Jeremiah Chapter 49 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 49:9–10
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
9If grape gatherers came to you, would they not leave some gleanings? Were thieves to come in the night, would they not steal only what they wanted? 10But I will strip Esau bare; I will uncover his hiding places, and he will be unable to conceal himself. His descendants will be destroyed along with his relatives and neighbors, and he will be no more.
What the first hearers heard
To Judeans, Edom's betrayal when Jerusalem fell was an open wound. They heard this verse as a promise that Edom would be judged more completely than any ordinary disaster. They would have nodded along at both pictures: of course harvesters leave gleanings, since their own law required it, and of course a burglar takes only what he can carry. Then v.10 overturns what they expected: God himself will strip Esau bare, uncover his hiding places, and leave nothing. In a land of terraced vineyards, the image of a vine stripped down to the last grape meant ruin with no remnant, a people that "will be no more" (v.10). Those who knew the gleaning laws may also have felt the irony: Edom showed no mercy to fleeing Judeans (Obad 14), and now Edom will not even be granted the leftover grapes owed to the poor.
From the study of Jeremiah 49:9.
Verse by verse
-
9If grape gatherers came to you, would they not leave some gleanings? Were thieves to come in the night, would they not steal only what they wanted?
Full study →Picture Edom as a vineyard and then as a house. Suppose the grape harvesters came to you: wouldn't they leave a few stray clusters on the vine? Every Israelite knew that harvesters never strip a vine completely. It does not happen in practice, and the law said those last grapes belonged to the poor, the widow and the orphan. Suppose burglars came in the night: wouldn't they wreck and take only as much as they wanted, and then slip away? Even a thief breaking in through the wall in the dark stops at "enough", at what he can carry.
Both pictures describe ordinary human loss: painful, but limited, and it always leaves something behind. The next verse turns on them: "But I will strip Esau bare." What God brings on Edom will be unlike the harvester or the thief. It will leave no gleanings and stop at no "enough". The harvesters (bōṣərîm) probably also play on the name of Edom's capital, Bozrah: Edom's own "Bozrah" will be harvested. Jeremiah's word for what the thieves do is stronger than "steal". It means "ruin" or "spoil". That makes the contrast sharper still: even destroyers stop somewhere, and this judgment will not.
-
10But I will strip Esau bare; I will uncover his hiding places, and he will be unable to conceal himself. His descendants will be destroyed along with his relatives and neighbors, and he will be no more.
Full study →Grape-pickers always leave a few clusters on the vine. Thieves in the night take what they want and go. But I myself, not some passing raider, have already stripped Esau naked. God speaks of what he will do as if it were finished. The words are the ones used for pulling off a person's clothes in public shame. I have laid open every place where he hides, every cave, cleft and rock shelter in Edom's mountains where its people and treasure were hidden. He will try to hide himself, and he will not be able to. Then comes the result, with the ruin put first for emphasis: ravaged — his offspring, his kinsmen and his neighbors. The violence takes the next generation, the related clans, and the peoples around Edom. And in two stark Hebrew words, the same idiom used of Enoch and of Rachel's lost children: "and he is not." Edom, the nation descended from Esau, Jacob's brother, will simply no longer exist.
Where the English drifted
-
in v9
they will destroy till they have enough (KJV)
hišḥîtû dayyām
- What we hear
- The thieves keep destroying until they are satisfied, which sounds like an extended rampage.
- What they heard
- The thieves ruin and take only as much as they need and then stop. The phrase is about a limit, and the contrast with v.10 depends on it.
-
in v10
Esau
ʿēśāw
- What we hear
- The individual man in Genesis, Jacob's brother, as if God were judging him personally.
- What they heard
- The nation of Edom, called by its ancestor's name and spoken of as one man.
-
in v10
his secret places (KJV, WEB, YLT)
mistārāyw
- What we hear
- His secrets, hidden sins or private thoughts that God will reveal.
- What they heard
- Physical hiding places: caves, rock clefts, lairs and hidden stores in Edom's mountains.
-
in v10
his seed is spoiled (KJV)
šuddad zarʿô
- What we hear
- 'Spoiled' sounds like rotten or pampered, and 'seed' like something planted in the ground.
- What they heard
- His offspring (descendants) are violently plundered and devastated.
Every word
-
אִם־
ʾim · H0518A
if · v9
Opens an imagined situation: 'suppose harvesters came...'. The verbs after it describe a hypothetical case, not something that has happened.
-
בֹּֽצְרִים֙
bōṣərîm · H1219
grape-harvesters · v9
Workers who cut the clusters off the vine at vintage. The word sounds like Bozrah, Edom's chief city, which is named in v.13.
