Psalms Chapter 88 Read as one passage

Psalm 88:10–12

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10Do You work wonders for the dead? Do departed spirits rise up to praise You? Selah 11Can Your loving devotion be proclaimed in the grave, Your faithfulness in Abaddon? 12Will Your wonders be known in the darkness, or Your righteousness in the land of oblivion?

What the first hearers heard

For worshippers at Israel's sanctuary, this verse turned a familiar hymn phrase upside down. "The God who does wonders" was a line of praise sung about the Exodus (Exod 15:11; Ps 77:14). Here it becomes a desperate question: what use are your wonders if I am dead?

They would have heard several things:

  • A real argument for rescue. The singer stands at the edge of Sheol and reminds God that thanksgiving belongs to the living. Rescued people bring thank-offerings and tell their story. The dead do not. Lamenters were allowed, even encouraged, to press God with arguments like this.
  • A blunt picture of death. The dead are rephaim, shadows who do not get up. In a world where neighbouring peoples honoured the dead as powerful ancestors, this kept all power, and all wonder, with the LORD alone.
  • Permission to lament without resolution. The psalm was sung in the temple liturgy, with its Selah, as a recognised prayer, even though it ends without relief. Bringing God unanswered questions was itself treated as faithful prayer.
  • Unanswered tension. "Wonder" means the humanly impossible. Hearers who knew the LORD's wonders could feel the question pull against itself. Later Israelite texts would take up the same words and give a different answer (Isa 26:19; Dan 12:2). The psalm itself does not.

From the study of Psalm 88:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10Do You work wonders for the dead? Do departed spirits rise up to praise You? Selah

    "Is it for the dead that you do your wonders, you, the God whose title in every hymn is 'the One who does wonders'? Or will the shades, those faint shadows of people lying in the underworld, get up off the ground and stand to testify in front of everyone to what you did for them?" (pause)

    Both questions expect the answer "No." This is a man arguing in prayer, not stating doctrine. A wonder from God means rescue, and rescue needs a living person to receive it. Praise in Israel meant standing in the assembly and saying out loud, "I cried and the LORD answered me." So the dead are no use to God. They cannot receive his acts of deliverance, and they cannot tell anyone about them. If the singer goes down into death, God loses a witness. Behind the words is a quiet irony. A "wonder" means exactly what is humanly impossible, and that is the very kind of thing the singer says could never happen for the dead. The Selah leaves the question unanswered.

    Full study →
  2. 11Can Your loving devotion be proclaimed in the grave, Your faithfulness in Abaddon?

    "Down in the tomb, will anyone tell the story of your loyal love? In Abaddon, the Place of Perishing, will anyone recount how steady and dependable you are?"

    The question is rhetorical, and the expected answer is no. The verb pictures someone telling God's deeds over one by one, the way a worshipper stood up in the assembly and gave testimony: "I was going down, and the LORD rescued me." The two things that would be told are the pair Israel most often used to describe God. The first is chesed, his committed, loyal kindness that acts to save those who belong to him. The second is ʾemunah, his firmness, the reliability of someone who does not give way when you lean on him.

    The two places are the grave, the rock-cut family tomb where bodies were laid, and Abaddon, a poetic name for the world of the dead meaning "Ruin" or "Lostness." Here it is a place, not a demon. The poetry sets God's steadiness against the place where everything comes apart.

    The psalmist is not giving a lecture on the afterlife. He is arguing with God and pressing his case: if you let me die, you lose a witness. Your loyal love will have one less voice to tell it. Act now, while I can still tell it. The verse is the middle one of three paired questions (vv. 10–12): the dead and the departed spirits, the grave and Abaddon, the darkness and the land of forgetting. Each puts a quality of God's (his wonders, his loyalty, his rightness) next to a place where it cannot be celebrated.

    Full study →
  3. 12Will Your wonders be known in the darkness, or Your righteousness in the land of oblivion?

    "Down there in the dark, will anyone ever come to know the wonder you work? Will your acts of rescue and setting-right be recognised and told in the land where everything is forgotten, where the dead are forgotten and forget?"

