Ezra Chapter 2 Read as one passage
Ezra 2:59–63
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
59The following came up from Tel-melah, Tel-harsha, Cherub, Addan, and Immer, but they could not prove that their families were descended from Israel: 60the descendants of Delaiah, the descendants of Tobiah, and the descendants of Nekoda, 652 in all. 61And from among the priests: the descendants of Hobaiah, the descendants of Hakkoz, and the descendants of Barzillai (who had married a daughter of Barzillai the Gileadite and was called by their name). 62These men searched for their family records, but they could not find them and so were excluded from the priesthood as unclean. 63The governor ordered them not to eat the most holy things until there was a priest to consult the Urim and Thummim.
What the first hearers heard
For the community rebuilding Jerusalem and its temple in the Persian period, this verse was part of a founding document. The list of Ezra 2 / Nehemiah 7 answered the question "who are we?" by naming the families who had come back and claiming that they continued historic Israel.
The verse shows that this identity was not a closed or tidy category. Some families had done what everyone else did: left their Babylonian villages and made the "going up" to Judah. Yet they could not attach themselves to any known ancestral clan. Perhaps their records were lost over generations in distant rural settlements. Perhaps their ancestry was mixed, or their link to Israel came through some route the registers did not record. The text does not say which.
What the first readers would have noticed:
- Honesty in the record. The registry openly admits a gap instead of quietly dropping these families or inventing a lineage for them.
- Inclusion without full confirmation. The lay families are counted alongside the rest (v. 60), and nothing in the text shuts them out.
- The stakes of genealogy. The verses that follow show where unconfirmed descent mattered most: at the altar, where priestly service needed proven descent from Aaron (vv. 61–63). The temple's holiness was the community's central concern, and genealogy guarded access to it.
The verse captures a community whose membership was defined by kinship and covenant, trying to be careful about who belonged while making room for people whose paperwork had not survived the exile.
From the study of Ezra 2:59.
Verse by verse
-
59The following came up from Tel-melah, Tel-harsha, Cherub, Addan, and Immer, but they could not prove that their families were descended from Israel:
Full study →"And these are the ones who also made the ascent home: people from Salt Mound, from Tel-harsha, from Kerub, Addan and Immer, the old ruin-mound villages of Babylonia where deported Judeans had been settled. But they could not lay out their ancestry. They could not name the registered ancestral clan they belonged to or trace their line of descent, so whether they truly belonged to Israel, the covenant family, stayed an open question."
The verse does two things at once. It counts these people among those who "went up," the honoured word used for the whole return to Jerusalem, and the next verse gives their numbers just like everyone else's (652). It also marks their status as unconfirmed, because they could not link themselves to a recognised "father's house," the clan unit through which the restored community registered its members, tied them to ancestral land, and assigned temple duties. The Hebrew does not call them outsiders. It says they were unable to declare their descent, and leaves the question "whether they were from Israel" unanswered.
-
60the descendants of Delaiah, the descendants of Tobiah, and the descendants of Nekoda, 652 in all.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
61And from among the priests: the descendants of Hobaiah, the descendants of Hakkoz, and the descendants of Barzillai (who had married a daughter of Barzillai the Gileadite and was called by their name).
Full study →Among the men who claimed to be priests, three families could not prove it: the clan of Hobaiah, the clan of Hakkoz ('the Thorn'), and the clan that went by the name 'Barzillai'.
The last name needed explaining, because Barzillai was no priest. He was the rich old landowner of Gilead who fed King David in his darkest days and whose household David told Solomon to treat with lasting kindness. Generations earlier, a priest had married a woman of that famous family. He then came to be known and registered under her family's name: he was counted as belonging to Barzillai's house, not to Aaron's. His descendants carried an honoured name, but they had lost the written record of where they came from.
So when these families returned from Babylon and claimed the right to serve at the altar, an inheritance that existed only by birth, nobody could find their entry in the priestly registers (v. 62). The verse is a single entry in a list, but it shows that a priest's identity rested on genealogy, and that a name could carry a family's standing or erase it.
-
62These men searched for their family records, but they could not find them and so were excluded from the priesthood as unclean.