-
בָּ֣אוּ
bāʾû · H0935G
they came · v9
A completed-action verb used inside the 'if' clause to set up the imagined scene: 'if harvesters had come'.
-
לָ֔ךְ
lāk · H9032
to you · v9
'To you' in the singular. Edom/Esau is addressed directly as one person, as though he were a vineyard or a house.
-
לֹ֥א
lōʾ · H3808
not · v9, v10
A plain negative. With no question word present, it allows either 'would they not leave...?' or 'they would not leave...'.
-
יַשְׁאִ֖רוּ
yašʾîrû · H7604
they leave remaining · v9
'Cause to remain, leave behind'. The same root gives the prophets' word for a 'remnant', the survivors who are left.
-
עֽוֹלֵל֑וֹת
ʿôlēlôt · H5955
gleanings · v9
The stray grapes left on the vine after the main harvest. Israelite law said these were to be left for the poor (Lev 19:10; Deut 24:21).
-
גַּנָּבִ֥ים
gannābîm · H1590
thieves · v9
Burglars who take property secretly. They are not an army. The point is that they take only what they can carry off.
-
בַּלַּ֖יְלָה
ballaylâ · H3915
in the night · v9
Night-time burglary means working quickly and in secret, so it is limited by its nature.
-
הִשְׁחִ֥יתוּ
hišḥîtû · H7843
they ruined / did damage · v9
'Ruin, spoil, wreck.' This is a stronger word than Obadiah's 'steal': the thieves damage and plunder, but only up to a point.
-
דַיָּֽם׃
dayyām · H1767
their sufficiency · v9
'Their enough', meaning only as much as they wanted. This is the limit every human plunderer reaches, and it sets up God's total stripping in v.10.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
for, because; but rather · v10
It follows the two rhetorical questions of v.9 (grape-pickers and thieves always leave something). Here it means 'but in fact' or 'no, rather': unlike them, God will leave nothing. That is why BSB and KJV have 'But' and YLT has 'For'.
-
אֲנִ֞י
ʾănî · H0589
I · v10
The verb already says 'I', so the separate pronoun adds emphasis: 'I myself'. The real plunderer is not a human raider but the LORD, the God of Israel.
-
חָשַׂ֣פְתִּי
ḥāśaptî · H2834
to strip bare, lay bare · v10
'I have stripped bare.' The word is used for pulling off a covering, whether clothing, bark or a sleeve. It carries the shame of being exposed in public. The past-tense form announces a future act as if it were already done.
-
אֶת־
ʾet · H0853
[direct-object marker] · v10
Marks 'Esau' as the thing stripped. It has no English equivalent.
-
עֵשָׂ֗ו
ʿēśāw · H6215H
-
גִּלֵּ֙יתִי֙
gillêtî · H1540I
to uncover, reveal · v10
'I have uncovered.' It pairs with 'strip bare'. In the intensive form used here, this verb is the standard Hebrew wording for uncovering nakedness (Lev 18), so the two verbs together suggest shameful public exposure.
-
מִסְתָּרָ֔יו
mistārāyw · H4565
hiding place, lair · v10
'His hiding places': physical places of concealment, like the lurking-spots of a predator (Ps 10:8–9). In Edom these are the caves and rock clefts of its mountains (v.16), where people and stored goods could be hidden.
-
וְנֶחְבָּ֖ה
wəneḥbâ · H2247
to hide oneself · v10
'And to hide himself...' The written form looks like a finite verb ('and he hides'), but the sense is plain. Edom will try to hide and fail. Most translations treat it as 'to hide'.
-
יוּכָ֑ל
yûkāl · H3201
to be able, prevail · v10
'He will (not) be able.' The mountain hideouts that made Edom feel untouchable (v.16) give it no power to escape.
-
שֻׁדַּ֥ד
šuddad · H7703
-
זַרְע֛וֹ
zarʿô · H2233H
seed; offspring · v10
'His seed', meaning his offspring or descendants: the next generation of Edom, its future.
-
וְאֶחָ֥יו
wəʾeḥāyw · H0251G
brother; kinsman · v10
'And his brothers': Edom's kin, probably related clans and tribes. It does not mean Israel here, although Esau was Jacob's brother.
-
וּשְׁכֵנָ֖יו
ûšəkēnāyw · H7934
neighbor, inhabitant nearby · v10
'And his neighbors': the peoples living around Edom, possibly the Arabian groups such as Dedan named in v.8. The ruin spreads beyond Edom's own borders.
