2 Samuel Chapter 1 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 1:5–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

5Then David asked the young man who had brought him the report, “How do you know that Saul and his son Jonathan are dead?” 6“I happened to be on Mount Gilboa,” he replied, “and there was Saul, leaning on his spear, with the chariots and the cavalry closing in on him. 7When he turned around and saw me, he called out to me, and I answered, ‘Here I am!’ 8‘Who are you?’ he asked. So I told him, ‘I am an Amalekite.’ 9Then he begged me, ‘Stand over me and kill me, for agony has seized me, but my life still lingers.’ 10So I stood over him and killed him, because I knew that after he had fallen he could not survive. And I took the crown that was on his head and the band that was on his arm, and I have brought them here to my lord.”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite listeners this verse was the opening of a testimony to be weighed, not just a scene to picture. They had heard the narrator's account of Saul's death in 1 Samuel 31, and they would hear the gaps. The man insists his presence was an accident. He has Saul leaning on a spear, not falling on a sword. He brings chariots onto a hillside where the narrator mentioned archers. And he is an Amalekite carrying the crown.

The passage works in the larger story that defends David's rise to the throne. David did not kill Saul or arrange his death. When a man came claiming credit for it, hoping for a reward, David treated killing "the LORD's anointed" as a capital crime (vv. 14–16), and then mourned Saul and Jonathan in the Song of the Bow (vv. 17–27).

At the same time, the picture of Saul propped on his spear, hunted by the enemy's chariots, was a sad image of the first king's end. The spear, Saul's mark of power and his weapon against David, is now just a prop for a dying man.

From the study of 2 Samuel 1:6.

Verse by verse

  1. 5Then David asked the young man who had brought him the report, “How do you know that Saul and his son Jonathan are dead?”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 6“I happened to be on Mount Gilboa,” he replied, “and there was Saul, leaning on his spear, with the chariots and the cavalry closing in on him.

    The young man who had brought the news answered David's question, "How do you know?", by painting a scene. "I just happened to be there, purely by chance, on the Gilboa ridge," he insists. The Hebrew doubles the verb to stress that his presence was an accident, as though he expects to be asked why he was on that battlefield at all. "And look: there was Saul, propped up on his spear." The king is not standing tall. He is holding himself up on the same spear he once threw at David and Jonathan, now the only thing keeping him upright. "And look: the chariots and their horsemen had caught up with him," pressing right onto him with no way out.

    Twice he says "look!", pulling David into the scene as if he were seeing it with his own eyes. Every detail sets up what he says next: Saul was finished, trapped, and beyond saving. That prepares his claim, in verses 9–10, that he killed the king at Saul's own request. Readers who already know 1 Samuel 31 will notice the gaps. There, archers hit Saul and he falls on his own sword. That makes this eyewitness report something to weigh, not simply accept.

    Full study →
  3. 7When he turned around and saw me, he called out to me, and I answered, ‘Here I am!’

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 8‘Who are you?’ he asked. So I told him, ‘I am an Amalekite.’

    The young messenger is still telling David about Saul's last moments on Mount Gilboa: "And he said to me, 'Who are you?' And I said to him, 'An Amalekite — that's what I am.'"

    On the surface this is a simple exchange of identity. A dying king asks a stranger who he is and where he belongs, and the stranger names his people. But the man has chosen the one label in Israel's vocabulary most loaded with doom. Amalek was the people Israel was commanded never to forget and to blot out (Exod 17; Deut 25). It was the people Saul spared, and because of that sparing, Samuel declared, the kingdom was torn from Saul (1 Sam 15; 28:18). And it was the people David had just finished slaughtering after they burned his town of Ziklag (1 Sam 30; 2 Sam 1:1).