Full study →These three families (Hobaiah, Hakkoz and Barzillai) went looking for their written entry in the official genealogical register, the roll of families whose descent was formally recognised. Neither they nor their entry could be found. So they were officially classed as ritually unfit and, on that basis, set apart from the priesthood.
The Hebrew packs a lot into its last two words. The verb is not 'redeem' but its look-alike, 'defile', used in the sense of declared unfit for sacred use. Joined to 'from the priesthood', it means two things at once: they were ruled unfit, and so they were shut out. This was a ruling about status, made because the paperwork was missing. It was not a verdict that they were immoral or had faked their claim. The office they lost was an inheritance God was said to have given to Aaron's descendants 'by a perpetual statute'. It brought the right to serve at the altar and to eat the 'most holy' portions of the offerings. The next verse shows that the exclusion was meant to be provisional: they were barred from that sacred food 'until a priest arises with Urim and Thummim', that is, until God could be asked directly.
-
63The governor ordered them not to eat the most holy things until there was a priest to consult the Urim and Thummim.
Full study →The governor, the Persian-appointed official with the court title Tirshatha ("His Excellency"), gave a ruling about the priestly families who said they were descended from Aaron but could not find their names in the family records. They were not to eat any part of the most holy portions, the sacred food set aside from the purification offerings, guilt offerings, grain offerings and the bread of the Presence. Only true priests could eat that food, and only in the sanctuary. Eating it was both a priest's income and the public proof that he was one. The ban was to last until a priest arose who could use the Urim and Thummim: the sacred objects in the high priest's breastpiece through which Israel had once received God's own decision on questions people could not settle.
In short: "You may be priests, but we cannot prove it, and we will not risk treating God's holy things as common. Hold back until God himself can settle it through his priest." The verse does not reject these families outright. It suspends them and leaves the final word to God.
Where the English drifted
-
in v59
their father's house (KJV)
bêt 'ăbôtām
- What we hear
- The home of each person's own father, or simply 'their family' in a loose sense.
- What they heard
- Their ancestral clan: a formally recognised kinship group, traced through a named ancestor and recorded in genealogical registers. It was the basic unit of the restored community.
-
in v59
Cherub
kərûb
- What we hear
- The winged heavenly being, or a chubby angel in art.
- What they heard
- A place in Babylonia where exiles had settled. The spelling matches the word for the temple's winged guardian figures, but here it is only a place name.
-
in v59
Israel
yiśrā'ēl
- What we hear
- The modern nation-state, or an ethnic group defined by biology.
- What they heard
- The covenant people descended from Jacob, now represented by the returned exiles. Belonging was shown through registered family descent.
-
in v61
the children of (KJV, WEB)
bənê
- What we hear
- Young sons and daughters of the named man.
- What they heard
- The descendants or clan of an ancestor, a family line that might reach back many generations.
-
in v61
priests
kōhănîm
- What we hear
- Clergy who are called, trained and ordained to the role.
- What they heard
- Members of a hereditary caste descended from Aaron. You could not choose, train for or be appointed to the role; you had to be born into it and be able to prove it.
-
in v61
was called by their name
wayyiqqārēʾ ʿal-šəmām
- What we hear
- He picked up a nickname or was informally known by that surname.
- What they heard
- He was counted as belonging to their family, and probably registered as a member of Barzillai's house in lineage and perhaps in property.
-
in v62
unclean / polluted
wayᵉgōʾᵃlû (gāʾal II)
- What we hear
- Dirty, morally corrupt, disgraced, perhaps exposed as frauds.
- What they heard
- Officially classed as ritually unfit for sacred office: a status ruling based on unproven lineage, not a moral judgment. The men were not accused of sin, and the ruling could be reversed by divine decision (2:63).
-
in v62
redeemed (YLT)
wayᵉgōʾᵃlû
- What we hear
- Rescued, bought back, set free from the priesthood.
- What they heard
- 'Defiled, declared unfit.' The verb is spelled the same as gāʾal I 'redeem', but here it is the other root (gāʾal II, a variant of gāʿal, 'to loathe, defile').
-
in v62
family records / genealogy
kᵉtāb … hammityaḥśîm
- What we hear
- Private family papers or a family tree, an ancestry hobby.
- What they heard
- An official public register of recognised families. Being entered in it established legal rights to office, land and sacred portions.