-
וְאֵינֶֽנּוּ׃
wəʾênennû · H0369
The world behind it
An oracle against Edom. Jeremiah 46–51 is a collection of prophecies against the nations around Judah. The Edom section (49:7–22) shares a great deal with the book of Obadiah: v.9 is almost word for word Obadiah 5, and vv.14–16 match Obadiah 1–4. Edom, the descendants of Esau, Jacob's brother, lived in the rugged highlands south-east of the Dead Sea, with its chief city at Bozrah. Israel remembered Edom bitterly for joining in, or cheering, the fall of Jerusalem to Babylon in 587/586 BC (Ps 137:7; Lam 4:21–22; Obad 10–14). Edom's kingdom did decline in the following generations. The Babylonian king Nabonidus campaigned in the region around 552 BC, and Arab groups later moved into its territory.
Harvest custom. At vintage the main crew cut the clusters, but some grapes were always missed or left on purpose. Israelite law required that the vineyard not be gone over a second time; those grapes were for the poor and the foreigner (Lev 19:10; Deut 24:21). So "harvesters always leave gleanings" was common knowledge, and a matter of religious duty too.
Night thieves. Houses were mud-brick, and burglars often 'dug through' the walls at night (Exod 22:2; Job 24:16). Such thieves had to work quickly and travel light, so they took only what they could carry.
Dedan (v.8) was an Arabian trading people whose caravans passed through Edom. They are warned to get out of the way before the judgment falls.
From the study of Jeremiah 49:9.
Where scholars differ
in v9
Are the lines rhetorical questions ('would they not leave gleanings?') or statements ('they will leave no gleanings')?
-
Rhetorical questions: even harvesters and thieves leave something, but God will leave nothing (v.10).
The parallel Obadiah 5 has the question word hălôʾ. Hebrew can ask questions without a particle. The 'But I' (kî-ʾănî) of v.10 reads naturally as a contrast. This is the view of most modern translations and commentaries.
-
Statements: the harvesters who come against Edom will leave nothing, and the thieves will destroy all they can.
Jeremiah lacks the question particle that Obadiah has, and may have reshaped the saying deliberately. The Septuagint appears to read statements, and YLT follows the Hebrew literally.
in v9
How is Jeremiah 49:7–22 related to Obadiah 1–6?
-
Jeremiah adapted Obadiah.
Obadiah's version is tighter and more natural in its context. Jeremiah's changes (the order, 'ruin' for 'steal', no question words) look like reworking.
-
Obadiah drew on Jeremiah.
Obadiah is often dated after 587 BC because of its account of Edom's conduct at Jerusalem's fall, which could make it later than Jeremiah's oracle.
-
Both used an older oracle against Edom.
Each version has material the other lacks, and each fits its own context. A shared earlier saying explains the overlap and the differences.
in v10
Who are 'his brothers and his neighbors'?
-
Related clans and tribes allied with Edom, such as Dedan, Tema or Buz, which are named around this oracle (49:8; 25:23).
Verse 8 tells the people of Dedan to flee, which places them in the same disaster. 'Brothers' often means kin groups or tribes.
-
The terms simply round out the picture of total destruction: family, kin and surroundings.
Lists like 'seed, brothers, neighbors' are a common way of saying 'everyone connected to him'.
-
In the Greek tradition, brother and neighbor are the agents of Edom's ruin.
The Septuagint appears to read 'by the hand of his brother and neighbor', which some link to the later Arab (Nabataean) takeover of Edom.
in v10
How does 'he is no more' fit with God's care for Edom's orphans and widows in v.11?
-
Verse 11 is a real offer of mercy: God will look after the helpless survivors even as the nation ends.
'I will keep them alive' and 'let your widows trust in me' match God's usual role as protector of orphans and widows (Deut 10:18; Ps 68:5).
-
Verse 11 is ironic or bitter. No men will be left to care for the families, so 'leave them to me'.
It directly follows the statement that the men, kin and neighbors are destroyed, and its tone in context is debated among commentators.
in v10
Did Jeremiah borrow from Obadiah, or Obadiah from Jeremiah?
Sources
- BDB s.v. בָּצַר, עֹלֵלוֹת, שָׁחַת, דַּי
- HALOT s.v. עֹלֵלוֹת; שׁחת hiphil
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §150a on questions without an interrogative particle
- Obadiah 1–6 (parallel text)
- Leviticus 19:10; Deuteronomy 24:21 (gleaning laws)
- Exodus 22:2–3; Job 24:16 (night burglary)
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia) on 49:7–22
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible) on 49:9
- Septuagint Jeremiah ch. 29 (Edom oracle)
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 49:9
- BDB s.v. חָשַׂף, מִסְתָּר, שָׁדַד, אַיִן
- HALOT s.v. חשׂף, מִסְתָּר, חבה, שׁדד
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia), on 49:7–22
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible), on 49:9–10
- J. R. Bartlett, Edom and the Edomites
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.257–258
- Nabonidus relief at as-Sela' (southern Jordan)
- BHS critical apparatus on Jer 49:10
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).