Judges Chapter 10 Read as one passage

Judges 10:1–2

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1After the time of Abimelech, a man of Issachar, Tola son of Puah, the son of Dodo, rose up to save Israel. He lived in Shamir, in the hill country of Ephraim. 2Tola judged Israel twenty-three years, and when he died, he was buried in Shamir.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers, this verse was a turning point after a horror story. Chapter 9 had shown what happens when a man grabs kingship by murder: fratricide, a city destroyed, and a curse carried out. Tola's brief notice answers it with a different kind of leader. He comes from a respected clan, does not make himself king, has no famous war to his name, and is simply there for twenty-three years. He is a man who "saved Israel" by holding it together.

The hearers would have noticed several things:

  • Pedigree. "Tola son of Puah" sounded like a roll call of Issachar's founding clans. This was a leader with legitimate roots, unlike Abimelech, who traded on his mother's Shechemite kin.
  • Place. An Issacharite living in Ephraim's hills, near the ruined Shechem region, suggested a leader for more than one tribe, settled in the centre of the land.
  • What is missing. There is no apostasy, oppression, cry for help or divine raising-up. This quiet stretch stands in contrast to the cycle that starts again in 10:6, where Israel "again did evil" and things get worse under the Ammonites and Philistines.

In the book's larger argument, which points toward the question of kingship ("in those days there was no king in Israel", 17:6; 21:25), Tola and Jair show that non-royal tribal leadership could bring long periods of order, even as the book shows that order steadily coming apart.

From the study of Judges 10:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1After the time of Abimelech, a man of Issachar, Tola son of Puah, the son of Dodo, rose up to save Israel. He lived in Shamir, in the hill country of Ephraim.

    "Then, after Abimelech, Tola stepped forward to rescue Israel. He was the son of Puah and grandson of Dodo, a man of the tribe of Issachar, and he made his home at Shamir in the highlands of Ephraim."

    The verse opens with the narrator's ordinary "and then", and the first thing it names is the ruin left behind: after Abimelech. Abimelech had murdered his brothers, crowned himself, and dragged Shechem and its neighbours into a civil war that ended with his death (chapter 9). Into that wreckage a new man "arose", meaning he came forward to act. His purpose was to save: in Judges, that means rescuing Israel from real danger in this world. No foreign enemy is named this time. The danger may well have been Israel's own collapse.

    Unusually, the narrator does not say the LORD raised Tola up, sent his Spirit, or answered a cry for help. The verse reads like a record: name, father, grandfather, tribe, home town. The names carry weight. Tola and Puah are the names of Issachar's ancient founding clans (Genesis 46:13), so a Hebrew listener would have heard that this man came from the oldest, best-known families of his tribe. Tola's name also means the "crimson worm" that scarlet dye came from. Yet this northern tribesman lived in Ephraim's central highlands, close to where the chaos had happened. The next verse adds that he led Israel quietly for twenty-three years and was buried in the same town. This was a deliverance by steady leadership, not by a famous battle.

    Full study →
  2. 2Tola judged Israel twenty-three years, and when he died, he was buried in Shamir.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v1

    to save (Israel)

    lᵉhôšîaʿ

    What we hear
    Many churchgoing readers hear 'save' as spiritual salvation: rescue from sin, a right relationship with God, eternal life.
    What they heard
    To rescue a people from real, present danger: enemies, oppression, or here possibly the political chaos after Abimelech. A môšîaʿ ('savior, deliverer') in Judges is a tribal rescuer who restores safety and order.
  • in v1

    mount Ephraim (KJV)

    har ʾeprāyim

    What we hear
    A single mountain called Ephraim.
    What they heard
    The whole central highland region held by the tribe of Ephraim, the 'hill country of Ephraim'.
Every word
  1. וַיָּקָם֩

    wayyāqom · H6965B

    rise, arise, stand up · v1

    'And there arose.' This is the ordinary Hebrew verb form for telling the next event in a story. Used of a leader, it means he stepped forward or came onto the scene. Unlike Judges 2:16 and 3:9, it does not say that the LORD 'raised him up'.

  2. אַחֲרֵ֨י

    ʾaḥărê · H0310A

    after, behind · v1

    'After' in time. It ties Tola straight back to the disaster of chapter 9, so his rise is a response to the wreckage Abimelech left.

  3. אֲבִימֶ֜לֶךְ

    ʾăbîmelek · H0040H

    Abimelech ('my father is king') · v1

    Gideon's son by a concubine from Shechem. He murdered seventy of his brothers, made himself king, and died in the civil war that followed (Judges 9). Naming him here frames what follows as the time after a failed, bloody kingship.

  4. לְהוֹשִׁ֣יעַ

    lᵉhôšîaʿ · H3467

    to save, deliver, rescue · v1

    'To save / deliver.' This is the standard job description of a deliverer-judge in this book: rescuing Israel from real, present danger. That usually meant enemies, but here possibly the chaos left behind by Abimelech. It is not about spiritual or eternal salvation.

  5. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    (marker of definite direct object) · v1

    This small word has no English equivalent. It marks 'Israel' as the one being saved.

  6. יִשְׂרָאֵ֗ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v1

    The tribal people as a whole. The book's editor speaks of all Israel, though a judge's actual reach was probably regional.

  7. תּוֹלָ֧ע

    tôlāʿ · H8439H

    Tola ('worm', i.e. the crimson-dye insect) · v1

    The deliverer's name. It is also the name of Issachar's firstborn son and of a leading Issacharite clan (Genesis 46:13; Numbers 26:23; 1 Chronicles 7:1–2). The common noun means the scale insect that crimson dye was made from.

  8. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121A

    son (of) · v1

    'Son of.' This begins a short family line that marks him as a man with a known pedigree.

