Judges Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Judges 9:9–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9But the olive tree replied, ‘Should I stop giving my oil that honors both God and man, to hold sway over the trees?’ 10Then the trees said to the fig tree, ‘Come and reign over us.’ 11But the fig tree replied, ‘Should I stop giving my sweetness and my good fruit, to hold sway over the trees?’ 12Then the trees said to the grapevine, ‘Come and reign over us.’ 13But the grapevine replied, ‘Should I stop giving my wine that cheers both God and man, to hold sway over the trees?’

What the first hearers heard

To the lords of Shechem, hearing it shouted from Gerizim, the olive's reply was an accusation they could not miss. The worthy people of Israel, like Gideon, who had just said "the LORD will rule over you", knew that their calling was to produce and to give: to feed, to light, to honor God and neighbor. They would not leave that to sway over others. So the only one left to say yes would be someone with nothing to give up.

The fable sets two kinds of worth against each other. One is the worth of producing something: oil that "honors gods and men". The other is the worth of position: being lifted above the others. In an honor-shame culture, where kingship was the highest honor, this turned expectations upside down. Here the throne is a step down for anyone who has real fruit to give.

For Israel, which kept this story in Judges, the episode also warned about the period before the monarchy. Kingship grabbed by violence, with money from a Baal temple, gives no shelter. It gives fire (vv. 15, 20), and the rest of chapter 9 shows that fire consuming both Abimelech and Shechem.

From the study of Judges 9:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9But the olive tree replied, ‘Should I stop giving my oil that honors both God and man, to hold sway over the trees?’

    The olive tree answered the trees who had come to anoint it king: "Am I really supposed to give up my rich oil, the very thing people use to honor gods and humans alike, just to go off and wave my branches over the rest of you?"

    The question expects the answer no. In the hill country the olive was the most useful tree there was. Its oil fed people, lit lamps, healed wounds, perfumed guests, was poured out in offerings, and was used to anoint kings and priests. So there is a sharp irony: the trees go "to anoint a king" (v. 8) and ask the one tree whose product is used for anointing. The olive already gives honor to heaven and earth, so it has no need to grab honor for itself.

    The olive's word for ruling is the real insult. It doesn't say "reign". It says "to sway", the restless waving of branches in the wind, the staggering of a drunk, the drifting of a wanderer. In the olive's view, kingship means leaving the place where you bear fruit and swaying uselessly over everyone else. The fig (v. 11) and the vine (v. 13) give the same answer. Only the thornbush, which has nothing to give up, says yes (vv. 14–15).

    Full study →
  2. 10Then the trees said to the fig tree, ‘Come and reign over us.’

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 11But the fig tree replied, ‘Should I stop giving my sweetness and my good fruit, to hold sway over the trees?’

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 12Then the trees said to the grapevine, ‘Come and reign over us.’

    So the trees went on to the next candidate. They turned to the grapevine and said, "Come on, then, you: be king over us."

    This is the third offer in Jotham's fable. The olive tree has said no and so has the fig. Now the trees try the vine, the third of the land's great fruit-bearers, using the same words they used for the fig, word for word. The Hebrew addresses the vine as feminine throughout ("you" and "reign" are both feminine forms). "Come" is not really about walking anywhere. It is an urging word, close to "come on, now." The extra "you" puts the weight on the vine: you be the one, since the others refused. What the trees want is not help but a king (the verb is from the same root as melek, "king"). That is exactly the office Gideon refused (8:22–23) and the one the men of Shechem have just handed to Abimelech. The words "over us" set up the vine's mocking reply in the next verse: why would it give up the wine that cheers God and people just "to sway over the trees"?

    Full study →
  5. 13But the grapevine replied, ‘Should I stop giving my wine that cheers both God and man, to hold sway over the trees?’

    The vine answers the trees, who have just asked her to be their king: "What, am I supposed to give up my new wine, the fresh vintage that brings festive joy to God (or the gods) and to people alike, and go off to flap and totter about above the trees?"