    The verse is a question the psalmist expects to be answered "No." It is the last of three paired questions (vv. 10–12), each setting one of God's great qualities against a name for the world of the dead:

    • your wonder, for the dead ones
    • your loyal love, in the grave
    • your faithfulness, in Abaddon (the place of destruction)
    • your wonder, in the darkness
    • your righteousness, in the land of forgetting

    "Wonder" means God's astonishing deeds of rescue, the kind of thing he did at the Exodus. "Righteousness" here does not mean God's moral purity. It means his active putting-right: stepping in to vindicate and save someone who belongs to him. Both are meant to be known, seen and then told in worship. But the underworld is dark, so nothing can be seen there, and it is the land of forgetting, so nothing is remembered or retold.

    So the psalmist is not calmly describing the afterlife. He is arguing with God, pleading as someone who is close to death: if you are going to rescue me, it has to be now. Once I am in the grave, your wonder will have no witness and your saving justice no one to sing of it. He says it while still praying (v. 13: "But to you, O LORD, I cry for help"), which shows he has not given up on God, even in the Bible's darkest psalm.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    departed spirits (BSB, WEB, NASB); the departed (ESV)

    rĕpāʾîm

    What we hear
    Disembodied souls who have gone on to another life, whether in heaven, as ghosts, or elsewhere, still conscious and active.
    What they heard
    The 'shades': weakened, shadowy remnants of the dead in Sheol, cut off from the life and worship of God's people. The word also carried associations of the legendary mighty dead, the 'Rephaim'.
  • in v10

    praise you

    yôdûkā (yādâ, Hiphil)

    What we hear
    Adoration in general, or worship singing.
    What they heard
    To acknowledge and give thanks publicly, telling in the assembly what God concretely did, usually alongside a thank-offering after a rescue.
  • in v11

    destruction / Destruction (KJV, YLT, WEB)

    ʾabaddon

    What we hear
    An event or outcome, being destroyed or annihilated, as if the question were "will your faithfulness be shown in the act of destroying?"
    What they heard
    A name for a place: the underworld, "the Place of Perishing," in parallel with "the grave."
  • in v11

    Abaddon (BSB, ESV, NASB)

    ʾabaddon

    What we hear
    A demon or angel: the "Destroyer" of Revelation 9:11, or a hell of torment.
    What they heard
    The realm of the dead, a poetic partner of Sheol. It is a place of silence and lostness, not a personal being and not a place of punishment in this psalm.
  • in v11

    lovingkindness (KJV) / loving kindness (WEB)

    chesed

    What we hear
    Gentle tenderness, a warm feeling of affection.
    What they heard
    Loyal, committed kindness shown in action, especially rescue, by someone who has bound himself to another.
  • in v12

    righteousness

    tsedaqah

    What we hear
    God's moral perfection, or a status of being right that is credited to believers.
    What they heard
    God's active putting-right: his acts of rescue and vindication on behalf of those bound to him, close in meaning to 'salvation' and 'loyal love'.
  • in v12

    land of oblivion

    erets neshiyyah

    What we hear
    Non-existence or annihilation, where consciousness simply ends.
    What they heard
    The 'land of forgetting': the underworld where the dead are forgotten and cannot remember or retell God's deeds. The shades exist there in a weakened state.
  • in v12

    the darkness / the dark

    ḥōshekh

    What we hear
    Readers who know later Christian imagery may hear 'outer darkness' or hell as a place of punishment.
    What they heard
    The gloom of Sheol, the common destination of all the dead, with no idea of punishment attached.
Every word
  1. הֲלַמֵּתִ֥ים

    hălammētîm · H4191

    (is it) for the dead? · v10

    Three parts: the question marker ha-, the preposition 'for/to' with 'the', and the plural participle of 'to die', meaning 'those who have died'. Putting 'for the dead' first in the sentence stresses it: is it *the dead* you do wonders for?

  2. תַּעֲשֶׂה־

    taʿăśeh · H6213A

    you will do / make · v10

    An unfinished-action verb, 'will you do' or 'do you (ever) do', addressed to God. Together with the next word it repeats a set hymn phrase, 'doing wonder' (Exod 15:11; Ps 77:14), one of God's standard titles in praise.

  3. פֶּ֑לֶא

    peleʾ · H6382

    wonder, extraordinary deed · v10, v12

    Singular but standing for a whole class: the kind of act that is beyond human possibility and belongs to God alone, above all rescue. The singer has in mind a wonder of deliverance done for him.

  4. אִם־

    ʾim · H0518H

    or · v10

    It brings in the second half of a two-part question (ha-… ʾim… = 'is it…? or…?'). Both halves expect the answer 'No'.

