Job Chapter 35 Read as one passage
Job 35:12–13
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
12There they cry out, but He does not answer, because of the pride of evil men. 13Surely God does not listen to empty pleas, and the Almighty does not take note of it.
What the first hearers heard
To an ancient Israelite hearer, the scene was familiar: the poor crying out against powerful oppressors. Israel's law and psalms promised that God hears that cry (Exodus 22:23; Psalm 34:17). Job had used exactly that expectation against God: he cried out "Violence!" and got no answer (19:7; 30:20), and the wounded in the city groan while God does nothing (24:12).
Elihu does not deny that the cries go unanswered. He tries to protect God's justice by explaining why. In his view, the cry raised under the arrogant power of evil men is a cry of pain and nothing more. It does not turn to "God my Maker" with the trust and openness that verses 10–11 describe. A cry like that is "emptiness" (v. 13), and God has no obligation to answer it. In verse 14 he aims the point at Job: if Job's complaint is the same kind of cry, he should not expect an answer.
Hearers would also catch the irony the book is building. Elihu says confidently that God does not answer such cries. Then God answers Job out of the whirlwind (38:1), and his answer overturns several of the human explanations that came before it.
From the study of Job 35:12.
Verse by verse
-
12There they cry out, but He does not answer, because of the pride of evil men.
Full study →"There, right in the thick of it, they shriek for help, and no rescue comes from Him, in the face of the arrogance of evil men."
The verse belongs to an argument that begins in verse 9: people groan under "many oppressions" and cry for help against "the arm of the mighty". But, Elihu says in verses 10–11, nobody asks, "Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night?" "There" points back to that scene of oppression. The verb shows ongoing action: they keep crying out, the loud cry of victims calling for rescue. "He does not answer" means God does not step in. In biblical idiom, God's "answer" to a cry is deliverance, not a spoken reply.
The last phrase, literally "from the face of the arrogance of evil ones", names the cause. Most naturally it describes what the victims are crying out against: the high-handed, self-exalting arrogance of oppressors. Elihu's explanation for God's silence comes in the next verse: "God does not hear emptiness" (v. 13). In his view, the cry is only a howl of pain. It never turns toward God as Maker and teacher (vv. 10–11), so it is "empty" and goes unanswered. Some readers take the phrase differently: God does not answer because of pride, either the pride of the criers themselves or the pride that hangs over the whole scene. The Hebrew allows both readings.
Elihu is also turning Job's own words back on him. Job had complained, "If I cry out 'Violence!' I am not answered" (19:7). Elihu agrees that such cries go unanswered and offers his own reason, which he then applies to Job (v. 14).
-
13Surely God does not listen to empty pleas, and the Almighty does not take note of it.
Full study →"Indeed, a hollow cry is not something God listens to. Shaddai does not even turn his eyes toward it."
Elihu is explaining why people who groan under oppression (vv. 9–12) seem to get no answer from heaven. The word put first in the Hebrew, for emphasis, is emptiness: a cry with nothing real in it. It is the scream of pain that never becomes a turning to "God my Maker, who gives songs in the night" (v. 10). It may even be a cry that is false or self-serving. That kind of cry, Elihu says, God does not hear in the Hebrew sense of hearing, which means listening in order to answer and act. In the second half of the line, the ancient name Shaddai echoes "God." God's ears (he does not hear) are matched by his eyes (he does not look at it). The verb for "look" sets up a sharp turn in the next verse. Job has complained that he cannot see God (v. 14). Elihu replies, in effect, that God does not look at hollow cries, so how much less will he attend to a complaint like Job's?
The opening word can also be read as "only": it is only the empty cry that God ignores. On that reading Elihu is defending God's attentiveness: real appeals are heard, and silence points to something lacking in the cry, not in God.
Where the English drifted
-
in v12
pride
geʾon (gaʾon)
- What we hear
- Self-esteem or vanity, a private attitude that can even be healthy ('I'm proud of my work').
- What they heard
- Loftiness, self-exaltation. Used of the wicked it means overbearing arrogance that lords it over others and goes with oppression.
-
in v13
vanity (KJV, YLT)
shaw'
- What we hear
- Conceit or excessive pride in one's appearance or achievements, so the line sounds like "God won't listen to vain, self-admiring people."
- What they heard
- Emptiness, hollowness, falseness. Here it is a cry with no real substance or no real turning to God in it.
