Job Chapter 28 Read as one passage

Job 28:9–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9The miner strikes the flint; he overturns mountains at their base. 10He hews out channels in the rocks, and his eyes spot every treasure. 11He stops up the sources of the streams to bring what is hidden to light.

What the first hearers heard

To an ancient Israelite or Edomite listener, verse 9 described something astonishing yet real: miners who attack the hardest stone and bring whole mountains down. Mountains stood for permanence ("the everlasting hills"), and overturning them was something hymns said God did (Job 9:5). By using the same verb for a human miner, the poet pays humanity a large compliment. No animal goes where this person goes, and no rock stops him.

The compliment sets up a trap. The listener is meant to feel the wonder of human mastery, and then to see where it falls short. For all their tunneling, humans cannot find wisdom by digging or buy it with the gold they dig up (vv. 12–19). The idea that human skill reaches everything except the one thing that matters most supports the closing line of the chapter. For humans, wisdom is not a mineral to be extracted but a stance toward God: "the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom" (v. 28). In Job's own crisis, this answers the hope, shared by Job and his friends, of digging out the logic behind his suffering by their own effort.

From the study of Job 28:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9The miner strikes the flint; he overturns mountains at their base.

    "Against the flint, the hardest of all rock, he drives his hand; he turns mountains over, bringing them down from their very roots."

    The "he" is the human miner described since verse 3, who goes down shafts where no hawk has seen and no lion has walked (vv. 7–8). The Hebrew verbs describe what miners regularly do, not a single past event. The line is built to impress. First comes flint, the byword for rock that will not give way. Then the miner "sends out his hand against" it, the language of an attack. Then come mountains, the oldest and most fixed things in the world, and he overturns them. That is the word used for the overthrow of Sodom, and the word Job used in 9:5 for what God does to mountains in his anger. He does it from the root: he tunnels beneath the mountain's base, deep in the earth, until it falls.

    The verse therefore gives a human being near-godlike power over the physical world: he breaks the unbreakable and topples the immovable. That is the point of the build-up. The poem will soon ask, "But where can wisdom be found?" (v. 12). Someone who can find gold and sapphire in the roots of mountains still cannot dig out wisdom. Only God knows the way to it (v. 23).

    Full study →
  2. 10He hews out channels in the rocks, and his eyes spot every treasure.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 11He stops up the sources of the streams to bring what is hidden to light.

    The miner, working deep in the earth in shafts no bird has seen (vv. 7–8), comes up against water: underground streams that seep and drip through the rock like tears. He binds them up, plugging and damming the leaks the way someone bandages a wound, so the "weeping" of the rivers stops and the shaft stays workable. (Many scholars read the opening words as "the sources of the rivers": he reaches all the way down to where the rivers rise.) Then he brings the earth's hidden things out into the light: gold, silver, copper, lapis, everything that lay concealed in darkness since creation.

    The verse ends the poem's tribute to human skill on a high note. Humans really can turn darkness into light and make the hidden visible. But the word for "what is hidden" is chosen with a purpose. Its root comes back in v. 21, where wisdom is "hidden from the eyes of all living". So the next line lands hard: "But wisdom — where can it be found?" Everything buried in the earth can be dug out. Wisdom cannot.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v9

    puts his hand on (WEB); putteth forth his hand upon (KJV)

    shālaḥ yādô ba-

    What we hear
    Touching or laying a hand on something gently, as in blessing or examining it.
    What they heard
    Thrusting the hand against something with force. With the preposition "against," the phrase is the usual Hebrew way of saying "attack" or "strike at."
  • in v9

    the rock (KJV)

    ḥallāmîsh

    What we hear
    Any ordinary stone.
    What they heard
    Flint, the hardest stone known and a byword for what cannot be broken (Isa 50:7; Deut 8:15).
  • in v11

    "bindeth the floods from overflowing" (KJV)

    mibbəkhî nəhārôt ḥibbēsh

    What we hear
    Holding back catastrophic floods, which also suggests God taming great waters as in creation or Noah's flood.
    What they heard
    A miner sealing off water that drips and seeps (literally 'weeps') into his shaft, or, if the word is re-vowelled, reaching the sources of underground streams. The picture is slow seepage, not flooding.
Every word
  1. בַּֽחַלָּמִישׁ

    baḥallāmîsh · H2496

    flint, flinty rock · v9

    "Against the flint." Flint was the hardest stone people knew, the stock picture of rock that does not give way. The prefix ba- ("in / on / against") paired with the following verb means "against": the miner is attacking the flint, not resting a hand on it. Putting this word first in the line stresses how hard the target is.