    So when the messenger says, in Hebrew word order, "Amalekite, I", the first hearers would have caught a bitter irony: by this man's account, Saul's end came at the hands of the very nation whose survival had cost him his crown. They would also have felt the danger. He is saying it to David, fresh from war with Amalek, while holding Saul's crown and armband and expecting a reward (v. 10; 4:10). The line is the hinge of the scene. In the man's story it explains why Saul could ask an outsider to do what his own armour-bearer would not. In the narrator's design it marks the man for judgement before David ever says a word.

    Full study →
  5. 9Then he begged me, ‘Stand over me and kill me, for agony has seized me, but my life still lingers.’

    The Amalekite tells David that the fallen king said to him: "Please, stand over me and finish me off. Something has gripped me, a spasm or seizure, the throes of a dying man. And yet my life is still all here in me."

    The picture is of a warrior down on the ground and badly wounded. He cannot get up and he cannot die. He begs a passing stranger to stand over him and give the final blow, the way a mortally wounded fighter might ask his armour-bearer to (compare Abimelech in Judges 9:54). "Stand over me" is the stance of the one who kills. The verb for "kill" here means finish off. The thing that has "seized" him is named with a word found nowhere else in the Bible. It means some kind of cramp, convulsion, faintness or agony, but its exact sense was already lost to the ancient translators, who rendered it "terrible darkness", "distress" and "trembling". The last clause, "all still my life in me", means "I am not dead yet." His life-breath stubbornly stays in his body.

    All of this is the Amalekite's report, not the narrator's. The reader has just read in 1 Samuel 31 that Saul fell on his own sword after his armour-bearer refused to kill him. The Amalekite's words echo that request a little too neatly, as if he is building a story in which the king asked him to do it.

    Full study →
  6. 10So I stood over him and killed him, because I knew that after he had fallen he could not survive. And I took the crown that was on his head and the band that was on his arm, and I have brought them here to my lord.”

    "So I stood over him, just as he asked, and gave him the death-blow, because I was certain that once he had gone down he was not going to live. Then I took the royal diadem, the band of his consecrated office, from his head, and the king's armlet from his arm, and I have brought them here, to you, my lord."

    The young Amalekite builds his story carefully. He borrows Saul's own words from the previous verse ("stand over me… kill me") so that the killing sounds like obedience and mercy. "I knew he would not live" is meant to remove any guilt. He then produces his proof: the two emblems everyone in Israel would recognise as the king's. The diadem (nezer) was more like a band than a modern jewelled crown, and its name comes from a word for being consecrated, the same word behind "Nazirite" and the high priest's holy gold plate. The armlet was a royal arm-band, not a wrist bracelet. Carrying these to David and calling him "my lord" is a political act: he is handing Saul's kingship to David and expecting to be rewarded for it.

    The first hearers, however, had just been told in 1 Samuel 31 that Saul fell on his own sword and his armour-bearer saw him die. They would hear this speech as a messenger trying to win favour, and they would note the bitter irony. Saul lost his throne over Amalek (1 Sam 15), and now an Amalekite says he killed Saul and walks in carrying Saul's crown. In the verses that follow, David treats the man's own words as a confession to killing "the LORD's anointed" and has him executed.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v6

    cavalry (BSB) / horsemen

    ba'alei happarashim

    What we hear
    An organised mounted branch of an army, soldiers fighting on horseback, separate from chariots.
    What they heard
    "Masters of horses": the men handling or riding the horses tied to the chariot force, probably chariot crews or riders and possibly their officers. Organised cavalry as a separate arm is not clearly attested this early.
  • in v6

    young man

    na'ar

    What we hear
    Just a description of age: a youngish man.
    What they heard
    Often a statement of status: an attendant, servant, or junior soldier, sometimes an adult. Here, a hanger-on at the edge of the army, a resident foreigner's son, not necessarily a youth.
  • in v9

    anguish (KJV, WEB)

    shabats

    What we hear
    Mental or emotional torment, heartbreak.
    What they heard
    Almost certainly a physical seizure: cramp, convulsion, giddiness or death-throes gripping a wounded body. The exact sense is uncertain.
  • in v9

    my soul (YLT)

