1 Samuel Chapter 8 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 8:5–6

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

5“Look,” they said, “you are old, and your sons do not walk in your ways. Now appoint a king to judge us like all the other nations.” 6But when they said, “Give us a king to judge us,” their demand was displeasing in the sight of Samuel; so he prayed to the LORD.

What the first hearers heard

For the people in the story, the elders' words would have sounded sensible and even pious. They name a real failure of justice, since Deuteronomy forbids bribery, and they use the vocabulary of Deuteronomy's own king law. Many would have heard nothing wrong. Military logic pointed the same way: the Philistines had kings and armies, and Israel had an ageing prophet and corrupt sons.

For the hearers of the finished narrative, probably Israelites who had lived through the whole history of the monarchy down to its collapse, the verse carries heavy irony.

  • "Like all the nations" is the warning sign. Israel's calling was to be different, YHWH's own people. Wanting to be normal sounded to them like the old pattern of turning to other gods (8:8).
  • "Set up a king for us" gives the order to the prophet, where Deuteronomy says God chooses. The story corrects this at once: YHWH picks Saul (9:16) and later rejects him, then chooses David.
  • The sons problem is not solved by kingship. Kingship is just as inherited. Whether a king's son 'walked in the ways of his father' became the standing question of the books of Kings, and many did not. Samuel's warning about conscription, seizure and forced labour came true under Solomon and broke the kingdom apart (1 Kgs 5:13–14; 12:4).

The verse therefore works as the hinge of Israel's political history: the moment a covenant people asked to trade a leadership raised up by God case by case for a permanent institution modelled on its neighbours. The narrator treats this with sympathy for the grievance and suspicion of the remedy.

From the study of 1 Samuel 8:5.

Verse by verse

  1. 5“Look,” they said, “you are old, and your sons do not walk in your ways. Now appoint a king to judge us like all the other nations.”

    The elders of Israel, the "old men" of the tribes, came to Samuel and told him: "Look at the facts. You yourself have grown old. And your sons have not walked the road you walked. Their whole way of life is not yours." Everyone knew what that meant: Joel and Abijah, whom Samuel had installed as judges in the south, were taking bribes and bending verdicts (8:3).

    "So now, set up a king for us, one who will govern us and do justice for us" (the Hebrew word covers judging cases, ruling, and leading in war to rescue the people, everything Israel's "judges" had done) "just like all the nations have."

    On the surface the request is reasonable. It starts from a real injustice and borrows the wording of Deuteronomy's law about a future king ("set a king over me like all the nations," Deut 17:14). But it is phrased entirely around us: for us, to judge us. Its stated goal is to be like everyone else. And the elders tell Samuel to supply a king, where Deuteronomy says the king must be one "whom YHWH your God chooses." The hearer is meant to feel both sides: the complaint is fair, and the solution is wrong-shaped. Samuel's displeasure (8:6) and YHWH's verdict, "they have rejected me from being king over them" (8:7), follow from that.

    Full study →
  2. 6But when they said, “Give us a king to judge us,” their demand was displeasing in the sight of Samuel; so he prayed to the LORD.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v5

    to judge us

    ləšāpṭēnû (šāpaṭ)

    What we hear
    A courtroom figure who hears cases and hands down sentences.
    What they heard
    To govern and set things right: deciding disputes, ruling, and leading in war to deliver the people. In 8:20 the elders spell it out: 'our king will judge us and go out before us and fight our battles.'
  • in v5

    make us a king (KJV, WEB)

    śîmāh-lānû melek

    What we hear
    Create or produce a king, as though manufacturing one.
    What they heard
    Install or set up a king over us, the same verb used in Deuteronomy 17:15 and in 8:1 of Samuel installing his sons.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּאמְר֣וּ

    wayyōʾmərû · H0559

    and they said · v5

    The subject is 'all the elders of Israel' from verse 4. This is the formal voice of the tribal leadership, not a crowd, so the request carries official weight.

  2. אֵלָ֗יו

    ʾēlāyw · H0413

    to him · v5

    Addressed to Samuel at his home in Ramah. They bring the request to the man who holds the office they want to replace.

  3. הִנֵּה֙

    hinnēh · H2009

    look, behold · v5

    A word that points at something: 'Look at the facts.' It opens their case by naming what everyone can see, like a speaker laying out evidence before making a demand.