  2. שָׁלַ֣ח

    shālaḥ · H7971

    send, stretch out · v9

    "He sends out / thrusts out." The Hebrew past-tense form here describes a typical action, so it is best read as present: "he stretches out." With "hand" it makes a fixed phrase for putting force to something, and with "against" it often means to attack.

  3. יָד֑וֹ

    yādô · H3027

    hand; power · v9

    "His hand." The literal hand, the one that holds the pick and hammer. Because yad also stands for power and control, the image is human strength set against the hardest stone.

  4. הָפַ֖ךְ

    hāfakh · H2015

    turn, overturn, overthrow · v9

    "He overturns." The word is dramatic. It is the verb used for God overthrowing Sodom and Gomorrah, and in Job 9:5 for God overturning mountains in anger. Here a human being does it.

  5. מִשֹּׁ֣רֶשׁ

    mishshōresh · H8328

    root · v9

    "From the root." Mountains were pictured as having roots that reach deep into the earth. The miner tunnels under a mountain and brings it down from below, at its base.

  6. הָרִֽים׃

    hārîm · H2022

    mountain · v9

    "Mountains" (plural, with no "the"): mountains in general. Mountains were the oldest and most fixed things in the world as people saw it, and the miner overturns even these.

  7. מִ֭בְּכִי

    mibbəkhî · H1065

    from weeping · v11

    Literally 'from weeping', made up of the preposition 'from' plus the noun for weeping. Here it is a picture of water oozing or dripping, the way tears do, through the rock walls of a mine shaft. The miner binds the rivers so that they stop 'weeping'. Many scholars re-vowel it as mabbekhê, 'sources', which matches Job 38:16 and Ugaritic usage (see textual notes).

  8. נְהָר֣וֹת

    nəhārôt · H5104

    rivers, streams · v11

    'Rivers' or 'streams'. In this setting it means the underground water courses and seepage a miner hits as he cuts into the earth, not rivers on the surface. The plural pairs with the 'channels' (yəʾōrîm) of v. 10.

  9. חִבֵּ֑שׁ

    ḥibbēsh · H2280

    to bind, tie up · v11

    'He has bound / tied up'. The verb is used for binding a wound, saddling a donkey or wrapping a turban. Here it means damming or plugging the water, like bandaging a leaking wound in the rock. The form is a completed-action verb, describing something the miner habitually manages to do.

  10. וְ֝תַעֲלֻמָ֗הּ

    wə-taʿălummāh · H8587

    hidden thing, secret · v11

    'And its hidden thing'. The feminine 'its' most likely points back to the earth (v. 5) or the rock. The word means what is concealed, the ore and gems buried out of sight. It comes from the same root as 'it is hidden' (neʿelmāh) in v. 21, where wisdom is hidden from every living eye. That link is the hinge of the poem.

  11. יֹ֣צִא

    yōṣiʾ · H3318

    to go out; (causative) bring out · v11

    'He brings out'. This is the causative form of 'go out', spelled here without one of its usual vowel letters. The ongoing-action form describes the miner's regular success in hauling buried things up out of the dark.

  12. אֽוֹר׃

    ʾôr · H216

    light · v11

    'Light'. With no preposition it means '(into the) light'. It closes the section on mining that began in v. 3, where man 'puts an end to darkness'. Humans really can turn darkness into light, everywhere except where wisdom is concerned.

The world behind it

Mining in the world of Job. The first eleven verses of Job 28 are the Bible's most detailed picture of mining. Its first hearers would have known that mining was real, dangerous work. Copper was mined on a large scale in the Arabah, at Timna and at Faynan (Wadi Feinan) in Edom. That area is near the traditional setting of Job's land of Uz. Egyptian expeditions dug turquoise and copper in Sinai at Serabit el-Khadim. Gold and silver came from farther away (v. 1–2, 6). Miners cut shafts and side tunnels (v. 4, 10). They often broke hard rock with fire, heating it and then cracking it (perhaps the "as by fire" of v. 5). They worked by lamplight in total darkness (v. 3).

"Overturning mountains" was not just poetic exaggeration. Undermining a hillside until it collapsed was a known method. Much later, the Roman writer Pliny the Elder (Natural History 33.70–73, 1st century AD) described how miners in Spain dug long galleries under a mountain, left pillars, then knocked them out. The mountain fell with a roar while the miners "gaze as conquerors on the collapse of nature." Pliny wrote centuries after Job and is not a source for it, but he shows that the picture in verse 9 matches what miners actually did.

