Job Chapter 17 Read as one passage

Job 17:3–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

3Give me, I pray, the pledge You demand. Who else will be my guarantor? 4You have closed their minds to understanding; therefore You will not exalt them. 5If a man denounces his friends for a price, the eyes of his children will fail.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelite hearers, the vocabulary of guarantee and handclasp came straight from the village gate and the marketplace. It was the stuff of loans, bail and the risky business that Proverbs warns about. Hearing Job use it of God would have been jarring. Israel's psalms and prophets could ask God to be their guarantor against human oppressors (Psalm 119:122; Isaiah 38:14). Job asks God to stand surety for him before God himself.

The verse did two things in the book. First, it shows how completely Job has been abandoned: friends turned mockers, no one willing to vouch for him (vv. 2, 4). Second, it pushes forward the book's struggle over whether God can be both Job's accuser and his defender. The arbiter of 9:33, the heavenly witness of 16:19–21, this guarantor, and the redeemer of 19:25 trace Job's growing and paradoxical insistence that justice must finally come from God's side. Readers were left to hold the tension. The verse does not resolve it.

From the study of Job 17:3.

Verse by verse

  1. 3Give me, I pray, the pledge You demand. Who else will be my guarantor?

    Job turns to God in the middle of his lawsuit and pleads: "Please, put down the deposit yourself. Post my bond with you, be my guarantor. Because who else is there who will clasp my hand and take on my liability?"

    The language comes from the debt-and-bail customs of village life. A guarantor (ʿārab) put himself or his property on the line so that someone else's obligation was covered, and he sealed it publicly with a handclasp ("striking hands"), the way a co-signer signs a loan today. Job is accused, and he is pressing his case against God. He needs someone to vouch for him. His friends have become mockers (v. 2), and God has closed their minds (v. 4), so no human will put a hand in his. That leaves only one party who could post the guarantee, and it is the same party Job is suing. So the verse holds a startling paradox: Job appeals from God to God, and asks the One who seems to be his opponent to stand surety for him with Himself. The word "please" (nāʾ) makes it a plea, not a demand. The closing question, "who is he...?", expects the answer "no one". It is a cry of total isolation and, at the same time, a stubborn hope that God himself will take Job's side.

    Full study →
  2. 4You have closed their minds to understanding; therefore You will not exalt them.

    Job turns from asking God for a guarantor (v. 3) to explaining why none of the men around him will step forward: "Because you yourself have shut their minds away from good sense, locked them out of insight. So you will not let them come out on top."

    The "heart" here is the thinking, judging centre of a person, not the seat of feeling. Job's complaint is that his friends cannot see straight, not that they are unkind. The verb for "closed" really means hidden away or stored out of reach. It is the same word Job used when he accused God of hiding hostile plans in his own heart (10:13). The friends' blindness is one more thing God has done in secret. "Understanding" is practical, perceptive good sense, the kind of wisdom that in Israel's proverbs brings honor and success. So the second line follows naturally: men without that sense will not be "raised high". They will not be vindicated, will not win the case, will not stand over Job. The Hebrew leaves the object unspoken ("you will not raise up…"), and the line carries something between a confident prediction and a plea: you will not, you must not, let them triumph.

    Full study →
  3. 5If a man denounces his friends for a price, the eyes of his children will fail.

    "A man who turns informer on his friends to get a cut of the spoils — his own children will be left wasting away, their eyes worn out looking for help that never comes."

    Job is quoting, or coining, something that sounds like a proverb (in the next verse he complains that he himself has become a byword, a proverb people repeat). The first word is the motive: for a share, meaning a portion of goods, the kind of word used for dividing up plunder. The verb means to tell or report. When the people being reported on are your friends (the very word the book uses for Eliphaz, Bildad and Zophar), it means exposing them, speaking against them for gain.

    The second line gives the consequence: the betrayer's children's eyes will be spent. In Hebrew, eyes that are "used up" belong to someone worn down by hunger, grief or long waiting. Think of a starving child staring at a door no one comes through, not someone going blind. The phrase is almost word for word what Zophar threatened against "the wicked" in 11:20. Job takes the friends' own rule, that sin falls on the sinner's household, and points it at them: you are the ones betraying a friend, and that rule cuts against you.

