Song of Songs Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Song of Songs 8:9–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9If she is a wall, we will build a tower of silver upon her. If she is a door, we will enclose her with panels of cedar. 10I am a wall, and my breasts are like towers. So I have become in his eyes like one who brings peace.

What the first hearers heard

To its first hearers this was a family scene in the language of love poetry. The brothers, the men responsible for their sister's marriage and the family's honour, talk about her as a fortified city they will finish building. Listeners would have recognised their tone: protective, proud, a little proprietorial, and occupied with value (silver, cedar).

The two conditions let the brothers keep their options open. If she proves to be a 'wall', they will crown her with silver, which honours, adorns and perhaps dowers her. If she proves to be a 'door', they will case her in cedar, strengthening, decorating and perhaps restraining her. The siege verb in the second line lets the audience hear how such guardianship might feel to the one being guarded.

The scene is there to set up the woman's reply in v. 10. She takes the brothers' own metaphor and turns it: "I am a wall, and my breasts are like towers." She is no longer the flat-chested little sister, and she says she has guarded herself. She is not waiting for her brothers to decide what she is. That is why she can say "in his eyes I became like one who finds (or brings) peace (shalom)", a likely play on the names Shulammite and Solomon. Then, in vv. 11–12, she sets the silver-counting world of Solomon and his tenants against "my vineyard, which is mine". For an ancient audience the brothers' voice stands for the social order around love, family honour and bride-price. The Song lets that voice speak and then lets the woman answer it in her own words.

From the study of Song of Songs 8:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9If she is a wall, we will build a tower of silver upon her. If she is a door, we will enclose her with panels of cedar.

    The brothers have just asked what they should do for their little sister, who is still too young to have breasts, "on the day she is spoken for", meaning the day someone asks for her in marriage (v. 8). Now they answer like builders planning work on a city:

    "If she is a wall, a solid city rampart with no way through, we will build on top of her battlements of silver. And if she is a door, the swinging leaf in the city gate, the one place a wall can open, we will close her in with a plank of cedar."

    The pictures are architectural and military. A girl is pictured as a fortified town. If she is wall-like, closed and holding her own, her brothers will crown her with silver, a costly ornament more like jewellery or a crown than a real defence. If she is door-like, they will fit cedar panelling over her. Cedar is the luxury timber of Solomon's Temple, and the panel can strengthen the door, decorate it, or bar it shut. The verb for this second job usually means "besiege" when used with "upon/against". So the second line has an edge: the protectors sound for a moment like an army surrounding the gate.

    The Hebrew leaves one thing open, and translations have to choose. "And if" may mean "but if" (wall = chaste and rewarded; door = accessible and restrained) or simply "and if" (wall and door both need guarding and honouring). Either way, the speakers are brothers acting as guardians of a sister's marriage. They see her value partly in terms of silver, the same word as "money", and the next verses keep counting silver. In the following verse the sister answers them herself: "I am a wall, and my breasts are like towers." She is no longer little, and she has kept her own walls.

    Full study →
  2. 10I am a wall, and my breasts are like towers. So I have become in his eyes like one who brings peace.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v9

    palace (KJV, YLT)

    ṭîrat

    What we hear
    A royal residence, a grand house built on the sister.
    What they heard
    A battlement, parapet or turret, the crenellated top course of a city wall. It is something added on top of the wall, not a separate building.
  • in v9

    door

    delet

    What we hear
    A house door, perhaps by itself suggesting a 'revolving door' or promiscuity.
    What they heard
    The swinging leaf of a door or gate. Set beside 'wall' and 'battlement', it most naturally pictures a city gate. Whether it implies sexual accessibility is debated, not given by the word itself.
Every word
  1. אִם־

    ʾim · H0518A

    if · v9

    Opens a real condition: the brothers do not yet know what kind of woman their little sister will turn out to be (v. 8), so they plan for one possibility and then the other.

  2. חוֹמָה

    ḥômâ · H2346G

    wall (especially a city wall) · v9

    The great defensive wall around a town: solid, unbroken, hard to get through. As a picture of a girl it suggests someone closed off and holding her own. In v. 10 she takes this word for herself: "I am a wall."

  3. הִיא

    hîʾ · H1931

    she · v9

    "She [is]": Hebrew needs no verb "to be" here. The pronoun points back to "our little sister" in v. 8.

  4. נִבְנֶה

    nibneh · H1129

    to build · v9

    "We will build" or "let us build". The brothers talk like builders adding to an existing wall. The Hebrew form covers both a plan and a resolve.

  5. עָלֶיהָ

    ʿāleyhā · H5921A

    upon her · v9

    "On top of her": the new structure goes on top of the wall, as battlements crown a city rampart.

  6. טִירַת

    ṭîrat · H2918

    encampment, enclosure, row of stones, battlement · v9

    Here it means the crenellated top course of a wall (battlements or a turret), made of silver. It is a crown on the wall, both defensive and showy.

  7. כָּסֶף

    kāsef · H3701G

    silver, money · v9

    Silver as costly material, so the battlement is an ornament as much as a defence. The same word was the everyday word for money, and it comes back in vv. 11–12 ("a thousand pieces of silver").

  8. דֶּלֶת

    delet · H1817C

    door, the leaf of a door or gate · v9

    The swinging panel in a doorway or city gate, the one part of a wall that opens. Next to "wall" it calls up a city gate. It may suggest that she is accessible, or simply name another part of the city to be strengthened and adorned.

