Jeremiah Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 9:12–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

12Who is the man wise enough to understand this? To whom has the mouth of the LORD spoken, that he may explain it? Why is the land destroyed and scorched like a desert, so no one can pass through it? 13And the LORD answered, “It is because they have forsaken My law, which I set before them; they have not walked in it or obeyed My voice.

What the first hearers heard

To people in Judah who heard this before 586 BC, it was a provocation. Their leaders were saying the nation was secure ('the temple of the LORD,' 7:4) and that its wise men had God's instruction in hand (8:8). Jeremiah describes the land as though it has already died, scorched and empty like the wilderness. Then he asks who among their experts can explain it. Anyone who knew Deuteronomy would recognise the vocabulary of the covenant curses ('perish from the land') and the stock question 'Why has the LORD done this?' That pointed them to the answer before 9:13 spelled it out: the cause was abandoning the LORD's instruction, not bad luck, bad politics or a weak god.

To the exiles who read the scroll after the destruction, the same verse helped explain a disaster that had already happened. The ruin was not a sign that the LORD had been defeated. It was his covenant warnings coming true. True wisdom meant accepting that explanation, not the comforting assurances of the court experts. The verse also prepares for the climax of the chapter: 'Let not the wise man boast in his wisdom… but let him who boasts boast in this, that he understands and knows me' (9:23–24). The verb 'understand' there is a different Hebrew word from the one in this verse, but the point carries across.

From the study of Jeremiah 9:12.

Verse by verse

  1. 12Who is the man wise enough to understand this? To whom has the mouth of the LORD spoken, that he may explain it? Why is the land destroyed and scorched like a desert, so no one can pass through it?

    Who is truly wise, wise enough to see what is behind this? Who has actually heard the LORD speak, so that he can stand up and tell the people plainly what it means? Here is what needs explaining: why has the land died? Why has it been burned and wrecked until it looks like the empty wilderness, with not even a traveller crossing it?

    The verse is a challenge. Judah had its professional sages and its prophets, the people whose job was to read events and speak for God. Jeremiah 8:8–9 has just said that these wise men rejected the LORD's word. So the question 'Who is the wise man?' is pointed, and the expected answer is close to 'no one.' Two qualifications are named. One is insight, the ability to discern causes. The other is revelation, having been spoken to by 'the mouth of the LORD.' Having received the word also means being obliged to pass it on publicly.

    The disaster is described in heavy, covenant-laden words. The land has 'perished,' the verb Deuteronomy uses when it warns that Israel will 'perish from the good land' if it forsakes the LORD. The land is 'burned' or 'laid waste' (the Hebrew allows both). It has become 'like the wilderness,' the uninhabited back-country Israel once crossed on the way into the land (2:6). And 'no one passes through': even the roads are empty. The promised land has gone back to the wilderness Israel was rescued from. The verse sets up a question that only God can answer, and in the next verse he does: 'Because they have forsaken my instruction…'

    Full study →
  2. 13And the LORD answered, “It is because they have forsaken My law, which I set before them; they have not walked in it or obeyed My voice.

    The prophet has just asked a question nobody wants to answer: Who is wise enough to explain why the land lies ruined, burnt like a wilderness that no one passes through? Now the LORD answers it himself, and the verse could be expanded like this:

    "Here is the reason. They walked out on my teaching, the instruction I personally gave them and set right in front of their eyes. They would not listen when I spoke to them, and they would not walk the road that teaching laid out."

    There are three charges, and each one makes the others worse:

    • Desertion. The verb is the one used for abandoning a partner or ally. Leaving God's torah is the same thing as leaving God (as in Jer 2:13).
    • A gift refused. "My torah, which I gave, before their faces." "Torah" is broader than a legal code. It is a teacher's or parent's instruction, a whole way of living, and it was offered openly, the way Deuteronomy says God "set before" Israel life and death.
    • A voice ignored and a road not taken. In Hebrew, "listening to someone's voice" means heeding it, and "walking in" a teaching means living by it. The next verse finishes the picture. Israel kept walking, but after their own stubborn hearts and after the Baals. They didn't stop following; they changed masters.

