Exodus Chapter 17 Read as one passage
Exodus 17:2–3
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
2So the people contended with Moses, “Give us water to drink.” “Why do you contend with me?” Moses replied. “Why do you test the LORD?” 3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?”
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites hearing this story, the verse explained two familiar names, Massah and Meribah, and made them a lasting warning. Their own scriptures returned to it again and again: 'Do not test YHWH your God as you tested him at Massah' (Deut 6:16), and 'Do not harden your hearts as at Meribah, as on the day of Massah in the wilderness' (Ps 95:8; compare Deut 9:22; 33:8; Ps 78; 106:32).
The verse taught them to tell three things apart:
- Need: being thirsty is not the sin, and God answers it immediately (vv. 5–6).
- Grumbling (lûn, v. 3): complaining against a leader.
- Putting God on trial (nissâ): treating God's presence as unproven and demanding he justify himself. This is the charge that sticks.
It also shaped how they understood the relationship between God, his spokesman and the people. Attacking God's appointed messenger is in the end an attack on the God who sent him (compare 16:8: 'Your grumbling is not against us but against YHWH'). Later Jewish and early Christian readers kept using the episode this way (Matt 4:7; 1 Cor 10:4, 9; Heb 3:7–11).
From the study of Exodus 17:2.
Verse by verse
-
2So the people contended with Moses, “Give us water to drink.” “Why do you contend with me?” Moses replied. “Why do you test the LORD?”
Full study →So the people brought their complaint against Moses: not a murmur of discontent but an angry confrontation, almost a charge in court, accusing him of failing the people he led out of Egypt. Together they demanded, without a word of courtesy: "You leaders, give us water, so we can drink!" Moses threw their own word back at them: "Why ever are you bringing a case against me? Why are you putting YHWH on trial?"
The two questions climb. On the surface the dispute is with Moses, but the camp is where it is because YHWH led them there (v. 1). So demanding that the leaders produce water is really a demand that God prove, once again, that he is present and able. Testing here does not mean being lured into sin. It means putting someone to the proof. Only a chapter earlier God was the one testing Israel (15:25; 16:4). Now Israel turns the test on him. The narrator will fix both accusations in the landscape: Massah ('Testing') and Meribah ('Quarrel'), 'because they tested YHWH, saying, "Is YHWH among us or not?"' (v. 7).
-
3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?”
Full study →There at Rephidim the people were desperately thirsty. A dry camp, families, flocks: this was the kind of thirst people die of. The whole community, acting as one body, rose up in open, angry protest against Moses. This was not quiet muttering under their breath; the next verse shows Moses afraid of being stoned. With one voice, as if each person were speaking for himself, they demanded: “Why on earth did you bring us up out of Egypt?” They used the words Israel normally used for God's great act of rescue, but they pinned it on Moses. “Was it so you could kill me, my children and my animals, everything I have, with thirst?” The verse begins with thirst and ends with thirst. Between the two, the people turn their rescue from slavery into a story of a leader who brought them out to die.
Where the English drifted
-
in v2
tempt (KJV: "wherefore do ye tempt the LORD?")
nāsâ / tənassûn
- What we hear
- Trying to lure God into doing wrong, or provoking a desire.
- What they heard
- Putting God to the proof: demanding that he show again, on the people's terms, that he is present and able, despite the evidence he has already given.
-
in v2
chide (KJV: "the people did chide with Moses")
rîv
- What we hear
- A mild scolding or rebuke.
- What they heard
- A hostile confrontation, close to bringing a legal accusation. By v. 4 Moses fears being stoned.
-
in v3
murmured (KJV, WEB, YLT); grumbled (BSB and most modern versions)
vayyalen (lun)
- What we hear
- Quiet, low-voiced muttering or petty grousing under one's breath: annoying but harmless.
- What they heard
- Open, collective protest against the leader God appointed, close to revolt. The next verse has Moses fearing he will be stoned, and the parallel in Num 14 includes plans to replace the leaders and go back to Egypt.
-
in v3
cattle (KJV)
miqneh
- What we hear
- Cows specifically.
- What they heard
- All livestock as property, including sheep, goats and cattle: a household's wealth.
Every word
-
וַיָּ֤רֶב
wayyārev · H7378
to contend, quarrel, bring a case · v2
'And (so) the people contended.' This is the verb behind the place name Meribah ('Quarrel') in v. 7. It means a hostile, accusing confrontation, the kind of complaint you would bring against someone in court, not a passing grumble. The verb is singular because 'the people' acts as one body.
-
הָעָם֙
hāʿām · H5971A
people · v2, v3
'The people': the whole congregation of v. 1, Israel as a kin-group and community. The word stresses them as one body confronting its leader.
-
עִם־
ʿim · H5973A
with · v2
'With.' Together with rîv it means 'to quarrel with, to have a dispute with': it names who the opposing party is.