-
in v63
the most holy things
qōdeš haqqŏdāšîm
- What we hear
- Sacred objects or relics, or things that are especially pure or spiritual in a moral sense.
- What they heard
- The top grade of sacred food: priestly shares of certain offerings that only priests could eat, in the sanctuary. 'Holy' here means owned by God and set apart, not morally good.
-
in v63
governor
tiršātāʾ
- What we hear
- A local elected or civil administrator, as in a modern state governor.
- What they heard
- A Persian honorific title ('His Excellency') for the official the empire set over Judah. He was an imperial appointee, yet here he defers to God's priestly verdict.
Every word
-
וְאֵ֗לֶּה
wə'ēlleh · H0428
and these · v59, v62
Opens a new section of the return list. Up to this point the list has named families whose descent was known. From here it turns to a group whose descent could not be checked.
-
הָֽעֹלִים֙
hā'ōlîm · H5927
-
מִתֵּ֥ל
mittēl · H8528
from Tel(-melah) · v59
'From' plus tel, 'mound.' A tel is a hill built up from the ruins of earlier settlements. Here it is the first part of a Babylonian place name.
-
תֵּ֣ל
tēl · H8521
mound, Tel(-harsha) · v59
A second settlement whose name begins with 'mound.' The pattern fits Babylonian names built on tīlu, 'ruin mound.'
-
כְּר֥וּב
kərûb · H3743
Kerub (place) · v59
A place name, written the same way as the Hebrew word for 'cherub.' The spelling may be a coincidence, or it may come from a Babylonian word. It has nothing to do with angels in this verse.
-
אַדָּ֖ן
'addān · H0135
Addan (place) · v59
Another Babylonian locality whose location is unknown. Nehemiah 7:61 spells it Addon. Some scholars read 'Kerub-addan' as a single place name.
-
אִמֵּ֑ר
'immēr · H0564
Immer · v59
Probably a place here. Immer is also the name of a priestly family (Ezra 2:37), so some scholars think it names a person who led the group.
-
וְלֹ֣א
wəlō' · H3808
and not · v59, v62, v63
Starts the qualification: these people came up, but something was missing.
-
יָֽכְל֗וּ
yākəlû · H3201
they were able · v59
With 'not': 'they were unable.' The verb states a fact they could not get past, a lack of means. It does not suggest they refused or were hiding something.
-
לְהַגִּ֤יד
ləhaggîd · H5046
to tell, declare, make known · v59
'To declare' or 'to show.' They could not state and support their descent in a form that could be checked. Verse 62 shows that checking meant written genealogical registers.
-
בֵּית־
bêt- · H1004
house (of) · v59
'House' in the sense of a family line, not a building. Together with the next word it forms the fixed phrase 'father's house.'
-
אֲבוֹתָם֙
'ăbôtām · H0001
their fathers · v59
'Their fathers' house' means their ancestral clan. This was the kinship group through which people in the restored community were registered, organised and tied to land.
-
וְזַרְעָ֔ם
wəzar'ām · H2233
and their seed · v59
'Seed' means descent or line of offspring. They could not trace the lineage that would link them to a recognised clan.
-
אִ֥ם
'im · H0518
if, whether · v59
Introduces an indirect question: 'whether.' The verse leaves the question open. It does not say they were not Israelites.
-
מִיִּשְׂרָאֵ֖ל
miyyiśrā'ēl · H3478
from Israel · v59
'Out of Israel': belonging to the people of Israel by descent. In Ezra, 'Israel' means the covenant people as a whole, whose core is now the returned exiles. It does not mean a territory or a state.
-
הֵֽם׃
hēm · H1992
they · v59
Ends the clause: 'whether from Israel they were.' Putting 'they' last leaves the question of their status hanging.
-
וּמִבְּנֵי֙
ū-mibbənê · H1121
and from the sons of · v61
'Sons of the priests' is a Hebrew way of saying 'members of the priestly class'. It names the group, not children. The prefix 'from' marks these as a subset of the priests: the ones whose descent could not be proven.
-
הַכֹּ֣הֲנִ֔ים
hakkōhănîm · H3548
the priests · v61, v63
These are the men who serve at the altar, an office passed down by birth from Aaron. Because it was inherited, being a priest depended on proving who your ancestors were. That is exactly where these families came up short.