    The ruin of the land is therefore not presented as bad luck or a Babylonian victory alone. It is what happens when a people breaks faith with the covenant partner who taught them how to live in that land.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    desert

    midbar

    What we hear
    A sandy, barren desert like the Sahara.
    What they heard
    Uncultivated, unsettled open country (steppe, scrub, seasonal pasture), defined by having no towns or farms. It also recalls the wilderness of the exodus wanderings.
  • in v12

    the wise man

    ha'ish hechakham

    What we hear
    Any thoughtful, intelligent person.
    What they heard
    Includes that, but in Jeremiah 'the wise' are also a recognised class of royal counsellors and scribes (8:8–9; 18:18). The question puts their claimed expertise to the test.
  • in v13

    my law

    tôrātî

    What we hear
    A legal code or set of statutes, like criminal or civil law, enforced with penalties; often heard in contrast to 'grace'.
    What they heard
    'My instruction or teaching': the covenant guidance God gave Israel. It includes commands but has the feel of a parent's or teacher's direction, a way of life given as a gift ('which I gave before them').
Every word
  1. מִֽי־

    mi · H4310

    who? · v12

    Opens a challenge-question. It governs both halves of the first line: who is wise, and who has received the LORD's word. In context the question is close to rhetorical: Judah's self-styled wise men have just been exposed (8:8–9).

  2. הָאִ֤ישׁ

    ha'ish · H376

    man, person · v12

    'The man.' This is the ordinary word for a person, and the definite article makes it a type: 'the sort of man who is truly wise.'

  3. הֶֽחָכָם֙

    hechakham · H2450

    wise · v12

    'The wise one.' In Jeremiah this points at the recognised class of sages and counsellors (18:18). The question puts their competence to the test.

  4. וְיָבֵ֣ן

    veyaven · H995

    to understand, discern · v12

    'So that he may understand.' The verb means discerning, seeing through to the real cause. Here the cause is why the catastrophe happened.

  5. אֶת־

    et · H853

    (direct-object marker) · v12, v13

    An untranslated marker. It shows that 'this' is the object of 'understand.'

  6. זֹ֔את

    zot · H2063

    this · v12

    'This.' It means the whole devastation just announced in 9:10–11. The word is feminine, and the 'it' in 'declare it' points back to it.

  7. וַאֲשֶׁ֨ר

    va'asher · H834

    who, which · v12, v13

    'And [the one] whom.' This starts a second candidate, the person who has received revelation, next to the wise man.

  8. דִּבֶּ֧ר

    dibber · H1696

    to speak · v12

    'Has spoken.' The tense describes completed speech: someone to whom God has actually said something.

  9. פִּֽי־

    pi · H6310

    mouth · v12

    'The mouth of.' The idiom 'the mouth of the LORD has spoken' marks direct, authoritative speech from God (compare Isaiah 1:20; 40:5). It is the mark of a true prophet.

  10. יְהוָ֛ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (the divine name) · v12, v13

    Israel's covenant God, named personally. Only his word can explain what he himself has done to the land.

  11. אֵלָ֖יו

    elav · H413

    to, toward · v12

    'To him.' It finishes the Hebrew way of saying 'whom': literally 'who … spoke to him.'

  12. וְיַגִּדָ֑הּ

    veyaggidah · H5046

    to tell, declare, make known · v12

    'So that he may declare it.' The causative form means to set something plainly in front of someone. The recipient of revelation is expected to report it publicly.

  13. עַל־

    al · H5921

    upon, on account of · v12, v13

    Combined with 'what,' it means 'on what grounds,' that is, 'why.' It asks for the cause.

  14. מָה֙

    mah · H4100

    what? · v12

    'What?' Together with the previous word: 'on account of what?' This is the standard form of the 'why did this happen?' question.

  15. אָבְדָ֣ה

    avedah · H6

    to perish, be lost, be ruined · v12

    'Has perished.' The land itself is pictured as dying or being lost. The word is strong enough to be used of people who die.

  16. הָאָ֔רֶץ

    ha'arets · H776

    land, earth · v12

    'The land': the territory of Judah, the land promised and given under the covenant. It does not mean the whole planet.

