Ecclesiastes Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Ecclesiastes 11:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4He who watches the wind will fail to sow, and he who observes the clouds will fail to reap. 5As you do not know the path of the wind, or how the bones are formed in a mother’s womb, so you cannot understand the work of God, the Maker of all things.

What the first hearers heard

To people who lived by the farming year, this verse needed no explanation. Every one of them had stood at the edge of a field squinting at the sky. They knew the farmer who always found one more reason to wait: too windy today, those clouds look heavy. They knew how that ended: no seed in the ground and no grain in the barn.

Inside Qoheleth's argument, the proverb does a specific job. The book has spent chapters taking apart people's confidence that they can know and control outcomes. A reader might draw the wrong conclusion: if nothing is certain, why risk anything? Verses 3–6 shut that door. Clouds will rain and trees will fall where they fall (v. 3). You cannot read the wind or the hidden work of God (v. 5). Uncertainty is part of the world God made. Watching harder will not remove it, and so it is no reason to hold back. Since you cannot know which effort will succeed, put seed in morning and evening (v. 6). The first hearers would have taken it as down-to-earth wisdom: risk is everywhere, and refusing to act is the one sure way to have no harvest.

From the study of Ecclesiastes 11:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4He who watches the wind will fail to sow, and he who observes the clouds will fail to reap.

    The man who keeps his eye fixed on the wind never gets his seed into the ground. The man who stands staring at the rain-clouds never gets his sickle into the grain.

    The picture comes straight from the farming year in ancient Israel. At sowing time a farmer walked his ploughed field and flung seed from his hand, and a strong gust could carry it off. At harvest he cut the ripe grain, and a sudden downpour could rot what lay cut in the field. So the worries are real. But the Hebrew describes people for whom watching has become a way of life: one who keeps watching, one who keeps gazing. The first verb is the word for a guard at his post. The man has made himself sentry over the wind. And the wind is just "a wind," any wind. He is waiting for a day with no breeze at all, and that day never comes.

    Each line ends the same way: not will he sow… not will he reap. That is a plain statement of what follows, not a command. Waiting for perfect conditions costs you both ends of the year, planting and harvest. The verse before says the clouds will rain when they are full whether anyone watches or not. The verse after uses the same word, ruach, for something no one can trace: "you do not know the way of the wind (or: of the breath of life)" any more than how a child forms in the womb, "so you cannot know the work of God." Watching the wind does not let you read it. The answer comes in verse 6: sow morning and evening, because you do not know which will succeed.

    Full study →
  2. 5As you do not know the path of the wind, or how the bones are formed in a mother’s womb, so you cannot understand the work of God, the Maker of all things.

    "Just as you don't know where the wind is going, or how the breath of life gets into a child's bones as they take shape inside a pregnant woman, so you don't know, and will never work out, what God is doing, the God who is at work in everything."

    The verse is built as one comparison: just as… so… It gives two everyday mysteries and then the point they illustrate.

    • The wind. One verse earlier, the farmer who keeps watching the wind never gets his seed in the ground (v. 4). The Hebrew word ruach means both "wind" and "breath / life-breath." So "the way of the wind" means the wind you can't predict, and it also leads into the next picture.
    • The womb. The pregnant woman is literally called "the full one," echoing the "full" rain clouds of verse 3. Inside her, bones take shape where no one can see. Ancient listeners would think of the life-breath that God alone gives (12:7). The weather in the sky and the life in the womb are both real, both happening, both full, and both completely closed to human inspection.
    • God's work. "In the same way, you will not know the work of God." This is the book's recurring phrase for God's activity in events (3:11; 8:17). God "does the all," and the Hebrew form means ongoing activity, not only creation at the beginning. Wind, rain, conception, success and failure all fall within what he is doing, and that is why none of it can be traced from below.