    It is a rhetorical question, and the expected answer is a scornful No. The vine names its whole reason for being: every year it gives the new wine that is poured out at the altar and drunk at feasts and weddings. That gift reaches the whole range of beings who can rejoice, divine and human. Against this, kingship is not described as power or honour. It is called waving about over the others, the restless, rootless swaying of a plant that has left its proper place and bears nothing. The verb can also mean a drunk staggering, which is a sharp touch coming from the vine. There is wordplay too: the trees asked her to reign over them, and she says that would only be to sway over them. Like the olive (v. 9) and the fig (v. 11) before her, the vine judges that the truly productive have better things to do than rule. That leaves the job for the bramble (vv. 14–15), which has nothing to give.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v9

    to be promoted over the trees (KJV)

    lānûaʿ ʿal-hāʿēṣîm

    What we hear
    Moving up to a better job, rising in rank, a reward.
    What they heard
    'To sway / totter over the trees.' It is a mocking picture of kingship as useless waving above others, not an honor to be taken.
  • in v9

    to hold sway over the trees (BSB and several modern versions)

    lānûaʿ

    What we hear
    To exercise real power and dominance.
    What they heard
    The literal 'sway' is the point: unsteady waving with nothing produced. The English idiom gives the position the dignity the olive is mocking.
  • in v9

    my fatness (KJV)

    dešen

    What we hear
    Body fat, being overweight.
    What they heard
    Richness, the rich oil the tree produces. It is a picture of abundance and blessing.
  • in v13

    promoted (KJV)

    lanua'

    What we hear
    Raised to a higher rank or office: an honourable step up.
    What they heard
    To sway, wave about, totter: a mocking picture of kingship as useless flapping above others.
  • in v13

    God (capitalised)

    elohim

    What we hear
    Specifically and only the God of Israel, as a theological statement that God enjoys wine.
    What they heard
    Either 'God' or 'gods', paired with 'men' to mean all beings, divine and human. It reads as a proverb-like saying in a fable told to a Baal-worshipping city, though in Israel's worship it could point to the wine libation to YHWH.
  • in v13

    new wine (WEB, NASB, YLT)

    tirosh

    What we hear
    Unfermented grape juice, or a spiritual image (as in 'new wine into old wineskins').
    What they heard
    The fresh wine of the year's harvest, one of the land's three staple blessings. It could intoxicate (Hos 4:11).
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֤אמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and said · v9, v12, v13

    The ordinary storytelling verb that moves the fable along. In the story the tree talks the way a person would. The olive is answering the trees' request in verse 8.

  2. לָהֶם֙

    lāhem · H9038

    to them · v9, v13

    'Them' is the trees who came to anoint a king. The olive answers the whole group directly.

  3. הַזַּ֔יִת

    hazzayit · H2132H

    the olive tree · v9

    The olive was the most valuable tree of the hill country around Shechem. Its oil was used for food, light, medicine, perfume, offerings, and anointing kings and priests. That is why the trees ask it first.

  4. הֶחֳדַ֙לְתִּי֙

    heḥŏdaltî · H2308

    to cease, give up, leave off · v9, v13

    The verb carries a question marker and is in the 'have done' form: 'Have I given up…?' Hebrew uses this to wave off an idea as absurd, so the sense is 'Am I supposed to give up…?' The question expects the answer no.

  5. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    (marks the object) · v9, v13

    An untranslatable particle marking 'my richness' as the thing the olive would have to give up.

  6. דִּשְׁנִ֔י

    dišnî · H1880

    fatness, richness; (elsewhere) fat-soaked ashes · v9

    'My richness': the rich, oily yield that is the olive's whole purpose. The supplied gloss 'ashes' comes from a separate use of the word for the greasy ashes of sacrifices. It does not fit here. The olive means its oil.

  7. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾăšer- · H0834A

    which, that · v9

    Points back to the richness (the oil) and opens a description of what it is used for.

  8. בִּ֛י

    bî · H9030

    by me, with me · v9

    'By means of me.' The olive stresses that the honor is given through its own product. It is proud of what it does, not of having power.

  9. יְכַבְּד֥וּ

    yəkabbədû · H3513G

    they honor, give weight/glory to · v9

    The verb means 'to honor' (literally 'to make heavy, give weight to'). Its subject is 'they', meaning people in general. The form points to habit: this is how gods and people are always honored. Oil was poured in offerings, burned in sanctuary lamps, rubbed on guests and used to anoint leaders.

  10. אֱלֹהִ֖ים

    ʾĕlōhîm · H0430J

    God / gods · v9, v13

    Inside a fable, paired with 'men', this most naturally reads as 'gods and men', a stock phrase for 'heaven and earth, everyone'. Many translations still read 'God'. See the debates section.

  11. וַאֲנָשִׁ֑ים

    waʾănāšîm · H0582

    and men, humans · v9, v13

    'And humans.' Together with 'gods' it covers everyone above and below. Oil honors the whole order of things.

  12. וְהָ֣לַכְתִּ֔י

    wəhālaktî · H1980G

    and go · v9, v12, v13

    'And go off.' It picks up verse 8, where the trees 'went' to anoint a king. To become king the olive would have to leave its place and its work.

