1 Samuel Chapter 15 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 15:23–28

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23For rebellion is like the sin of divination, and arrogance is like the wickedness of idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the LORD, He has rejected you as king.” 24Then Saul said to Samuel, “I have sinned; I have transgressed the LORD’s commandment and your instructions, because I feared the people and obeyed their voice. 25Now therefore, please forgive my sin and return with me so I can worship the LORD.” 26“I will not return with you,” Samuel replied. “For you have rejected the word of the LORD, and He has rejected you as king over Israel.” 27As Samuel turned to go, Saul grabbed the hem of his robe, and it tore. 28So Samuel said to him, “The LORD has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today and has given it to your neighbor who is better than you.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this was the turning point in the story of their first king. It explained why the kingdom passed from Saul to David, and it explained it in terms of covenant loyalty, not politics or bad luck.

The lesson they heard was this: Israel's king is not like the kings of the nations. Those kings consult omens and gods to steer their own plans. Israel's king is under the word of Yahweh, delivered by the prophet. When he puts his own judgment, or the crowd's pressure (v. 24, "I feared the people and obeyed their voice"), above that word, it is not a technicality. It sits in the same category as the banned practices of divination and idolatry, which Deuteronomy treats as betraying Yahweh outright.

The verse also guarded against a religious loophole. Saul's defence was worship: he kept the animals for sacrifice. Samuel's oracle stands in the line that runs through the prophets (Hos 6:6; Amos 5:21–24; Mic 6:6–8; Jer 7:21–23): no amount of offering makes up for refusing to listen. The matching "you rejected / he rejected you" would have landed as just retribution, and the echo of 1 Samuel 8:7 reminded hearers that the monarchy began as Israel's own rejection of Yahweh as king.

From the study of 1 Samuel 15:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 23For rebellion is like the sin of divination, and arrogance is like the wickedness of idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the LORD, He has rejected you as king.”

    "For defiance of God's word is in the same class as the sin of reading omens, and pushing ahead on your own will is in the same class as the wickedness of idols and household gods. You threw aside Yahweh's word as if it were worthless, so he has thrown you aside: you are cut off from being king."

    The first half is two short lines of poetic parallelism, a style in which the second line restates and sharpens the first. The Hebrew has no "is like" or "as". It simply sets the items side by side: the sin of divination — rebellion; wickedness and teraphim — insistence. The effect is closer to an equation than a comparison: in God's sight, the one counts as the other.

    The pairing is pointed. Divination and teraphim were the pagan king's ways of deciding what to do: lots, omens, consulting the household gods. Israel's king was meant to be guided by the word of Yahweh through his prophet. Saul did not consult omens. But by overriding a clear command with his own judgment and the crowd's wishes (v. 24), and then pressing ahead in self-justification, he put another authority in the place of God's word. That is what divination does too.

    The second half delivers the verdict with the same verb used twice: you rejected… he rejected you. It also echoes 1 Samuel 8:7, where Israel "rejected" Yahweh "from being king" by asking for Saul. Saul's kingship began with a rejection of God and ends with God's rejection of Saul.

    Full study →
  2. 24Then Saul said to Samuel, “I have sinned; I have transgressed the LORD’s commandment and your instructions, because I feared the people and obeyed their voice.

    Saul answered Samuel: "I am in the wrong. I stepped over the line drawn by the LORD's own mouth, and over your words as well. The reason is that I was afraid of my troops, and so it was their voice I listened to."

    Several things in the Hebrew do not come through in English:

    • "I have sinned" is one word, chatati. It is the standard formula for a guilty party admitting fault, used by Pharaoh, Balaam, Achan and David. It says Saul is guilty. It does not by itself prove his heart has changed.
    • "Transgressed the commandment" is literally "crossed over the mouth of the LORD." God's spoken order is pictured as a boundary, and Saul admits he walked across it. Four verses earlier he had insisted, "I did obey the voice of the LORD" (v.20).
    • "Your words" puts Samuel's speech, the prophet's passing-on of the order in 15:1–3, alongside the LORD's mouth.
    • "I feared the people" uses the same verb that elsewhere in Samuel describes the loyalty owed to God ("fear the LORD," 12:14, 24). The king's fear went to his own soldiers ("the people" here means the army) instead of to his God.
    • "Obeyed their voice" is literally "listened to their voice." Hebrew uses one verb for hearing and obeying. That ties the confession to Samuel's line just before, "to listen is better than sacrifice" (v.22). Saul did listen, but to the troops, not to the LORD.

    The sentence has a set shape: an admission, then a "for" that defines the fault, then a "because" that explains it. That last part of the confession moves the blame onto the people.

    Full study →
  3. 25Now therefore, please forgive my sin and return with me so I can worship the LORD.”