    The verse is not meant to leave the listener stuck. It sits between "the wind-watcher never sows" (v. 4) and "sow in the morning and don't stop in the evening, for you do not know which will succeed" (v. 6). Because you cannot know how God's work will turn out, don't wait for certainty. Act, spread your efforts, and keep working.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    regardeth (KJV, WEB 'regards')

    ro'eh be- (ra'ah with the preposition be-)

    What we hear
    Today 'regard' usually means to consider, think of, or esteem ('I regard him highly'), so 'he that regardeth the clouds' can sound like someone who takes the clouds seriously or respects them.
    What they heard
    To look at intently, stare, gaze at. The point is the man's fixed eyes and the work he never starts, not his opinion of the clouds.
  • in v5

    the way of the spirit (KJV, YLT); the spirit comes to the bones (ESV)

    derek hārûaḥ

    What we hear
    The Holy Spirit's ways, or an immaterial soul entering the body at some moment, a later theological and philosophical idea of 'soul'.
    What they heard
    The way of the wind or of the life-breath: moving air in the sky, and the breath of life that God gives to a body (Genesis 2:7; Ecclesiastes 12:7). It is a picture taken from nature and from the body, not a teaching about the Holy Spirit's work or about when a soul arrives.
  • in v5

    the Maker of all things (BSB); who maketh all (KJV)

    ʾăsher yaʿăśeh ʾet-hakkōl

    What we hear
    God as Creator at the beginning, who made the universe once.
    What they heard
    God who 'does / is doing' everything. The Hebrew form means ongoing activity, so it includes today's wind, a child forming now, and whether this season's crop succeeds, not only creation in the past.
Every word
  1. שֹׁמֵ֥ר

    shomer · H8104

    keep, guard, watch · v4

    An ongoing action: 'one who keeps watching.' It is the same verb used for a watchman on a wall or for Eli watching Hannah's mouth (1 Samuel 1:12). It pictures someone who keeps an anxious eye on the sky and never looks away from it to the field.

  2. ר֖וּחַ

    ruach · H7307

    wind, breath, spirit · v4, v5

    Moving air, here plainly the weather wind. There is no 'the' in Hebrew, so it means any wind at all: the man waits until no breeze is blowing. In the next verse the same word comes back for something nobody can track.

  3. לֹ֣א

    lo · H3808

    not · v4, v5

    A flat negative. It states what will happen, not a ban: this man simply will not get round to sowing.

  4. יִזְרָ֑ע

    yizra' · H2232

    to sow, scatter seed · v4

    Sowing by hand, flinging seed across ploughed ground. Wind really does carry seed off, so the man's worry is reasonable. The trouble is that it never ends. The Hebrew verb form points to what will follow from his watching: no seed goes into the ground.

  5. וְרֹאֶ֥ה

    vero'eh · H7200

    and one who sees / looks · v4

    'And one who keeps looking.' This matches 'one who keeps watching' in the first line, a second picture of the same person.

  6. בֶעָבִ֖ים

    ve'avim (be-'avim) · H5645

    (at) the clouds, thick rain-clouds · v4

    'At the clouds.' The little word 'at' (Hebrew be-) with the verb 'see' usually means staring, gazing intently. The 'avim are the dark clouds that carry rain, the same clouds that 'pour out rain upon the earth' in verse 3.

  7. יִקְצֽוֹר׃

    yiqtsor · H7114

    to reap, harvest · v4

    Cutting standing grain with a sickle. Rain on cut grain could ruin it, so the cloud-watcher holds off. But he keeps holding off until the crop is lost anyway. 'Sow' and 'reap' mark the two ends of the farming year.

  8. כַּאֲשֶׁ֨ר

    ka'asher · H0834D

    just as · v5

    Opens the first half of a 'just as… so…' comparison. Its partner is כָּכָה ('thus') in the middle of the verse.

  9. אֵֽינְךָ֤

    ʾênəkā · H0369

    there is not; you are not · v5

    The word for 'nothing / there is not' with 'you' attached: 'you are not [knowing]'. It is addressed to the individual listener, the same farmer-student spoken to in verses 4 and 6.

  10. יוֹדֵ֙עַ֙

    yôdēaʿ · H3045

    knowing · v5

    A participle, so it describes an ongoing condition: you are, as a matter of course, someone who does not know. The exact phrase comes back in verse 6 ('for you do not know which will succeed').