-
מֹשֶׁ֔ה
mōsheh · H4872
Moses · v2, v3
Moses, God's appointed spokesman. The people aim their accusation at the human leader they can see.
-
וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ
wayyōʾmrû · H0559
to say · v2, v3
'And they said.' Now the verb is plural: the single body of the people breaks into many voices.
-
תְּנוּ־
tənû · H5414G
give · v2
'Give!' A blunt command, and plural ('you people, give'). It treats the leaders as the ones who owe the people water. Who the plural addresses is debated: perhaps Moses and Aaron together.
-
לָ֥נוּ
lānû · H9035
to us · v2
'To us': the people who are owed.
-
מַ֖יִם
mayim · H4325G
water · v2, v3
'Water.' In the desert this is a matter of life or death for people and herds (v. 3), not a comfort.
-
וְנִשְׁתֶּ֑ה
wənishteh · H8354
to drink · v2
'And let us drink' or 'so that we may drink.' After a command, this form gives the purpose or result: give water, and then we can drink. It picks up v. 1's 'no water for the people to drink.'
-
לָהֶם֙
lāhem · H9038
to them · v2
'To them.' Moses answers the crowd directly.
-
מַה־
mah · H4100
what? why? · v2, v3
Literally 'What?', used here as 'Why?' It is a rebuking question that challenges what they are doing, not a request for information.
-
עִמָּדִ֔י
ʿimmādî · H5978
with me · v2
'With me.' Moses names himself as the one they are attacking, and the next clause shows he is not the real party.
-
תְּנַסּ֖וּן
tənassûn · H5254G
you test, put to the proof · v2
'Are you putting to the test?' It means putting someone on trial to see whether they will prove themselves, here by demanding that God show he is present and able (v. 7: 'Is YHWH among us or not?'). It also has the weighty final -n.
-
אֶת־
ʾet · H0853
[direct object marker] · v2, v3
An untranslatable marker that points to the object of the verb. Here it points at YHWH as the one being tested.
-
יְהוָֽה׃
YHWH · H3068G
Yahweh, the LORD · v2
The personal name of Israel's God, who has just led them out of Egypt and is leading their camp 'by his mouth' (v. 1). The verse ends on this word: the real defendant in their complaint is not Moses but YHWH.
-
וַיִּצְמָ֨א
vayyitsma · H6770
to thirst · v3
“And (the people) thirsted.” Real bodily thirst in the desert, not a picture for spiritual longing. The verb is singular because the whole people is treated as one body.
-
שָׁ֤ם
sham · H8033
there · v3
At Rephidim, the camp where “there was no water for the people to drink” (v. 1). It ties the thirst to that dry place and suggests the need was getting worse.
-
וַיָּ֥לֶן
vayyalen · H3885B
to grumble, complain · v3
“And (the people) grumbled.” This is the special word for the wilderness complaints: open, hostile protest against the leaders, not quiet muttering. In the next verse Moses fears he will be stoned.
-
עַל־
'al · H5921A
upon, against · v3
“Against.” With this verb the word marks who the complaint is aimed at. It is directed at Moses, though v. 7 shows that in the end it is aimed at God.
-
זֶּה֙
zeh · H2088
this · v3
Added to “why” to make it stronger: “Why on earth…?” / “Why ever…?” KJV and YLT try to show it (“Wherefore is this”).
-
הֶעֱלִיתָ֣נוּ
he'elitanu · H5927
to go up; (causative) bring up · v3
“You brought us up.” This is the standard phrase for the exodus, a phrase normally used of God. Here the people say it to Moses, as though the rescue were his idea, and so his fault.
-
מִמִּצְרַ֔יִם
mimmitsrayim · H4714
Egypt · v3
“From Egypt.” The land of slavery, which in the complaint is now remembered as a place where at least there was water.
-
לְהָמִ֥ית
lehamit · H4191
to die; (causative) to kill · v3
“To put to death.” The form means “to cause to die,” and the prefix expresses purpose. They charge Moses with planning their deaths, not just making a mistake.
-
בָּנַ֥י
banay · H1121A
son, child · v3
“My sons/children.” The family line, a household's future. Dying children is the most emotional point of the complaint.
-
מִקְנַ֖י
miqnay · H4735
livestock, property in animals · v3
“My livestock.” The word comes from a root meaning “acquire.” Flocks and herds were a household's wealth and means of living (Exod 12:38), and they need huge amounts of water.
-
בַּצָּמָֽא׃
batstsama' · H6772
thirst · v3
“By thirst.” The noun comes from the same root as the verse's first word, so the verse begins and ends with thirst.
The world behind it
- The third crisis in a series. Since crossing the sea, Israel has hit bitter water at Marah (15:22–26), hunger in the Desert of Sin (ch. 16), and now no water at Rephidim. Each time God has provided. So this demand comes after repeated proof, not before any.