-
in v13
the Almighty
Shaddai
- What we hear
- A title stating that God is all-powerful (omnipotent) in the abstract philosophical sense.
- What they heard
- An ancient proper name of God of uncertain origin (perhaps "the One of the mountains"). In Job it carries majesty and power, but it works as a name, not a definition.
Every word
-
שָׁ֣ם
sham · H8033
there · v12
Points back to the situation just described in verse 9, people crushed under oppression. In Hebrew poetry 'there' can mean 'in that very circumstance' or 'at that point' (compare Psalm 14:5) and need not name a place.
-
יִ֭צְעֲקוּ
yitsʿaqu · H6817
to cry out · v12
The loud cry of people in distress calling for rescue, the same word used for Israel groaning in Egypt. The verb form shows repeated or ongoing action: they keep crying out.
-
וְלֹ֣א
welo · H3808
and not · v12, v13
'And' plus a negative. In context the 'and' works as 'but': the cry goes up and nothing comes back.
-
יַעֲנֶ֑ה
yaʿaneh · H6030
to answer · v12
'He answers.' The unstated subject is God, named as 'God my Maker' in verse 10. When God 'answers' a cry in the Bible, he acts to rescue, not just replies in words. The main pause in the verse falls on this word.
-
מִ֝פְּנֵ֗י
mippenei · H6440
because of; from before · v12
Literally 'from the face of'. It is the normal Hebrew for 'because of', and can also mean fleeing 'from before' a threat. It gives the cause, but the grammar leaves open whether it explains the crying or the silence.
-
גְּא֣וֹן
geʾon · H1347
pride, arrogance, majesty · v12
From a root meaning 'to rise high'. Used of people it means a haughty, overbearing loftiness, the arrogance of those who put themselves above others and above God.
-
רָעִֽים׃
raʿim · H7451
evil, bad · v12
An adjective used as a noun: 'evil ones', people whose conduct does harm. Here they are probably the oppressors of verse 9, though some read them as the people crying out.
-
אַךְ־
'akh · H0389
surely; only; but · v13
A short word that either stresses the statement ("surely, indeed") or narrows it ("only"). Read as "only," the line means it is just the empty cry that God ignores, which implies that real appeals are heard.
-
שָׁ֭וְא
shaw' · H7723
emptiness, falsehood, worthlessness · v13
Placed first for emphasis, before its verb. It means a cry with nothing real in it: a groan of pain or a protest that never actually turns to God (see v. 10, "no one says, 'Where is God my Maker?'").
-
יִשְׁמַ֥ע׀
yishma' · H8085
hear, listen, heed · v13
In Hebrew, "hear" applied to God and a cry means listening that leads to action: answering, stepping in to help. The verb form (here, ongoing or habitual) describes how God normally deals with such cries: he does not take them up.
-
אֵ֑ל
'el · H0410
God · v13
The old, general Semitic word for God. The poetry of Job prefers it, along with Eloah and Shaddai, to Israel's covenant name YHWH, which fits the book's setting outside Israel.
-
וְ֝שַׁדַּ֗י
weshadday · H7706
and Shaddai (traditionally "the Almighty") · v13
An ancient name of God that Job uses about 31 times. Here it balances "El" in the first half of the line. The "and" brings in the second half, which restates the first.
-
יְשׁוּרֶֽנָּה׃
yeshurennah · H7789
look at, gaze on, regard · v13
A poetic verb for looking at something attentively. With the ending "-nah" ("it") it means "he does not look at it," i.e. he pays the empty cry no attention. Elihu uses the same verb against Job in the very next verse.
The world behind it
Who is speaking. These are the words of Elihu, a young man who appears only in Job 32–37. He speaks after Job and his three friends have fallen silent. Chapter 35 is his third speech. It replies to Job's claims that being righteous gains him nothing (35:2–3, echoing 34:9) and that God ignores the cries of the oppressed (24:12: "the wounded cry for help, yet God charges no one with wrong").
How the argument runs (vv. 9–14):
- v. 9: the oppressed cry out under the power of the mighty.
- vv. 10–11: but no one says, "Where is God my Maker… who teaches us more than the beasts?"
- v. 12: so they cry and are not answered (this verse).
- v. 13: God does not listen to "emptiness" (shaw).
- v. 14: "how much less when you say you do not see him", which applies the point to Job.