    The Hebrew is compressed and hard, and the first line may be read differently. Some take it as "he invites friends to a share (of a meal) while his own children go hungry", a proverb about offering others what you cannot provide even for your own. The KJV reads "flattery to his friends". On every reading the core is the same: treachery or hollowness dressed up as friendship, and its cost falling on the next generation.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v3

    strike hands with me (KJV, WEB)

    lə-yādî yittāqēaʿ

    What we hear
    To hit or fight someone, or simply an odd expression.
    What they heard
    To clasp hands as a binding gesture that seals a legal guarantee: to co-sign for someone and take on their liability.
  • in v3

    pledge

    ʿārab (ʿērābôn)

    What we hear
    A spoken promise or vow, as in a pledge of commitment.
    What they heard
    A material deposit or legal guarantee that secures an obligation: collateral, a bond, bail.
  • in v3

    surety (KJV)

    ʿārab

    What we hear
    Hardly understood at all, or confused with "surely" or "certainty".
    What they heard
    A guarantor who is personally liable for someone else's debt or appearance in court.
  • in v4

    heart (KJV, WEB, YLT, NASB, ESV)

    lēb

    What we hear
    Emotions, affections, inner feelings, as opposed to the head or intellect.
    What they heard
    The mind and will: the place of thinking, discernment and decision. Here specifically the friends' capacity to reason about Job's case.
  • in v5

    the eyes of his children will fail

    ʿênê bānāyw tiklênāh

    What we hear
    His children will lose their eyesight or go blind.
    What they heard
    His children will be worn out and wasting away, eyes spent from hunger, grief or watching in vain for rescue. It is an idiom for despair and destitution, not a medical condition.
Every word
  1. שִֽׂימָה־

    śîmāh · H7760

    put, set, lay down · v3

    An imperative with extra emphasis: "Set it down!" Here it means putting down a deposit, the way someone lays collateral on the table. The object (the pledge) is implied by the next word.

  2. נָּ֭א

    nāʾ · H4994

    please, I pray · v3

    A small word that turns a command into a plea. Job is not ordering God. He is begging a favour from a superior.

  3. עָרְבֵ֣נִי

    ʿārəbēnî · H6148

    to stand surety, to pledge, to guarantee · v3

    "To stand surety for me" or "be my guarantor": to take on legal liability for another person's debt or appearance. The supplied data parses it as an infinitive ("[a pledge] to stand surety for me"). Many read it as a command, "be surety for me". The legal picture is the same either way.

  4. עִמָּ֑ךְ

    ʿimmāk · H5973A

    with you · v3

    "With yourself" or "in your keeping". The pledge is to be lodged with God himself. That is the paradox: God, the opposing party, is asked to hold the guarantee and also to provide it.

  5. מִֽי

    mî · H4310

    who? · v3

    Opens a question that expects the answer "no one". Nobody else is available or willing.

  6. ה֝֗וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he, that one · v3

    Adds weight to the question: "Who is he, the one who...?" It points to a guarantor who cannot be found.

  7. לְיָדִ֥י

    lə-yādî · H3027

    to my hand · v3

    "To my hand" or "with my hand". The hand is where the guarantee is sealed. (The supplied gloss "themselves" is a database artefact. The word is simply "hand".)

  8. יִתָּקֵֽעַ׃

    yittāqēaʿ · H8628

    to strike, clap, blow (a horn), drive in (a peg) · v3

    In this passive or reflexive form: "will strike (hands)", "will let himself be clapped to my hand". This is the handclasp that sealed a guarantee, the ancient equivalent of signing as co-signer. It is not a blow or a fight.

  9. כִּֽי־

    kî · H3588A

    for, because · v4

    Gives the reason for v. 3. Job has just asked who will strike hands with him as his guarantor, and this explains why none of his friends will: God has dulled their minds.

  10. לִ֭בָּם

    libbām · H3820A

    heart (+ 'their') · v4

    Their 'heart' is their mind: the inner place where a person thinks, judges and decides. It is put first in the Hebrew for emphasis: 'their heart, you have hidden it'. 'Their' points to the friends.

  11. צָפַ֣נְתָּ

    ṣāpantā · H6845

    to hide, store away, treasure up · v4

    'You have hidden away / shut away.' The verb pictures something put out of reach, as in a storeroom. Their minds have been locked away from insight. The perfect tense presents it as already done.

  12. מִּשָּׂ֑כֶל

    miśśākel · H7922

    insight, good sense, prudence · v4

    'Away from insight.' The prefix 'from' means 'kept from'. Śēkel is practical, perceptive good sense, the kind that sees a situation rightly and acts well. The friends lack it, which is why they misread Job's case.