  13. לָנ֖וּעַ

    lānûaʿ · H5128

    to sway, totter, wave, wander · v9, v13

    'To sway': the movement of branches in the wind, or of a drunk or a wanderer who cannot stay put. The olive mocks kingship as useless waving above the others. It is a deliberately scornful word, not a neutral word for 'rule'.

  14. עַל־

    ʿal- · H5921A

    over, above · v9, v12, v13

    'Over' the trees. It is physically above them, and it is also the same word used for ruling 'over' someone in verse 8 ('reign over us'). The olive turns their request back on them.

  15. הָעֵצִֽים׃

    hāʿēṣîm · H6086H

    the trees · v9, v12, v13

    The other trees of the fable. In Jotham's story they stand for the lords of Shechem, who were looking for a king.

  16. לַגָּ֑פֶן

    laggāpen · H1612

    to the vine · v12, v13

    The grapevine, one of the staple crops of the land (with olive and fig). The noun can be masculine or feminine; here it is treated as feminine, so every following word addressed to it is feminine.

  17. אַ֖תְּ

    ʾat · H0859

    you (feminine singular) · v12

    The pronoun is not needed grammatically, since the verb already says 'you'. Spelling it out puts weight on it: 'you, then', the one they turn to now that the others have refused. KJV and YLT keep this with 'Come thou'.

  18. מָלְכִ֥י

    mālkî · H4427

    reign, be king · v12

    Command form, feminine singular: 'be king', 'rule as king'. It is the key word of the whole chapter, which turns on who should become king (melek) at Shechem.

  19. תִּ֣ירוֹשִׁ֔י

    tiroshi · H8492

    new wine, fresh wine of the vintage · v13

    "My new wine": the fresh yield of the grape harvest. The word goes with grain and oil in the standard list of the land's blessings. It is the vine's own product and its gift to others.

  20. הַֽמְשַׂמֵּ֥חַ

    hamsammeach · H8055

    to make glad, cause to rejoice · v13

    "The one that makes glad." The verb form means 'causes to rejoice'. It describes the new wine as something that brings festive joy, the joy of feasts and celebrations, not just a mild 'cheer'.

The world behind it

The story behind the fable. Gideon (also called Jerubbaal) had turned down an offer to make him king: "I will not rule over you… the LORD will rule over you" (Judg 8:22–23). After his death, Abimelech, his son by a concubine from Shechem, got the leading men of Shechem to back him. He hired thugs with money from the temple of Baal-berith ("Baal of the covenant") and killed his seventy half-brothers "on one stone". Then the lords of Shechem made him king by the oak of the pillar (9:1–6).

Jotham on Mount Gerizim. Jotham, the youngest brother, escaped. He climbed Mount Gerizim, the mountain that rises over Shechem and that Deut 27:12 links with blessing, and shouted this fable down to the town (9:7–21). The trees stand for the Shechemites. The olive, fig and vine stand for fruitful, worthy people who would not take a throne. The bramble stands for Abimelech: a plant with no fruit, no shade worth having, and a habit of catching fire.

Why the olive comes first. Shechem lies in olive country, and oil was its main wealth. Oil was food, lamp fuel, medicine, cosmetic, and a gift of hospitality (Ps 23:5). It was mixed into grain offerings and burned in sanctuary lamps (Lev 2; Exod 27:20). It was poured on the heads of priests and kings (Exod 29:7; 1 Sam 10:1). For the first hearers, "my oil, by which gods and men are honored" would bring to mind the altar, the lampstand, the feast and the anointing all at once.

A known kind of story. Stories in which plants argue were familiar in the ancient Near East. Mesopotamian debate poems such as "The Tamarisk and the Palm" are one example. The Bible has another plant fable in 2 Kgs 14:9 (the thistle and the cedar). Jotham uses a form his audience knew.

From the study of Judges 9:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

Is the fable against kingship as such, or only against Abimelech's kind of king?

  • Against monarchy in general: in the fable, only a worthless person would ever want to be king.

    All three fruitful trees turn the throne down as something that takes them away from their real purpose. That echoes Gideon's refusal in 8:23 ('the LORD will rule over you'). Older critical scholars such as Buber called it the most anti-monarchic text in the Hebrew Bible.

  • Against an illegitimate, bloody grab for power, specifically Abimelech's.

    Jotham's own application (9:16–20) is about whether the Shechemites acted 'in truth and integrity' toward Gideon's house, not about kingship as such. Judges later laments that 'there was no king in Israel' (17:6; 21:25). Many commentators, such as Block and Webb, read the fable as aimed at Abimelech.

  • An older, freestanding fable adapted for this setting.