-
חֳבַיָּ֖ה
ḥŏbayyāh · H2252
Hobaiah / Habaiah · v61
The ancestor of a priestly clan. The name probably means 'Yah has hidden' or 'Yah has sheltered'. The vowels allow either Hobaiah or Habaiah, which is why translations differ. The name appears only here and in Nehemiah 7:63.
-
הַקּ֑וֹץ
haqqôṣ · H6976
Hakkoz · v61
Literally 'the thorn'. The 'the' (ha-) is part of the name, which is why most versions write 'Hakkoz' and the KJV writes 'Koz'. A priestly division of this name appears in 1 Chronicles 24:10, so it was a recognised priestly family. What these men lacked was paperwork.
-
בַרְזִלַּ֗י
barzillay · H1271
Barzillai · v61
Built from barzel, 'iron', so roughly 'man of iron'. Here it is the name a priestly clan carried. It came from the wife's family, not from a priestly ancestor, as the rest of the verse explains.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H834
who · v61, v63
Opens an explanatory aside. The writer stops to explain how a priestly family came to carry a lay name.
-
לָ֠קַח
lāqaḥ · H3947
took · v61
'Take a wife' is the ordinary Hebrew phrase for marrying. The subject is the unnamed priestly ancestor of this clan, at some earlier time.
-
מִבְּנ֞וֹת
mibbənôt · H1323
from the daughters of · v61
'One of the daughters of Barzillai' means a woman descended from Barzillai's line, not necessarily his own daughter. The Gileadite lived centuries earlier, in David's time.
-
הַגִּלְעָדִי֙
haggilʿādî · H1569
the Gileadite · v61
From Gilead, the highlands east of the Jordan. It identifies him beyond doubt as David's patron, a layman and not a priest.
-
אִשָּׁ֔ה
ʾiššāh · H802
woman, wife · v61
After 'took', the word means 'as a wife'. The same Hebrew word serves for both 'woman' and 'wife'.
-
וַיִּקָּרֵ֖א
wayyiqqārēʾ · H7121
and he was called · v61
'He was called' (passive). He came to be known and registered under that name. This was more than a nickname: it marked whose family he officially belonged to.
-
עַל־
ʿal- · H5921
upon, by · v61
In the phrase 'called upon a name', 'upon' marks the name a person is officially counted under, the one that claims him.
-
שְׁמָֽם׃
šəmām · H8034
their name · v61
'Their name' points to the Barzillai family, the 'daughters of Barzillai' and their clan. The priest took his wife's family name, and his descendants were listed as 'sons of Barzillai' rather than under their priestly ancestor.
-
בִּקְשׁ֧וּ
biqšû · H1245
to seek, search for · v62
An active, deliberate search. The families themselves (or officials on their behalf) went looking for written proof of descent. The verb assumes such proof was expected to exist.
-
כְתָבָ֛ם
kᵉtābām · H3791
writing, document, register · v62
'Their writing': the written entry that would record their line. A word found mostly in late books, typical of Persian-period administration. It means an official written record, not family memory or oral tradition.
-
הַמִּתְיַחְשִׂ֖ים
hammityaḥśîm · H3187
to be enrolled by genealogy · v62
'The ones enrolled in the genealogy.' Either it explains what 'their writing' was (the genealogical enrollment) or it means they looked for their entry 'among those enrolled' (KJV). Either way it refers to the formal register of recognised families.
-
נִמְצָ֑אוּ
nimṣāʾû · H4672
to be found · v62
'They were not found.' The plural can mean the men were not found in the register, or that their records were not found. The result is the same: no written proof.
-
וַֽיְגֹאֲל֖וּ
wayᵉgōʾᵃlû · H1351
to be defiled, treated as unclean · v62
This is the verb for 'defile', not the identical-looking verb for 'redeem'. In the passive it means they were declared or treated as ritually unfit. Followed by 'from', it means that being declared unfit pushed them out of the priesthood. This was a ruling on their status, not a charge of personal sin.
-
מִן־
min- · H4480A
from · v62
Means separation: 'away from'. Joined to 'defiled', it packs two ideas into one: declared unfit, and so cut off from.