  13. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon, on account of · v4

    First half of the set phrase 'therefore' (literally 'on account of so').

  14. כֵּ֝֗ן

    kēn · H3651C

    so, thus · v4

    Completes 'therefore'. The second line follows from the first: because they lack insight, they will not be raised up.

  15. לֹ֣א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v4

    Plain negation. With the following imperfect verb it can be a statement ('you will not') or close to a strong appeal ('you must not').

  16. תְרֹמֵֽם׃

    tərōmēm · H7311A

    to raise high, exalt · v4

    'You will raise high': an intensive form meaning lift up, honor, or let someone come out on top. The object is unstated, and 'them' (the friends) is the natural reading. Job is saying God will not let these men win the argument or be vindicated over him.

  17. לְ֭חֵלֶק

    le-ḥēleq · H2506

    for a portion, share · v5

    "For a share": the payoff someone hopes to get, most likely a cut of goods taken from someone else (the word is used for shares of plunder). A rarer word spelled the same way means "smoothness", which is where the KJV gets "flattery". The opening word puts the motive first: it is done for gain.

  18. יַגִּ֣יד

    yaggîd · H5046

    to tell, declare, report · v5

    "He tells / reports". With people as its object it most naturally means informing on them or exposing them. The verb form describes what such a person typically does, as a proverb would. Some read it as "announces (a share) to friends", meaning he invites them to a share.

  19. רֵעִ֑ים

    rēʿîm · H7453

    friends, companions, neighbors · v5

    "Friends": people bound by companionship and mutual loyalty. In Job this is the word used for Eliphaz, Bildad and Zophar (2:11), so the saying points straight at the men sitting with him.

  20. וְעֵינֵ֖י

    we-ʿênê · H5869

    and the eyes of · v5

    "And the eyes of". Here the eyes stand for a person's life and longing, the part that watches and waits for help that does not come.

  21. בָנָ֣יו

    bānāyw · H1121

    his sons, children · v5

    "His children": the betrayer's own offspring, who carry the consequences of his treachery. This draws on the shared ancient assumption, used often by the friends, that a guilty man's household suffers with him.

  22. תִּכְלֶֽנָה׃

    tiklênāh · H3615

    to be finished, spent, fail · v5

    "Will be used up / waste away". Eyes that are "finished" belong to someone worn out by hunger, grief or longing for help that never comes. It does not mean losing one's eyesight. It echoes Zophar's warning in 11:20 that "the eyes of the wicked will fail".

The world behind it

Surety and pledges in ancient Israel. In a farming society with no banks, loans and obligations were secured by people and things. A debtor might hand over a pledge (ʿērābôn): a personal object such as Tamar's seal, cord and staff in Genesis 38, or a cloak (Exodus 22:26). A third party could also stand surety, making himself legally liable if the debtor failed. Judah does this when he offers himself for Benjamin (Genesis 43:9; 44:32). The arrangement was made binding by a public handclasp ("striking palms"). Proverbs repeatedly warns against doing this rashly (6:1–5; 17:18; 22:26), because a guarantor could lose his property or even his freedom.

Job's lawsuit. From chapter 9 on, Job speaks of his situation as a court case against God. He wishes for an arbiter who could "lay his hand on us both" (9:33). He insists that "my witness is in heaven" (16:19) and that someone must argue his case with God (16:21). Later he declares "I know that my redeemer (goʾel) lives" (19:25). Job 17:3 belongs to this chain of legal images. A man bringing a case had to guarantee he would see it through, and Job, abandoned by everyone, has no one to stand bond. His only recourse is to ask God to provide the guarantee.

From the study of Job 17:3.

Where scholars differ

in v3

How should עָרְבֵנִי be read: an infinitive, a command, or a noun?

  • Infinitive ("lay down [a pledge] to stand surety for me"), following the Masoretic vowels as parsed in the supplied data.

    Keeps the received vowels. Gives the first verb, "set down", an implied object (a pledge).

  • Imperative, "be surety for me"

    The identical form ʿorbēnî appears in Isaiah 38:14 in a lament addressed to God. Psalm 119:122 uses the imperative in a similar prayer. It needs only a small vowel change.

  • Noun, "my pledge" (ʿerbōnî)

    Gives "set down" an explicit object ("set down my pledge with you"). Connects to ʿērābôn in Genesis 38. Followed in effect by YLT and by many modern versions' "a pledge".

in v3

Is the guarantor God himself, or a heavenly figure distinct from God?