    nafshî

    What we hear
    An immortal inner spirit about to depart for the afterlife.
    What they heard
    The life-breath and vitality of the body. 'My nefesh is still in me' means 'I am still alive.'
  • in v10

    crown

    nezer

    What we hear
    A tall jewelled crown of the kind worn by European monarchs.
    What they heard
    A royal diadem, probably a metal band or fillet around the head. Its name means "consecration" or "setting apart", and the same word names the high priest's holy gold plate.
  • in v10

    bracelet

    'ets'adah

    What we hear
    A light piece of jewellery worn on the wrist.
    What they heard
    A metal band worn on the arm (zeroa), a mark of royal or high rank, like the armlets kings wear in Assyrian reliefs.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֜אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    to say · v6, v8, v9

    "And he said". The ordinary verb that moves the story along, here bringing in the young man's answer to David's direct question in verse 5, "How do you know?"

  2. הַנַּ֣עַר

    hanna'ar · H5288

    youth, lad, attendant · v6

    "The young man". Na'ar can mean a youth, but it often points to rank more than age: a servant, aide, or soldier's attendant. He is someone who hangs around the edges of an army. Verses 8 and 13 reveal he is an Amalekite, the son of a resident foreigner.

  3. הַמַּגִּ֣יד

    hammaggid · H5046

    to tell, report, declare · v6

    "The one who was reporting". The form describes him by what he does, "the reporter, the messenger". Repeating it from verse 5 keeps the reader's eye on him as the bearer of news, and the narrator invites us to weigh his story.

  4. ל֗וֹ

    lo · H9033

    to him · v6

    "To him", that is, to David.

  5. נִקְרֹ֤א

    niqro · H7122

    to happen, meet by chance · v6

    An emphatic form of the verb placed before the main verb of the same root, roughly "by sheer chance". It stresses that he was there by accident and did not plan it. The spelling with aleph is a known alternative spelling of qarah, "to happen".

  6. נִקְרֵ֙יתִי֙

    niqreti · H7136

    to happen, chance upon · v6

    "I happened to be". Put together with the word before it: "I just happened to find myself". The doubled insistence that it was an accident sounds like someone getting ahead of an awkward question: why was this man on the battlefield at all?

  7. בְּהַ֣ר

    behar · H2022

    mountain, hill country · v6

    "On the mountain of". Har can mean a single peak or a whole ridge of hill country. Here it means the Gilboa range.

  8. הַגִּלְבֹּ֔עַ

    haggilboa' · H1533

    Gilboa · v6

    "The Gilboa". The ridge on the southeast edge of the Jezreel Valley where Israel made its last stand and Saul died (1 Samuel 28:4; 31:1, 8).

  9. וְהִנֵּ֥ה

    vehinneh · H2009

    behold, look · v6

    "And look!" A storyteller's word that drops the listener into the speaker's point of view, as if seeing the scene through his eyes. Here it is the first of two.

  10. שָׁא֖וּל

    Sha'ul · H7586

    Saul · v6

    Saul, Israel's first king. His death is the news being reported.

  11. נִשְׁעָ֣ן

    nish'an · H8172

    to lean, support oneself · v6

    "Leaning". The form describes a continuing state: Saul is propped up, holding himself upright by his weapon. The picture is of a wounded, worn-out man near collapse. Some readers also see in it a failed attempt to fall on his weapon.

  12. עַל־

    'al · H5921

    upon, on · v6, v9, v10

    "On, upon". The weight is resting on the spear.

  13. חֲנִית֑וֹ

    chanito · H2595

    spear · v6

    "His spear". Throughout 1 Samuel the spear is Saul's signature object. He hurls it at David (18:10–11; 19:10) and at Jonathan (20:33), and it marks his place as he sleeps (26:7, 11). The king's own emblem now holds up his failing body.

  14. הָרֶ֛כֶב

    harekhev · H7393

    chariot, chariotry · v6

    "The chariotry". The word is singular but refers to the whole chariot force. The Philistines were known for their chariots (1 Samuel 13:5).