-
הַכְּהֻנָּֽה׃
hakkᵉhunnāh · H3550
-
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v63
The ordinary verb for speaking. Here it introduces an official ruling: what the governor 'said' is a binding order, which is why BSB gives 'ordered'.
-
הַתִּרְשָׁ֙תָא֙
hattiršātāʾ · H8660
the Tirshatha, governor · v63
A Persian title of honour, roughly 'His Excellency', used for the man the Persian crown put over Judah. It names his office, not his personal name. He was a civil official ruling on a question about priests.
-
לָהֶ֔ם
lāhem · H9038
to them · v63
'Them' means the priestly families of verses 61–62 (Habaiah, Hakkoz, Barzillai), who claimed priestly descent but could not find their names in the family records.
-
יֹאכְל֖וּ
yōʾkəlû · H0398
they shall eat · v63
Literally 'eat'. The ban is about food: the shares of offerings that only priests could eat. Eating these portions was both a priest's income and a public sign that he was a priest.
-
מִקֹּ֣דֶשׁ
miqqōdeš · H6944G
from the holiness of · v63
The prefix 'from' means 'any of' or 'any part of': they may not eat even a portion. 'Qodesh' is what belongs to God's sphere and is set apart from ordinary use.
-
עַ֛ד
ʿad · H5704
until · v63
Makes the ban temporary in form. It holds until a set condition is met, and is not presented as a permanent rejection.
-
עֲמֹ֥ד
ʿămōd · H5975H
to stand, arise · v63
The verb form names the action without a set time: 'the standing up of'. Here it means a priest coming forward, or appearing, in a position to act. It may also carry the idea of standing in office before God.
-
לְאוּרִ֥ים
ləʾûrîm · H0224
for/with Urim · v63
The prefix 'for' means a priest equipped for, or serving with, the Urim. These were sacred objects kept in the high priest's breastpiece and used to get a decision from God.
-
וּלְתֻמִּֽים׃
ûləṯummîm · H8550
and for/with Thummim · v63
The partner object to the Urim. The two always appear together in Ezra. The ruling hands the final decision on these families to God, through the priestly way of asking him.
The world behind it
Where these people came from. After Judah fell (597 and 586 BC), the Babylonians resettled many deportees in rural districts of southern Mesopotamia. They were often placed on abandoned tells (ruin mounds) and given land to farm. Ezekiel lived among exiles at Tel-abib (Ezekiel 3:15). Cuneiform tablets from a village called āl-Yāhūdu, "Judah-town," and from nearby settlements show Judean families living there across several generations, from the 6th into the 5th century BC. Tel-melah ("Salt Mound"), Tel-harsha, Kerub, Addan and Immer were evidently settlements of this kind. Their exact locations are unknown.
Why lineage mattered. When Persia allowed the return (Cyrus, 538 BC, Ezra 1), the community that formed around the rebuilt temple organised itself by bêt 'ābôt, "fathers' houses": registered clans traced back to known ancestors. Belonging to such a clan was how a family showed it belonged to Israel. It was the basis for claiming ancestral land, and it decided who could serve at the altar. The list in Ezra 2 (copied again in Nehemiah 7) is that kind of registry. It is probably a compilation covering more than one wave of returnees.
The structure around the verse. Verses 59–63 form an appendix to the list for cases that could not be confirmed:
- Lay families (vv. 59–60: the descendants of Delaiah, Tobiah and Nekoda, 652 people) are named and counted, and no penalty is mentioned.
- Priestly families (vv. 61–63) who could not find their entry "in the register of genealogies" were "excluded from the priesthood as unclean." The governor ordered them not to eat the most holy food "until a priest could consult the Urim and Thummim," the sacred lots used to ask God for a decision.
So uncertain descent had concrete consequences for priests. For lay families the text records the uncertainty but does not describe any exclusion.
From the study of Ezra 2:59.
Where scholars differ
in v59
Were these families Israelites who had lost their records, or people of non-Israelite origin who had joined the exiles?
-
Israelites whose genealogical records had been lost.
The wording 'they were not able to declare' points to a lack of documents, not to known foreign ancestry. Several generations in scattered rural Babylonian settlements (attested in the āl-Yāhūdu tablets) would make records easy to lose. The family names (Delaiah, 'YHWH has drawn up'; Tobiah, 'YHWH is good') are Yahwistic, meaning they contain the name of Israel's God.