  4. אַתָּ֣ה

    ʾattāh · H0859A

    you (masc. sing.) · v5

    Hebrew verbs already include the subject, so adding the pronoun stresses it: 'you yourself.' The focus is on Samuel personally.

  5. זָקַ֔נְתָּ

    zāqanttā · H2204

    you have grown old · v5

    A completed state: 'you have become old.' It picks up verse 1 ('when Samuel was old'). There is a sound-play here: the zəqēnîm ('elders', literally 'old men') are telling Samuel that he has become zāqēn ('old').

  6. וּבָנֶ֕יךָ

    ûbānêkā · H1121A

    and your sons · v5

    Joel and Abijah, whom Samuel had installed as judges at Beersheba (8:1–2). The phrase brings up dynasty: Samuel had tried to pass leadership down to his sons.

  7. לֹ֥א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v5

    A plain, flat negation. The statement is blunt.

  8. הָלְכ֖וּ

    hāləkû · H1980I

    they have walked · v5

    'Walking' is the ordinary Hebrew picture for how a person lives. The completed verb form presents their conduct as a settled pattern, not one lapse. Verse 3 spells it out: they chased profit, took bribes and bent justice.

  9. בִּדְרָכֶ֑יךָ

    bidrākêkā · H1870G

    in your ways · v5

    'Your ways' means Samuel's pattern of conduct, especially his integrity as a judge, which he defends in 12:3–4 ('Whose ox have I taken? … From whom have I taken a bribe?').

  10. עַתָּ֗ה

    ʿattāh · H6258

    now · v5

    Marks the turn from facts to demand: 'So now…', 'Therefore…'. It is logical as much as temporal.

  11. שִֽׂימָה־

    śîmāh · H7760L

    set, put, appoint · v5

    A command, in a lengthened form that can sound urgent or polite: 'do set up.' It is the same verb used when Samuel 'set' his sons as judges (8:1), and it echoes Deuteronomy 17:15, 'you may surely set a king over you.'

  12. לָּ֥נוּ

    lānû · H9035

    for us · v5

    'For us.' Together with 'to judge us' a few words later, the request keeps returning to 'us': what the people want for themselves.

  13. מֶ֛לֶךְ

    melek · H4428G

    king · v5

    Not a general word for 'leader.' A melek in their world was a permanent, normally hereditary ruler with a court, a standing army and the power to tax and conscript, as Samuel's warning in 8:11–17 lays out.

  14. לְשָׁפְטֵ֖נוּ

    ləšāpṭēnû · H8199

    to judge us · v5

    'To govern us / to do justice for us.' Šāpaṭ covers ruling, settling disputes and rescuing a people from enemies, which is everything the 'judges' had done. They want a king to do the judges' job, but permanently and with an institution behind him.

  15. כְּכָל־

    kəkol · H3605

    like all · v5

    'Like all' of them, with no exceptions. The comparison is total: they want the normal arrangement that everyone else has.

  16. הַגּוֹיִֽם׃

    haggôyim · H1471A

    the nations · v5

    The surrounding peoples, such as Ammon, Moab, Edom and the Canaanite city-states, all of which had kings. The exact phrase kəkol-haggôyim also appears in Deuteronomy 17:14 and becomes the key phrase of the chapter (repeated in 8:20).

The world behind it

When and where. The scene belongs to the late Iron Age I, around the late 11th century BC. Israel was a loose union of tribes with no capital, no standing army and no central taxation. Leadership came from tribal elders and from "judges" whom God raised up in a crisis. These men and women were not hereditary rulers.

The pressure. Chapters 4–7 tell how the Philistines defeated Israel at Aphek, captured the Ark and destroyed the shrine at Shiloh (cf. Jer 7:12). The Philistines were organised, armed with iron and allied as five cities. To the east, Ammon under Nahash (ch. 11) was a kingdom. Every visible neighbour had a king and a permanent army, and Israel did not.

The internal crisis. Samuel was prophet, priest-like intercessor and circuit judge (7:15–17). He tried something new by installing his sons as judges at Beersheba (8:1–2), a step toward inherited office. They took bribes, which Deuteronomy 16:19 expressly forbids. The elders' complaint is legitimate, and it repeats what happened with Eli's sons a generation earlier.