  15. וּבַעֲלֵ֥י

    uva'alei · H1167

    owner, master, possessor of · v6

    "And the masters of". Ba'al plus a noun is a common Hebrew way of describing someone by what they own or do: a "master of horses" is a horseman or charioteer. It may point to the crews or riders, or to their officers.

  16. הַפָּרָשִׁ֖ים

    happarashim · H6571

    horseman; horse · v6

    "The horsemen / horses". Parash can mean either a horse (especially a chariot horse) or a rider. Joined to "chariotry", the phrase names the Philistines' mobile horse-drawn forces.

  17. הִדְבִּקֻֽהוּ׃

    hidbiquhu · H1692

    to cling; (this form) to overtake, catch up with · v6

    "Had caught up with him". The root means to cling or stick. In this form it means pursuers closing in until they are right on someone (compare Judges 18:22; 1 Samuel 14:22). It is the same verb used in 1 Samuel 31:2 for the Philistines pressing hard after Saul.

  18. לִ֖י

    lî · H9030

    to me · v8, v9

    'To me.' The messenger keeps himself at the centre of his own story: Saul turned to him, called him, questioned him.

  19. מִי־

    mî · H4310

    who? · v8

    The question word for persons. Asking 'who are you?' in this culture usually means asking about family, people or standing, not just a personal name.

  20. אָ֑תָּה

    ʾāttâ · H0859A

    you (masc. sing.) · v8

    'You.' Hebrew needs no 'are' here; 'Who you?' is a full sentence. Saul is shown asking a stranger to identify himself before making his request in v. 9.

  21. אֵלָ֔יו

    ʾēlāyw · H0413

    to him · v8, v9, v10

    'To him,' that is, to Saul.

  22. עֲמָלֵקִ֖י

    ʿămālēqî · H6003

    Amalekite · v8

    A member of Amalek, the people Israel's traditions marked as its permanent enemy. Saul lost his kingship over Amalek (1 Sam 15), and David has just come back from slaughtering Amalekites (2 Sam 1:1). For any Israelite hearer, this one word sets off alarm bells.

  23. אָנֹֽכִי׃

    ʾānōkî · H0595

    I · v8

    'I', the longer of Hebrew's two forms of the word. It comes last, after 'Amalekite'. Word order is flexible, but here it puts the identity first: 'An Amalekite, that's what I am.'

  24. עֲמָד־

    ʿămod · H5975

    stand · v9, v10

    A command, 'stand'. Paired with 'over me', it is the posture of a man standing above someone who has fallen, ready to give the final blow.

  25. נָ֤א

    nāʾ · H4994

    please, I pray · v9

    A softening word that turns the command into a plea: 'please'. The king is begging a foreigner, which deepens the picture of how far he has fallen.

  26. וּמֹ֣תְתֵ֔נִי

    ûmōtĕtēnî · H4191

    and kill me · v9, v10

    The intensive form of 'die', which means 'put to death'. It is used for finishing off someone already wounded. Abimelech uses this same word when he begs his armour-bearer to kill him (Judges 9:54).

  27. כִּ֥י

    kî · H3588

    for, because · v9, v10

    Gives the reason for the plea: he is in the grip of something unbearable.

  28. אֲחָזַ֖נִי

    ʾăḥāzanî · H0270

    it has seized me · v9

    'It has grabbed hold of me.' The verb is used of pangs and trembling taking hold of people (Exodus 15:14; Psalm 48:6). The Hebrew puts the verb before its subject, so the seizing comes first and its cause second.

  29. הַשָּׁבָ֑ץ

    haššābāṣ · H7661

    cramp, agony, dizziness (uncertain) · v9

    The word occurs only here in the Bible, so its exact meaning is unknown. It names some physical seizure: cramp, convulsion, giddiness or the faintness of dying. The sense of 'an affliction that has gripped him' is clear even though the precise symptom is not.