-
Families of mixed or non-Israelite background who had attached themselves to the Judean community.
In Babylonia, deported groups lived alongside one another and could intermarry. Ezra–Nehemiah elsewhere worries about the community's boundaries (Ezra 9–10). Some connect the Tobiah clan with the later Tobiah 'the Ammonite' who opposed Nehemiah (Nehemiah 2:10), but this link is speculative.
in v59
Did failing to prove descent exclude these lay families from the community?
-
No. They were included, with their status simply noted as unconfirmed.
Verse 60 counts them (652) just like the other families. Exclusion is spelled out only for the priests (v. 62), and the text gives no such ruling for the laypeople.
-
They held a provisional or lesser status.
Separating them into an appendix marks them off from the fully registered families. In a society where land claims and inheritance went through recognised fathers' houses, having no registered clan probably had practical drawbacks.
in v61
Why did the priest take the name of Barzillai's family?
-
He married an heiress, and taking the name kept Barzillai's line and land going.
There are parallels for continuing a line with no sons through a daughter: Sheshan and Jarha (1 Chronicles 2:34–35), and the daughters of Zelophehad (Numbers 27; 36). The phrase 'called by the name' is tied to inheritance in Genesis 48:6, 16. Many commentators (for example Williamson, Fensham) consider this likely.
-
He took the name for the prestige of Barzillai's house, which was bound to the Davidic court.
1 Kings 2:7 promises royal kindness to Barzillai's sons. An honoured lay name could bring social advantage. The text gives no motive, so this remains a guess.
-
Taking a lay name and land in effect meant giving up priestly status.
Priests were not to hold a tribal land portion (Numbers 18:20). By joining a landed lay clan, the family may have drifted out of priestly registers. This is suggested by some interpreters. The text only records the outcome, that the records could not be found.
in v61
Was the Hakkoz family permanently excluded?
-
No. The family was later restored.
'Meremoth son of Uriah, the priest' takes charge of temple treasure (Ezra 8:33). 'Meremoth son of Uriah son of Hakkoz' repairs the wall (Nehemiah 3:4, 21). If these are the same family, its status was later confirmed, perhaps after the records were found or a ruling was given.
-
The later Hakkoz figures are a different branch or are unrelated.
Nehemiah 3 does not call Meremoth a priest. Names recur across families, and Ezra 8:33 may have reached Hakkoz's line through a different chain of records. The identification is likely but not proven.
in v62
Was the exclusion permanent, and was any of these families later reinstated?
-
At least the Hakkoz family was later recognised as priestly.
Hakkoz is a priestly course in 1 Chr 24:10. 'Meremoth son of Uriah the priest' receives Temple silver in Ezra 8:33, and Neh 3:4, 21 call him 'son of Uriah son of Hakkoz'. That implies the doubt was resolved in their favour (a view taken by several commentators, e.g. Williamson).
-
The Meremoth references do not prove reinstatement.
The Hakkoz in Nehemiah 3 may be another branch, or 'priest' in Ezra 8:33 may refer to Uriah rather than Meremoth. The text never reports the Urim-and-Thummim decision that 2:63 waits for.
in v62
How does 'the ones enrolled by genealogy' fit the sentence?
-
It explains 'their writing': 'they sought their record, that is, the genealogical enrollment'.
Hebrew often places an explanatory phrase beside a noun like this. The participle has the article, like a label.
-
It is a short way of saying 'among those enrolled' (KJV supplies 'among').
Fits the sense that they looked for their entry within the larger register. The identical wording in Neh 7:64 does not settle it.
in v62
What 'was not found': the men or the records?
-
The men were not found in the register.
The plural verb most naturally shares the subject of 'sought' (the men). Compare Neh 7:5, 'I found the book of the genealogy … and found written in it'.
-
Their records were not found.
BSB and others take it so. 'Their writing' is the nearest object, though grammatically singular. The practical meaning is the same either way.
in v63
Who was the Tirshatha in Ezra 2:63?
-
Zerubbabel
He heads the list of leaders in Ezra 2:2, and Haggai 1:1 calls him governor (peḥah) of Judah, so he is the natural leader of this return.