    "So now — I beg you — lift my sin off me. Turn back and come with me, so that I can get down on my face before Yahweh."

    The verse depends on the confession just before it (v. 24): "I have sinned… because I feared the people." "And now" makes the request follow from that confession, as if saying it should settle the matter. The plea is made to Samuel, not to God. "Lift, please, my sin" uses the ordinary Hebrew idiom for asking someone you have wronged to stop holding it against you: take the weight off, carry it away. Saul has admitted breaking "the LORD's command and your words," so he is asking the offended prophet to drop the offense and, in practice, to stand by him again.

    The wording almost exactly repeats Pharaoh's words to Moses during the plagues: "Now therefore, forgive, please, my sin just this once" (Exod 10:17). A Hebrew listener could hear in it a ruler who confesses under pressure and wants the man of God to make the consequences go away.

    "Turn back with me" uses the chapter's keyword. God has said Saul "turned back" from following him (v. 11). Now Saul asks the prophet to turn back, and Samuel throws the word back at him: "I will not turn back with you" (v. 26). The purpose clause says what the return is for: "so that I may bow down," literally lie face-down in homage, at the sacrifices waiting at Gilgal. Verse 30 makes explicit what is already under the surface here. Samuel being seen at the king's side during that public act would show the elders that nothing has broken between Saul, the prophet, and Yahweh. Saul's confession is real in its words, but what it asks for is to be seen as restored.

    Full study →
  4. 26“I will not return with you,” Samuel replied. “For you have rejected the word of the LORD, and He has rejected you as king over Israel.”

    Samuel answered Saul with a flat refusal, using Saul's own words against him: "I will not turn back with you." Saul had begged the prophet to go back with him so the king could worship in public with the prophet at his side. To the ancient hearer that was a request for visible proof that God still stood behind the king. Samuel gives the reason in two matching lines, and they turn on the same verb: "Because you have refused and set aside the word of YHWH, YHWH has refused and set you aside, so that you are no longer king over Israel."

    "The word of YHWH" here is not scripture in general. It is the specific command Samuel brought at the start of the chapter: put Amalek under the ban. Saul spared their king and kept the best of the livestock, and then said he had obeyed. Because the verb is repeated, the sentence reads as exact justice: as Saul treated God's word, God now treats Saul. The verb "turn back" also carries weight. In this chapter Saul is the one who "turned back" from following God (v.11), and now he asks the prophet to "turn back" with him. What Saul loses is spelled out precisely: from being king. His position as God's deputy over God's people is withdrawn. He keeps the throne in practice for years, but the next scene, where Saul grabs Samuel's robe and it tears, shows the kingdom being torn from him.

    Full study →
  5. 27As Samuel turned to go, Saul grabbed the hem of his robe, and it tore.

    Samuel has just said his last word: "I will not go back with you. You rejected the LORD's word, and the LORD has rejected you as king." Now he turns his back to leave. As he goes, Saul seizes hold of the corner of Samuel's robe. This is no light tug but a hard, clinging grip. In Saul's world, grabbing the edge of someone's garment was what a petitioner did when begging a patron not to cut him off: don't leave me; I'm still yours. The robe is Samuel's outer mantle, the garment that identified him as prophet and priest since his childhood at Shiloh. Then it ripped. The Hebrew names no one as the tearer. The cloth simply gives way. Samuel at once tells Saul what it means, using the same verb: "The LORD has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today." (The Hebrew does not actually say "Saul" here. It only says "he took hold of his robe." Ancient translators and nearly all modern readers understand it as Saul grasping Samuel's robe.)

    Full study →
  6. 28So Samuel said to him, “The LORD has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today and has given it to your neighbor who is better than you.

    Saul has just grabbed the edge of Samuel's robe, and it has ripped. Samuel turns the tear into a verdict:

    "Yahweh has ripped the kingship of Israel off you, today, and he will hand it to another man from among your own people, one who is good — better than you."

    The verb is the same one as the robe that just tore. What happened to the cloth is a picture of what God has done to Saul's reign. The Hebrew speaks of the kingship as something resting on Saul, like a mantle, and now torn off. The verdict is spoken as already done ("has torn") and dated "today", though Saul will go on sitting on the throne for years. In God's decision the matter is settled. Carrying it out is only a question of time. The successor is pointedly not named. He is simply "your fellow", another Israelite, someone close at hand. The reader meets him in the very next chapter, and he will become Saul's own servant, son-in-law, and his son's best friend. The last words cut deepest. When Saul first appeared, he was the man nobody in Israel was "better than" (9:2). Now he hears that someone is better than him. The "good" that counts is no longer looks and height but faithfulness to Yahweh's word, the very thing Saul has just failed to show with Amalek.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    witchcraft (KJV, NLT)

    qesem

    What we hear
    Spell-casting, curses, occult magic, Wicca, or demonic power; something witches do.
    What they heard
    Divination: seeking hidden knowledge or guidance through omens, lots, arrows, livers or household gods. It was a method of decision-making that rivalled listening to Yahweh's prophet.
  • in v23

    is as / is like

    (no word: a verbless clause)