  • God himself: Job appeals from God to God.

    "With yourself" (ʿimmāk) is addressed to God. The request is that God post the pledge with God. This fits the paradox Job voices elsewhere (16:19–21; 19:25) of God as both opponent and vindicator.

  • A third party in the heavenly court, distinct from the God Job is accusing.

    Job wishes for an arbiter between himself and God (9:33) and speaks of a witness or advocate in heaven (16:19–21). Some (e.g. Habel, and in different ways Clines on 16:19) argue that Job imagines a figure separate from God. On this view 17:3 asks God to *allow* or *arrange* such a guarantee.

in v4

What does 'you will not exalt' mean, and whom does it concern?

  • A statement of outcome: God will not vindicate the friends, and they will not win the dispute with Job.

    'Therefore' presents the line as following from their lack of insight. Rûm (intensive stem) is used for an opponent prevailing (Ps 13:2; 89:42). This fits the ending, where God rebukes the friends (42:7–8). NIV, ESV and most commentators take it this way.

  • A plea: 'so do not let them triumph [over me]'.

    A Hebrew imperfect with lōʾ can carry strong appeal force, and Job is speaking directly to God in a run of requests (v. 3 'give me a pledge'). NLT reads it like this.

  • A different text: 'therefore their hand is not raised' (they will not pledge for Job).

    It would tie neatly to the hand-striking surety image of v. 3, but it requires changing the consonants and has no manuscript support.

in v4

Who are 'they'?

  • Job's three friends.

    They are the ones Job has called 'mockers' (17:2), and 17:10 addresses them directly. This is the near-universal reading.

  • The broader crowd of mockers around Job (17:2, 6).

    Verse 2 speaks of mockers in general, and the plural suffix need not be limited to the three. In practice this overlaps with the first view.

in v5

What does חֵלֶק mean here: "share" or "smoothness/flattery"?

  • "Share/portion", meaning a cut of goods or spoil (most modern translations).

    This is the common meaning of ḥēleq, including elsewhere in Job (20:29; 27:13; 31:2). The Vulgate's "praedam" (spoil) supports it, and it fits the verb "report/denounce".

  • "Smoothness", meaning flattering speech (KJV).

    A noun spelled the same way means smooth or seductive speech (Prov 7:21), and flattery fits a verb of speaking. But this sense is rarer and leaves the verb's object awkward.

in v5

What situation does the saying picture?

  • An informer who betrays his friends for profit, and whose children then suffer.

    This is the natural sense of the verb with people as its object (compare Jer 20:10). It fits Job's charge that the friends have turned on him, and their own principle that guilt falls on a man's household.

  • A man who invites friends to share his food while his own children go hungry. This is a proverb about hollow or misplaced generosity, applied to friends who offer "comfort" they do not have.

    The verb can mean "announce", and ḥēleq can mean a share of food. The Vulgate's "promises prey to his companions" points this way. It also makes sense of the contrast between "friends" and "his children" in the two lines.

in v5

Is the second line a prediction or a curse?

  • A statement of consequence: "his children's eyes will fail".

    Ordinary future or habitual sense of the verb, typical of proverbs.

  • An imprecation: "may his children's eyes fail".

    The same Hebrew verb form can express a wish, and Job's speeches include curse-like outbursts (compare 27:7). Some translations, such as the NLT, render it as a wish.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. עָרַב I
  • HALOT s.v. ערב I; s.v. עֵרָבוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. תקע
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary 17)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • É. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
  • R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
  • BDAG s.v. ἀρραβών (for the Semitic loanword)
  • BDB s.v. צָפַן, שֵׂכֶל, רוּם, לֵב
  • HALOT s.v. צפן; שֶׂכֶל; רום (Polel)
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary), on 17:3–5
  • É. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job, on 17:4
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Job 17:4
  • Vulgate, Job 17:4
  • BDB s.v. חֵלֶק I (portion) and חֵלֶק II (smoothness)
  • HALOT s.v. חֵלֶק, נגד hif., כלה
  • BDB s.v. כָּלָה (of eyes: fail with longing)
  • Job 11:20; 31:16; Deut 28:32; Lam 2:11; 4:17; Ps 69:3 (idiom of failing eyes)
  • Jeremiah 20:10 (friends as informers)
  • Vulgate, Job 17:5
  • Septuagint (Old Greek) Job 17:5

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).