-
Sheshbazzar
Ezra 1:8 and 5:14 name him as the first governor, appointed by Cyrus, who brought the temple vessels back. If the list reflects the first return, he could be the official meant.
-
Nehemiah (via the Nehemiah 7 setting)
The same list appears in Nehemiah 7, where the title is used of Nehemiah (Nehemiah 8:9; 10:1), and 1 Esdras 5:40 names Nehemiah. Most scholars think the list is older than Nehemiah and that Nehemiah reused it, so this is a minority view for Ezra 2.
in v63
Did 'until a priest arises with Urim and Thummim' express a real expectation or an indefinite postponement?
-
A real, expected condition
'Until' and the verb 'arise' point to a future event. The returnees were restoring the temple and its high priest (Jeshua), so they may have hoped to restore the Urim and Thummim as well.
-
An indefinite postponement
There is no clear record of Urim and Thummim in use after David. Josephus, the Mishnah (Sotah 9:12) and the Talmud (Yoma 21b) say the Second Temple lacked them. Putting the decision off until they returned meant putting it off without a date, perhaps until a new age.
in v63
How did the Urim and Thummim work?
-
Lot-like objects giving yes / no / no answer
The longer Greek text of 1 Samuel 14:41–42 contrasts 'give Urim' and 'give Thummim' when deciding between two parties. 1 Samuel 28:6 shows that sometimes no answer came.
-
A means of light or revelation, linked to the breastpiece stones
The word 'Urim' may relate to 'light', and Josephus (*Antiquities* 3.214–218) describes the high priest's stones shining. Cornelis Van Dam (*The Urim and Thummim*, 1997) argues for a revelatory function rather than simple lots. This view relies more on later tradition and is less certain.
in v63
Were these families barred only from the most holy food, or from all priestly rights?
-
Only the most holy portions
The verse names only 'the most holy things'. Later rabbinic discussion took this to mean that lesser holy food was not covered.
-
Excluded from priestly service and income altogether
Verse 62 says they were 'excluded from the priesthood as unclean', which suggests a full suspension. On this view the most holy food is named as the clearest example.
Sources
- BDB s.v. תֵּל, בַּיִת, נָגַד
- HALOT s.v. תֵּל מֶלַח, תֵּל חַרְשָׁא, כְּרוּב II, אַדָּן
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- J. Weinberg, The Citizen-Temple Community (on the bêt 'ābôt)
- L. E. Pearce and C. Wunsch, Documents of Judean Exiles and West Semites in Babylonia (āl-Yāhūdu tablets)
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 2:59; 1 Esdras 5:36–40
- Nehemiah 7:61–65 (parallel list)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. בֵּן, כֹּהֵן, קָרָא (niphal with עַל־שֵׁם), שֵׁם
- Joseph Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F. Charles Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- Jacob M. Myers, Ezra–Nehemiah (Anchor Bible)
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.30–36 (priestly genealogies)
- 1 Esdras 5:38 (Greek parallel)
- 2 Samuel 17:27–29; 19:31–40; 1 Kings 2:7; 1 Chronicles 2:34–35; 24:10; Nehemiah 3:4, 21; 7:63–65; Ezra 8:33
- BDB s.v. גָּאַל II, יָחַשׂ, כְּתָב, כְּהֻנָּה
- HALOT s.v. גאל II; יחשׂ
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 2:62; 1 Esdras 5:38–40
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.30–36; Life 1–6
- Mishnah Middot 5:4; Sotah 9:12; Kiddushin 4:1
- Nehemiah 7:64; 13:29; 2 Chronicles 31:16–19; Ezekiel 13:9; Numbers 18:7
- HALOT s.v. תִּרְשָׁתָא
- BDB s.v. קֹדֶשׁ; s.v. עָמַד; s.v. אוּרִים; s.v. תֻּמִּים
- Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on grades of holiness and most holy offerings
- Cornelis Van Dam, The Urim and Thummim: A Means of Revelation in Ancient Israel (1997)
- Josephus, Antiquities 3.214–218; Against Apion 1.30–36
- Mishnah Sotah 9:12; Babylonian Talmud Yoma 21b; Ketubot 24b–25a
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 2:63; 1 Esdras 5:40
- Vulgate, Ezra 2:63
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 2
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.