    What we hear
    Rebellion is somewhat similar to, or merely comparable with, divination.
    What they heard
    The Hebrew sets the terms side by side with no comparison word. It is a near-equation: rebellion *is* the sin of divination, in the sense that it counts the same before God.
  • in v24

    I have sinned

    chatati

    What we hear
    A heartfelt confession that shows true repentance: if he said it, he meant it, and it should have been enough.
    What they heard
    A standard formula admitting guilt to someone in authority. It is used both by sincere penitents (David, 2 Sam 12:13) and by people who admit fault under pressure and go back on it (Pharaoh, Exod 9:27; 10:16). The word establishes guilt. The surrounding story shows whether the heart behind it has changed.
  • in v24

    transgressed the commandment

    'avarti et-pi YHWH

    What we hear
    Broke a rule or a regulation.
    What they heard
    "Crossed over the mouth of the LORD": stepped across a line drawn by God's own spoken word. The picture is a boundary physically crossed, and the 'rule' is a voice that spoke.
  • in v25

    worship

    hishtaḥavah (ʾeshtaḥaveh)

    What we hear
    A church service, singing, or an inner attitude of devotion.
    What they heard
    Bodily prostration, lying face-down in homage. Here it is a public act at a sacrificial assembly at Gilgal, in front of the elders.
  • in v25

    forgive / pardon

    nasa (ḥaṭṭaʾt)

    What we hear
    An inner emotional release, or God's removal of guilt. Readers may wonder why Saul asks Samuel to do what only God can do.
    What they heard
    "Lift / carry" the offense: a common request from one person to another to stop holding a wrong against them (as in Gen 50:17; 1 Sam 25:28). Here it is aimed at the prophet Saul has offended, with the hope that he will stand with Saul and plead for him.
  • in v26

    rejected you

    ma'as

    What we hear
    God has stopped loving Saul or cast him off as a person, possibly for eternity.
    What they heard
    God has withdrawn his acceptance of Saul as king. The verb is limited by 'from being king over Israel', which names what is lost: legitimate royal office.
  • in v26

    the word of the LORD

    devar YHWH

    What we hear
    The Bible or scripture in general.
    What they heard
    One specific spoken command given through Samuel (15:1–3) about the ban on Amalek.
  • in v27

    skirt (KJV, WEB) / hem (BSB)

    kənaf

    What we hear
    'Skirt' suggests a woman's garment. 'Hem' suggests the stitched bottom fold of a piece of clothing, a trivial bit of fabric.
    What they heard
    The 'wing', meaning the corner or edge of a man's outer robe. It was a part of the garment that stood for the wearer's person and status, and grasping it was a known gesture of pleading or attaching oneself to someone.
  • in v28

    neighbor / neighbour

    re'a

    What we hear
    Someone who lives next door or nearby.
    What they heard
    A fellow, companion, another person within the community: 'one of your own'. It says nothing about where he lives and stresses that the successor is a fellow Israelite, even someone close to Saul.
  • in v28

    kingdom

    mamlekhut

    What we hear
    A country or territory with borders.
    What they heard
    Kingship, the royal office and the right to reign. Saul is not losing land. He is losing the throne God gave him.
Every word
  1. כִּי

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v23, v24, v26

    Ties this line to verse 22 and gives its reason: obedience is better than sacrifice *because* disobedience counts as heavily as the gravest religious crimes.

  2. חַטַּאת־

    chattat · H2403B

    sin, offence; also sin-offering · v23, v25

    "The sin of": an offence that puts you in the wrong before God. The same word also names the sin-offering, which gives an edge to it here, where Saul has just defended himself by talking about sacrifice.

  3. קֶסֶם

    qesem · H7081

    divination · v23

    Getting hidden knowledge or guidance from omens, lots, arrows, livers and similar methods. This is not spell-casting. Moses' law bans it outright (Deut 18:10), and here it stands for the worst kind of religious disloyalty.

  4. מֶרִי

    meri · H4805H

    rebellion, defiance · v23

    Deliberate, defiant resistance to a known command. This is the word used for Israel's defiance in the wilderness. Grammatically it is the subject the line is defining: rebellion *is* (or counts as) the sin of divination.