  30. כָל־

    khol · H3605

    all, whole · v9

    Paired with 'still' it makes an idiom: 'all still' means 'still wholly' or 'all the while'. Life has not yet drained out of him.

  31. ע֥וֹד

    ʿôd · H5750

    still, yet · v9

    'Still.' Death is taking its time. Job 27:3 uses the same phrase: 'as long as my breath is still in me.'

  32. נַפְשִׁ֖י

    nafshî · H5315

    my life, my life-breath · v9

    Here nefesh means the life-force that keeps a body alive, not a soul separate from the body. His life is 'still in him' because he is not yet dead.

  33. יָדַ֔עְתִּי

    yada'ti · H3045

    know · v10

    "I knew." He claims certainty that the wound was fatal, which makes the killing sound like mercy. KJV's "I was sure" catches the confidence well.

  34. לֹ֥א

    lo' · H3808

    not · v10

    Plain negation: he would not live.

  35. יִֽחְיֶ֖ה

    yichyeh · H2421

    live · v10

    "He would live." The verb looks forward from a point in the past: "he was not going to survive".

  36. אַחֲרֵ֣י

    'acharei · H310

    after · v10

    "After", fixing the moment as the point when Saul had already gone down.

  37. נִפְל֑וֹ

    niflo · H5307

    fall · v10

    "His falling." This can mean collapsing physically or falling in battle, which in Hebrew is a stock way of saying a man was cut down or defeated. "Fall" is the key word of the whole chapter (vv. 4, 12, 19, 25, 27: "How the mighty have fallen!"). It also recalls 1 Sam 31:4, where Saul "fell" on his own sword.

  38. וָאֶקַּ֞ח

    va'eqqach · H3947

    take · v10

    "And I took." A plain, quick verb for stripping the body. Taking things from the fallen was normal after a battle (compare 1 Sam 31:8–9).

  39. הַנֵּ֣זֶר

    hannezer · H5145

    diadem, crown; consecration · v10

    "The diadem": the king's own head-band of office, marked as the one everyone would recognise. It comes from a root meaning "set apart, consecrate". The same root gives the word "Nazirite", and the same noun names the high priest's holy gold plate.

  40. אֲשֶׁ֣ר

    'asher · H834

    which, that · v10

    Relative word: "which [was]".

  41. רֹאשׁ֗וֹ

    rosho · H7218

    head · v10

    "His head." The detail says the diadem was being worn: he took it from the body, not from a baggage cart.

  42. וְאֶצְעָדָה֙

    ve'ets'adah · H685

    armlet, arm-band · v10

    "And an armlet": a metal band worn on the arm. Kings across the ancient Near East wore these as symbols of rank. The only other place the word appears is the list of plundered gold ornaments in Num 31:50.

  43. זְרֹע֔וֹ

    zero'o · H2220

    arm, forearm; strength · v10

    "His arm." Zeroa means the arm, not the wrist, so the ornament was an armlet. In Hebrew the arm often stands for strength and power, which suits a royal ornament.

  44. וָאֲבִיאֵ֥ם

    va'avi'em · H935

    (causative) bring · v10

    "And I brought them." He has carried the king's emblems some 80 miles (about 130 km) to Ziklag. This is a deliberate gesture, not chance.

  45. אֲדֹנִ֖י

    'adoni · H113

    lord, master · v10

    "My lord": a respectful address. Coming right after the words about the crown, it quietly treats David as the next king and the messenger as his loyal servant who should be rewarded.

  46. הֵֽנָּה׃

    henah · H2008

    hither, here · v10

    "Here", to this place. The sentence ends with the objects now physically in David's presence.

The world behind it

Two accounts of one death. 1 Samuel 31:1–6 is the narrator's report. Archers find and badly wound Saul. He begs his armour-bearer to kill him so that "these uncircumcised" will not abuse him, and when the armour-bearer refuses, Saul falls on his own sword. In 2 Samuel 1 a man who later says he is an Amalekite arrives at Ziklag with torn clothes and dust on his head, the signs of mourning. He brings Saul's crown and armlet and tells a different story: he came on Saul by chance, and at Saul's request he killed him (vv. 9–10).