  5. רְ֝פָאִ֗ים

    rĕpāʾîm · H7496

    shades, Rephaim · v10

    The dead in the underworld, pictured as faint, weak shadows of the people they were. Israel's neighbours used the same word for honoured, even god-like, dead ancestors. Here they are powerless.

  6. יָק֤וּמוּ׀

    yāqûmû · H6965B

    they will rise, stand up · v10

    'Will they get up?' The word means getting up from lying down, here from the grave, and perhaps also standing up to take part in worship. Isaiah 26:14 uses the same word with the same subject: 'shades do not rise.'

  7. יוֹד֬וּךָ

    yôdûkā · H3034

    they will acknowledge / give thanks to you · v10

    To declare in public what God has done, usually as thanksgiving for being rescued, given among the worshippers at the sanctuary. It is open testimony, not simply a feeling of praise.

  8. סֶּֽלָה׃

    selâ · H5542

    Selah · v10

    A liturgical or musical marker whose meaning is uncertain, possibly a pause or a cue to 'lift up' voice or instruments. It sets the unanswered question hanging in silence.

  9. הַיְסֻפַּ֣ר

    hayesuppar · H5608A

    to count, recount, tell · v11

    The question marker ha- ("is it…?") plus a passive form: "will it be told over / recounted?" The root means counting things out one by one, and so telling a story item by item. In the Psalms it is the word for publicly telling God's deeds in the gathered community. The question expects the answer "No."

  10. בַּקֶּ֣בֶר

    baqqever · H6913

    grave, tomb, burial place · v11

    "In the tomb." It is the physical burial place, in Judah usually a family tomb cut into rock. Paired with Abaddon, it stands for the whole state of being dead. It echoes verse 5, "like the slain who lie in the grave."

  11. חַסְדֶּ֑ךָ

    chasdekha · H2617A

    loyal love, steadfast kindness · v11

    "Your chesed": God's committed, loyal kindness, shown in action, especially rescue, toward those bound to him. It is what the psalmist is begging for, and what he says will go untold if he dies.

  12. אֱ֝מֽוּנָתְךָ֗

    ʾemunatekha · H0530

    firmness, faithfulness, reliability · v11

    "Your steadfastness": God's dependability, the quality of being someone you can lean your weight on. It is the usual partner word of chesed. The verb "told" carries over from the first half of the line: "[will] your faithfulness [be told]…?"

  13. בָּאֲבַדּֽוֹן׃

    baʾabaddon · H0011

    Abaddon, (place of) destruction · v11

    "In Abaddon," literally "the Place of Perishing," from the verb ʾavad, "to perish, be lost." Here it is a poetic name for the world of the dead, a partner word for Sheol. It is not a person or a demon.

  14. הֲיִוָּדַ֣ע

    hayiwwadaʿ · H3045

    to know; (passive) be known, be made known · v12

    The opening הֲ marks a question, and the verb is passive: 'will it be known / get made known?' In Hebrew 'knowing' God's deeds means having them told and recognised, so the question is whether anyone down there will ever hear or tell of what God has done. The expected answer is 'no.'

  15. בַּחֹ֣שֶׁךְ

    baḥōshekh · H2822

    darkness · v12

    'In the darkness': not night-time but the lightless world of the dead (compare v. 6, 'in dark places', and v. 18, 'darkness is my closest friend'). It stands in parallel with 'the dead', 'the grave' and 'Abaddon' in vv. 10–11.

  16. וְ֝צִדְקָתְךָ֗

    wetsidqatekha · H6666

    righteousness, right action, saving justice · v12

    'And your righteousness': here God's *acts* of setting things right, keeping faith and rescuing the wronged, not a quiet moral quality. It pairs with 'wonder' in this verse and with 'loyal love' and 'faithfulness' in v. 11. The verb 'be known' carries over from the first line.

  17. בְּאֶ֣רֶץ

    beʾerets · H0776G

    land, earth, ground; also the underworld · v12

    'In the land of.' Erets usually means earth or country, but in poetry it can name the underworld, the land beneath (as in Jonah 2:6, and like the related Ugaritic word arṣ). Here it means the realm of the dead.

  18. נְשִׁיָּֽה׃

    neshiyyah · H5388

    forgetfulness, forgetting · v12

    'Forgetting': the word occurs only here in the Bible and comes from the verb nashah, 'to forget.' The 'land of forgetting' is where the dead are forgotten (by people, and seemingly by God, v. 5), and probably also where the dead themselves no longer remember or praise.