  9. פּוּאָ֛ה

    pûʾâ · H6312H

    Puah · v1

    Tola's father. In Genesis 46:13 and 1 Chronicles 7:1, Puah (Puvah) is Tola's brother, another of Issachar's sons. This suggests the tribe's old clan names were passed down and reused as personal names.

  10. דּוֹד֖וֹ

    dôdô · H1734G

    Dodo (cf. dôd, 'beloved; uncle') · v1

    The Hebrew tradition reads this as Tola's grandfather's name. The same letters can also mean 'his uncle', which is how the Greek and Latin translators took it (see textual notes).

  11. אִ֣ישׁ

    ʾîš · H0376G

    man (of) · v1

    'A man of,' meaning a member of a tribe. It gives his tribal identity.

  12. יִשָּׂשכָ֑ר

    yiśśākār · H3485G

    Issachar · v1

    A northern tribe whose land lay in and around the Jezreel Valley. The second ש is written but traditionally not pronounced: Yissakhar.

  13. וְהֽוּא־

    wᵉhûʾ- · H1931

    and he · v1

    'And he.' It starts a background note about where he lived, as opposed to what he did.

  14. יֹשֵׁ֥ב

    yōšēb · H3427

    dwelling, sitting, living · v1

    'Was living / was settled.' The participle (an '-ing' form of the verb) describes his ongoing residence. The same verb can mean sitting as a ruler or judge, but here the plain sense is where he lived.

  15. בְּשָׁמִ֖יר

    bᵉšāmîr · H8069H

    in Shamir · v1

    His home town and later his burial place (10:2). Its location is unknown, and it is not the Shamir in Judah (Joshua 15:48).

  16. בְּהַ֥ר

    bᵉhar · H2022H

    in the mountain / hill country (of) · v1

    Har here means the whole central highland region, not a single peak. KJV's 'mount Ephraim' can mislead on this point.

  17. אֶפְרָֽיִם׃

    ʾeprāyim · H0669G

    Ephraim · v1

    The powerful central tribe whose highlands included the Shechem region, where Abimelech's disaster had just played out. So an Issacharite was based in Ephraimite territory.

The world behind it

After a failed kingship. Judges 9 tells how Abimelech, Gideon's son by a Shechemite concubine, became the first Israelite to try ruling as king. He killed seventy brothers, ruled three years, destroyed Shechem and burned its tower with the people sheltering inside, and was finally killed at Thebez by a millstone a woman dropped on him. Judges 9:56–57 presents this as God paying back evil for evil. Judges 10:1 begins a new section (the Hebrew text marks a paragraph break before it), and its first words, "after Abimelech", place Tola in the aftermath of civil war in the central highlands.

The "minor judges." Tola (10:1–2) and Jair (10:3–5), and later Ibzan, Elon and Abdon (12:8–15), are given short, formula-like notices: who arose, his family and home, how many years he judged, where he died and was buried. The long stories of Ehud, Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah and Samson are different. They follow a cycle in which Israel sins, is oppressed, cries out, and the LORD raises up a deliverer. Tola's notice has none of that cycle, yet it alone among the short notices uses the deliverer verb "to save". That makes him a bridge between the two kinds of leader.

Tribe and clan. Issachar held the fertile Jezreel Valley and the lower Galilee. Genesis 49:14–15 pictures the tribe as a strong donkey that bowed to forced labour. Tola and Puah(/Puvah) are both listed as sons of Issachar and heads of clans (Genesis 46:13; Numbers 26:23). In a society organised by kinship, giving a man's clan names was a way of placing him and vouching for him. A man of Issachar living in Ephraim shows that tribal territory was more mixed than the neat boundary lists in Joshua might suggest.

From the study of Judges 10:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

From what did Tola 'save' Israel?

  • From the internal chaos and division left by Abimelech's civil war.

    The verse's opening phrase 'after Abimelech' ties Tola directly to chapter 9. No foreign enemy is named. Tola was based in Ephraim's hills near the ruined Shechem region. Several commentators (e.g. Block, Webb) read his 'saving' as restoring stability.

  • From an external threat that the brief notice simply does not record.

    In Judges, 'save' normally means rescue from enemies (2:16, 18). The short notices drop the details found in the full stories, so a military deliverance could lie behind the formula.

  • The phrase is an editorial formula linking the short notices to the deliverer stories, not a report of a specific event.

    None of the other short notices uses 'save'. Its presence here may be the editor's way of turning from the deliverer stories to the list of administrators.

in v1

Were the 'minor judges' a different kind of office from the deliverers?

  • Yes. They held a standing legal or administrative office, while the deliverers were charismatic military leaders.

    Martin Noth and others pointed to the precise list of years, the burial notices, and the absence of battles or the Spirit, and argued for an office of 'judge of Israel' attested in a separate source.

  • No sharp distinction. Both kinds are 'judges' who govern and rescue, and the difference lies in how much the narrator tells.

    Tola is said both to 'save' (10:1) and to 'judge' (10:2). Deliverers such as Othniel and Jephthah are also said to 'judge'. The Hebrew šāpaṭ covers ruling and leading as well as deciding court cases.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. יָשַׁע, קוּם, תּוֹלָע, דּוֹד, הַר
  • HALOT s.v. ישׁע, תּוֹלָע, דּוֹד
  • TDOT s.v. yāšaʿ (J. F. Sawyer)
  • R. G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible) on 10:1–5
  • D. I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary) on 10:1–5
  • B. G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
  • M. Noth, The Deuteronomistic History (on the 'minor judges')
  • Septuagint, Judges 10:1 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Iudicum 10:1
  • Genesis 46:13; Numbers 26:23; 1 Chronicles 7:1–2 (Issachar clans)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.