  5. וְאָוֶן

    ve'aven · H0205G

    wickedness, trouble, emptiness · v23

    "And wickedness". The word often has idolatry around it (prophets mock Bethel, "house of God", as Beth-aven, "house of wickedness"). Paired with teraphim it probably means "the wickedness of idols" or "idolatrous iniquity".

  6. וּתְרָפִים

    utrafim · H8655

    teraphim, household gods · v23

    "And teraphim": household god-figures, sometimes used to get oracles. Translators often render it "idolatry", but it names specific cult objects.

  7. הַפְצַר

    haftsar · H6484

    to press, urge, insist · v23

    A rare causative form found only here, from a verb meaning "to press hard, insist". It means pushing your own way: presumption, self-willed insistence. Rendered "stubbornness", "arrogance" or "presumption".

  8. יַעַן

    ya'an · H3282

    because · v23

    Opens the legal grounds for the sentence, as prophets do when they pronounce judgment: "because you did X…".

  9. מָאַסְתָּ

    ma'asta · H3988A

    to reject, refuse, despise · v23, v26

    "You rejected": you treated it as worthless and threw it aside. The verb describes a completed act. Saul's partial obedience counts as rejection.

  10. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    [direct-object marker] · v23, v24, v25, v26, v28

    Marks "the word of Yahweh" as what was rejected. It has no English equivalent.

  11. דְּבַר

    devar · H1697G

    word, command, matter · v23, v24, v26

    The specific command Yahweh gave through Samuel in 15:1–3 to put Amalek under the ban. It means a spoken instruction from God through his prophet, not scripture in general.

  12. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh, the LORD · v23, v24, v25, v26, v28

    Israel's God, named by his personal name. He is the true king who appointed Saul and whose word Saul set aside.

  13. מִמֶּלֶךְ

    mimmelekh · H4428G

    from (being) king · v23, v26

    Literally "from king". The "from" means removal: Saul is cut off from the office of king. The sentence is spoken now, though David's anointing (ch. 16) and Saul's death (ch. 31) come later.

  14. וַיֹּ֨אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v24, v26, v28

    The ordinary verb that moves the story along. It opens Saul's second answer to Samuel. His first answer (v.20) was a denial: "I did obey." This one is an admission.

  15. שָׁא֤וּל

    Sha'ul · H7586

    Saul · v24, v26

    Israel's first king, named here as the speaker. His name means "asked for," a reminder that the people asked for a king (1 Sam 8). That fits a verse in which the king admits he was steered by the people.

  16. אֶל־

    el- · H0413

    to · v24, v26, v28

    Saul speaks to Samuel, not to YHWH. The confession is made to the prophet who has just announced that Saul is rejected.

  17. שְׁמוּאֵל֙

    Shemu'el · H8050

    Samuel · v24, v26, v27, v28

    The prophet who anointed Saul (10:1) and who passed on the order to wipe out Amalek (15:1–3).

  18. חָטָ֔אתִי

    chatati · H2398

    I have sinned · v24

    A single-word admission of fault: "I'm in the wrong, I failed what I owed." In Hebrew narrative it is a set phrase used by people who have been caught, from Pharaoh to David. It says that one is guilty. On its own it says nothing about how sincere the speaker is.

  19. עָבַ֥רְתִּי

    'avarti · H5674

    I passed over, transgressed · v24

    Literally "I crossed over." It is the verb for crossing a river or a border. Saul pictures the LORD's order as a boundary line and admits he stepped over it.

  20. פִּֽי־

    pi- · H6310

    mouth (of) · v24

    "The mouth of the LORD," a Hebrew idiom for a command given in speech. English "commandment" is accurate, but it loses the picture of a voice actually speaking.

  21. יָרֵ֙אתִי֙

    yareti · H3372

    I feared · v24

    "I was afraid of." In Samuel the right object of this verb is YHWH (12:14, 24). Saul admits his fear was aimed at the wrong place. The king was afraid of his own troops.

  22. הָעָ֔ם

    ha'am · H5971

    the people · v24

    In this chapter, as often in battle stories, "the people" means the fighting men, Saul's army. They are the ones who "took from the spoil" (15:15, 21).

  23. וָאֶשְׁמַ֖ע

    va'eshma' · H8085

    and I listened, obeyed · v24

    "And so I listened." In Hebrew, hearing and obeying are one verb. This is the key word of the chapter: Saul was told to listen to YHWH's voice (v.1), and he listened to the troops' voice instead.

  24. בְּקוֹלָֽם׃

    beqolam · H6963

    to their voice · v24

    "To their voice." The phrase "listen to the voice of" is the standard Hebrew way of saying "obey." Here it sets the people's voice against "the voice of YHWH" in vv.1, 19, 20 and 22.