Why it matters for reading the verse. This is one character's argument inside a book that tests its characters' theology. At the end God speaks to Job directly (38:1). He rebukes the three friends for not speaking rightly about him (42:7) and does not mention Elihu at all. Interpreters still argue over whether Elihu's views are meant to be endorsed, corrected, or simply heard. The verse reports Elihu's explanation of why cries go unanswered. It is not a narrator's statement about how God treats prayer.
From the study of Job 35:12.
Where scholars differ
in v12
What does 'because of the pride of evil men' explain: the crying, or God's silence?
-
It explains the crying. The oppressed cry out because of (or 'from before') the arrogance of evil oppressors. God's silence is explained separately in v. 13: their cry is 'empty', a howl that does not seek God.
Verse 9 has already said the cry is raised under oppression by 'the mighty'. The pause after 'he answers' sets the 'because' clause apart. Verses 10 and 13 give the reason for the silence: no one seeks God, and God does not hear emptiness.
-
It explains the silence. God does not answer because of pride, whether the pride of the criers themselves (who are the 'evil ones') or the pride that marks the whole situation.
The phrase comes straight after 'he does not answer', and that is the natural English reading. Wisdom literature often links pride with God turning away (e.g. Proverbs 16:5; compare Job 35:13 and 36:9), and Elihu goes on to accuse Job of speaking without knowledge (35:16).
-
It is deliberately compressed. The oppressors' arrogance causes the cry, and the criers' failure to turn humbly to God (vv. 10–11) explains why it goes unanswered.
Elihu's poetry is dense throughout. The verse sits between verse 9 (cause of the cry) and verse 13 (reason for the silence) and can be read as bridging the two.
in v12
Does the book of Job endorse Elihu's explanation?
-
Yes, in large part. Elihu prepares the way for God's speeches and corrects both Job and the friends.
God does not rebuke Elihu in 42:7–9. Elihu's themes of God's majesty in the storm (ch. 37) lead directly into the speeches from the whirlwind.
-
No, or only partly. Elihu is one more confident human voice whose theory God's appearance overturns.
Elihu claims God does not answer such cries, and then God does answer Job (38:1). God's speeches never give Elihu's explanation of unanswered prayer. Elihu is also ignored in the epilogue.
in v13
Does אַךְ mean "surely" (emphatic) or "only" (restrictive)?
-
Emphatic: "Surely God does not hear emptiness."
This is the traditional rendering (KJV and most modern versions). It fits Elihu's explanation in v. 12 of why the oppressed are not answered.
-
Restrictive: "Only emptiness God does not hear," meaning it is just hollow cries that go unanswered and so God does attend to real ones.
"Only" is a common meaning of אַךְ, and this reading fits Elihu's defence of God's attentiveness against Job 24:12. Both readings give a similar overall point, with a different emphasis.
in v13
Whose "empty" cry is meant?
-
The oppressed of vv. 9–12, who cry from pain but do not seek their Maker.
The verse follows straight on from v. 12 ("there they cry out, but he does not answer"), and v. 10 describes what is missing from their cry.
-
Job's own complaints, at least by implication.
Verse 14 ("how much less when you say...") and v. 16 ("Job opens his mouth in emptiness [hebel]") point the principle directly at Job, and the repeated verb shur links v. 13 to Job's complaint in v. 14.
in v13
Is the verse a statement about God's hearing, or a rebuttal of a false claim?
-
Statement: God does not attend to hollow cries.
The plain grammar: shaw' is the object of "hear," in parallel with the suffix "it" on "look at." Most translations and commentators read it this way.
-
Rebuttal: "It is false [to say] God does not hear" (reflected in the NLT).
This fits the flow of Elihu's response to Job 24:12 and 30:20, but it requires supplying an unstated "to say," and few modern scholars favor it.
Sources
- BDB s.v. צָעַק, עָנָה, גָּאוֹן, פָּנִים
- HALOT s.v. גָּאוֹן
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Job 35:12
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Job 35:12
- BDB s.v. שָׁוְא, שׁוּר, אַךְ, שַׁדַּי
- HALOT s.v. שָׁוְא; שׁוּר I; שַׁדַּי
- Septuagint, Job (Göttingen edition, ed. J. Ziegler)
- Vulgate, Job 35:13
- Deir 'Alla plaster inscription (Balaam text), on šdyn
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).