Why it matters who is speaking. Hebrew narrative often lets a character's speech differ from what the narrator has already reported, and leaves the reader to notice. The man is an Amalekite, from the people Saul was told to wipe out and failed to (1 Samuel 15). David has just come back from fighting Amalekites (1 Samuel 30; 2 Samuel 1:1). A foreigner showing up with royal insignia was plainly hoping for a reward from Saul's rival (compare 2 Samuel 4:10, where David says he gave that man "the reward for his news" by having him executed).

The battlefield. Gilboa is a limestone ridge above the eastern Jezreel Valley. The Philistines had come north and camped at Shunem, across the valley (1 Samuel 28:4). The valley floor suited their chariots. The ridge itself is steeper ground, where archers and infantry would have done most of the fighting.

From the study of 2 Samuel 1:6.

Where scholars differ

in v6

Is the Amalekite's account true, false, or a separate tradition?

  • He is lying, or at least making it up, to win David's favour.

    1 Samuel 31:4–5 has Saul die by his own sword, and the armour-bearer dies only after seeing that Saul is dead. The emphatic "by sheer chance" sounds defensive. He has chariots on a ridge where the narrator mentions archers. He clearly wants a reward (2 Samuel 4:10). He probably stripped the crown and armlet from the body, perhaps while looting the dead (compare 1 Samuel 31:8).

  • Both accounts can be partly true: Saul's suicide attempt failed and the Amalekite finished him.

    The image of Saul "leaning on his spear" could describe a botched attempt to fall on his weapon. Josephus (Antiquities 6.370–372) harmonises along these lines. Some older Jewish and Christian commentators followed him.

  • Two separate traditions of Saul's death have been placed side by side.

    Some historical-critical scholars think the differences (spear vs. sword, chariots vs. archers) are better explained as two traditions combined by the final editor than as a deliberate lie inside the story. Others reply that the narrative hints of self-interest point to a deliberate contrast by the narrator.

in v8, v9

Is the Amalekite telling the truth about killing Saul?

  • He is lying, or at least embellishing, in hope of a reward from David.

    The narrator's account in 1 Sam 31:4–5 has Saul die by his own sword, and the armour-bearer then kills himself, apparently after seeing that Saul was dead. The messenger's details (leaning on a spear, chariots closing in) do not match. He was likely stripping the dead, found Saul's body, took the crown and armband, and invented a mercy-killing to win favour. David's later summary, 'he thought he was bringing good news' (2 Sam 4:10), fits this reading. This is the majority view among modern commentators (e.g. McCarter, Anderson, Bergen).

  • Both accounts are true: Saul's suicide attempt failed, and the Amalekite finished him off.

    Josephus (Antiquities 6.370–372) harmonises the accounts in this way: Saul falls on his sword but is too weak to drive it home, sees the young man, learns he is an Amalekite, and asks him to finish the job. Supporters point to v. 9, 'agony has seized me, but my life still lingers', as consistent with a failed suicide. The difficulty is that 1 Sam 31:5 implies the armour-bearer saw Saul was dead.

  • The two accounts preserve different traditions, and the narrative does not require deciding.

    Some scholars see two traditions of Saul's death placed side by side. Either way, the story's point is the same. David condemns the man by his own words ('your mouth has testified against you', 1:16), and his guilt rests on what he claimed, whether or not it happened.

in v8

How does this Amalekite relate to the Amalek-ḥērem tradition?

  • Deliberate narrative irony and fulfilment of judgement.

    The thematic links (1 Sam 15; 28:18; 30; 2 Sam 1:1) are too close to be accidental. Saul's failure to finish Amalek ends with an Amalekite claiming Saul's life, and David, who did fight Amalek, executes the Amalekite. Many literary readers of Samuel stress this pattern.

  • The identity mainly serves to explain why an outsider could do what an Israelite would not.