  17. נִצְּתָ֥ה

    nitstsetah · H3341

    to be kindled, burned · v12

    'Has been burned' or 'laid waste.' Lexicons disagree about the root (see textual notes). Either way it describes a land scorched or wrecked by invasion.

  18. כַמִּדְבָּ֖ר

    khammidbar · H4057

    wilderness, steppe · v12

    'Like the wilderness.' The farmed and settled land has become like the uncultivated back-country where nobody lives.

  19. מִבְּלִ֖י

    mibbeli · H1097

    without, for lack of · v12

    'With no…' or 'so that there is no…'. It states the result: the land is empty.

  20. עֹבֵֽר׃

    over · H5674

    to pass over, pass through · v12

    'One passing through.' Not even travellers or caravans cross it any more. The roads are dead, which is a step beyond 'without inhabitant' in 9:11.

  21. וַיֹּ֣אמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v13

    Brings in God's own answer to the riddle of verse 12 ('Why has the land perished?'). The prophet asked who could explain it. Now the One whose mouth speaks gives the explanation himself.

  22. עָזְבָם֙

    ʿozbām · H5800A

    to leave, abandon, forsake · v13

    A verb-noun with a suffix: 'their forsaking'. It names deliberate desertion, the kind of leaving one does to a partner or an ally, and it is the charge on which the whole verdict rests.

  23. תּ֣וֹרָתִ֔י

    tôrātî · H8451

    instruction, teaching, law · v13

    'My instruction': the covenant teaching God gave Israel. It holds commands, but it is framed as a teacher's or parent's guidance, a way to live. The 'my' makes it personal.

  24. נָתַ֖תִּי

    nātattî · H5414Q

    to give, set, put · v13

    'I gave / I set.' The verb stresses that God took the first step and that the instruction was a gift. Israel did not lack it. They had it and walked away from it.

  25. לִפְנֵיהֶ֑ם

    lipnêhem · H6440G

    before (literally 'to the face of') · v13

    'Before their faces': set out in plain view, the way Deuteronomy says God 'sets before' Israel life and death. No one can claim not to have known.

  26. וְלֹא־

    wəlōʾ- · H3808

    and not · v13

    Starts the first of two parallel denials that spell out what 'forsaking' looked like in practice.

  27. שָׁמְע֥וּ

    šāməʿû · H8085H

    to hear, listen, heed, obey · v13

    'They listened.' With 'to the voice' it means listening that responds: heeding, obeying. Hebrew has no separate verb for 'obey', so to hear properly is to do.

  28. בְקוֹלִ֖י

    bəqôlî · H6963A

    voice, sound · v13

    'To my voice.' The torah is not a dead text here. It is God's living voice, heard again through priests and prophets such as Jeremiah himself.

  29. הָ֥לְכוּ

    hāləkû · H1980I

    to walk, go · v13

    'They walked.' Walking is the ordinary Hebrew picture for a way of life. Verse 14 turns on the same verb: they did walk, but 'after' their stubborn hearts and 'after' the Baals.

  30. בָֽהּ׃

    bāh · H9034

    in it (her) · v13

    'In it.' The suffix is feminine and points back to torah (a feminine noun). The torah is pictured as a road to walk in.

The world behind it

A familiar 'why' question. In the ancient Near East, when a city or land was ruined, people asked why its god had allowed it. Assyrian texts, for example, explain disasters by a god's anger at broken oaths. The Bible has a stock form of this question and answer: 'Why has the LORD done thus to this land?' — 'Because they forsook the covenant of the LORD…' (Deuteronomy 29:24–28; 1 Kings 9:8–9; Jeremiah 22:8–9). Jeremiah 9:12–13 follows the same pattern. The question here is voiced as a challenge to the experts, and the LORD gives the answer himself.

The wise, the priest and the prophet. In Jeremiah's Jerusalem (late 600s to 586 BC), three groups claimed to guide the nation: 'instruction from the priest, counsel from the wise, the word from the prophet' (18:18). The 'wise' were royal counsellors and scribes, the educated class who handled written instruction (8:8). By asking for someone who is both wise and addressed by the LORD, the verse requires the two qualifications to go together, and implies that the official experts had neither.

