Hosea Chapter 13 Read as one passage
Hosea 13:10–11
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
10Where is your king now to save you in all your cities, and the rulers to whom you said, “Give me a king and princes”? 11So in My anger I gave you a king, and in My wrath I took him away.
What the first hearers heard
To Israelites in the 720s BC, this verse was a taunt aimed at a national illusion. Israel had treated its monarchy, and the endless supply of new kings each palace coup produced, as its security. Hosea had already said, "They made kings, but not through me" (8:4), and had put in the people's mouths the admission, "We have no king... and a king, what could he do for us?" (10:3).
Now, with Assyrian armies in the land and towns falling, God asks where that king is. The hearers would have caught several things:
- Their own words thrown back at them. "Give me a king and officials" recalls Israel's founding demand in 1 Samuel 8. The present disaster is the result of something they asked for.
- A contest over who saves. Verse 4 has just said, "I am the LORD your God ever since the land of Egypt... besides me there is no savior." The verse sets the human king, who cannot save, against the God who brought them out of Egypt.
- God's anger in giving and taking. The next verse ("I gave you a king in my anger, and took him away in my wrath") presents the whole monarchy, and its collapse, as God's judgment. Getting what they asked for was itself the punishment.
The verse is part of a final indictment (13:1–16) leading up to Samaria's fall. Its purpose was not to reform the monarchy but to strip away trust in it, leaving Israel facing the God it had abandoned. The book ends with the call to say, "Assyria will not save us... we will no longer say 'Our God' to the work of our hands" (14:3).
From the study of Hosea 13:10.
Verse by verse
-
10Where is your king now to save you in all your cities, and the rulers to whom you said, “Give me a king and princes”?
Full study →"So where is he now, this king of yours? Let him rescue you, in every one of your towns! And where are your rulers, the ones you demanded when you said, 'Give me a king! Give me officials!'?"
God is speaking to Israel as if to one person, and the tone is sharp. The opening word is a rare northern form of "where?", the same word he uses a few lines later to taunt Death itself (13:14). It is pointed: look around, the king is nowhere. "Save" here means real rescue: lifting a siege, driving off an army. It turns back on 13:4, where God said, "besides me there is no savior." Israel had looked to a king to do what only God does, and as Assyria takes the towns one by one, the king cannot be found or can do nothing.
The second half quotes Israel's own words back as evidence. "Give me a king" is close to the elders' demand in 1 Samuel 8:6, "Give us a king to judge us," using the same insistent form of "give". The "judges" here are not courtroom officials. They are the rulers who were meant to govern and defend, and the "princes" are the court's officers and commanders. Israel asked for a whole royal government. The next verse gives God's reply: "I gave you a king in my anger, and I took him away in my wrath."
-
11So in My anger I gave you a king, and in My wrath I took him away.
Full study →"I give you a king while my anger burns, and I take him away while my fury spills over."
God is speaking to Israel (here called Ephraim, the northern kingdom) as one person. In the verse before, he mocks them: Where is that king of yours now, the one who was supposed to save you? Where are the rulers you asked for when you said, "Give me a king and princes"? This verse answers the question. The king never stood apart from God. Israel demanded one, and God gave it, but as an act of anger, the way the snorting nostrils of an angry man show his rage. Now God takes the king back, in anger that has boiled over.
The two lines balance: give answers take, and anger answers fury. The monarchy began and ended inside God's displeasure. Both verbs are in the Hebrew form that usually describes repeated or ongoing action. So the verse can be heard as a settled pattern ("I keep giving you kings in my anger, and I keep taking them away in my fury"), and not only as a memory of Saul long ago. Hosea's audience had watched king after king murdered, and the last king of Israel was about to be carried off by Assyria. The point is not that God lost his temper. Kingship, which Israel trusted to save it in place of God, was never truly in their hands. It was God's to give and God's to take.
Where the English drifted
-
in v10
judges (KJV, WEB, YLT)
šōpĕṭîm
- What we hear
- Courtroom judges who hear cases and pass sentences.
- What they heard
- Rulers and leaders who governed, defended and decided matters for the people, as in the book of Judges. Here it means the ruling class around the king.
-
in v10
princes (KJV, BSB)
śārîm
- What we hear
- The king's sons, members of the royal family.
- What they heard
- Court officials, commanders and governors: the men who ran the kingdom's administration and army.
-
in v10
save
yāšaʿ
- What we hear
- Spiritual salvation: forgiveness, rescue from sin, going to heaven.
- What they heard
- Physical, political rescue: winning a war, delivering besieged towns from an enemy army.