  25. וְעַתָּ֕ה

    veʿattah · H6258

    and now · v25

    "And now" turns from what has been said to what should happen next: "I have confessed (v. 24), so now…" It ties the request directly to the confession and makes it feel urgent.

  26. שָׂ֥א

    sa · H5375

    lift, carry; forgive · v25

    A command form of the verb "lift / carry." Said of an offense, it means to lift the weight of it off the guilty person, or to carry it yourself and not press it on him. Saul says it to Samuel, not to God.

  27. נָ֖א

    na · H4994

    please, I beg you · v25

    A particle of pleading that softens and presses the command at once. A king is begging a prophet.

  28. וְשׁ֣וּב

    veshuv · H7725

    turn back, return · v25, v26

    "And turn back." Samuel is about to leave or has started to (v. 27). Saul wants him to turn around and go with him. This is the same verb the chapter uses for Saul "turning back" from following God (v. 11) and the usual Hebrew verb for repenting.

  29. עִמִּ֔י

    ʿimmi · H5973

    with me · v25, v26

    "With me," at my side. What Saul wants is for Samuel to be seen beside him.

  30. וְאֶֽשְׁתַּחֲוֶ֖ה

    veʾeshtaḥaveh · H7812

    bow down, prostrate oneself · v25

    "So that I may bow down." The form joined by "and" after the commands states their purpose. The verb pictures lying face-down. Here it is the act of homage at the sacrifices waiting at Gilgal (vv. 15, 21).

  31. לֹ֥א

    lo' · H3808

    not · v26

    A flat negation placed first for emphasis. It is a refusal, not a wish.

  32. מִהְי֥וֹת

    mihyot · H1961

    from being · v26

    'From' plus 'to be': rejected so as no longer to be king. It names exactly what Saul loses, which is legitimate standing as king.

  33. עַל־

    al · H5921

    over · v26, v28

    Rule over a people. The kingship is defined by the people of God it governs.

  34. יִשְׂרָאֵֽל׃

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v26, v28

    The tribal people bound to YHWH by covenant. The sentence ends here, and the Hebrew text marks a paragraph break (ס) before the scene of the torn robe.

  35. וַיִּסֹּב

    vayyissōv · H5437

    turn around, go around · v27

    Samuel turns his body around to leave, putting his back to Saul. Coming right after 'I will not return with you' (v. 26), the turn acts out his refusal and ends the conversation.

  36. לָלֶכֶת

    lāleket · H1980

    to go, walk · v27

    'In order to go': this states his purpose. Samuel is about to walk away from Saul, and with him the prophetic word and God's backing.

  37. וַיַּחֲזֵק

    vayyaḥăzēq · H2388

    be strong; (causative) seize, grip firmly · v27

    A strong verb: he seized it and held on hard, more than touching or tugging. The Hebrew gives no new subject. The context (Saul has just been pleading, vv. 24–25) points to Saul, and the ancient Greek translation names him.

  38. בִּכְנַף־

    bikhnaf- · H3671

    wing; edge, corner, hem of a garment · v27

    'By the wing of', meaning the corner or edge of the robe. In Israel and its neighbours the corner of a garment stood for the person who wore it. Seizing it was the gesture of someone begging, and cutting or tearing it could mean ending a relationship.

  39. מְעִילוֹ

    məʿîlô · H4598

    robe, outer mantle · v27

    'His robe': the sleeveless outer cloak worn by people of standing, priests and royalty. For Samuel it was his trademark garment (2:19; 28:14). The 'his' most naturally means Samuel's, though grammatically it could be Saul's.

  40. וַיִּקָּרַע

    vayyiqqāraʿ · H7167

    tear, rip · v27, v28

    'And it was torn' or 'it tore'. The verb form gives no one as the tearer, as if the tearing simply happened. Samuel picks up the same verb in the next verse: 'The LORD has torn the kingdom from you.'

  41. מַמְלְכ֧וּת

    mamlekhut · H4468

    kingship, royal rule, kingdom · v28

    The office and authority of ruling, not a stretch of land. What is torn away is Saul's right to reign over Israel.

  42. הַיּ֑וֹם

    hayyom · H3117

    today, this day · v28

    'Today', the day of the Amalek disobedience at Gilgal. The verdict takes effect now, even though carrying it out will take years.

  43. וּנְתָנָ֕הּ

    unetanah · H5414

    and he will give it · v28

    'And he will give it'. The verb form here usually looks forward ('will give'), though translators often match it to the past tense of 'has torn'. 'It' is the kingship.

  44. לְרֵעֲךָ֖

    lere'akha · H7453

    to your fellow, companion, another person · v28

    'To your fellow', meaning another Israelite, someone from among Saul's own people. It is not 'the man next door'. The person is left unnamed on purpose. David appears in the very next chapter.