  11. מַה־

    mah- · H4100

    what? · v5

    'What [is]…': brings in an indirect question. You don't know what the wind's way is.

  12. דֶּ֣רֶךְ

    derek · H1870L

    way, road, manner · v5

    The route something takes, and also how it behaves. Here: where the wind comes from and where it goes, or how breath makes its way into a body.

  13. כַּעֲצָמִ֖ים

    kaʿăṣāmîm · H6106G

    like bones · v5

    'Like / as [with] bones': a short, verbless second comparison. You don't know the wind's way, just as you don't know about the bones in the womb. Bones stand for the body's frame taking shape. Some manuscripts read 'in the bones' (see variants).

  14. בְּבֶ֣טֶן

    bəbeṭen · H0990H

    in the womb of · v5

    The belly or womb: the hidden inner place where a child takes shape out of sight (compare Psalm 139:13–15; Job 10:8–11).

  15. הַמְּלֵאָ֑ה

    hamməlēʾāh · H4392

    the full [woman] · v5

    Literally 'the full one': a plain, earthy idiom for a pregnant woman. It picks up verse 3, where clouds 'full' of rain empty themselves (same root): full clouds and a full womb both carry something whose timing and shape no one controls.

  16. כָּ֗כָה

    kākāh · H3602

    thus, so · v5

    'So, in the same way': turns the two examples into the main point.

  17. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [object marker] · v5

    Marks 'the work of God' as the thing not known. It has no English equivalent.

  18. מַעֲשֵׂ֣ה

    maʿăśēh · H4639G

    work, deed, doing · v5

    'The work of': what God does, his activity in events, not only the finished creation. It is a set phrase in Ecclesiastes (3:11; 7:13; 8:17).

  19. הָֽאֱלֹהִ֔ים

    hāʾĕlōhîm · H0430G

    God · v5

    'The God', with the article, as Ecclesiastes normally names him. The book never uses the personal name YHWH. God is spoken of as the sovereign Creator over all people.

  20. יַעֲשֶׂ֖ה

    yaʿăśeh · H6213H

    does, makes · v5

    An imperfect form, so ongoing or habitual: 'who does / keeps doing'. The point is less 'who once created everything' than 'who is at work in everything that happens'.

  21. הַכֹּֽל׃

    hakkōl · H3605

    the all, everything · v5

    'The everything', the book's word for the whole of reality (as in 'all is breath/vapor', 1:2). God is behind all of it, including wind, rain, conception, success and failure (see 7:14).

The world behind it

The farming year. In the hill country of Israel, sowing came after the early rains softened the ground (roughly October–December). Seed was usually scattered by hand and then ploughed or scratched in, so a strong wind on sowing day could blow seed away or pile it up unevenly. Harvest came in spring: barley around April, wheat around May–June. Cut grain lay in the field before threshing, so rain then was a disaster ("like rain at harvest," Proverbs 26:1; Samuel's harvest thunderstorm was a terrifying sign, 1 Samuel 12:17–18). Rain is actually rare at wheat harvest in that climate. A man who stands watching every cloud then is being anxious beyond reason.

Reading the sky. Israelites knew their winds: the west wind off the sea brought rain (1 Kings 18:44–45; compare Luke 12:54), and the east wind off the desert was hot and dry. Watching the weather was ordinary good sense. Qoheleth (the book's Hebrew name for its speaker, "the Teacher") is not mocking that. He is describing good sense that has turned into paralysis.

The passage around it (11:1–6). This short section is built around not knowing. "You do not know what disaster may come" (v. 2), "you do not know the way of the wind" (v. 5), "you do not know which will succeed" (v. 6). Qoheleth repeatedly insists that people cannot see the future (8:7; 9:12; 10:14). He does not conclude that people should freeze. He concludes that they should act widely and with energy (compare 9:10, "whatever your hand finds to do, do it with your might").

From the study of Ecclesiastes 11:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

Is the verse a warning against overcaution, or just an observation about how things are?

