Hosea Chapter 4 Read as one passage

Hosea 4:13–14

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

13They sacrifice on the mountaintops and burn offerings on the hills, under oak, poplar, and terebinth, because their shade is pleasant. And so your daughters turn to prostitution and your daughters-in-law to adultery. 14I will not punish your daughters when they prostitute themselves, nor your daughters-in-law when they commit adultery. For the men themselves go off with prostitutes and offer sacrifices with shrine prostitutes. So a people without understanding will come to ruin.

What the first hearers heard

To a man of the northern kingdom, the first half of this verse probably sounded like a description of ordinary religious life: the feast on the hill, the smoke, the shade of the old tree. Hosea's phrasing takes the holiness out of it. There is no mention of God appearing there or commanding it, only the remark that the shade is good. After verse 12, where the people ask questions of a piece of wood and go astray "from under" their God, it is hard to miss that they are now sitting under trees.

The second half turns the charge personally. "Your daughters... your daughters-in-law" would have stung, as the men's standing rested in part on the conduct of those women. The expected response might be to blame the girls and punish them. Verse 14 blocks that: God will not punish them, since the men are doing the same with prostitutes and shrine women. So the verse works as an accusation aimed upward. The women's behaviour is presented as the fruit of what the men have made normal, and it would have been heard as a public shaming of those who thought themselves the guardians of family and worship.

The line also carries Hosea's larger theme, that a nation's unfaithfulness to its God and the breakdown of its homes are one sickness, spoken of in one vocabulary.

From the study of Hosea 4:13.

Verse by verse

  1. 13They sacrifice on the mountaintops and burn offerings on the hills, under oak, poplar, and terebinth, because their shade is pleasant. And so your daughters turn to prostitution and your daughters-in-law to adultery.

    On the very heads of the mountains they keep slaughtering animals for their sacred feasts, and on the hills they keep sending up the smoke of their offerings. They do it under oak and poplar and terebinth, the grand old trees of the countryside, and the reason the prophet gives is almost a shrug: the shade is nice there. The people who have just strayed "from under" their God (verse 12) have settled down under a tree instead.

    Then the verse turns and speaks directly to the men listening: therefore it is your daughters, the unmarried girls of your own house, who are having sex outside any proper bond, and your daughters-in-law, the young wives brought into your family, who are breaking their marriages. The word used of the daughters is the same word just used of the whole people's unfaithfulness to God. The infidelity the men practise at the hilltop feast has come home to their own households, in the very women whose conduct carried a family's honour. The next verse goes further: God says he will not punish these women, because the men themselves are doing the same.

    Full study →
  2. 14I will not punish your daughters when they prostitute themselves, nor your daughters-in-law when they commit adultery. For the men themselves go off with prostitutes and offer sacrifices with shrine prostitutes. So a people without understanding will come to ruin.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v13

    sacrifice

    zavach

    What we hear
    Giving up something valuable at personal cost; a solemn act of self-denial.
    What they heard
    Slaughtering an animal in worship, usually leading to a shared meal with family and community. In this verse it describes a festive gathering.
  • in v13

    burn incense (KJV, WEB, NLT)

    qitter

    What we hear
    Lighting fragrant incense, a delicate ritual of aroma.
    What they heard
    Sending up the smoke of an offering, including burning fat, meat or grain. It need not involve incense at all.
  • in v13

    turn to prostitution / prostitute themselves

    zanah

    What we hear
    Selling sex for money, as a trade.
    What they heard
    Illicit sex outside a recognised bond, of which professional prostitution is one case. Nothing in this verse mentions payment, and the verb suits unmarried girls in a father's house generally.
  • in v13

    your spouses (KJV); your brides (ESV, NASB, WEB)

    kallah

    What we hear
    The listeners' own wives, or women on their wedding day.
    What they heard
    The young women who married into the household: chiefly sons' wives, as the pairing with 'your daughters' indicates.
Every word
  1. עַל־

    'al- · H5921A

    upon, on · v13

    Marks the location. Placed first, it puts the emphasis on where this is happening before saying what is happening.

  2. רָאשֵׁ֨י

    rashei · H7218I

    head, top · v13

    Literally 'heads of'. It is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying summits, and it pictures the highest, most visible points in the landscape.

