The Bible · Old Testament

Jonah

Jonah is a short story about a Hebrew prophet who runs from God's call to warn Nineveh, the capital of Assyria and Israel's enemy, is swallowed by a great fish, and then watches God spare the city when it repents. People read it for what it says about God's mercy reaching even Israel's enemies, and because Jesus used it as a sign of his own death and resurrection.

  • Hebrew (with some Aramaic)
  • In every Bible

Why it's in the Bible, and the doubts

The case for

  1. Jonah has belonged to the Book of the Twelve Prophets for as far back as the evidence goes, and no Jewish or Christian canon has ever left it out.

    The evidence

    Sirach 49:10 (c. 180 BC) already speaks of 'the twelve prophets', and Jonah appears in Dead Sea Scrolls copies of the Twelve (4QXIIa, 4QXIIg) and in the Greek Minor Prophets scroll from Nahal Hever. It is in every Jewish list, the Septuagint, Athanasius's list of 367, and every Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and Ethiopian Bible.

  2. Jesus treated Jonah's story as a sign that pointed to himself and used it to call his own listeners to repent.

    The evidence

    In Matthew 12:39–41 and Luke 11:29–32 Jesus compares his coming death and burial to Jonah's 'three days and three nights' in the fish, and says the people of Nineveh will judge his generation because they repented. Jewish tradition also gave the book a central place: it is read on the afternoon of Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement (Talmud, Megillah 31a).

  3. The book is tied to a known prophet and fits closely with what the rest of scripture teaches about God.

    The evidence

    2 Kings 14:25 names Jonah son of Amittai from Gath-hepher as a real prophet under Jeroboam II (c. 786–746 BC). Jonah's complaint in 4:2 quotes God's self-description in Exodus 34:6, as Joel 2:13 also does, and the book's concern for the nations matches Genesis 12:3 and Isaiah 49:6.

The case against

  1. Much of the story is hard to square with what is known of Assyrian history, so many readers take it as a teaching story (a parable) rather than a historical record.

    The evidence

    Assyrian records do not mention a prophet's visit or the whole city turning to Israel's God, and Assyrian kings were not called 'king of Nineveh' (3:6). The book calls Nineveh 'a three days' walk' across (3:3), while the excavated city walls run only about 12 km around, and the swallowing by a fish is a miracle story with no outside evidence.

  2. The book was probably not written by Jonah, and may have been written centuries after the events it tells.

    The evidence

    It is told about Jonah in the third person, not by him, and it describes Nineveh in the past tense. Scholars point to late Hebrew words and Aramaic influence (for example, the word for 'decree' in 3:7) as signs of a post-exilic date, which leaves a long gap between the 8th-century prophet and the written account.

  3. Jonah's prophecy does not come true as spoken, which raises questions about how its message fits other biblical teaching on prophecy.

    The evidence

    Jonah announces 'Forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown' (3:4) with no condition attached, yet God relents (3:10). Deuteronomy 18:22 says a word that does not happen was not from the LORD, and Numbers 23:19 says God does not change his mind, so Jewish and Christian interpreters have long had to explain the tension. Still, the book's place in the canon itself was never seriously disputed.

Both sides are written as strongly as the honest evidence allows, so you can decide for yourself. Researched by claude-opus-5-5.

When, where and by whom

Traditionally, Jonah son of Amittai, the 8th-century BC prophet named in 2 Kings 14:25, wrote the book himself in northern Israel under King Jeroboam II. Most modern scholars think an unknown author wrote it after the exile, around the 5th–4th century BC, pointing to late Hebrew wording and to Nineveh (destroyed in 612 BC) being described in the past tense ("Nineveh was a great city", 3:3).

Jesus, the New Testament and this book
  • Jesus' 'sign of Jonah': his three days in the grave compared to Jonah's three days in the fish, and Nineveh's repentance held up as a rebuke to his own generation (Matthew 12:39–41; 16:4; Luke 11:29–32). (strong link)
  • Jonah was the Old Testament figure shown most often in early Christian catacomb art and on sarcophagi (3rd–4th century), where he stood for resurrection. (strong link)
  • Jesus asleep in a boat during a storm, the terrified crew, and the sea suddenly calming (Mark 4:35–41) closely mirror Jonah 1:4–16, with Jesus as 'something greater than Jonah'. (likely link)
  • Paul says Christ was raised 'on the third day according to the Scriptures' (1 Corinthians 15:4). Jonah 1:17 (2:1 in Hebrew) may be one of the scriptures meant, alongside Hosea 6:2. (possible link)
  • Peter, called 'Simon son of Jonah' (Matthew 16:17), is sent from Joppa to bring the message to Gentiles (Acts 10). Jonah also set out from Joppa (1:3) to avoid preaching to Gentiles. (possible link)
How it came down to us

Jonah was handed down in Hebrew as part of the scroll of the Twelve Prophets. Jewish scribes kept copying it, which led to the Masoretic Text found in the Aleppo Codex (c. 930 AD) and the Leningrad Codex (1008 AD). Older evidence includes Dead Sea Scrolls fragments (4QXIIa, 4QXIIg, 2nd–1st century BC), the Wadi Murabba'at scroll of the Twelve (Mur 88, early 2nd century AD), and the Greek Minor Prophets scroll from Nahal Hever (8HevXIIgr, about the turn of the era). These agree closely with the later Hebrew text. Christians passed it on in Greek (Septuagint; Codex Vaticanus and Sinaiticus, 4th century), Latin (Vulgate), Syriac (Peshitta), Coptic, and Ge'ez in the Ethiopian church.

  • Hebrew Masoretic Text (Aleppo and Leningrad codices)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls Minor Prophets manuscripts 4QXIIa and 4QXIIg
  • Wadi Murabba'at Minor Prophets scroll (Mur 88)
  • Nahal Hever Greek Minor Prophets scroll (8HevXIIgr)
  • Septuagint and 4th-century Greek codices (Vaticanus, Sinaiticus)
  • Sirach 49:10 on the Twelve Prophets
  • 2 Kings 14:25 on Jonah son of Amittai
  • Gospel texts Matthew 12, 16 and Luke 11
  • Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 31a (Yom Kippur reading)
  • Athanasius' Festal Letter 39 (367 AD) and later canon lists
  • Archaeological surveys of Nineveh and Assyrian royal inscriptions
  • Modern critical and evangelical commentaries on dating, language and genre
  • Early Christian catacomb and sarcophagus art

Chapters

1 2 3 4