What invasion looked like. Babylonian campaigns (597 BC, and 588–586 BC) burned towns, cut down orchards and emptied the countryside. Trade routes through Judah would have gone quiet. 'No one passes through' describes that: no caravans, no pilgrims, no herders. It is a land outside the life of the region.

From the study of Jeremiah 9:12.

Where scholars differ

in v12

Did Jeremiah himself compose verses 12–16, or were they added later by editors explaining the exile?

  • These verses are later prose by editors (often linked to the school behind Deuteronomy, the 'Deuteronomistic' editors), added after 586 BC to explain the catastrophe.

    They are prose following a poetic lament. Their wording ('forsaken my instruction,' 'not listened to my voice,' 'walked after the stubbornness of their heart') is typical of Deuteronomy-style editing. The question-and-answer form also appears in Deuteronomy 29 and 1 Kings 9 (e.g. McKane, Carroll).

  • The material goes back substantially to Jeremiah, who himself drew on Deuteronomy's language.

    Jeremiah came from a priestly family and lived through Josiah's reform, which centred on a Deuteronomy-like scroll, so that vocabulary would be natural for him. The wise-man theme ties in with 8:8–9 and 9:23–24 (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom).

in v12

Is the question a real call for an interpreter or an ironic rhetorical question?

  • Ironic: no human expert can answer, so God answers himself in 9:13.

    8:8–9 says the wise have rejected the LORD's word. In 9:13 the LORD, not a sage, supplies the answer.

  • A real summons for the true prophet and true wisdom to step forward, implicitly Jeremiah himself.

    The second qualification, being spoken to by 'the mouth of the LORD,' describes a true prophet. Jeremiah is the one who does go on to 'declare' the answer to the people.

in v13

What does 'my torah' refer to here: a written book (Deuteronomy / the Mosaic law) or God's instruction more broadly, including priestly and prophetic teaching?

  • A written covenant document, most likely some form of Deuteronomy.

    The phrasing here ('forsake', 'set before', 'walk in', 'obey my voice') matches Deuteronomy closely. Deuteronomy calls itself 'this torah'. The 'book of the torah' found under Josiah (2 Kgs 22) was recent history. Jer 8:8 mentions a written torah handled by scribes.

  • God's covenant instruction in a broader sense, handed down by priests and renewed through prophets.

    Jeremiah also uses torah for priestly teaching (18:18) and links it closely to God's living 'voice' through the prophets (7:23–26; 26:4–5). The parallel with 'my voice' in this verse points to ongoing spoken instruction, not only a fixed text.

in v13

Who wrote the prose of 9:12–16: Jeremiah himself or later editors in the style of Deuteronomy?

  • Later editing in the 'Deuteronomistic' style (the school of writers whose language matches Deuteronomy and the books of Kings).

    Many of Jeremiah's prose sermons share fixed phrases with Deuteronomy and Kings. Scholars such as Hyatt, Nicholson and Thiel attribute them to editors working around the time of the exile.

  • Basically Jeremiah's own words, in the prose style of his time.

    Others (e.g. Holladay, Bright, Weippert) argue that Deuteronomy's style was simply the common prose style of late 7th-century Judah, and that the prose sermons fit Jeremiah's situation and themes.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חָכָם, בִּין, נָגַד, אָבַד, יָצַת, מִדְבָּר
  • HALOT s.v. יצת, נצה, מִדְבָּר
  • Burke O. Long, "Two Question and Answer Schemata in the Prophets," JBL 90 (1971)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:11; Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:12
  • BDB s.v. תּוֹרָה, עָזַב, שָׁמַע, הָלַךְ, נָתַן
  • HALOT s.v. תּוֹרָה; עזב I
  • Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (1972): treaty background and the 'why has the land been destroyed?' question-and-answer form
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia, 1986), on 9:11–15
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT, 1980)
  • Rahlfs–Hanhart Septuaginta; J. Ziegler, Ieremias (Göttingen Septuagint)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Jer 9:13
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology) and BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT texts

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).