees 3:27–37; 6:1–4
- 2 Maccabees 1:13–16; 4:39–42; 5:15–21; 13:6–8
- Josephus, Antiquities 12.354–359; 4.207
- Romans 2:22; Acts 19:37
- Diodorus Siculus 28.3; 29.15 and Strabo 16.1.18 (death of Antiochus III)
- Babylonian king list (Sachs & Wiseman, Iraq 16, 1954) for the date of Antiochus IV's death
- J. A. Goldstein, II Maccabees (Anchor Bible, 1983)
- R. Doran, 2 Maccabees (Hermeneia, 2012)
- D. R. Schwartz, 2 Maccabees (CEJL, 2008)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.