    Its wisdom-style tone and the parallels with ancient Near Eastern plant fables suggest it may have circulated on its own before. The bramble's reply (v. 15) fits Abimelech closely. Some scholars, such as Lindars, think the application was sharpened when the story was placed here.

in v9

Does ʾĕlōhîm here mean 'God' or 'gods'?

  • 'Gods': a stock phrase of the fable for 'everyone above and below'.

    The parallel in v. 13, where wine 'cheers gods and men', is awkward if it means Israel's God. The phrase 'gods and men' is known as a set pairing in the wider literature. The Vulgate and YLT read plural, and NIV and ESV read 'gods'.

  • 'God': a reference to offerings to Israel's God that use oil.

    Oil had a central place in Israelite offerings and anointing (Lev 2; Exod 29:7). One Septuagint tradition reads 'men will glorify God'. KJV, BSB, WEB and NASB use the singular.

in v12

Is the fable against kingship in general, or only against Abimelech's kind of king?

  • The fable is against monarchy as such. Every worthy plant refuses to rule, and only the useless bramble accepts, so kingship itself is shown as something no productive person would want.

    Martin Buber famously called it the strongest anti-monarchical poem in world literature. It fits Gideon's refusal (8:22–23) and the suspicion of kings found elsewhere (1 Sam 8).

  • The target is Abimelech and Shechem's bad faith, not kingship in principle.

    Jotham's own application (vv. 16–20) is conditional and turns on whether Shechem dealt honestly with Gideon's house. Later in the book there are hints that a king might have been welcome ('In those days there was no king in Israel…', 17:6; 21:25).

in v12

Did the fable exist before Jotham, and was it adapted for this story?

  • It was a pre-existing folk fable worked into the story.

    The fable and its application don't fit together perfectly. The fable is about the worth of each candidate, while vv. 16–20 are about good faith toward Jerubbaal. Similar plant debates are known from Mesopotamian disputation poems.

  • It was composed for its present setting.

    Its imagery fits the details closely: fire from the bramble (v. 15) matches the burning of the tower of Shechem (9:49), and the three crops match the hill-country setting around Shechem.

in v13

Does 'elohim' here mean Israel's God or 'gods' in general?

  • 'God': Israel's God, whom the wine libation pleases.

    Wine offerings are 'a pleasing aroma to YHWH' (Num 15:7, 10). The parallel in v. 9 (oil 'by which elohim and men are honored') fits the use of oil in Israel's worship. Most English versions and the Vulgate read it this way, and rabbinic tradition (b. Berakhot 35a) explains it through the Temple libation.

  • 'Gods': a general, proverbial expression.

    Fables use folk idiom, and Jotham is speaking to Shechemites who worship Baal-berith (9:4, 27). Ancient Near Eastern texts commonly picture gods feasting on wine. The Hebrew does not mark number here. YLT and the NIV render it as plural.

in v13

Is the fable against kingship in general or against Abimelech in particular?

  • Against monarchy in principle.

    Every worthy plant refuses, and kingship is described as useless 'swaying'. This echoes Gideon's refusal (8:23) and later warnings about kings (1 Sam 8).

  • Aimed at Abimelech and Shechem in particular.

    Jotham's application (vv. 16–20) turns on whether Shechem acted 'in good faith' toward Gideon's house, not on kingship as such. Elsewhere Judges seems to expect that a proper king would bring order (17:6; 21:25).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. דֶּשֶׁן, נוּעַ, חָדַל, כָּבֵד
  • HALOT s.v. דֶּשֶׁן; נוּעַ
  • Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC)
  • Robert G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
  • Trent C. Butler, Judges (WBC)
  • Barnabas Lindars, Judges 1–5 and related studies of the Jotham fable
  • Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 9
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta (Judges A and B texts)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Judices 9:9
  • BDB s.v. מָלַךְ; גֶּפֶן; הָלַךְ
  • HALOT s.v. מלך; גֶּפֶן
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 9:7–15
  • Amarna letters (EA 252–254, Lab'ayu of Shechem)
  • M. Buber, Kingship of God (on Jotham's fable)
  • Mesopotamian disputation poems, e.g. 'The Tamarisk and the Palm'
  • Septuagint (Judges, A and B texts); Vulgate, Judges 9:12
  • BDB s.v. תִּירוֹשׁ, נוּעַ, חָדַל, שָׂמַח
  • HALOT s.v. תִּירוֹשׁ; נוּעַ
  • Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 35a
  • Numbers 15:5–10; 28:7 (wine libations)
  • Psalm 104:15; Hosea 4:11
  • Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC), on Jotham's fable

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.