-
in v11
anger … wrath
'aph … 'evrah
- What we hear
- A volatile, emotional God losing his temper, or (in later religious language) 'wrath' as eternal punishment after death.
- What they heard
- Vivid bodily pictures (the flaring nostril, anger spilling over) for God's passionate but deliberate response to Israel breaking its covenant. Here the judgement is entirely historical: the rise and fall of the nation's kings.
Every word
-
אֱהִ֤י
ʾĕhî · H0165
where? · v10
A rare question word found only in Hosea, here and twice in 13:14 ("O Death, where are your plagues?"). It is probably a northern or dialect form of the usual ʾayyēh, "where?". Opening the verse with it makes the line a mocking challenge: show me this king.
-
מַלְכְּךָ֙
malkĕkā · H4428G
king · v10, v11
"Your king." The "your" (singular, spoken to Israel as one person) stresses ownership: this is the king you wanted, as opposed to the God who calls himself Israel's only savior in 13:4.
-
אֵפ֔וֹא
ʾēpôʾ · H0645
then, now · v10
A small particle that sharpens a question, like English "where, then...?" or "so where now...?" It adds impatience and sarcasm, as if the speaker is looking around for the king and not finding him.
-
וְיוֹשִׁיעֲךָ֖
wĕyôšîʿăkā · H3467
to save · v10
"So that he may save you" or "and let him save you." The verb is about rescue from a real enemy: winning a battle, lifting a siege. It deliberately echoes 13:4, "besides me there is no savior (môšîaʿ)."
-
בְּכָל־
bĕkol- · H3605
all · v10
"In all." The danger is everywhere across the land, not in one place.
-
עָרֶ֑יךָ
ʿārêkā · H5892B
city · v10
"Your cities": walled towns, which Assyrian armies were taking one after another. The picture is a king who cannot defend his towns.
-
וְשֹׁ֣פְטֶ֔יךָ
wĕšōpĕṭêkā · H8199
to judge · v10
"And your judges": the participle of the verb "to judge" used as a noun. In Israel a šōpēṭ was a ruler or leader who governed and defended, not just a courtroom official. Here it means the ruling class around the king.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H0834A
which, who · v10
Relative word: "of whom", pointing back to the king and rulers.
-
אָמַ֔רְתָּ
ʾāmartā · H0559
to say · v10
"You said": past tense, singular. The nation is reminded of its own words, as if quoted back to it as evidence.
-
תְּנָה־
tĕnâ- · H5414G
give · v10, v11
"Give!": an emphatic command form (with an added -â ending). It is the same form the elders used in 1 Samuel 8:6, "Give us a king to judge us," so it sounds like a demand.
-
לִּ֖י
lî · H9030
to me · v10
"To me": Israel speaking as one person, insisting on what it wants.
-
וְשָׂרִֽים׃
wĕśārîm · H8269
ruler, official · v10
"And officials/commanders": the court and military elite who run a monarchy. The plural shows that Israel asked for a whole state apparatus, not one man.
-
לְךָ֥
lekha
to you · v11
'To you' (masculine singular). The whole nation, Israel/Ephraim, is spoken to as one person, as all through Hosea 13.
-
בְּאַפִּ֔י
be'appi · H639
nose, nostril; anger · v11
Literally 'in my nostril'. Hebrew pictures anger as the snorting, flaring nose. The king was given while God's anger was burning, and as an expression of it, not as a reward.
-
וְאֶקַּ֖ח
ve'eqqach · H3947
take, take away · v11
'And I take.' It has a plain 'and' plus the same prefix form as the first verb, not Hebrew's usual way of telling a past story. 'Him' is not written in the Hebrew. It is understood. The verb mirrors 'give': the same God who handed over the king removes him.
-
בְּעֶבְרָתִֽי׃
be'evrati · H5678
overflow, outburst, fury · v11
'In my fury.' The word comes from a root meaning to pass over or spill over, so it pictures anger that boils over. It pairs with 'anger' in the first line and closes the verse: kingship began in anger and ends in fury.
The world behind it
The last years of the northern kingdom (about 732–722 BC). Hosea preached in the northern kingdom of Israel (also called Ephraim or Samaria) as it was falling apart. In its last 25 years it had six kings, and four of them were assassinated by rivals from the court (2 Kings 15). Hosea describes officials heated like an oven, devouring their rulers: "All their kings have fallen" (7:7).
Assyria and the cities. Assyrian armies under Tiglath-pileser III and Shalmaneser V took Israel's territory town by town. Galilee and Gilead were annexed in 733–732 BC. The last king, Hoshea, was arrested by the Assyrians (2 Kings 17:4), probably around 724 BC, before Samaria's three-year siege began. "Where is your king... in all your cities?" fits a moment when the towns were under attack and the king was absent, possibly in an Assyrian prison.