  9. נָצוּר

    nāṣûr · H6696A

    to bind, confine, besiege; (homonym) to form, fashion · v9

    "We will enclose / shut in." Followed by "upon" (ʿal), this verb usually means "lay siege against" a city, so the builders now sound like they are surrounding the door. The protection has a hint of confinement in it. A rarer root spelled the same way means "to fashion", which lies behind the Greek translation and YLT's "fashion".

  10. לוּחַ

    lûaḥ · H3871

    board, plank, tablet · v9

    A flat board or plank: a cedar panel fixed over the door, either to strengthen it or to bar it shut (perhaps both). It is the same word used for stone tablets and ship's planks.

  11. אָרֶז

    ʾārez · H0730

    cedar · v9

    Cedar of Lebanon: imported, fragrant, durable, the luxury timber of palaces and the Temple. A cedar panel is costly and strong, not a cheap board nailed over a gap.

The world behind it

Brothers as guardians. In ancient Israel, as across the ancient Near East, a girl's marriage was a family matter in which brothers had a real say, especially if the father was absent. Laban negotiates for his sister Rebekah (Gen 24:29–60). Dinah's brothers avenge her honour (Gen 34). Absalom takes in his violated sister Tamar (2 Sam 13). Earlier in the Song the woman complains that "my mother's sons were angry with me; they made me keeper of the vineyards" (1:6), and the Song never mentions her father. So vv. 8–9 voice the brothers looking ahead to the day a suitor "speaks for" her, which was the formal request for marriage (compare David 'speaking for' Abigail, 1 Sam 25:39). A family's honour depended heavily on a daughter coming to marriage as a virgin, and a bride-price in silver was usually involved.

The city as a woman. Hebrew poetry often pictures a city as a woman ("daughter Zion"), and the Song turns this round, describing the woman as a city with neck-towers, a tower of David hung with shields (4:4), and walls. A silver battlement may echo the "mural crown", a crenellated, wall-shaped headdress worn by queens and city goddesses in Near Eastern art (an Assyrian queen wears one in Ashurbanipal's 'garden party' relief). That would make the silver battlement something like a bridal crown. This connection is suggestive, not certain.

Silver and cedar. Both were prestige materials. Silver was the medium of exchange: there were no coins until late, and silver was weighed. Cedar had to be imported from Lebanon and was used for palaces and the Temple. Vv. 11–12 go straight on to Solomon's vineyard rented out for "a thousand pieces of silver", which the woman contrasts with "my own vineyard", herself, which is hers to give.

From the study of Song of Songs 8:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

Are 'wall' and 'door' opposites (chaste vs. accessible) or parallel images (both to be guarded and adorned)?

  • Antithetical: a 'wall' is a girl who resists advances and will be rewarded with silver ornament. A 'door' is a girl who is open or accessible and will be barred shut with a cedar plank. This is the reading of the medieval Jewish allegorists, many older Christian commentators (e.g. Delitzsch) and a good number of modern ones, and it is built into ESV/NASB 'but' and NLT.

    A wall is closed and a door opens, so the natural opposition is strong. The verb ṣûr with 'al usually means 'besiege/shut in', which suggests restraint. The 'door' is erotically charged elsewhere in the Song (5:2–6). The woman's reply 'I am a wall' (v. 10) would then mean 'I am the chaste one.'

  • Synonymous: both lines describe the brothers' plan to protect and beautify their sister, whatever she turns out to be. Wall and door are two parts of one fortified city. Several modern commentators (e.g. Fox, Keel) argue some form of this.

    Hebrew poetry usually builds parallel lines that say similar things. The second line opens with plain 'and', not a word for 'but'. Both materials are luxuries: silver is ornamental rather than defensive, and cedar is palace and Temple panelling, not a punishment. A door also needs reinforcing in a besieged city. YLT and the LXX ('fashion', 'trace') read the second line as decoration.

  • Deliberately ambiguous: the poet lets both readings sound, so the brothers' 'protection' is heard as both honour and control. The woman's reply in v. 10 cuts through their speculation. Exum and others stress this.

    The siege-colouring of ṣûr 'al next to the luxury of cedar. The brothers' earlier anger (1:6). The way v. 10 takes over their metaphor ('I am a wall') and vv. 11–12 assert 'my vineyard is mine', undercutting the guardians' talk of silver.

in v9

What does the 'silver' suggest?

  • Adornment or crown: silver battlements picture jewellery or a bridal headdress, perhaps echoing the 'mural crown' worn by queens in Near Eastern art.

    Silver is useless as fortification but splendid as ornament. Mural crowns are attested in Assyrian royal art.

  • Value and bride-price: silver (also 'money') hints at the economic side of marriage negotiation, which the following verses take up explicitly.

    Vv. 11–12 count 'a thousand pieces of silver' for Solomon's vineyard. Brothers negotiated bride-price (Gen 24:53; 34:12). This is a possible overtone, not demonstrable as the main sense.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. טִירָה, צוּר (I, III), דֶּלֶת, חוֹמָה
  • HALOT s.v. טִירָה; צוּר
  • Septuagint, Canticum 8:9 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Canticum Canticorum 8:9
  • Targum to Song of Songs 8:9; Rashi on Song 8:9
  • F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Song of Songs
  • M. V. Fox, The Song of Songs and the Ancient Egyptian Love Songs (1985)
  • M. H. Pope, Song of Songs, Anchor Bible (1977)
  • R. E. Murphy, The Song of Songs, Hermeneia (1990)
  • O. Keel, The Song of Songs, Continental Commentary (1994)
  • J. C. Exum, Song of Songs, Old Testament Library (2005)
  • T. Longman III, Song of Songs, NICOT (2001)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.