  3. הֶהָרִ֜ים

    he-harim · H2022G

    mountain · v13

    The mountains of the northern hill country. High ground was a long-standing place of worship in Israel, so this is a familiar scene and not an exotic one.

  4. יְזַבֵּ֗חוּ

    yezabbechu · H2076

    to slaughter for sacrifice · v13

    They slaughter animals in worship, normally followed by a shared sacred meal. The verb form describes ongoing, repeated practice: they keep doing this.

  5. הַגְּבָעוֹת֙

    ha-geva'ot · H1389I

    hill · v13

    Hills, the standard poetic partner of 'mountains'. Together the pair means the high ground everywhere, not two separate sets of places.

  6. יְקַטֵּ֔רוּ

    yeqatteru · H6999H

    to make (sacrificial) smoke · v13

    They send up the smoke of offerings. The word is about smoke rising to the deity and need not mean incense in particular; it pairs with the previous verb to describe the whole act of sacrifice.

  7. תַּ֣חַת

    tachat · H8478G

    under · v13

    Under. It picks up the end of verse 12, where the people have strayed 'from under' their God; now they are found under trees.

  8. אַלּ֧וֹן

    'allon · H0437

    oak · v13

    A large oak, one of the great landmark trees of the hill country. Such trees marked burial sites and holy places in Israel's own stories (Genesis 35:8).

  9. וְלִבְנֶ֛ה

    ve-livneh · H3839

    poplar or storax · v13

    A tree named from the root for 'white', probably the white poplar or the storax. The exact species is uncertain, but the point is a tree giving welcome shade.

  10. וְאֵלָ֖ה

    ve-'elah · H0424

    terebinth · v13

    The terebinth, a broad, long-lived tree of the pistachio family. Together the three trees say 'wherever there is a good big tree', not a botanical list of permitted species.

  11. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v13

    Gives the reason for choosing these spots. What follows is a very ordinary reason, and that is the sting.

  12. ט֣וֹב

    tov · H2896A

    good, pleasant · v13

    Good in the sense of agreeable or comfortable. It is not a moral term here: the shade is nice.

  13. צִלָּ֑הּ

    tsillah · H6738

    shade, shadow · v13

    'Its shade'. In a hot land shade is relief, and in biblical speech it is also a picture of protection, which Hosea later claims for life under God (14:7). The 'its' is singular, treating the trees as one or pointing to the last one named.

  14. כֵּ֗ן

    ken · H3651C

    so, thus · v13

    Second half of 'therefore'. It ties what the women do directly to what has just been said about the worship led and practised by the men.

  15. תִּזְנֶ֙ינָה֙

    tizneinah · H2181

    to engage in illicit sex; to prostitute oneself · v13

    The daughters have sex outside any legitimate bond. This is the same verb used of the people in verse 12, there masculine and about abandoning God, here feminine and about the household's own young women.

  16. בְּנ֣וֹתֵיכֶ֔ם

    benoteikhem · H1323G

    daughter · v13

    'Your daughters', meaning unmarried girls still under their father's roof and responsibility. The 'your' is masculine plural: the men are being addressed to their faces.

  17. וְכַלּוֹתֵיכֶ֖ם

    ve-khalloteikhem · H3618G

    bride; daughter-in-law · v13

    The young women who have married into your household, your sons' wives. The word views a woman from the side of the family she has joined.

  18. תְּנָאַֽפְנָה׃

    tena'afnah · H5003

    to commit adultery · v13

    They break a marriage bond. It is the right word for women who are already married, just as the earlier verb suits the unmarried, and it closes the verse on the most serious offence against a household.

The world behind it

When and where. Hosea spoke in the northern kingdom of Israel in the 8th century BC, from the prosperous years of Jeroboam II into the chaos before Assyria destroyed the kingdom (Hosea 1:1).

Worship on the heights. Hilltop and open-air worship was old and widespread in Israel. Samuel presided at one such place (1 Samuel 9:12-13), Solomon sacrificed at them (1 Kings 3:2-4), and Elijah repaired an altar on Carmel (1 Kings 18:30). Archaeology shows Iron Age open-air and hilltop cult sites in the region, such as the so-called Bull Site in the Samaria hills. So the people in this verse need not have felt they were doing anything strange. Many probably thought of it as traditional religion, perhaps even as serving Israel's God (see Hosea 2:16). Great trees had the same aura from the ancestor stories (Genesis 12:6-7; 35:4).