  45. הַטּ֥וֹב

    hattov · H2896

    good, fine, fit · v28

    'The good one'. Tov covers good, fine, fit, and pleasing. The phrase deliberately echoes 9:2, where Saul was introduced as so 'good' that no Israelite was 'better than he'.

  46. מִמֶּֽךָּ׃

    mimmekka · H4480

    from you / than you · v28

    With 'good' this makes the comparison 'better than you'. The same little word also means 'from', so the phrase quietly echoes 'from upon you' earlier in the verse.

The world behind it

The Amalek command. In 15:1–3 Samuel gives Saul a direct word from Yahweh to put Amalek under ḥerem, the "ban". In ancient Israel's holy-war practice, the ban meant everything captured was devoted wholly to God by destruction, not kept as plunder. Saul defeats Amalek but spares King Agag and the best livestock (v. 9). When confronted, he first claims full obedience (v. 13), then blames the troops and says the animals were kept "to sacrifice to Yahweh" at Gilgal (vv. 15, 21). Verses 22–23 are Samuel's reply in poetic form, and v. 22 sets "listening/obeying" against "sacrifice".

Divination as royal practice. Across the ancient Near East, kings consulted specialists before battles and major decisions. In Mesopotamia these included liver-readers, astrologers and lot-casters, and Ezekiel 21:21 shows Babylon's king using arrows, teraphim and a liver at a fork in the road. Deuteronomy 18:9–15 forbids all of this to Israel and gives the prophet as Yahweh's alternative: "the nations… listen to diviners, but as for you, Yahweh has not allowed this… he will raise up a prophet; to him you shall listen." Samuel's comparison draws on exactly this framework. A king who sets aside the prophetic word has stepped into the diviner's world.

Earlier warnings. In 13:8–14 Saul had already acted on his own at Gilgal, and Samuel announced that his kingdom (that is, his dynasty) would not last. Chapter 15 goes further: Saul himself is rejected. The narrative then moves straight to David's anointing (ch. 16) and later to Saul, cut off from any word from God, consulting a medium at Endor (ch. 28), the very kind of practice he had earlier expelled (28:3).

From the study of 1 Samuel 15:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

What does haftsar mean?

  • Presumption or arrogance: pushing one's own will forward.

    The basic verb patsar always means "press, urge, insist" (Gen 19:3, 9; 33:11; 2 Kgs 2:17; 5:16). BDB reads the causative as "display pushing". This fits Saul's self-promotion in vv. 12, 20 and 30.

  • Stubbornness, obstinacy or insubordination: refusing to give way.

    Tradition from the Vulgate ("refuse to submit") to the KJV, and the parallel with "rebellion" in the first line.

  • The text is damaged and should be corrected.

    The form is unique and the Greek translation reads differently. Some commentators propose emendations, but none has won general agreement.

in v23

Is this a comparison ("like") or an equation ("is")?

  • An equation: rebellion is, in substance, the sin of divination.

    The Hebrew is a verbless clause with no word for "like". Both disobedience and divination replace Yahweh's word with another source of direction.

  • A comparison of seriousness: rebellion is as grave as divination.

    Most translations, following the Vulgate's quasi. Poetic parallelism can imply comparison without a word for "like".

in v23

How does this rejection relate to 1 Samuel 13:13–14?

  • Two stages: chapter 13 ends Saul's dynasty, and chapter 15 rejects Saul himself.

    13:13–14 speaks of his kingdom not being established "forever". 15:23, 26, 28 speak of Saul being rejected "from being king" and the kingdom being torn from him "today".

  • Two narrative traditions about one rejection, later combined.

    Both scenes are set at Gilgal and both involve sacrifice and disobedience. Source-critical scholars often see doublets (two versions of the same story).

in v24

Was Saul's confession genuine?

  • Self-serving: an admission forced out of him, wrapped in an excuse and aimed at protecting his public standing.

    He first denied any wrongdoing (v.20). In this verse he shifts the blame to the people. In v.25 his request centres on Samuel coming back with him. In v.30 he repeats *chatati* and immediately asks, "honour me now before the elders." The confession is spoken to Samuel and not to YHWH, unlike David's in 2 Sam 12:13. This is the reading of most traditional and many modern commentators (e.g. Keil–Delitzsch; Bergen, NAC).

  • Sincere, or at least not simply false: a tragic figure who admits real fault and still cannot recover what he has lost.

    The admission is direct and in the first person ("I crossed the mouth of the LORD"). Fear of the troops fits his situation as described in 13:6–11. The narrative itself shows God "regretting" Saul (15:11, 35), and some readers see the rejection as severe compared with David's treatment. Literary readings such as D. M. Gunn (*The Fate of King Saul*, 1980) and J. Cheryl Exum (*Tragedy and Biblical Narrative*, 1992) read Saul as tragic and partly sympathetic.

in v24

Is "I feared the people" the true cause or a new excuse?