What a "king" meant. In ANE thought the king was the gods' appointed upholder of justice and the war leader. Kingship also came at a cost. Samuel's speech on "the way of the king" (8:11–17) lists conscripting sons for chariots, daughters as perfumers and cooks, taking the best fields, a tenth of grain and flocks, and forced labour. These match royal practices recorded in texts from Ugarit and Alalakh. The elders were asking for something real and known, not an abstract ideal.

The theological background. Israel's tradition held that YHWH was king (Exod 15:18; Num 23:21; Judg 8:23). Deuteronomy 17:14–20 allowed a human king, but with strict limits: one chosen by YHWH, an Israelite, not multiplying horses, wives or silver, and bound to read and keep the Torah.

From the study of 1 Samuel 8:5.

Where scholars differ

in v5

Was asking for a king wrong in itself, or was the problem the motive and manner?

  • Kingship as such was a rejection of YHWH's direct rule.

    YHWH says 'they have rejected me from being king over them' (8:7). Samuel repeats the charge (10:19; 12:12, 17, 19). Gideon refuses dynastic rule because 'YHWH will rule over you' (Judg 8:23). Hosea 13:10–11 speaks of a king given 'in anger.'

  • Kingship was legitimate. The sin lay in the motive ('like all the nations'), in bypassing God's choice, and in trusting a human institution over YHWH.

    Deuteronomy 17:14–20 permits a king chosen by YHWH. Judges repeatedly laments that 'there was no king in Israel' (Judg 17:6; 21:25). YHWH Himself chooses Saul 'to save my people from the Philistines' (9:16) and later establishes David's dynasty (2 Sam 7). The elders tell Samuel to supply a king rather than asking YHWH to choose.

  • The narrative deliberately combines or holds together pro- and anti-monarchy perspectives.

    Older source criticism (Wellhausen; Noth's 'Deuteronomistic History') identified a critical strand (chs. 8; 10:17–27; 12) and a favourable strand (9:1–10:16; 11). Many recent literary readings (e.g. Polzin; Alter) see a single narrator who is deliberately ambivalent: kingship is a concession that God shapes but does not endorse on the people's terms.

in v5

How does this verse relate to Deuteronomy 17:14?

  • The elders are echoing an existing law, perhaps unknowingly or ironically.

    The shared verb (śîm) and identical phrase (kəkol-haggôyim) suggest the narrator wants readers to hear Deuteronomy's anticipation fulfilled, and to notice the elders omit 'whom YHWH your God chooses.'

  • Both texts were shaped by the same writers reflecting on Israel's monarchy.

    Critical scholarship commonly dates Deuteronomy in its present form to the late monarchy (7th century BC) and sees the books Joshua to Kings as edited in the same tradition. On this view the king law in Deuteronomy 17 and this request were composed in conversation with each other, in light of the kings' actual record.

in v5

What exactly does 'to judge us' mean here: justice, or military leadership?

  • Mainly justice and administration.

    The immediate trigger is the sons' bribe-taking and perversion of justice (8:3), and ANE ideology presents the king as guardian of justice.

  • Mainly military leadership and deliverance.

    In Judges, 'judging' is largely military rescue. In 8:20 the elders add 'go out before us and fight our battles', and Philistine and Ammonite pressure dominates the context (chs. 4–7, 11).

  • Both. Comprehensive governance is meant.

    The Hebrew word covers the whole range, and 8:3 and 8:20 together show both concerns. Most commentators (e.g. McCarter; Klein) take it in this inclusive sense.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שָׁפַט, מֶלֶךְ, גּוֹי, שׂוּם, דֶּרֶךְ
  • HALOT s.v. שׁפט, מֶלֶךְ, גּוֹי
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8, 1980)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • I. Mendelsohn, 'Samuel's Denunciation of Kingship in the Light of the Akkadian Documents from Ugarit,' BASOR 143 (1956)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (1999)
  • Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist (1989)
  • Martin Noth, The Deuteronomistic History
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 8
  • Code of Hammurabi, prologue and epilogue (royal justice ideology)
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 8:5; Vulgate, 1 Samuel 8:5

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.