What the feast was. A zevach was a shared meal: animal killed, fat burned, meat eaten, usually with drink (4:11 mentions wine). These were community occasions, including for the household's women.

Why daughters and daughters-in-law. In this society a man was answerable for the sexual conduct of the women in his household, and his standing in the community was bound up with it. A daughter's chastity affected her marriage and the family's name (Deuteronomy 22:13-21). A son's wife had joined his house and came under its protection. Telling men "your daughters, your daughters-in-law" was a public attack on their honour, in a culture where honour was a real social asset. Genesis 38 offers a striking parallel: Judah hears that his kallah has done zanah, and in the same story zonah and qedeshah (the pair in Hosea 4:14) are used of the same woman.

From the study of Hosea 4:13.

Where scholars differ

in v13

What does 'therefore' connect? How does hillside worship lead to the sexual conduct of daughters and daughters-in-law?

  • Ritual sex: the women took part in sexual rites at the shrines, perhaps a once-only rite before or at marriage to secure fertility (the proposal of Leonhard Rost, developed by Hans Walter Wolff).

    Verse 14 places the men with qedeshot, 'consecrated women', in the context of sacrifice. Herodotus 1.199 describes Babylonian women having sex with a stranger at a temple once in life. Critics respond that Herodotus is late, foreign and doubtful, and that recent studies (Westenholz, Oden, Budin) have found little firm evidence for sacred prostitution in the ancient Near East.

  • Social consequence: the feasts and the men's own conduct created a setting and an example, and the young women's behaviour followed. It was real sexual misconduct, but not a formal rite.

    Verse 14 explains the women's behaviour by the men's: 'the men themselves go off with prostitutes'. Verse 11 mentions wine. Festivals as settings for sexual misconduct fit Judges 21:19-21 loosely, and this reading requires no reconstructed ritual.

  • Fitting judgement: the disgrace in the men's homes is the penalty for their infidelity, mirroring their offence.

    The same verb applies to men in verse 12 and women in verse 13. 'Therefore' introduces a consequence at 4:3. Amos 7:17 and Deuteronomy 28:30 threaten similar family disgrace. Verse 14's refusal to punish the women would fit their being more the sign of judgement than its target.

  • Largely metaphor: the sexual language describes the women's and nation's religious and social unfaithfulness, not chiefly sexual acts (variously Alice Keefe; compare Phyllis Bird on the metaphor's workings).

    Hosea uses zanah figuratively through the chapter. Critics note that the specific kinship terms and the careful choice of verbs by marital status in verse 13 look literal, at least in part. These readings are not all mutually exclusive.

in v13

Who is being worshipped on these hills: other gods, or Israel's God in forms Hosea rejects?

  • Baal and other deities.

    Hosea names the Baals as recipients of the same acts (2:13; 11:2). Verse 12 speaks of straying from their God. Some see goddess links in the trees, as at Kuntillet Ajrud.

  • A blended worship in which Israel's God was addressed in Baal-like terms, so that the people may have thought themselves faithful.

    Hosea 2:16 ('you will no longer call me my Baal'), the long history of accepted high places in Samuel and Kings, and the ancestral holy trees. This verse itself names no deity, so it can't settle the question alone.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. זָבַח, קָטַר, זָנָה, נָאַף, כַּלָּה, צֵל
  • HALOT s.v. זנה, נאף, כַּלָּה, אֵלָה, אַלּוֹן, לִבְנֶה
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Hosea 4:13
  • Vulgate, Hosea 4:13
  • H. W. Wolff, Hosea (Hermeneia)
  • F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Hosea (Anchor Bible 24)
  • L. Rost, 'Erwägungen zu Hosea 4:13f.' (1950)
  • P. Bird, 'To Play the Harlot: An Inquiry into an Old Testament Metaphor' (1989)
  • A. Keefe, Woman's Body and the Social Body in Hosea (2001)
  • J. G. Westenholz, 'Tamar, Qĕdēšā, Qadištu and Sacred Prostitution in Mesopotamia,' HTR 82 (1989)
  • S. Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (2008)
  • D. Edelman, 'The Meaning of Qiṭṭēr,' VT 35 (1985)
  • W. Holladay, 'On Every High Hill and Under Every Green Tree,' VT 11 (1961)
  • M. Zohary, Plants of the Bible (1982)
  • Herodotus, Histories 1.199

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.