  • A real explanation that exposes Saul's basic weakness as king: he is led by his army.

    It matches 13:11 ("the people were scattering from me") and 14:24–45, where the people overrule Saul's oath to save Jonathan. It fits the wider concern in the book about a king who answers to the people instead of to God.

  • A change of story that moves responsibility onto others.

    In vv.15 and 21 Saul described the troops' actions as pious, saving the best animals to sacrifice to YHWH, and said nothing about fear. Now, once that defence has failed, he says he was afraid of them. Changing the explanation looks like an attempt to blame someone else.

in v24

Why does Saul name "your words" alongside the LORD's command?

  • The prophet's words are simply the channel of God's word, so naming both is a full admission.

    In 15:1 Samuel's message is introduced as "the voice of the words of the LORD." In 1 Samuel, the prophet's word and God's word are regularly treated as one (3:19–21).

  • Saul presents the offence partly as a matter between himself and Samuel, which Samuel personally could smooth over.

    The following verses focus on Samuel personally: "pardon my sin, return with me" (v.25), and Saul seizing Samuel's robe (v.27). Saul seems to think a public reconciliation with the prophet will fix things.

in v25

Is Saul's confession and plea sincere?

  • It is self-serving: Saul is managing his public standing, not repenting.

    Before this he made excuses (vv. 15, 20–21). His confession blames the people (v. 24). His repeated plea openly asks Samuel to "honor me before the elders" (v. 30). The wording matches Pharaoh's (Exod 10:17).

  • Saul is a tragic figure: his confession is real, but the sentence is already fixed.

    He says "I have sinned" twice, the same words David says (2 Sam 12:13). The narrator also stresses God's fixed decision (v. 29) and his "regret" over making Saul king (vv. 11, 35). Readings such as D. Gunn's *The Fate of King Saul* argue that the story presents Saul as caught by a divine rejection his repentance could not undo.

in v25

What exactly is Saul asking Samuel to do by "lifting" his sin?

  • An ordinary social request: stop holding against me the offense against your words, and stand with me again.

    The same formula is used between people (Gen 50:17; 1 Sam 25:28), and Saul confessed to breaking Samuel's "words" (v. 24).

  • In effect a request for Samuel to act as go-between, getting God's sentence reversed through intercession.

    Samuel had interceded before (7:5–9; 12:19–23). The Pharaoh parallel goes on: "and plead with the LORD" (Exod 10:17). The sin Saul wants lifted is the one that brought the rejection.

in v26

Samuel says 'I will not return with you' (v.26), yet in v.31 he does return with Saul. How do these fit together?

  • The refusal is about endorsement, and the later return is a limited concession for public order. Samuel keeps the army and elders from witnessing an open split and then carries out the ban himself on Agag (v.33).

    In v.30 Saul asks only for honor 'before the elders'. Samuel's return in v.31 is followed immediately by his own action against Agag, which completes the command Saul neglected.

  • The tension is a deliberate narrative irony, and some think it reflects layers in how the story was composed. The prophet's firmness is shown and then partly softened, much as the chapter sets God 'regretting' (vv.11, 35) beside God who does not 'change his mind' (v.29).

    The repeated words for 'turn back' and 'regret' in ch. 15 form patterns that look intentional. Critical commentators such as McCarter discuss possible editorial layers here.

in v26

Was Saul's confession ('I have sinned', vv.24–25) genuine, and why was it not enough?

  • It was self-serving. Saul blames the people, and his chief concern is public honor.

    In v.24 Saul says 'I feared the people'. In v.30 he asks to be honored 'before the elders'. He earlier claimed he had obeyed (vv.13, 20).

  • Saul is a tragic figure whose confession is treated more harshly than David's later confession (2 Sam 12:13). The text deliberately raises questions about how God's choice and judgment work.

    Literary readings, for example D. M. Gunn, The Fate of King Saul, note the contrast with David and the fact that Saul's request for forgiveness gets no direct answer.

in v27

Whose robe was torn, and who grabbed it?

  • Saul grabbed Samuel's robe (the majority view).

    The Septuagint (and reportedly 4QSamᵃ) names Saul. The context has Saul pleading (vv. 24–25, 30) while Samuel turns away. The robe (meʿil) is Samuel's signature garment (2:19; 28:14). And v. 28 reads naturally as Samuel explaining an accident.

  • Samuel took hold of Saul's robe and tore it, as a deliberate prophetic sign (a minority view, also found in some Jewish interpretation).