What kings were for. Across the ancient Near East the king's basic job was to defend his people and win their wars. Israel's own request for a king said so: "that our king may judge us and go out before us and fight our battles" (1 Samuel 8:20). Asking where the king is "to save you" therefore challenges the reason the monarchy existed.
The 1 Samuel 8 echo. Hosea's hearers knew the story of the elders demanding a king "like all the nations", and of Samuel treating it as a rejection of God as king (1 Samuel 8:7). Hosea's wording ("Give me a king", "judges", "save") brings that story into the present.
From the study of Hosea 13:10.
Where scholars differ
in v10
Does ʾĕhî mean "where?" or "I will be"?
-
"Where?": a dialect form of the usual question word (most modern scholars and translations).
The Septuagint reads poû at 13:10 and 13:14. The sentence structure ("___ your king, then?") calls for a question, and ʾēpôʾ is a particle used in questions. Paul's quotation of 13:14 assumes "where". The word occurs only in Hosea, which suits a regional form.
-
"I will be": a form of the verb hāyâ, "to be" (KJV, some medieval Jewish interpreters).
The consonants resemble ʾehyeh. The reading gives a theological contrast (God as true king) that suits Hosea's message. But it needs words added to make the sentence work ("where is any other"), and it sits awkwardly with ʾēpôʾ.
in v10
Which king and which request does the verse have in view?
-
Israel's original demand for a king in Saul's day (1 Samuel 8).
"Give me a king" and the theme of "judging" closely echo 1 Samuel 8:5–6. Verse 11 ("I gave you a king in my anger and took him away in my wrath") would fit Saul's rejection.
-
The founding of the northern monarchy under Jeroboam I (1 Kings 12).
Hosea is addressing the northern kingdom specifically, and he treats its separate kingship as illegitimate from the start (8:4).
-
The rapid succession of the last northern kings, especially Hoshea's capture by Assyria.
"Where is your king now?" suits a moment when the king was gone, which matches 2 Kings 17:4, where Hoshea is imprisoned before Samaria's siege. Hosea 7:3–7 and 8:4 describe the court coups. Many commentators (e.g. Wolff, Macintosh) see a combination: the present collapse viewed as the outcome of the whole history of the monarchy.
in v11
Which king (or kings) does the verse mean?
-
Saul and the start of the monarchy
Verse 10 repeats the demand of 1 Samuel 8:5–6, 'Give us a king.' God gave Saul after calling the request a rejection of himself (1 Samuel 8:7), and later took the kingdom from him (1 Samuel 15:28; 31).
-
The northern monarchy as a whole, especially its last chaotic decades
Hosea elsewhere condemns northern kingship as a system ('They set up kings, but not by me,' 8:4; 'all their kings have fallen,' 7:7). He has just watched several kings assassinated. The repeated-action force of the verbs supports a pattern: 'I keep giving … and taking.'
-
Hoshea son of Elah, the last king
Verse 10's taunt 'Where is your king now?' fits a time when Hoshea had been arrested by Assyria (2 Kings 17:4), and Hosea 10:7 and 10:15 predict the king's being 'cut off'. On this reading the second line describes, or predicts, his removal.
in v11
Past event, repeated pattern, or future threat?
-
Past: 'I gave … I took'
Hebrew poetry can use prefix verbs for the past. The echo of 1 Samuel 8 points backward. Most English versions and the Septuagint's first verb take it as past.
-
Habitual: 'I give … I take'
In standard Hebrew grammar, two prefix verbs joined by a plain 'and' most naturally describe repeated action. That fits the rapid turnover of kings (YLT; the NJPS plural).
-
Future, at least for the second line
The Vulgate's future tenses, and the context of coming destruction (13:12–16), support reading 'and I will take him away' as a threat still to be carried out.
Sources
- BDB s.v. אֱהִי, יָשַׁע, שָׁפַט, שַׂר
- HALOT s.v. אֱהִי, יָשַׁע, שֹׁפֵט
- H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia)
- F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible)
- A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (International Critical Commentary)
- D. Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Septuagint, Hosea 13:10, 14; Vulgate, Hosea 13:10, 14
- 2 Kings 15–17; 1 Samuel 8; 1 Corinthians 15:55
- BDB s.v. אַף, עֶבְרָה, נָתַן, לָקַח
- HALOT s.v. אַף; עֶבְרָה
- Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied data)
- A. A. Macintosh, Hosea (ICC)
- D. A. Garrett, Hosea, Joel (NAC)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Hosea 13 and 2 Kings 15–17
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).