The world behind it

The darkest psalm. Psalm 88 is credited to Heman the Ezrahite, one of the temple singers (1 Chr 15:17–19), within the Korahite guild of temple musicians. Nearly every lament psalm turns to trust or praise by the end. This one never does: it ends "darkness is my closest friend" (v. 18). The singer has been near death "from my youth" (v. 15), cut off from friends (vv. 8, 18), and calls out day after day (v. 9).

Sheol and the shades. For most of the Old Testament period, the Israelite picture of death was Sheol: a dark, silent land below, "the pit", "Abaddon" (place of destruction, v. 11), "the land of forgetting" (v. 12). Its people were not tormented, and they were not in bliss either. They were rephaim, weak shadows. In Psalm 88's words they are "cut off from your hand" and "remembered no more" (v. 5). Worship, sacrifice and thanksgiving happened among the living at the sanctuary, so the dead were outside the worshipping life of Israel (Ps 6:5; 30:9; 115:17; Isa 38:18–19).

Against the cult of the dead. In Canaan and Ugarit, rpum/rephaim were dead royal ancestors. People called on them, fed them, and sometimes treated them as divine. Israel's law forbade consulting the dead (Lev 19:31; Deut 18:10–11; compare 1 Sam 28). In that light, a psalm insisting that the rephaim cannot even stand up to thank the LORD also says the dead hold no power, and every wonder belongs to Israel's God.

Arguing with God. Lament psalms often give God reasons to act. One of them is God's own interest: a living, rescued worshipper adds to his public honour, and a dead one adds nothing. Verses 10–12 are a run of six such questions, each pairing a gift of God (wonders, steadfast love, faithfulness, righteousness) with a name for the realm of death.

From the study of Psalm 88:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Does this verse teach that there is no meaningful life with God after death?

  • It reflects Israel's earlier common view of death: the dead are cut off from God's acts and from worship. Hope of resurrection came later (Isa 26:19; Dan 12:2).

    The same view appears consistently in Ps 6:5; 30:9; 115:17; Isa 38:18–19; Sirach 17:27–28, and in Ps 88:5 itself ('whom you remember no more').

  • The questions are rhetorical arguments meant to move God to act now, not a full doctrine of the afterlife. The verse says what the dead cannot do in the worship of the living community, nothing more.

    Lament psalms routinely argue from God's honour and interest. The verse's subject is public thanksgiving (yadah) and acts of rescue (pele), both bound to the living assembly.

  • Christian interpreters have read the questions as left open and later answered by resurrection, pointing to the overlap of words with Isa 26:19.

    Isa 26:14 and 26:19 use the same pair (metim/rephaim) and the same verb 'rise', first denied and then promised. Pele means precisely what is beyond human possibility.

in v10

What does 'rephaim' mean at root?

  • 'Healers' or 'blessed ones', from rāpāʾ 'to heal': the dead ancestors as protectors who bring blessing.

    Ugaritic rpum appear as revered ancestors in funeral liturgy (KTU 1.161). The Septuagint read 'physicians' here and in Isa 26:14.

  • 'Weak, slack ones', from rāpâ 'to sink, be weak': a word describing the feebleness of the dead.

    Isa 14:10 has the rephaim say 'you too have become weak like us', which may be wordplay. The general picture of Sheol is one of weakness.

  • Originally the name of a group (ancient heroes or a royal line, remembered as giants), later used for the dead in general.

    Gen 14:5; Deut 2:11; 3:11 (Og). Ugaritic texts treat the rpum as a named group linked with kingship.

in v11

Does the verse teach that God is absent from, or has no relationship with, the dead?

  • It reflects an early Israelite belief: the dead go to a silent underworld and are cut off from worship and from God's saving acts.

    The same theme recurs in Ps 6:5; 30:9; 115:17; Isa 38:18–19. Ps 88:5 itself says the dead are those "you remember no more, cut off from your hand." Clear hope of resurrection appears only later (Isa 26:19; Dan 12:2).

  • It is lament language used to move God to act, not a full statement of belief. Elsewhere the Hebrew Bible affirms that God's reach extends to Sheol.