    In the Hebrew the subject does not change: Samuel is the last person named. A deliberate tearing by the prophet would match Ahijah tearing his cloak in 1 Kgs 11:30. The torn corner of Saul's own robe would match David cutting Saul's robe in 24:4–5. The weakness of this view: the Hebrew's 'it tore', with no tearer named, suggests an accident rather than a planned act.

in v27

What does grasping the hem mean here?

  • It was the recognised gesture of pleading and seeking attachment, as in Akkadian 'seizing the hem'.

    Akkadian legal and religious texts use 'seize the hem' for begging or submission and 'cut the hem' for breaking a bond. Zech 8:23 has a similar act of clinging to someone's garment corner. (Brauner, JANES 6, 1974.)

  • It was simply a physical attempt to stop Samuel walking away, and the symbolic weight comes only from Samuel's words in v. 28.

    The narrative does not explain the gesture, and Saul's reason is clear from his words alone. Even so, the two readings are compatible: a desperate grab could carry the pleading meaning too.

in v28

Whose robe tore in v.27, Samuel's or Saul's?

  • Saul grabbed Samuel's robe and it tore. Most interpreters and translations take this view.

    The Septuagint (and reportedly 4QSamᵃ) name Saul as the one who grasped. Grabbing a superior's hem was a known gesture of pleading in the ancient Near East. Saul has just been begging Samuel to return (15:25).

  • Samuel grabbed Saul's robe and tore it as a deliberate sign-act, like Ahijah in 1 Kings 11.

    The Masoretic Hebrew (the standard medieval text) leaves the subject unstated, and Samuel is the subject of the verb just before. Prophets performed deliberate sign-acts. Some later Jewish interpretation took it this way. Against this view, the passive 'and it tore' sounds accidental, not deliberate.

in v28

In what sense is the successor 'better' (tov)?

  • Better in obedience and in heart toward Yahweh.

    The context is Saul's disobedience (15:22–23). 13:14 speaks of 'a man according to his heart', and 16:7 says Yahweh looks on the heart.

  • 'Better' mainly means 'more fit' or 'the one God prefers', with the irony aimed at 9:2. It is less a moral portrait than a verdict on suitability.

    Tov has a wide range (fine, fit, pleasing). 9:2 uses tov of Saul's appearance. Some scholars read 13:14 as 'a man of his [God's] own choosing', not as a statement about David's character. The later David narratives do not portray him as morally flawless.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. קֶסֶם, מְרִי, פָּצַר, תְּרָפִים, מָאַס
  • HALOT s.v. פצר, אָוֶן, תְּרָפִים
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 15:23
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 15:23
  • BDB s.v. חָטָא, עָבַר, פֶּה, יָרֵא, שָׁמַע
  • HALOT s.v. חטא, עבר, שׁמע (with בְּקוֹל)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible, 1980)
  • D. M. Gunn, The Fate of King Saul (JSOT Supplement 14, 1980)
  • J. Cheryl Exum, Tragedy and Biblical Narrative (1992)
  • Robert D. Bergen, 1, 2 Samuel (New American Commentary, 1996)
  • C. F. Keil and F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Books of Samuel
  • N. Lohfink, "חָרַם" in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, vol. 5
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Reigns 15:24; Vulgate, 1 Samuel 15:24
  • BDB s.v. נָשָׂא, חַטָּאת, שׁוּב
  • HALOT s.v. נשׂא, חַטָּאת, חוה (hištaphel)
  • Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax (purpose clauses after commands)
  • David M. Gunn, The Fate of King Saul
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 15:25
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 15:25
  • BDB s.v. מָאַס
  • HALOT s.v. מאס
  • HALOT s.v. שׁוב
  • W. L. Holladay, The Root šûbh in the Old Testament (1958)
  • D. M. Gunn, The Fate of King Saul
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 15
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 15:23–26
  • BDB s.v. כָּנָף, מְעִיל, קָרַע, חָזַק
  • HALOT s.v. כָּנָף; מְעִיל; קרע
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8, 1980), notes on 15:27
  • Ronald A. Brauner, "'To Grasp the Hem' and 1 Samuel 15:27," Journal of the Ancient Near Eastern Society 6 (1974)
  • Jacob Milgrom, "Of Hems and Tassels," Biblical Archaeology Review 9.3 (1983)
  • Chicago Assyrian Dictionary s.v. sissiktu
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Reigns 15:27
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 15:27
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. קָרַע, מַמְלָכוּת, רֵעַ, טוֹב
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 15:27–28 and the 4QSamᵃ/LXX evidence
  • Robert Alter, The David Story, notes on 1 Sam 9:2 and 15:27–28
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on hem-grasping and Mari prophetic hems
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) 1 Reigns 15:28; Vulgate 1 Samuel 15:28

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).