Where the verse sits. Job 28 is a poem about wisdom placed between the debates with Job's friends and Job's final speeches. Scholars debate whether Job speaks it or it is an interlude in the narrator's voice. Its structure is clear: human skill can reach every hidden treasure (vv. 1–11), but wisdom is hidden from every living thing (vv. 12–22). God alone knows its place, and for humans it consists in "the fear of the Lord" and turning from evil (vv. 23–28). Verse 9 is near the peak of the first section, the most extreme claim made for human power.

From the study of Job 28:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

Who is the "he" of verse 9: the human miner or God?

  • The human miner (the large majority of commentators and all major translations).

    The subject has been human since v. 3 ("he puts an end to darkness"), and v. 4 speaks of people "forgotten by the foot" in the shafts. The section is about human search, and v. 13 concludes that "man (enosh) does not know its value." Verses 10–11 (cutting channels, damming streams, bringing hidden things to light) describe mining work.

  • God, or deliberate double meaning (a minority view).

    Overturning mountains "from the root" uses the same verb as Job 9:5 and other descriptions of God's power. Some have therefore heard God as the actor, or suggested the poet invites both hearings. Most see the echo instead as a deliberate comparison: humans doing what elsewhere only God does, which sharpens the turn in v. 12.

in v9

Who speaks Job 28?

  • Job himself, continuing his speech from chapter 27.

    There is no new speech heading. The chapter opens with "For" (kî) as if continuing, and 29:1 says Job "again took up his discourse."

  • An independent interlude by the narrator or the book's author.

    The calm, reflective tone does not fit Job's anguish before and after. It anticipates the divine speeches (chs. 38–41), and its conclusion (v. 28) echoes the description of Job in 1:1 ("feared God and turned away from evil").

in v11

Who is the 'he' of vv. 9–11?

  • A human miner (or humankind as a whole). This is the majority view.

    Verse 3 begins the section with an unnamed agent who 'puts an end to darkness' and digs shafts. The flow from mining (vv. 1–4) through tunnelling (vv. 9–10) to v. 11 is unbroken. The contrast in vv. 12–13 ('humankind does not know its way') needs a human subject. NIV and NRSV make this explicit with 'they'.

  • A royal or heroic adventurer, modelled on ancient Near Eastern kings who boast of cutting through mountains and reaching remote places.

    S. C. Jones (Rumors of Wisdom, 2009) points to Mesopotamian royal inscriptions and the Gilgamesh tradition, where the hero goes to the ends of the earth in search of hidden knowledge. On this reading the poem critiques royal pride rather than mining as such.

  • God, at least in vv. 9–11.

    Overturning mountains 'by the roots' (v. 9) sounds like divine power (compare Job 9:5), and Job 12:22 says God 'brings deep darkness out to light'. Some older interpreters, and ambiguous translations like the KJV, allow this. But it breaks the contrast with v. 23 ('God understands its way'), so most modern commentators reject it.

in v11

Should the verb be read 'bound' (Hebrew text) or 'searched' (ancient translations)?

  • Keep 'bound / dammed'.

    It is the reading of the Hebrew text, it makes good sense as mining practice (sealing off seepage), and it pairs naturally with 'weeping/trickling'.

  • Read 'searched / probed'.

    The Septuagint ('uncovered') and the Vulgate ('searched') point to ḥippēś. It parallels 'brings to light' in the second half of the line and fits the theme of exploration. NIV and NRSV adopt it.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. חַלָּמִישׁ, הָפַךְ, שֹׁרֶשׁ
  • BDB s.v. שָׁלַח (Qal: with יָד + בְּ, 'put forth the hand against')
  • David J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
  • Norman C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • Marvin H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15)
  • Pliny the Elder, Natural History 33.70–73 (ruina montium in Spanish gold mines)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 28:9; Vulgate Job 28:9
  • BDB s.v. בְּכִי, חָבַשׁ, תַּעֲלֻמָּה
  • HALOT s.v. בְּכִי, נֵבֶךְ, חבשׁ, תַּעֲלֻמָּה
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15), on 28:11 and Ugaritic mbk nhrm
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • S. C. Jones, Rumors of Wisdom: Job 28 as Poetry (BZAW 398, 2009)
  • Ugaritic texts KTU 1.4 IV 21–22; 1.6 I 33–34 (El's dwelling at the sources of the rivers)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 28:11; Vulgate Job 28:11

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.