    In the messenger's own story, being a foreigner explains why he would agree to kill the king when Saul's armour-bearer refused. The theological irony is real but belongs to the narrator, not the speaker. On this reading, v. 13's 'son of a gēr' is what sets up David's legal verdict.

in v9

What is shabats?

  • A physical seizure: cramp, convulsion, giddiness or death-throes.

    It is the subject of 'seize' (ʾāḥaz), a verb used elsewhere of pangs and trembling. There are possible cognates in other Semitic languages. Most modern lexicons (BDB, HALOT) take this view.

  • Loss of consciousness ('darkness').

    The Septuagint has 'terrible darkness'.

  • Saul's checkered armour or mail-coat.

    The root š-b-ṣ means 'woven in a pattern' in Exodus 28. Some medieval Jewish commentators take it this way.

in v10

Was the Amalekite telling the truth about killing Saul?

  • He invented or embellished the story to win David's favour. This is the majority view among commentators.

    The narrator's own account says Saul fell on his sword and his armour-bearer saw that he was dead (1 Sam 31:4–5). The Amalekite's details (Saul leaning on a spear, chariots and horsemen pressing in) do not match the archers of 31:3. David later says the man "thought he was bringing good news" (2 Sam 4:10), which implies he was after a reward. He probably found the body while stripping the dead (as the Philistines do the next day, 31:8) and took the insignia.

  • Both accounts are true: Saul's attempt on his own life failed and the Amalekite finished him.

    Josephus (*Ant.* 6.370–372) harmonises the accounts this way. Saul's line in v. 9, "my life is still in me", could fit a wound that was not immediately fatal. Against this, 1 Sam 31:5 says the armour-bearer saw that Saul was dead.

  • Two separate traditions about Saul's death have been placed side by side.

    Source-critical scholars (who study how earlier written sources were combined into the present text) point to the differing details and propose that the editor kept both. Many of them still note that, as the text now stands, the arrangement leads readers to doubt the Amalekite.

in v10

Does David's execution of the man depend on whether he really killed Saul?

  • No. He is condemned on his own testimony.

    In v. 16 David says, "Your blood be on your own head, for your own mouth has testified against you". By claiming to have killed the LORD's anointed, the man condemned himself whether the claim was true or not.

  • The narrator also intends the execution to show that David had no part in Saul's death.

    Readings of Samuel as a defence of David (e.g. McCarter, "The Apology of David") see the episode as a public demonstration that David did not seek or reward Saul's death.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. קָרָה, קָרָא II
  • HALOT s.v. נַעַר; פָּרָשׁ; דבק
  • BDB s.v. שָׁעַן
  • Josephus, Antiquities 6.370–372
  • 1 Samuel 31:1–6 (parallel account)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 1:1–16
  • Robert Alter, The David Story, notes on 2 Samuel 1
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 1
  • BDB s.v. עֲמָלֵק, עֲמָלֵקִי
  • HALOT s.v. עֲמָלֵקִי; s.v. אָנֹכִי
  • Masoretic Ketiv/Qere note at 2 Sam 1:8 (BHS)
  • Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms (2 Samuel) 1:8
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 1:8
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Robert D. Bergen, 1, 2 Samuel (New American Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 15; 30; 2 Sam 1
  • BDB s.v. שָׁבָץ
  • HALOT s.v. שָׁבָץ
  • BDB s.v. מוּת (Polel)
  • HALOT s.v. אחז
  • HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ
  • Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 1:9
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 1:9
  • Targum Jonathan to 2 Samuel 1:9
  • Josephus, Antiquities 6.14.7; 7.1.1
  • BDB s.v. נֵזֶר, אֶצְעָדָה, מוּת
  • HALOT s.v. נֵזֶר; אֶצְעָדָה
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., "The Apology of David," JBL 99 (1980)
  • J. H. Walton, V. H. Matthews, M. W. Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 1
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 2 Kingdoms 1:10
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 1:10

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.