- Led there by God. Verse 1 stresses that they moved 'according to the mouth of YHWH', which probably means following the cloud (13:21–22). A dry campsite on God's own route is the background to Moses' reply: blaming the location blames the guide.
- Water in the desert. For a large group with flocks and herds (v. 3 mentions 'livestock'), a camp without water means death within days. Their fear is real. Water rights and wells were among the most common causes of disputes in that world (Gen 21:25; 26:20–22), and rîv is the very word used for those well-quarrels.
- The leader as the one responsible. In the ancient Near East a leader or king was expected to secure food and water for his people. The demand 'give us' treats Moses (and probably Aaron) as having taken on that duty by leading them out of Egypt, and v. 3 accuses him of bringing them out to kill them.
- Where Rephidim was is uncertain. Tradition places it in southern Sinai, often linked with the Wadi Refayid or Wadi Feiran region, but this cannot be confirmed.
From the study of Exodus 17:2.
Where scholars differ
in v2
Who is addressed by the plural 'Give us water'?
-
Moses and Aaron (and possibly the elders) together.
In 16:2 the people grumble 'against Moses and Aaron', and Aaron is active in this narrative (17:10–12). The Masoretic plural is the harder reading and is likely original.
-
Moses alone. The plural is a loose or generalizing form, or a scribe's change.
The verse names only Moses, and Moses answers alone ('with me'). The Septuagint and Samaritan Pentateuch have a singular.
in v2
How does this account relate to the Meribah story in Numbers 20:1–13?
-
Two separate events: one at Rephidim early in the journey, one at Kadesh near its end.
Different locations (Rephidim vs Kadesh), different instructions (strike the rock vs speak to it), and different outcomes (Moses and Aaron are condemned only in Numbers 20). Deut 33:8 and Ps 95 can be read as recalling more than one occasion.
-
Two versions of one remembered tradition, explaining the same place name.
Both stories involve no water, the people contending (rîv), a rock and a staff, and the name Meribah. Many critical scholars see parallel accounts from different strands of tradition. Deut 33:8 pairs Massah and Meribah as a single memory.
in v2
Was the people's demand itself wrong, or only the way they made it?
-
Their need was legitimate. The fault lay in the hostile accusation and in doubting God's presence.
God answers at once with no punishment (vv. 5–6). Verse 7 locates the 'testing' in the question 'Is YHWH among us or not?' rather than in asking for water.
-
The demand itself, after so much proof, was faithless.
This comes right after the provisions at Marah and with the manna. Later texts (Deut 6:16; Ps 78:18–20; Ps 95:8–9) treat Massah as a typical example of unbelief.
in v3
Why does v. 3 repeat the complaint of v. 2 (the people quarrel and ask for water, then thirst and grumble)?
-
Two sources combined. Older source-critical scholarship assigned v. 2 and v. 3 to different strands (often J and E), which would explain the doubled complaint and the extra “there.”
Duplication with different verbs (*riv* “quarrel” in v. 2, *lun* “grumble” in v. 3), and the place named twice (Massah and Meribah, v. 7). See Childs, *Exodus* (OTL).
-
Deliberate escalation in a single story. The quarrel of v. 2 becomes worse in v. 3 as the thirst deepens (“there”), moving from a demand to an accusation of murder, then a threat of stoning in v. 4.
The steady rise in intensity across vv. 2–4, and the way the verse is framed by thirst at both ends. Sarna (JPS Torah Commentary) and many literary readers take this view.
in v3
Is the people's complaint itself presented as sin, or only their distrust?
-
The grumbling is rebellion. The *lun* motif describes revolt against God's appointed leaders and so against God.
Moses: “Why do you test the LORD?” (v. 2). The rebuking place names (v. 7). Deut 6:16; Ps 95:8–11. Coats, *Rebellion in the Wilderness*.
-
The need is presented sympathetically before Sinai. What is condemned is testing God (“Is the LORD among us or not?”), not crying out for water as such.
v. 1 confirms there really was no water. God provides without punishing anyone in Exod 15–17, unlike the complaints after Sinai in Numbers. Commentators such as Fretheim point to this difference between before and after Sinai.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. רִיב
- BDB s.v. רִיב
- HALOT s.v. נסה
- BDB s.v. נָסָה
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §47m (paragogic nun)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 17:2
- Vulgate, Exodus 17:2
- Brevard S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL), on Exod 17:1–7
- William H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Exod 17
- Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied data)
- BDB s.v. לוּן II, צָמֵא, מִקְנֶה
- HALOT s.v. לון, עלה (hiphil), מות (hiphil)
- G. W. Coats, Rebellion in the Wilderness (1968)
- B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL, 1974)
- N. M. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary, 1991)
- W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible, 1999)
- T. E. Fretheim, Exodus (Interpretation, 1991)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 17:3
- Vulgate, Exodus 17:3
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).