  • Practical warning: excessive caution makes you unproductive, so act despite risk.

    Verse 6 follows directly with a command to sow morning and evening 'for you do not know which will succeed.' Most commentators (e.g. Murphy, Longman, Seow) read verse 4 as setting up that command.

  • A sober observation that belongs with verse 3's picture of events that cannot be controlled. It stresses human limits more than encouragement.

    Verse 3 describes things that simply happen (rain, a falling tree), and verse 5 stresses that people cannot know. Some interpreters (e.g. Fox, Krüger) say the passage's main concern is that the future cannot be known, and the call to act is how one copes with that limit, not cheerful optimism.

in v4

Is the cloud-watcher just a cautious farmer, or someone reading omens?

  • Ordinary weather-watching taken too far.

    The images (wind at sowing, rain clouds at harvest) match real farming risks exactly, and verse 3's clouds are plain rain-clouds. This is the majority reading.

  • There may be a side glance at divination by signs in the sky.

    Some scholars note that the word for a soothsayer (me'onen, Leviticus 19:26; Deuteronomy 18:10) has been linked, uncertainly, with 'anan, 'cloud.' But this verse uses 'av, not 'anan, and nothing in the context points to omens, so the suggestion is weak.

in v5

Does rûaḥ here mean 'wind' (two separate mysteries) or 'breath/spirit' entering the bones (one mystery)?

  • Wind: two parallel examples (wind; bones in the womb).

    Verse 4 has just used rûaḥ for the wind a farmer watches, and verse 3 talks about clouds. The standard Hebrew text reads 'like bones', which is naturally a second comparison. Many commentators and translations (KJV-tradition 'way', BSB, NIV, NASB) take it this way.

  • Breath/life-spirit: one example (how the life-breath comes into the bones of a fetus).

    Supported by the 'in the bones' reading of some manuscripts and the Targum. Ecclesiastes elsewhere uses rûaḥ for life-breath given by God (3:19–21; 12:7), and Ezekiel 37 pairs breath with bones. ESV and NRSV follow this, and so do a number of scholars (e.g. Seow).

  • A deliberate double meaning.

    Many interpreters (e.g. Fox, Krüger) think the Teacher exploits the word's range on purpose. The reader moves from the wind of v. 4 to the life-breath implied by the womb, and both examples illustrate the same hiddenness.

in v5

What does 'God who does everything' imply about how events are caused?

  • Strong divine control: God directly brings about all outcomes, including good and bad fortune.

    The ongoing 'does the all' together with 3:11, 3:14 ('whatever God does endures forever') and 7:14 ('God has made the one as well as the other').

  • The emphasis is on human ignorance, not on a theory of how God causes things.

    The sentence's structure is about what 'you do not know', and v. 6 applies it practically (sow anyway). Wisdom literature typically states God's sovereignty to humble people, not to build a philosophical system of determinism.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. שׁמר, רוּחַ, עָב, זרע, קצר
  • BDB s.v. שָׁמַר; רָאָה (with בְּ, 'look at, gaze upon')
  • Michael V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes (Eerdmans, 1999)
  • C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C, 1997)
  • Roland E. Murphy, Ecclesiastes (Word Biblical Commentary 23A, 1992)
  • Tremper Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT, 1998)
  • Thomas Krüger, Qoheleth (Hermeneia, 2004)
  • Oded Borowski, Agriculture in Iron Age Israel (1987)
  • Philip J. King and Lawrence E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (2001)
  • Gezer Calendar inscription (c. 10th century BC)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Ecclesiastes 11:4; Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 11:4
  • BDB s.v. רוּחַ, יָדַע, מָלֵא, מַעֲשֶׂה
  • HALOT s.v. רוּחַ; s.v. מָלֵא
  • C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C, 1997), on 11:1–6
  • Michael V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes (1999); JPS Bible Commentary: Ecclesiastes (2004)
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, critical apparatus at Eccl 11:5
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Ecclesiastes 11:5; Vulgate Ecclesiastes 11:5
  • 2 Maccabees 7:22 (comparative text)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).