    Ps 139:8 ("if I make my bed in Sheol, you are there"); Amos 9:2; Job 26:6 and Prov 15:11 (Sheol and Abaddon lie "open" before God). The point of verse 11 is that the dead cannot *testify*, not that God has no power over them.

in v11

Is Abaddon simply another name for Sheol, or a distinct, deeper region?

  • In the Hebrew Bible it is a poetic synonym for Sheol and the grave.

    It always appears in parallel with Sheol, Death, or the grave (Job 26:6; 28:22; Prov 15:11; 27:20; Ps 88:11), with no sign of a separate compartment or of punishment.

  • Later tradition treated it as a deep zone or as a name of the place of punishment, and some readers carry this back into the psalm.

    Dead Sea Thanksgiving Hymns (1QH col. XI) describe Abaddon as an abyss; b. Eruvin 19a lists it among the names of Gehinnom; Rev 9:11 personifies it. These developments postdate the psalm.

in v12

Who does the forgetting in the 'land of forgetting'?

  • The dead are forgotten: by the living, and apparently by God.

    Ps 88:5 ('whom you remember no more, cut off from your hand'); Ps 31:12; the Septuagint's 'forgotten land'.

  • The dead themselves forget: they have no memory, knowledge or capacity to praise.

    Eccl 9:5, 10 ('the dead know nothing'); Ps 6:5 ('in death there is no remembrance of you'). In the verse's logic, God's deeds cannot be 'known' there.

  • Both at once: Sheol is the place where memory fails in every direction.

    The surrounding verses stress both being cut off by God (v. 5) and being unable to praise (vv. 10–11). Many commentators (e.g. Tate, Goldingay) read the phrase as covering both.

in v12

Does the verse deny any life after death?

  • It reflects early Israel's belief that the dead live on only as shades, with no relationship to God.

    The consistent picture across Ps 6:5; 30:9; 115:17; Isa 38:18; Job 14; resurrection hope appears clearly only later (Dan 12:2).

  • It is the language of lament, overstated to strengthen the plea, rather than a worked-out doctrine of the afterlife.

    The questions are rhetorical arguments addressed to God. Other psalms hint that God's reach extends to Sheol (Ps 139:8; 49:15; 73:24).

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. רְפָאִים; s.v. פֶּלֶא; s.v. ידה hif.
  • BDB s.v. רָפָא II (rephaim); s.v. פלא
  • Marvin E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary 20)
  • John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2 (Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms)
  • Philip S. Johnston, Shades of Sheol: Death and Afterlife in the Old Testament
  • Brian B. Schmidt, Israel's Beneficent Dead
  • KTU 1.161 (Ugaritic royal funerary text); KAI 13–14 (Tabnit and Eshmunazar inscriptions)
  • Septuagint, Rahlfs ed., Ps 87:11
  • Vulgate: Psalterium Gallicanum and Psalterium iuxta Hebraeos, Ps 87:11
  • BDB s.v. סָפַר, קֶבֶר, חֶסֶד, אֱמוּנָה, אֲבַדּוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. אֲבַדּוֹן, חֶסֶד
  • Nelson Glueck, Hesed in the Bible (1927; ET 1967)
  • Katharine Doob Sakenfeld, The Meaning of Hesed in the Hebrew Bible (1978)
  • Gordon R. Clark, The Word Hesed in the Hebrew Bible (1993)
  • Nicholas J. Tromp, Primitive Conceptions of Death and the Nether World in the Old Testament (1969)
  • Philip S. Johnston, Shades of Sheol: Death and Afterlife in the Old Testament (2002)
  • Marvin E. Tate, Psalms 51–100 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2 (Baker Commentary on the Old Testament)
  • Septuagint, Psalm 87:12 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Psalm 87:12 (Gallican and iuxta Hebraeos)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls, 1QH (Hodayot) col. XI
  • Babylonian Talmud, Eruvin 19a
  • BDB s.v. נְשִׁיָּה, נָשָׁה, פֶּלֶא, צְדָקָה
  • HALOT s.v. נְשִׁיָּה; s.v. אֶרֶץ (netherworld sense)
  • John Goldingay, Psalms vol. 2: Psalms 42–89 (Baker Commentary on the OT)
  • Nicholas J. Tromp, Primitive Conceptions of Death and the Nether World in the Old Testament
  • Septuagint Ps 87:13 (Rahlfs); Vulgate Ps 87:13 (Gallican Psalter)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ps 88

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).